eikna romance
Menu

What Remains by Garrett Leigh Review

Eikna Score: 7.9/10. Recommended.

What Remains takes the amnesia plot and points it somewhere harder than usual: the man who forgets is not the one who suffers most, and Garrett Leigh lets Rupert's patience cost him something on every page. The prose wobbles and a late twist is too convenient, but the split between the couple's first years and their slow second courtship is genuinely moving.

Read it if you want an MM romance about an established couple starting over, or you like hurt/comfort that takes medical recovery seriously. Skip it if you need a fast plot, or a partner keeping the truth back from someone who cannot remember is a hard no for you.

What Remains by Garrett Leigh book cover

What Remains at a Glance

What Remains is a 2016 standalone MM romance by British author Garrett Leigh, first published by Riptide and reissued in a second edition with an extended epilogue in May 2022. It follows a London couple whose four years together are wiped from one partner's memory, and it ends with a happily ever after.

AuthorGarrett Leigh
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreMM romance, contemporary, set in North London
Main tropesAmnesia, established couple, falling in love again, hurt/comfort, bisexual awakening (again)
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsCar accident, traumatic brain injury, coma, memory loss, family conflict (full list below)
POVJodi and Rupert, with dated chapters that move between past and present
EndingHEA
Pages278 (2016 Riptide trade paperback); about 290 in the 2022 second edition
AudiobookNarrated by Craig Beck, about 7 hours 4 minutes (Riptide)
First published2016; second edition with an extended epilogue, May 11, 2022
PublisherRiptide Publishing (2016); Fox Love Press (2022 edition)

What Is What Remains About?

What Remains opens on a love story already in progress. Jodi Peters, a web designer who keeps to himself, meets Rupert O'Neil, a newly divorced Irish firefighter, and the two fall hard. They build a life in Jodi's Tottenham flat for four years.

Then a car accident puts Jodi in a coma. When he wakes, the last five years are gone, and with them his memory of Rupert, of their home, and of the fact that he had only recently made peace with being attracted to men. Rupert remembers everything. Jodi looks at him and sees a stranger, and Rupert has to decide how much to tell him and how long he can wait.

What Makes This Amnesia Romance Work

What Remains works because it flips the usual amnesia setup. Most memory loss romances are about the person who forgets. This one gives equal weight to the person who is forgotten, and Rupert's chapters are the ones that hurt. He is grieving a partner who is sitting across the table from him.

The second hook is the structure. Leigh alternates dated chapters from the early relationship with the present-day recovery, so you watch Jodi and Rupert fall in love for the first time while Jodi is, slowly and with plenty of false starts, doing it again. Caz Owens at All About Romance singled out that alternating history as the book's great strength, and I agree: it means the reader always knows what is at stake, even when Jodi does not.

And it refuses the magic fix. Jodi does not get his memories back in a tidy rush. What he and Rupert end up with is a new relationship built on the bones of the old one, which is a braver ending than the trope usually allows. Readers who like second chance stories will recognize the shape, even though nobody here broke up.

My Review

I went into What Remains braced for melodrama and got something quieter and more stubborn. The accident happens early, and the book spends most of its length in the unglamorous months afterward: hospital corridors, headaches, a man who is irritable with the person caring for him and has no idea why that person looks so wrecked. It is a sad book in places. It is also funnier than I expected, mostly thanks to Jodi, who is sharp-tongued even when he is lost.

Romance and Chemistry

The romance runs on two tracks and both of them land. In the past chapters, Jodi and Rupert's first meeting has the giddy speed Publishers Weekly called love at first sight, and their early months are warm and very physical. In the present, the attraction has to be rebuilt from scratch, which gives the book a second round of first kisses and awkwardness. PW, otherwise lukewarm, admitted the memory loss device lets Leigh replay the couple's attraction in an interesting way.

The part that bothered some readers is Rupert's choice, early on, not to tell Jodi exactly who he is. J.L. Gribble found that decision hard to watch even while understanding why he made it. I felt the same. It is a believable choice for a frightened man, and the book does not pretend it was a good one.

The Characters

Rupert is the heart of the book. He is kind, patient, a good dad to the daughter he shares with his ex-wife, and so devoted that Caz Owens wondered whether he was a bit too good to be true. I see her point, but his chapters show the cost of all that patience, and he gets angry and tired in ways that kept him human for me.

Jodi is the more interesting puzzle. The brain injury changes his temper and his confidence, and Leigh lets him be unlikeable for stretches: he lashes out, he pulls away, he resents being looked after. His bisexuality adds a layer that I have not seen handled this way before. Jodi has forgotten not only Rupert but the long process of accepting his own attraction to men, so he has to do that work a second time. Supporting characters, including Rupert's daughter and a couple of close friends, are pleasant but lightly drawn, and a StoryGraph reader, nickoliver, felt the family side was thin.

Writing and Pacing

The writing is where the book is most uneven. The dialogue is good, very London and very Irish, and Owens praised it for sounding like real British people talking. The narration is looser. PW was blunt about some clumsy sentences, and I hit a few that made me wince.

