Overall ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ 4.14 Goodreads average, about 4.6 million ratings
- ✓ Series sales over 13 million copies
- ✓ Sequel rated far higher at 4.63
- ✓ Slow first half dominates the criticism
A Court of Thorns and Roses Review: YA or Adult, Spice and Series
This review contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Eikna Romance earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Verdict: A fae bargain story with a gripping final third and a heroine readers rally behind, held back by a slow first half that sends a steady stream of readers to the DNF pile and a romance that the series itself later rewrites.
Best for: Readers who want the book that started the romantasy boom, who will give a slow faerie manor stretch 200 pages to turn into a trial plot, and who can forgive a love interest that much of the fandom now treats as a warm up act.
Heat level: ★★★☆☆ (3/5, romance.io gives book 1 a steam rating of 3 out of 5; open door, a handful of scenes, with the series getting steamier from book 2)
Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.8/5, a 4.14 Goodreads average across about 4.6 million ratings, pulled down because the slow first half is the complaint that comes up in nearly every critical review we read, from School Library Journal to DNF blogs)
Tropes: Human and fae romance, Beauty and the Beast retelling, Magical bargain, Masked court and a curse, Huntress heroine, Cruel faerie queen, Trials to win a lover's freedom, Love triangle set up, Sisters she would die for, Brooding High Lord.
A Court of Thorns and Roses is the first of Sarah J. Maas's ACOTAR novels, a fantasy romance set between a starving human village and the faerie lands of Prythian, in which Feyre Archeron, a nineteen year old huntress who kills a wolf to feed her family, is claimed in payment by Tamlin, a masked High Lord of the Spring Court who needs something from a human that he can't ask for outright.
The scale is enormous. Goodreads shows a 4.14 average from about 4.6 million ratings and roughly 347,000 written reviews, and Wikipedia puts series sales at more than 13 million copies. Yet this is the second lowest rated full book in the series on Goodreads, well below A Court of Mist and Fury at 4.63, and with book 6 due on October 27, 2026, a fresh wave of readers is starting here right now. Most finish the series. The split is over whether book 1 is worth reading for itself or only as the ticket to book 2, and that is the question worth settling before you buy.
What Is A Court of Thorns and Roses About?
This is a fairy tale that turns into a survival story. The first half is set at Tamlin's spring manor, a house of masked servants, rose gardens and a creeping sickness called the blight, where Feyre is a guest who can't leave and slowly stops wanting to. Maas built it from Beauty and the Beast and the ballad of Tam Lin, and the bones show: a beast, a curse, a girl who has to see past the mask.
The last third is a different book. The story moves Under the Mountain, into the court of a faerie queen named Amarantha, and becomes a sequence of trials with real violence and a ticking clock. Readers who quit early never reach the part fans remember, and readers who arrive expecting the steamy, sprawling series from TikTok find a tighter, tamer opener whose biggest romantic payoff happens in other books.
What Makes This Fae Bargain Romantasy Work
- Feyre as a heroine: Even critics who disliked the book name her as a strength, a hunter and a fighter who saves the day herself rather than waiting to be saved.
- The Under the Mountain section: Reviewers who nearly gave up, including a 5 star blogger who almost quit twice, say the book turns around near the halfway mark and doesn't let go.
- Rhysand's first appearances: Fans on a long Goodreads ending thread say they preferred him to Tamlin from his first scenes, which is why the series could pivot to him later.
- Planted clues: Several readers say the mysteries of the first half are deliberate and that the hints pay off on a reread, which helps explain why the slow chapters get forgiven.
- The gateway effect: Reddit threads for newcomers repeat the same advice, push through book 1, and readers report finishing all five books in a couple of weeks.
Book Synopsis
Winter has lasted too long in the human lands south of the wall. Feyre Archeron, nineteen, keeps her family alive with a bow and the little she can catch. Her father was once a rich merchant and is now a broken man, her older sister Nesta is all edges, and her gentler sister Elain tends a garden that never quite grows. North of the wall lies Prythian, home of the High Fae, whom humans fear and half remember from old wars.
One afternoon in the snow, Feyre shoots an enormous wolf, sells its pelt and brings home meat. The wolf was a faerie. Days later a creature with horns and claws breaks into the family's cottage and invokes an old treaty: a life taken must be paid with a life. Feyre can die or come with him across the wall and live in Prythian for the rest of her days. She goes, expecting to be killed.
