Trick Play by Eden Finley Review
Eikna Score: 7.6/10. Recommended.
Trick Play is the Fake Boyfriend book where the fake relationship has real teeth: an outed NFL tight end needs a boyfriend for the cameras, and the rich kid who volunteers is mostly doing it to embarrass his father. The banter carries it, the family drama sometimes drags, and the payoff lands warmer than the setup promises.
Read it if you love fake dating with a public audience, or you want a prickly, funny love interest hiding a softer core. Skip it if you are tired of outing plots and homophobic sports media, or you want a book that stands entirely apart from its series.
Trick Play at a Glance
Trick Play is book 2 of Eden Finley's Fake Boyfriend series, a self-published MM sports romance first released in June 2018. It pairs NFL player Matt Jackson with Noah Huntington III in a fake relationship for the press, runs 328 pages in paperback, has steamy open-door scenes and ends happily.
| Author | Eden Finley |
|---|---|
| Series | Fake Boyfriend, book 2 (each book follows a new couple) |
| Subgenre | MM romance, sports romance (American football) |
| Main tropes | Fake dating, enemies to lovers (mild), outed athlete, rich boy with a political family, found family |
| Spice level | 4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes |
| Content warnings | Forced outing, homophobia, press intrusion, family rejection (full list below) |
| POV | Dual, Matt and Noah |
| Ending | HEA; the couple ends together, with the friend group carried into later books |
| Pages | 328 (paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Alexander Cendese and Iggy Toma, about 8 hours (Tantor Audio, 2018) |
| First published | June 25, 2018 |
| Publisher | Independently published |
What Is Trick Play About?
Trick Play opens with Matt Jackson already in trouble. A photo of the NFL tight end at a gay bar has gone public, his career is wobbling, and the only thing he wants is to get back on a roster. His agent, Damon, has an idea: if Matt is going to be the out football player, he should at least look happy about it.
Enter Noah Huntington III, rich, mouthy and a friend of Damon's, who agrees to play the boyfriend largely because it will annoy his politician father. Matt thinks Noah is arrogant. Noah thinks Matt is a grump. They have to convince teams, cameras and families anyway, and the act gets harder to keep up once it stops feeling like one.
What Makes This Fake Dating Romance Work
Trick Play works because its fake dating romance has an audience with something at stake. Matt is not pretending for a wedding weekend; he is pretending for general managers and photographers while his career depends on how the story plays. That pressure makes every public touch between Matt and Noah feel like a performance and a risk at once.
The second engine is Noah. He is the kind of love interest who deflects everything with a joke and a price tag, and the book slowly lets you see what the jokes are covering. Becca at Love Bytes Reviews liked his humor and flirtation but said the real pleasure was the softer side under the defensive front, and that is the right read on him.
Readers who come to fake dating for the moment the act turns real will find it here, and the football frame gives the trope more weight than usual.
My Review
I came to Trick Play straight from Fake Out, and the change in temperature is obvious within a chapter. The first book is a breezy holiday weekend. This one starts with a man whose private life has just been made public against his will, and Eden Finley lets that sting for a while before she lets the jokes in.
That choice is the best thing about the book and the source of its slowest stretch. Matt is bitter, and the early chapters spend a lot of time in that bitterness. Goodreads readers who mention a slow start are not wrong. Once Noah is in the room, though, the book picks up and mostly stays up.
Romance and Chemistry
The chemistry is the reason to read this. Matt and Noah do not like each other at first, and Finley gets real mileage from the gap between how they act in public and how they bicker in private. The fake relationship gives them an excuse to touch, and the book is honest about how quickly that excuse wears thin. Love Bytes called the growing bond between them the core of the book, and I agree. They share pasts that neither likes talking about, and the scenes where those come out are quieter and better than the set pieces.
Some readers on Goodreads felt the relationship moved too fast or lacked depth. I see it in the middle third, where the pair go from mutual irritation to something tender with fewer steps than I wanted. It did not stop me caring. It did make the third act feel slightly pre-arranged.
