Ready or Not by Cara Bastone Review
Eikna Score: 7.4/10. Recommended.
Ready or Not is a funny, tender Brooklyn novel about an unplanned pregnancy and the childhood friend who has loved the heroine all along. Eve's voice and her changing relationships are the real story, which makes the book moving, though the romance comes second and the hero is a little too perfect.
Read it if you want a warm, voicey contemporary about a woman remaking her life, with a slow friends to lovers romance woven through it. Skip it if you want the romance to lead, or pregnancy, fertility struggles and miscarriage are hard subjects for you right now.
Ready or Not at a Glance
Ready or Not is the first Hearts of New York novel by Cara Bastone, published by the Dial Press in February 2024. Eve Hatch, a nonprofit administrative assistant in Brooklyn, gets pregnant after a one-night stand and has to rethink everything, including her oldest friendship. It is told by Eve in first person, has mild heat and ends happily.
| Author | Cara Bastone |
|---|---|
| Series | Hearts of New York #1 (reads as a standalone) |
| Subgenre | Contemporary romance, women's fiction crossover |
| Main tropes | Friends to lovers, unplanned pregnancy, best friend's brother, secret pining hero, found family |
| Spice level | 2/5: Mild, fade to black |
| Content warnings | Pregnancy and birth, fertility struggles, miscarriage, parental loss (full list below) |
| POV | First person, Eve |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 400 (US paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Alex Finke, about 10 hours 50 minutes |
| First published | February 13, 2024 |
| Publisher | The Dial Press (Penguin Random House) |
What Is Ready or Not About?
Eve Hatch does not do one-night stands, except for the one time she did. A few weeks later she is pregnant by Ethan Rise, a bartender she barely knows, and she decides to keep the baby.
Her childhood best friends, siblings Willa and Shep Balder, react in opposite ways. Willa, who has been trying for a baby with her husband, pulls away. Shep throws himself into helping, from doctor appointments to furniture assembly, and Eve is far too busy to notice what everyone else can see. Over nine months in Brooklyn, every relationship she has gets rearranged.
What Makes This Friends to Lovers Romance Work
Ready or Not works because its friends to lovers romance grows out of a real crisis. Eve is not looking for love; she is trying to figure out how to have a baby on a nonprofit salary with a near stranger as the father. Shep's steady presence becomes romantic slowly, in the cracks of ordinary help.
The second hook is Eve's voice. Kirkus praised her snappy voice and poignant vulnerability, and it is the reason the book is funny about things that are not, on paper, funny. Monica Juárez-Smith at Monica Reads Through pointed to the first kick as an emotional turning point, and it is one of several small, perfectly judged scenes.
Then there is the honesty about pregnancy. Publishers Weekly praised the credible characters and the range of family arrangements on the page. If you like friends to lovers stories where life gets in the way first, this one does that well.
My Review
Ready or Not is the kind of book I recommend to people who say they do not read romance. It is mostly about a woman figuring out who she is when her body and her plans stop cooperating, and the love story arrives so quietly that it feels like part of the furniture.
Romance and Chemistry
Shep has loved Eve for a long time, and she has no idea. That gives the romance a sweet dramatic irony: every reader can see it, and Eve is busy with sonograms. When she does see it, the shift is tender and well earned. vanessaandbooks on StoryGraph found Shep appealing, and so did I.
The romance is also the thinnest part of the book. Melanie at Smexy Books felt the pregnancy dominated and the romance was underdeveloped, and Jules at Aromantic Reads Romance enjoyed the broader life story while finding Shep thin. The Candid Bibliophile felt the couple's conflict was weaker than everything around it. I agree that this is a pregnancy novel first, which will suit some readers and frustrate others.
The Characters
Eve is wonderful company: funny, anxious, stubborn and generous. Quinn Keaney at What Is Quinn Reading found her quirkiness irritating at times, which I understand, but I liked the way her humor covers real fear.
The supporting cast is the book's quiet strength. Willa's withdrawal is painful and honest, and Ethan, overwhelmed and confused, is drawn with more sympathy than a lesser book would give him. Shep is almost too good; the StoryGraph reader pagesplotsandpints found him too perfect, and I would have liked one real flaw.
Writing and Pacing
Bastone writes dialogue that sounds like people talking, and the Brooklyn setting is specific without being a postcard. Miss Bates Reads Romance valued the character nuance, and Harlequin Junkie praised the intimate pregnancy narration.
At 400 pages the book takes its time, moving through the pregnancy month by month. Kirkus questioned how briefly Eve's decision to keep the baby is examined and noted that child support from Ethan is barely discussed, and Melanie at Smexy Books found the reproductive framing troubling. Alex Finke's audiobook, just under eleven hours, suits Eve's voice.
Ready or Not is a warm, funny, honest pregnancy novel with a slow friends to lovers romance inside it. Read it for Eve's voice and the way her world rearranges; skip it if you need the romance to lead or the subject matter is painful.
How Spicy Is Ready or Not?
Ready or Not is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. Jules at Aromantic Reads Romance reported one lightly described open-door scene, and most of the physical content is about pregnancy rather than romance.
The heavier material is reproductive. Willa and her husband are dealing with fertility issues, and Harlequin Junkie flagged miscarriage, fertility struggles and past parental loss. Eve's choice to continue the pregnancy is stated rather than explored, which Kirkus and Smexy Books both noted.