Instead she wakes at a manor in the Spring Court, where her captor turns out to be Tamlin, a High Lord who wears a mask he cannot remove, as does his sharp tongued emissary Lucien and every servant in the house. Something called the blight is eating away at the magic of Prythian, and nobody will tell her what it is. Feyre plans escapes, paints for the first time in years and starts to see Tamlin less as a jailer. Then, on a night of old fae ritual, she learns the Spring Court is under a threat far larger than one hunter's debt, with a deadline attached.
Our Review
Feyre is the reason this book took off, and the evidence backs that up. She's stubborn, practical, illiterate in a way the book treats with care, and willing to do terrible things for people who haven't earned it. Bianca White, who gave the book 3 stars, still writes that Feyre is not a damsel in distress, and SciFiNow, mixed overall, praised her independence and bravery. When a negative reviewer singles out the heroine, it tells you where the book's strength lies.
We may earn a commission from purchases through our links, at no extra cost to you.
The second strength is the turn Under the Mountain. Once the story leaves the Spring Court, Maas tightens everything: the stakes are a riddle, three trials and a queen who enjoys cruelty, and the violence is real enough that Common Sense Media flags torture and gore as a constant presence. This is also where Rhysand, High Lord of the Night Court, steps in as an ambiguous ally. Miranda Reads, who gave the book 5 stars, says things turned around around the halfway mark, and that line describes a lot of reader experience.
Where it struggles is the first half, and that is the dominant complaint by a wide margin. School Library Journal called the pacing uneven, with a sluggish beginning and a sudden information dump. A 2015 blogger DNF'd at 50 percent, a Cannonball Read reviewer gave it 2 stars for mostly watching Feyre and Tamlin have dinner, and the same Miranda Reads review that ended at 5 stars found the heroine maddening for the first 200 pages. Behind that sit smaller, recurring problems: the Tamlin romance reads as rushed or tame to several reviewers, a midpoint scene with Tamlin that's meant to be heated left at least one reader creeped out, and SciFiNow found Amarantha theatrical and the ending's cure far fetched.
Reset one expectation before you start, and it's a spoiler for the series, not this book. Much of the fandom's love for ACOTAR belongs to book 2, where the romance shifts away from Tamlin and the Spring Court is shown in a very different light. Read book 1 knowing that and you'll notice Rhysand's every line. Read it cold and you'll get a complete Beauty and the Beast arc that the sequel then questions. If you want the full experience, treat this as part one. If you want a self contained romance, this isn't quite it.
The second thing to know is that Rhysand's book 1 behaviour is a live argument. Under the Mountain he keeps Feyre drugged on faerie wine and makes her dance and dress for the court, and Plugged In describes these scenes as coercive. Fans defend him on the grounds that he is acting under Amarantha's control; one reader on the Goodreads thread said the scenes made her physically sick. Both camps are right about what's on the page, and how you read it will shape how you feel about the series that follows.
On the line level, the prose is quick and plain, which is why people finish all five books in a fortnight. It's also why critics such as SLJ felt the characters lacked depth. Maas writes momentum better than she writes stillness, and the book's structure, a long still stretch followed by a long run of momentum, shows both sides of that.
Our honest note: A slow, fairy tale first half and a fierce final third, held together by a heroine readers love and a romance the series later rethinks. Read it if you plan to continue into A Court of Mist and Fury and can give it 200 pages; skip it if you want a standalone romance that pays off on its own terms.
| Element | In A Court of Thorns and Roses |
|---|---|
| Central relationship | Feyre Archeron, a mortal huntress, and Tamlin, High Lord of the Spring Court, with Rhysand of the Night Court in the wings |
| Core tropes | Beauty and the Beast retelling, magical bargain, curse and masks, trials, love triangle set up |
| Setting | A human village south of the wall, Tamlin's Spring Court manor and Amarantha's court Under the Mountain in Prythian |
| Heat level | 3/5, open door with a handful of scenes, mostly in the second half; later books get steamier |
| Series | ACOTAR #1 of 5 published; book 6 due October 27, 2026 and book 7 January 12, 2027, with more to come |
| Content notes | Graphic violence, torture and gore, sexual assault and coercion, forced intoxication, emotional manipulation, poverty and a family's ruin; Common Sense Media rates it 16+ |
How Spicy Is A Court of Thorns and Roses?
Moderately, and less than its reputation. romance.io gives book 1 a steam rating of 3 out of 5, the same as books 2 to 4, with A Court of Silver Flames rising to 4. Plugged In counts four sexual encounters, from Feyre's casual affair with a village boy to scenes with Tamlin, and at least one is described in detail. Common Sense Media lists intercourse, oral sex and nudity. We put it at 3: the door is open, but the scenes are few, short and clustered in the second half.
