eikna romance
Menu

Fool Hearts by Emmy Sanders Review

Eikna Score: 8.1/10. Recommended.

Fool Hearts is a friends to lovers romance with thirty years of history behind it, and that history is why the payoff lands: by the time Easton catches up, you have watched Wyatt wait for most of his life. The middle sags under grief and Easton's turn arrives a little suddenly, but the pining is the real thing.

Read it if you want long-haul, decades-deep pining that ends in a warm HEA, or you like cowboys, ranch life and two men raising a kid together. Skip it if you want the couple together early, or you cannot enjoy a romance where one lead marries someone else first.

Fool Hearts by Emmy Sanders book cover

Fool Hearts at a Glance

Fool Hearts is the first book in Emmy Sanders's Plum Valley Cowboys series, a self-published MM contemporary romance set on a Texas ranch and first released in March 2022. It follows best friends Wyatt and Easton over three decades, builds slowly to moderate open-door heat and ends with a happily ever after.

AuthorEmmy Sanders
SeriesPlum Valley Cowboys, book 1 of 6 (can be read as a standalone)
SubgenreMM romance, contemporary small-town cowboy romance
Main tropesFriends to lovers, unrequited love and pining, slow burn, late-in-life sexuality awakening, co-parenting
Spice level3/5: Moderate, some open door
Content warningsDeath of a spouse and grief, homophobic parent, outing, long unrequited love (full list below)
POVAlternates between Wyatt and Easton
EndingHEA
PagesAbout 294 (ebook); the paperback runs about 306
AudiobookNarrated by Blake Lockheart, about 8 hours 58 minutes
First publishedMarch 24, 2022
PublisherSelf-published by Emmy Sanders

What Is Fool Hearts About?

Fool Hearts follows Wyatt Montgomery and Easton Moore, best friends who grow up together on Easton's family ranch in Plum Valley, Texas, starting in 1991. Wyatt figures out by sixteen that what he feels for Easton is love. He never says it. Easton marries a woman named Becca, and Wyatt leaves.

When loss hits Easton's family, Wyatt comes home to help raise Easton's young son, Will, and the two men share a house and a child for years. In his thirties, Wyatt decides it is finally time to stop waiting and try to have a life of his own. Easton, who has always felt a little out of step with everyone, starts noticing things about his best friend he never let himself see.

What Makes This Friends to Lovers Romance Work

Fool Hearts works as a friends to lovers romance because Emmy Sanders actually shows the friendship, year by year, instead of summarizing it. The book moves through vignettes from boyhood into middle age, so the reader carries the same weight Wyatt does: every birthday, every bad decision, every time he chose to stay quiet.

That structure makes the eventual shift between the two men feel earned rather than convenient. When Easton finally starts to look at Wyatt differently, it lands on top of decades of shared chores, fights, jokes and a child they both love. Love Bytes reviewer Sadonna called it one of the most thoughtful best friends to lovers stories she had read, and that is the right word for it. It is thoughtful more than it is dramatic.

The ranch matters too. Cattle, a small Texas town and a family that is not uniformly kind give the book texture. If you like your slow burn with real history rather than a few weeks of tension, this is that book.

My Review

I went into Fool Hearts expecting a cowboy romance and came out of it feeling like I had read a small family saga with a love story buried in the middle of it. That is mostly a compliment. Sanders is patient in a way that a lot of self-published MM romance is not, and the patience is the point.

The book is built in parts, each covering a stretch of years. All About Romance reviewer Caz Owens noted the structure runs from a prologue in 1991, when the boys are eleven, through to their mid-thirties. That means a lot of the early book is friendship and nothing else. Wyatt's crush shows up in his teens and stays unspoken; nothing romantic happens between the two of them until they are grown men with a mortgage's worth of history.

Romance and Chemistry

The pining is the best thing in the book. Wyatt is quiet and stubborn and a little self-punishing, and his love for Easton reads less like a crush and more like weather: always there, sometimes bad, never discussed. When Easton marries Becca, the book does not make her a villain, and it does not let Wyatt off the hook for leaving either.

The weak point is the turn. Easton is demisexual, which Owens points out the book makes clear early, and his attraction is supposed to grow out of deep emotional connection. That is a good idea. The execution is uneven. Once Easton notices Wyatt, the romance shifts gears fast, and Owens said plainly that the way Easton's desire wakes up did not work for her. I agree with her about the speed. After two hundred pages of waiting, the get-together felt like it skipped a step or two. I still believed in these two as a couple, because the book had already done the hard work of showing why they fit.

The Characters

Wyatt is the heart. His growth from a lovesick kid into a man who helps raise someone else's son, and is good at it, is the strongest arc in the book. Will, the son, is written as an actual child and not a prop, which Sadonna at Love Bytes singled out too.

Easton is harder to love for a while, and I think that is deliberate. He is slow on the uptake about almost everyone's feelings, including his own. Some readers will find that frustrating. I found it believable, especially once the book frames it as part of who he is rather than a plot convenience.

The secondary cast is mixed. Easton's family is largely supportive, but his father is not, and the eventual apology is thin; Sadonna gave the parents poor marks and I would too. Becca is the real casualty of the structure. Owens felt she came off more as a plot device than a real person, and that is fair. She exists mostly so the story can move.

Writing and Pacing

The prose is plain and warm, with enough ranch detail to make the setting feel lived in. Sanders handles time jumps well; each part announces where you are and you rarely feel lost. Love Bytes noted it reads like the work of a more experienced author than a series opener usually does.

