eikna romance
Menu

Five Dares by Eli Easton Review

Eikna Score: 6.8/10. Recommended with reservations.

Five Dares has one of the most ridiculous setups in MM romance: two best friends burn their hands in a graduation prank and spend the summer unable to take care of themselves, so they start taking care of each other. It is funny, very explicit and sweet underneath, but the flashbacks, the slow first half and Andy's pushiness keep it from being more.

Read it if you want a low-angst, high-heat best friends to lovers story with a goofy hook, or you like a pining best friend. Skip it if you need a plausible premise, or a lead who pressures his friend and sulks when told no would sour it for you.

Five Dares by Eli Easton book cover

Five Dares at a Glance

Five Dares is a standalone MM new adult romance by Eli Easton, published by Riptide Publishing in October 2017. Lifelong best friends Andy and Jake, both injured in a firework stunt, turn a summer of recovery into a series of sexual dares. It runs 245 pages, is very explicit and ends with an HEA.

AuthorEli Easton
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreMM romance, new adult, contemporary romance
Main tropesBest friends to lovers, secret pining, forced proximity, hurt and comfort, sexual discovery
Spice level5/5: Very explicit, sex central to the plot
Content warningsBurn injuries, temporary dependence, a controlling father, one scene of suicidal thoughts (full list below)
POVDual, Andy and Jake
EndingHEA, with an epilogue
Pages245 (trade paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Tristan Josiah, about 6 hours (Riptide Publishing)
First publishedOctober 2, 2017
PublisherRiptide Publishing

What Is Five Dares About?

Five Dares begins with a prank gone wrong. Andy Tyler and Jake Masterson have been best friends since middle school and pranking partners for just as long. At their college graduation, a firecracker stunt backfires and burns both their palms badly. Neither of them can use his hands.

They spend the summer recovering together at Andy's family cottage on the Massachusetts coast, bandaged, bored and in need of help with everything. Frustration turns into a dare, and the dare turns into a habit. What Andy does not know is that Jake has been quietly in love with him for years, and every dare costs Jake more than it costs Andy.

What Makes This Friends to Lovers Romance Work

Five Dares works because its best friends to lovers romance gives the trope a physical reason to change. Andy and Jake literally cannot look after themselves, so intimacy arrives through need before either of them admits to desire. That gets two guys who have never touched each other past the awkward first step fast, and with a lot of laughs.

The second engine is Jake's secret. The book is a comedy on the surface and a pining story underneath, and Easton plays the gap well: Andy treats the dares as a game, Jake treats them as the thing he has wanted for years and cannot ask for. Publishers Weekly called the premise a bit unlikely but said the characters' shared history and chemistry make up for it, which is exactly the bargain the book asks you to accept.

My Review

Five Dares is the kind of book I recommend with a raised eyebrow. The premise is absurd, the sex starts early and does not let up, and the whole thing is a lot more fun than it has any right to be. I also wanted to shake Andy several times.

Eli Easton is a skilled, funny writer, and the book clearly enjoys its own setup. Two newly graduated twenty-somethings who cannot open a jar, unzip their own jeans or scratch an itch are a gift to a comic writer, and the early chapters land a lot of jokes.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry between Andy and Jake comes from history. They have been inseparable since middle school, and their teasing has the ease of people who have nothing left to prove to each other. When the dares start, that ease is what makes them work: they trust each other enough to try things, and the book is frank and specific about what they try. Love Bytes Reviews said the sex scenes are hot and do a lot for the storyline, and I agree they carry the relationship forward rather than pause it.

The pining is the emotional core. Jake has loved Andy for years, and his point of view is where the book gets its ache. The trouble is Andy. The Novel Approach reviewer found him selfish at times, pushing Jake to keep going and sulking when Jake says no, and that matched my experience. The book knows Andy is careless with Jake's feelings. It forgives him a little faster than I did.

The Characters

Jake is the easier one to love: steady, funny and hiding a lot. Andy is more complicated than he first looks, which the Novel Approach also noted, and his relationship with his controlling father adds weight to what otherwise reads as a sunny summer. That father is a frequent topic in Goodreads reviews, and he gives Andy a reason for some of his choices without excusing them.

The side characters are thin. Love Bytes found the secondary cast forgettable, and the Novel Approach thought the women and the strict father came across as one-dimensional. This is a two-hander, and anyone else on the page mostly exists to interrupt.

Writing and Pacing

The structure is the book's weakest point. Easton alternates the summer with flashbacks to the friendship's past, and while those flashbacks explain Jake's feelings, they also break the momentum. Love Bytes said the alternating timeline disrupted the flow and the first half felt slow, heavy on internal monologue, with the switching points of view sometimes making the angst repetitive. Goodreads readers make the same complaint.