The spice gap between book 1 and the rest of the series is the thing to know. Bianca White called book 1 low steam and very tame, while the fandom's famous scenes belong to A Court of Mist and Fury and A Court of Silver Flames, and Bark's parent review warns the content gets more explicit in later books. If TikTok sold you the series on heat, book 1 will feel restrained. If you came from YA fantasy, it's a clear step up.
Who Should Read This Book?
You'll likely love it if: you like fairy tale retellings with teeth, you want a heroine who rescues the hero, and you're happy to read book 1 as the opening act of a five book story.
You may want to skip it if: slow world building in a single setting tests your patience, coercion played as a gray area bothers you, or you need the first book's romance to be the one that lasts.
In short: a necessary first chapter more than a standalone triumph; the final third and the sequel are what keep people reading.
What Readers Are Actually Saying (October 2026)
Eleven years after publication, the conversation around A Court of Thorns and Roses is mostly a conversation about starting the series. The book was published as YA by Bloomsbury in 2015, nominated for a Goodreads Choice Award in Young Adult Fantasy, and then reissued with new covers in 2020, when booksellers moved it out of the teen section. The Hulu adaptation with Ronald D. Moore was cancelled in February 2025, and in March 2026 Maas said on Call Her Daddy that she now has the rights back. Add the announcement of books 6 and 7, with covers revealed in August, and the book is selling to a new set of first time readers this autumn. We could not open StoryGraph or full Reddit threads for this review, so the reader picture here comes from Goodreads, blogs, Reddit mirrors and trade reviews.
Why readers love it: Readers love Feyre, the trials and the sense of a world much bigger than the manor. A Reddit thread for newcomers is full of people who read all five books in two weeks and wish they could forget them and start again, and Audible's edition, narrated by Jennifer Ikeda at 16 hours and 7 minutes, holds a 4.6 average across about 79,600 listener ratings. The 5 star reviews tend to describe the same arc: unsure for half the book, then hooked by Under the Mountain, then straight on to book 2.
What readers argue about and complain about: The complaint is the pacing, and it isn't close. SLJ, SciFiNow, Bianca White, Cannonball Read, Love Is Not a Triangle and even the 5 star Miranda Reads all flag a slow first half. The second strand is Tamlin, who a reader on the Goodreads ending thread called boring and whom others found a flat golden boy next to Rhysand. The third is consent: Plugged In and Bark both describe coercive scenes Under the Mountain, and fans and critics still argue about how much to excuse Rhysand for them. A smaller group defends Tamlin, and a long running Goodreads thread is titled as a case against vilifying him.
The series question worth asking first: Book 1 resolves its main plot and doesn't end on a hard cliffhanger, but it sets up a love triangle and the bigger story, and SciFiNow judged the closing hook weak. The series is not finished. Five books are out: A Court of Mist and Fury at 4.63 on Goodreads, A Court of Wings and Ruin at 4.46, the novella A Court of Frost and Starlight at 3.70 and A Court of Silver Flames at 4.45. A Court of Splintered Harmony follows on October 27, 2026 and A Court of Forgotten Melody on January 12, 2027, and Maas has said these are not the conclusion.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is A Court of Thorns and Roses YA or adult?
It's adult now. Bloomsbury published it as YA in 2015, and PW listed it for ages 14 and up, but the series was reissued in 2020 and moved out of the teen section. Common Sense Media rates it 16+, and Wikipedia calls the series New Adult.
How spicy is A Court of Thorns and Roses?
Moderately. romance.io rates book 1 at 3 out of 5 for steam, with a few open door scenes mostly in the second half. Later books are steamier, and A Court of Silver Flames rises to 4 out of 5.
Is the ACOTAR series finished?
No. Five books are out, book 6 arrives on October 27, 2026 and book 7 on January 12, 2027, and Maas has said more is still to come after those two.
Does Feyre end up with Tamlin?
Not for good, and that's a series spoiler. Book 1 centres Feyre and Tamlin, but from A Court of Mist and Fury the main romance is with Rhysand, which is why fans tell newcomers to watch him closely.
Is there an ACOTAR TV show?
Not yet. Hulu's adaptation was cancelled in February 2025, and in March 2026 Maas said she has the rights back. No studio has been confirmed.
Do I need to read Throne of Glass first?
No. ACOTAR is a separate series and book 1 needs no other Maas book. Some readers speculate about crossovers in the new books, but that's fan theory.
If You Loved A Court of Thorns and Roses, Read These Next
For a sheltered heroine, a guard she shouldn't trust and a slow reveal of who he really is, read From Blood and Ash. If it was the dark prince and the bargain you liked, try Kingdom of the Wicked. And for the other romantasy giant of the decade, with more heat and a dragon war college, read Fourth Wing.