The Characters
Noah is the star. He is rich in the specific, slightly obnoxious way of someone who learned early that money is the only language his family speaks, and his snark is a shield. A few Goodreads reviewers expected more of the Noah they met in Fake Out and found him gentler here. I liked the gentler version; it is the point of the book.
Matt is harder to love on the page because he spends so long angry, but his anger is earned, and his relationship with his younger brother Jet is one of the warmest threads in the book. Jet steals scenes, and readers who loved him here get his own story later in the series. Damon and Maddox from book 1 drift through as friends, which gives the whole thing a found family feel.
Writing and Pacing
Finley writes in a quick, conversational style with lots of dialogue, and the jokes mostly land. The weak point is the family drama. Noah's father is a politician with a cold streak, and the book returns to that conflict often enough that some Goodreads readers called it overdone. I found the father convincing and a little repetitive. The football material is light: you need no knowledge of the NFL to follow Matt's free agency worries, and the book treats the sport as a pressure on him rather than a playbook.
At 328 pages it is a fair length, though the middle could lose twenty without anyone noticing. The ending is warm and gives both men a resolution that feels like a choice rather than a reward.
Trick Play is a funnier and sharper fake dating romance than its slow opening suggests, with a love interest worth the price of entry. Read it if you liked Fake Out or want an MM sports romance where the publicity stunt is the plot, and forgive the family drama for overstaying.
How Spicy Is Trick Play?
Trick Play is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. Once the fake relationship turns physical, the sex is on the page and frank, and there is more than one scene. It is consensual and adult throughout. The heat builds rather than opens the book, so the first stretch is mostly tension and argument.
For more in this range, see our spicy romance list; the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Content warnings, drawn from the publisher description and reader reviews:
- Forced outing of a closeted athlete via a published photo
- Homophobia in professional sport and the media
- Paparazzi and press intrusion
- Career discrimination and uncertainty
- An emotionally cold, controlling political father; family rejection
- Alcohol
- Explicit on-page sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Trick Play?
Trick Play suits readers who want a fake dating MM romance with banter, a public relationship under pressure and a warm friend group around it. It is less suited to readers who want very little angst, or who find outing plots painful to read.
Best for:
- Fans of Fake Out who want to stay with the same circle of friends
- Readers who love a snarky love interest with a soft center
- Anyone who likes fake dating played for the cameras
- Readers new to MM sports romance who do not care much about the sport
Not for:
- Readers who need the leads to like each other from page one
- Anyone who finds extended family drama tiresome
- Readers sensitive to homophobia and forced outing storylines
- People who want a book with no ties to a wider series
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Trick Play is one of the better rated books in the Fake Boyfriend series, with a 4.12 average from more than 21,000 Goodreads ratings. Professional reviews are scarce, as with most self-published MM romance, so most of the conversation lives in blogs and reader reviews.
Where they agree. The banter and chemistry. Becca at Love Bytes Reviews gave it 4.5 hearts, called the series fun and singled out Noah's humor and the way he and Matt come to care for each other. Goodreads reviewers repeatedly praise the witty exchanges, the side characters (Jet above all) and the steam.
Where they split. Pacing and the drama. Several Goodreads readers found the start slow and the middle sluggish, some felt the family conflict was overdone, and others wanted more of Noah's bite from book 1. Love Bytes added a practical warning: readers who skip Fake Out may feel a little lost among the returning characters. The audiobook also splits listeners, with some calling the narration uneven.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Trick Play scores 7.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its strongest marks for the romance, the characters and the steam, and its lowest for writing and pacing, emotional impact and reread appeal, where readers point to a slow start and heavy family drama.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4 | Strong push and pull; Love Bytes Reviews calls the growing bond the heart of the book. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Noah and Jet stand out; Goodreads readers praise the side cast. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Quick, funny dialogue; Goodreads readers flag a slow start and sluggish middle. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | The outing gives real stakes, though the family drama repeats itself. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Delivers the explicit payoff the fake relationship builds toward. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 4 | A warm, earned ending for both men, per Love Bytes and reader reviews. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | Banter rereads well; the middle stretch less so. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Trick Play sits among the strongest of the early Fake Boyfriend books, a notch more emotional than Fake Out, and earns a final Eikna Score of 7.6/10.