Content warnings, drawn from critics and reader reviews:
- Unplanned pregnancy and childbirth
- Fertility struggles
- Miscarriage
- Past parental loss
- Pregnancy choices discussed briefly
- One lightly described sex scene
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Who Should Read Ready or Not?
Ready or Not suits readers who want a voicey, heartfelt contemporary about pregnancy, friendship and family, with a gentle friends to lovers romance. It is less suited to readers who want a romance-first plot, high heat or a flawed, complicated hero.
Best for:
- Readers who like women's fiction with a romance thread
- Fans of friends to lovers and secret pining
- Anyone who enjoys Brooklyn settings and found family
- Readers who loved Nora Goes Off Script
- Audiobook listeners who like a funny first-person narrator
Not for:
- Readers who want the romance center stage
- Anyone avoiding pregnancy, fertility or miscarriage content
- Readers looking for spice
- Anyone who dislikes quirky heroines
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Ready or Not was well reviewed by trade critics. Publishers Weekly praised the credible characters and emotional support, Kirkus called it funny and touching, and Miss Bates Reads Romance valued the character nuance and reported a happy ending.
Where they agree. Eve's voice and the emotional journey. Kirkus praised her snappy vulnerability, Monica Juárez-Smith at Monica Reads Through singled out the first-kick scene, and Harlequin Junkie loved the pregnancy narration. vanessaandbooks on StoryGraph found Eve relatable. Where they split. The balance between pregnancy and romance. Melanie at Smexy Books dissented, finding the romance underdeveloped. Jules at Aromantic Reads Romance and pagesplotsandpints on StoryGraph found Shep thin or too perfect. The Candid Bibliophile was mixed, and Quinn Keaney found Eve irritating at times.The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Ready or Not scores 7.4 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with high marks for writing, emotional impact and the ending, and lower marks for heat and the romance's depth.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Sweet slow-dawning love, per Miss Bates; underdeveloped, per Smexy Books. |
| Characters (15%) | 3.5 | Eve shines, per Kirkus; Shep is too perfect, per StoryGraph readers. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4 | Snappy voice and real dialogue, per Kirkus. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | Moving on pregnancy and friendship, per Harlequin Junkie. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3 | Low heat that fits the story. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 4 | A happy ending, per Miss Bates Reads Romance. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | Eve's voice rewards a reread; the plot is gentle. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Ready or Not is Cara Bastone's strongest-reviewed novel so far and one of the warmer pregnancy romances in recent contemporary fiction, with a final Eikna Score of 7.4/10.
Is Ready or Not a Standalone?
Ready or Not is listed as book 1 of Cara Bastone's Hearts of New York books, but it tells a complete story with its own happy ending, so you can read it on its own and start here.
Best format: Alex Finke's audiobook, which runs just under eleven hours and gets the humor in Eve's voice. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved Ready or Not, Read These Next
If you loved Ready or Not, try these warm contemporaries about women remaking their lives.
- Nora Goes Off Script by Annabel Monaghan: a single mother and a movie star, with real family stakes.
- Georgie, All Along by Kate Clayborn: a heroine at a crossroads goes home and finds an unexpected partner.
- The Flatshare by Beth O'Leary: a London flat, notes on the fridge and a slow, kind romance.
- People We Meet on Vacation by Emily Henry: best friends of many years finally admit what they feel.
- The Rom-Commers by Katherine Center: a caregiver heroine gets a chance at her own life and a love story.
Frequently Asked Questions
Ready or Not raises a few common questions about heat, the series and the ending. Short answers below.
Is Ready or Not by Cara Bastone spicy?
Not very. Ready or Not is a 2 out of 5 on our scale, with one lightly described open-door scene.
Is Ready or Not a standalone?
Yes. It is listed as Hearts of New York book 1, but it is a complete story that reads as a standalone.
Does Ready or Not have a happy ending?
Yes. Ready or Not ends with a happily ever after.
Who is the love interest in Ready or Not?
Shep Balder, Eve's childhood best friend and Willa's brother, is the romantic lead; Ethan is the baby's father.
Who narrates the Ready or Not audiobook?
Alex Finke narrates the audiobook, which runs about 10 hours 50 minutes.
The Bottom Line
Ready or Not earns a 7.4/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a funny, honest, heartfelt novel about an unplanned pregnancy and the friend who was there all along, and who are happy for the romance to share the stage. The reason to pick it up is Eve: a narrator whose jokes and fears make nine months in Brooklyn feel like your own.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Ready or Not, Penguin Random House (Dial Press)
- Ready or Not, Cara Bastone official page
- Books, Cara Bastone official site
- Ready or Not audiobook, Libro.fm (Alex Finke)
- Ready or Not, Kirkus Reviews
- Ready or Not, Publishers Weekly
- Review, Miss Bates Reads Romance
- Review, Smexy Books (Melanie)
- Review, Aromantic Reads Romance (Jules)
- Review, Monica Reads Through (Monica Juárez-Smith)
- Review, What Is Quinn Reading? (Quinn Keaney)
- Review, The Candid Bibliophile
- Review, Harlequin Junkie
- Reader review, StoryGraph (pagesplotsandpints)
- Reader review, StoryGraph (vanessaandbooks)
Spice level is our own reading of reader reports; the author does not publish a heat rating.
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.