Browse more in fantasy romance, forbidden love romance and spicy romance.
The Bottom Line
A Court of Thorns and Roses sets out to retell Beauty and the Beast with the fae as monsters, and its best idea is to make the beauty the one who fights. What works: Feyre, the Under the Mountain trials and the first sight of Rhysand. What doesn't: a first half many readers nearly quit, a Tamlin romance that several reviewers call tame, and coercive scenes the book leaves murky. If you're reading it as the opening of a five book series, it does its job and then some. If you want a romance that stands alone, this one hands its real payoff to the sequel.
The Eikna Overall Ranking
On the Eikna scale, A Court of Thorns and Roses ranks as an essential but uneven series opener, strongest in its final third and its heroine, constrained by a slow first half and a romance the sequel overturns, and best approached as the doorway to A Court of Mist and Fury rather than as a self contained love story.
The Evidence Scorecard
Eight dimensions, each scored out of 5 from the reader and critic evidence above. Overall is anchored on the reader ratings and adjusted for how much the recurring complaints cost the reading experience. Heat describes how explicit the book is; it is not a quality judgement. Every line marked ✓ is a checked finding, including the limits. How we assess books.
Romance ★★★★☆ 3.5/5
- ✓ Beauty and the Beast arc completes in book
- ✓ Rhysand's scenes draw the strongest reader reaction
- ✓ Trials give the romance real stakes
- ✓ Tamlin pairing called rushed and tame
Characters ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Feyre praised even by negative reviewers
- ✓ Rhysand a fan favourite from first scene
- ✓ Lucien and Feyre's sisters add texture
- ✓ SLJ found characters lacking depth
Writing ★★★★☆ 3.7/5
- ✓ Plain, quick prose keeps readers moving
- ✓ Planted clues reward a second read
- ✓ Final third tightens into a trial plot
- ✓ SLJ flags sluggish start and info dump
Emotional impact ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Under the Mountain trials land hard
- ✓ Feyre's sacrifice for family drives stakes
- ✓ Readers rush through all five books
- ✓ Violence and coercion unsettle some readers
Heat level ★★★☆☆ 3/5
- ✓ romance.io steam rating 3 of 5
- ✓ Plugged In counts four sexual encounters
- ✓ Scenes clustered in the second half
- ✓ Far tamer than books 2 and 5
Ending ★★★★☆ 3.8/5
- ✓ Main plot resolves, no hard cliffhanger
- ✓ Climax praised as the book's peak
- ✓ Sets up the series' larger story
- ✓ SciFiNow calls the cure far fetched
Re-read value ★★★★☆ 4/5
- ✓ Gateway book for a five book series
- ✓ Clues read differently after book 2
- ✓ Audible edition rated 4.6 by listeners
- ✓ Many rereaders skip straight to book 2
Sources We Checked
- Goodreads: A Court of Thorns and Roses
- Goodreads: A Court of Thorns and Roses series page (ratings for books 1 to 7)
- Goodreads discussion: What do we think about the ending with Rhysand
- romance.io: A Court of Thorns and Roses series (steam ratings)
- Wikipedia: A Court of Thorns and Roses
- Publishers Weekly: A Court of Thorns and Roses review
- School Library Journal: A Court of Thorns and Roses review
- SciFiNow: A Court of Thorns and Roses review
- Common Sense Media: A Court of Thorns and Roses parents' guide
- Bark: A Court of Thorns and Roses content review
- Plugged In: A Court of Thorns and Roses
- Willamette Week: ACOTAR shelving and the 2020 reissue
- Bookstacked: ACOTAR new covers (2020)
- Book Riot: Hulu's ACOTAR adaptation is dead
- TheWrap: Sarah J. Maas says she has the ACOTAR TV rights back
- Scary Mommy: ACOTAR books 6 and 7 release dates
- Book Riot: Covers of ACOTAR books 6 and 7
- Audible: A Court of Thorns and Roses audiobook
- Miranda Reads: A Court of Thorns and Roses
- Bianca White: A Court of Thorns and Roses review
- Cannonball Read: Mostly boring dinners
- Love Is Not a Triangle: DNF review
- r/acotar (mirror): New to ACOTAR thread
- StoryGraph (JavaScript rendered, not checked for this review)
Checked October 6, 2026. Ratings and counts change; the numbers above are as of that date.
Affiliate disclosure: Eikna Romance is a participant in the Amazon Associates Program. If you buy through a link on this page we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.