Fake Boyfriend Series Reading Order
Trick Play is book 2 of Eden Finley's Fake Boyfriend series. Each book follows a new couple from the same circle, so Trick Play can be read alone, but Damon and Maddox from Fake Out appear throughout and later heroes like Jet are introduced here.
- Fake Out (2018): Maddox and Damon
- Trick Play (2018): Matt Jackson and Noah Huntington III
- Deke: Ollie Strömberg and Lennon
- Blindsided: Shane Miller and Marcus Talon
- Hat Trick: Jet Jackson and Caleb "Soren" Sorensen
- Fake Boyfriend Breakaways: short stories, including Rebound (2.5), best read after Trick Play
- Final Play: a Fiji group vacation with the whole cast
Best start: Fake Out, then Trick Play. The Breakaways story Rebound is best read after this book. Best format: the ebook or paperback for the banter, though the Tantor audiobook with Alexander Cendese and Iggy Toma gives each lead his own voice. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved Trick Play, Read These Next
If you loved Trick Play, the closest matches are MM romances with fake relationships, public pressure and a sharp-tongued love interest.
- Fake Out by Eden Finley: book 1, a lighter fake boyfriend weekend with Damon and Maddox.
- Deke by Eden Finley: book 3, a closeted NHL player and a sports reporter who offers to fake it.
- Boyfriend Material by Alexis Hall: a tabloid scandal, a fake relationship for respectability and some of the best banter in the genre.
- Egotistical Puckboy by Eden Finley and Saxon James: Finley again, with hockey, a big ego and a lot of steam.
- Red, White & Royal Blue by Casey McQuiston: a politician's son, a secret relationship and the press closing in.
Frequently Asked Questions
Trick Play raises the same questions for most readers: how spicy it is, whether you need Fake Out first, how it ends and whether there is an audiobook. Short answers below.
Is Trick Play spicy?
Yes. Trick Play is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit, consensual open-door scenes once the fake relationship turns physical.
Do I need to read Fake Out before Trick Play?
No, but it helps. Trick Play follows a new couple, yet characters from Fake Out appear often, and some readers say they felt lost without book 1.
Does Trick Play have a happy ending?
Yes. Matt and Noah end the book together, and the couple appears again later in the Fake Boyfriend series.
What is the Fake Boyfriend reading order?
Fake Out, Trick Play, Deke, Blindsided, Hat Trick, the Fake Boyfriend Breakaways collection and Final Play.
Is there a Trick Play audiobook?
Yes. Tantor Audio released it in 2018, narrated by Alexander Cendese and Iggy Toma, running about 8 hours.
What sport is Trick Play about?
American football. Matt Jackson is an NFL tight end trying to get back on a team after he is outed.
The Bottom Line
Trick Play earns a 7.6/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a steamy MM fake dating romance with a public audience, a grumpy athlete and a rich smart mouth who turns out to be kind. The one reason to pick it up is Noah: Finley builds the whole book around peeling back his act, and it is worth watching.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Fake Boyfriend series, Eden Finley (series order, Breakaways)
- Trick Play (Fake Boyfriend #2), Goodreads (first published date, ratings, reader reviews)
- Trick Play paperback listing, Walmart (ISBN)
- Trick Play audiobook, Blackstone Library (narrators, length, Tantor Audio)
- Book Review: Trick Play, Love Bytes Reviews (Becca)
- Reader reviews on Goodreads and StoryGraph; professional trade reviews of this title were not found
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.