Pacing is the bigger split. The early present-day chapters are short and the flashbacks keep interrupting, which nickoliver found frustrating; I mostly liked the rhythm, but I can see how it would grate if you want to stay in the present. The real stumble is a late-act plot contrivance that PW flagged and I would not argue with. It feels bolted on to create one more crisis the story did not need. The ending recovers, and the 2022 edition adds an extended epilogue, though Love Bytes noted that epilogue mainly introduces Leigh's later book Misfits rather than adding to Jodi and Rupert's story.

What Remains is a tender, clumsy, affecting amnesia romance where the forgotten partner carries the book. Read it if you want an established couple rebuilt from the ground up; skip it if uneven prose and a late contrivance will spoil the ride.

How Spicy Is What Remains?

What Remains is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. Romance.io readers rate it 4 of 5 for steam, and PW described it as escapist erotic romance with plenty of sex. Most of the explicit scenes sit in the flashback chapters, where Jodi and Rupert are newly in love.

In the present timeline, intimacy is slower and more careful, because Jodi does not remember Rupert and is unsure of his own desires. The book treats that hesitation with care. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reports and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read What Remains?

What Remains suits readers who want an emotional MM romance about an established couple, told through two timelines, with a hero who has to earn love twice and a recovery plot that takes brain injury seriously. It is less suited to readers who want fast pacing, polished prose or a story without a partner withholding the truth.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

What Remains has a small but loyal readership, mostly MM review blogs and reader platforms rather than mainstream outlets. Publishers Weekly is the exception, and its review was mixed: interested in the premise and the replayed attraction, unimpressed by the writing and a late contrivance.

Where they agree. The structure and the emotion. All About Romance's Caz Owens called it a compelling read and praised the timelines, the dialogue and the lack of a magical cure. Jules at The Novel Approach gave it five stars and praised its realistic picture of life after a traumatic brain injury. Valerie at Love Bytes gave the 2022 edition 4.5 hearts and found the nonlinear structure easy to follow.

Where they split. Pacing and Rupert's secret. J.L. Gribble struggled with Rupert hiding their relationship at first. StoryGraph reader nickoliver wanted more present-day development and less flashback. PW thought the prose let down the drama. On audio, The Novel Approach found Craig Beck's narration excellent once he settled into Rupert's accent.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

What Remains scores 7.9 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its highest mark for emotional impact and lower marks for writing and reread appeal, where uneven prose and a late contrivance hold it back.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Two love stories in one, per All About Romance; the replayed attraction works, per Publishers Weekly.
Characters (15%)4Rupert is affecting if a little too good, per All About Romance; Jodi is allowed to be difficult.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Strong dialogue, clumsy narration and choppy early pacing, per PW and StoryGraph reader nickoliver.
Emotional impact (15%)4.5A realistic picture of life after brain injury, per The Novel Approach, and Rupert's grief lands.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the steam promised, rated 4 of 5 by Romance.io readers, mostly in the flashbacks.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4An earned HEA with no magical cure, per All About Romance, reached past a late contrivance.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5The emotional peaks are worth revisiting; the slow middle and the contrivance less so.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: What Remains is one of Garrett Leigh's most emotional standalones and a standout among MM amnesia romances, landing at a final Eikna Score of 7.9/10.

Is What Remains a Standalone?

What Remains is a standalone. the author's own site lists it with Leigh's standalone novels, Jodi and Rupert's story is complete in one book, and you need nothing else to read it. The 2022 second edition adds an extended epilogue that links to Leigh's later novel Misfits, but it is a bonus rather than a sequel.

Best format: the audiobook is a strong choice. Craig Beck handles the London and Irish voices well, and the dated chapter headings make the time jumps easy to follow by ear. Our series order guide covers connected MM romances if you want a longer run.

If You Loved What Remains, Read These Next

If you loved What Remains, look for MM romances about couples who have to rebuild what they had, and for books that treat care and recovery as part of the love story.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Remains prompts the same questions from most readers: whether Jodi gets his memory back, how spicy it is, and whether it stands alone. Short answers below.

Is What Remains spicy?

Yes. What Remains is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit scenes, most of them in the flashback chapters.

Is What Remains a standalone?

Yes. What Remains is a complete standalone; the 2022 edition's extended epilogue links to Misfits but is not a sequel.

Does What Remains have a happy ending?

Yes. Jodi and Rupert get a happily ever after, built on a new relationship rather than a sudden return of memory.

Does Jodi get his memory back in What Remains?

Not in a magical rush. All About Romance notes there is no miracle cure, and the couple rebuild instead.

Is What Remains a second chance romance?

Not exactly. The couple never break up, but because Jodi forgets Rupert, they effectively fall in love a second time.

Is there a What Remains audiobook?

Yes. Riptide published an audiobook narrated by Craig Beck, running about 7 hours 4 minutes.

What is the difference between the 2016 and 2022 editions of What Remains?

The 2022 second edition has a new cover and an extended bonus epilogue; the main story is the same.

The Bottom Line

What Remains earns a 7.9/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want an established couple torn apart by memory loss and stitched back together slowly, with real steam in the flashbacks and a recovery that feels lived rather than tidy. The reason to pick it up is Rupert: few romances give the forgotten partner this much room to grieve.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.