The ending moves in the opposite direction: fast. Some Goodreads readers found the final grand gesture abrupt or over the top. I liked its sweetness and wished it had been given another chapter of setup.

Five Dares is a funny, very steamy best friends to lovers romance whose silly premise works better than its structure. Read it if you want low-angst heat and a pining best friend, and skip it if you need a hero who never pushes his luck.

How Spicy Is Five Dares?

Five Dares is a 5 out of 5 on our scale: Very explicit, sex central to the plot. The dares are the plot, so sex is on the page early and often, and the scenes are detailed. Publishers Weekly said the book will appeal most to fans of queer erotic romance. Andy and Jake are both adults, just out of college.

Consent note: the dares are agreed to by both men, but some reviewers flag that Andy pressures Jake to go further and sulks when refused. If you are interested in the heat, our spicy romance list and the romance heat levels guide are good next stops.

Content warnings, drawn from the publisher description and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Five Dares?

Five Dares suits readers who want a short, funny, very explicit MM friends to lovers romance with a pining best friend and little angst. It is less suited to readers who need a believable setup, a tight structure or a hero who always respects a no the first time.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Five Dares holds a 3.88 average from more than 5,000 Goodreads ratings. Beyond a short Publishers Weekly notice, coverage comes mostly from MM review blogs and reader reviews.

Where they agree. The humor and the heat. Publishers Weekly said the history and chemistry compensate for the premise, Love Bytes Reviews gave the audiobook four hearts and called it humorous and well written, and Goodreads readers praise the chemistry, the steam and the sweet epilogue. Narrator Tristan Josiah gets high marks from both audio reviewers.

Where they split. Structure and Andy. Love Bytes found the flashbacks disruptive and the first half slow. The Novel Approach rated the story three and a half stars, called it low-angst, bro-tastic new adult fun, and found Andy hard to like when he pressures Jake. Goodreads readers are divided on the flashbacks, the abrupt grand gesture and whether the book handles bisexuality well.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Five Dares scores 6.8 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top mark for heat, which the premise is built to deliver, and its lowest for writing, emotional impact and reread appeal, where reviewers point to disruptive flashbacks, a slow first half and a pushy lead.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Easy, trusting chemistry and real pining; Andy's pushiness undercuts it, per The Novel Approach.
Characters (15%)3.5Jake and Andy are layered; Love Bytes finds the side cast forgettable.
Writing and pacing (15%)3Funny prose, but Love Bytes and Goodreads readers find the flashbacks disruptive.
Emotional impact (15%)3Sweet but low-angst; the pining lands more than the drama.
Heat level (10%)4.5Delivers frequent explicit scenes, as Publishers Weekly signals for erotic romance fans.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A warm HEA, though Goodreads readers find the grand gesture abrupt.
Reread appeal (10%)3Fun once; the structure makes rereading less tempting.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Five Dares is a lighter, steamier entry in Eli Easton's catalogue and a middling one within MM new adult, and it earns a final Eikna Score of 6.8/10.

Is Five Dares a Standalone?

Yes. Five Dares is a standalone novel with no series attached, so you can start and finish Andy and Jake's story in this one book. Best format: the Riptide audiobook narrated by Tristan Josiah, about six hours, which both audio reviewers praised for giving Andy and Jake distinct voices and the humor its timing.

If you want more connected MM romances after this, our series order guide covers the long-running ones.

If You Loved Five Dares, Read These Next

If you loved Five Dares, the closest matches are MM romances with old friends, a summer together and a first time that changes everything.

Frequently Asked Questions

Five Dares raises the same questions for most readers: how spicy it is, whether it is part of a series, whether it ends happily and what age range it suits. Short answers below.

Is Five Dares spicy?

Very. Five Dares is a 5 out of 5 on our scale; the sexual dares are the plot, and the scenes are frequent and explicit.

Is Five Dares part of a series?

No. Five Dares is a standalone novel by Eli Easton.

Does Five Dares have a happy ending?

Yes. Andy and Jake get an HEA, with a romantic grand gesture and an epilogue.

Is Five Dares new adult?

Yes. Andy and Jake have just graduated from college, and reviewers describe it as new adult. It is written for adult readers because of its explicit content.

Is there a Five Dares audiobook?

Yes. Riptide Publishing released an audiobook narrated by Tristan Josiah, running about six hours.

The Bottom Line

Five Dares earns a 6.8/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a short, funny, very explicit best friends to lovers romance and do not mind a premise that requires a shrug. The one reason to pick it up is Jake: his years of quiet pining give a goofy summer story the ache that makes it stick.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.