The middle is the problem. The grief section, after the loss in Easton's family, goes on longer than it needs to, and Owens called that stretch meandering and overlong. She is right. There is a version of this book that is forty pages shorter and better for it. I also wanted a little more after the couple finally get together, though the book does give them a later section covering several years, which helps.

A word on Harrison, the vet's assistant who catches Wyatt's eye: he is a good character with an unfinished story, and Love Bytes wanted his own happy ending. That loose thread did not bother me. It made the town feel bigger than the two leads.

Fool Hearts is a patient, generous friends to lovers romance whose decades of history make up for a soggy middle and a rushed turn. Read it if you love pining and found family and do not mind waiting a long time for the first kiss.

How Spicy Is Fool Hearts?

Fool Hearts is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. The first half of the book has no romance between the leads at all, because it is about a friendship and a one-sided love. Once Wyatt and Easton get together as adults, the intimate scenes are on the page and consensual, but they are not the focus of the book. Readers looking for nonstop heat will find this one tame; readers who want the closeness to feel earned will be happy.

Wyatt's teenage feelings are unrequited and never acted on. All romantic and sexual content between the leads happens when both are adults in their thirties. For more books in this heat range, see our romance heat levels guide.

Content warnings, drawn from reviews and reader reports:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Fool Hearts?

Fool Hearts suits readers who love long-game pining, ranch settings and a romance built on years of friendship and shared parenting. It is less suited to readers who want early tension, lots of heat or a fast-moving plot.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Fool Hearts has built a steady reader following since 2022, with a Goodreads average of about 4.1 out of 5 across more than ten thousand ratings according to the aggregated listing on Margins. Coverage is mostly from MM romance blogs and reader reviews rather than trade critics.

Where they agree. The pining and the depth of the friendship. Love Bytes gave it 4.75 hearts and praised Will and the accepting extended family. Caz Owens at All About Romance recommended it, calling it "a love story, plain and simple," and praised Blake Lockheart's narration of the audiobook. A StoryGraph reader called it the ultimate friends to lovers story and said it has become a comfort reread.

Where they split. The middle and the switch. All About Romance found the middle overlong, Becca underwritten and Easton's sudden awakening unconvincing. Love Bytes was much warmer overall but disliked how the parents were handled, especially Easton's father. Readers who come for slow burn tend to forgive the pace; readers who want romance on every page tend not to.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Fool Hearts scores 8.1 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with top marks for romance and emotional impact, where thirty years of pining pay off, and its lowest marks for writing and heat, held back by a slow middle and a quick turn in Easton's feelings.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4.5Decades of pining with a real payoff; Love Bytes calls it unusually thoughtful.
Characters (15%)4Wyatt and Will are vivid; All About Romance finds Becca a plot device.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Clean time jumps, but All About Romance calls the middle overlong.
Emotional impact (15%)4.5Grief, sacrifice and waiting all land; StoryGraph readers tag it emotional and sad.
Heat level (10%)3.5Delivers modest adult open-door intimacy after a long build, as readers expect.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A warm HEA with a later section that lets it breathe.
Reread appeal (10%)4A StoryGraph reader calls it a repeat comfort read.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Fool Hearts is the book that launched Plum Valley Cowboys and sits near the top of the MM friends to lovers books we have covered for sheer pining, landing at a final Eikna Score of 8.1/10.

Plum Valley Cowboys Reading Order

Plum Valley Cowboys has six books, all published in 2022 and 2023. Fool Hearts is book 1 and the right place to start, though the Audible listing says it can be read as a standalone. Later books follow other couples connected to the town.

  1. Book 1: Fool Hearts (2022): Wyatt and Easton
  2. Book 2: Virgin Hearts (2022)
  3. Book 3: Unconventional Hearts (2022)
  4. Book 4: Swan Hearts (2022)
  5. Book 5: Courageous Hearts (2023)
  6. Book 6: Wishing Hearts (2023)

Best format: the audiobook. All About Romance praised Blake Lockheart's baritone and his character work, and a book this driven by voice and memory suits listening. Our series order guide covers more romance series.

If You Loved Fool Hearts, Read These Next

If you loved Fool Hearts, look for MM romances built on long friendships, unspoken feelings and a hero working out who he is later than he expected.

Frequently Asked Questions

Fool Hearts raises the same handful of questions for most new readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how it ends and where to start the series. Short answers below.

Is Fool Hearts spicy?

Moderately. Fool Hearts is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with open-door intimacy between the adult leads that arrives late in a long slow burn.

Is Fool Hearts a standalone?

Fool Hearts is book 1 of the Plum Valley Cowboys series, but Wyatt and Easton's story is complete in this book and it can be read on its own.

Does Fool Hearts have a happy ending?

Yes. Fool Hearts ends with a happily ever after for Wyatt and Easton, followed by a later section that shows their life together.

How old are Wyatt and Easton in Fool Hearts?

The story starts when they are boys in 1991 and runs to their mid-thirties. Wyatt's teenage crush is unspoken, and the romance itself happens when both men are adults.

Is there a Fool Hearts audiobook?

Yes. The Fool Hearts audiobook is narrated by Blake Lockheart and runs about 9 hours.

What is the Plum Valley Cowboys reading order?

Fool Hearts, Virgin Hearts, Unconventional Hearts, Swan Hearts, Courageous Hearts, then Wishing Hearts.

The Bottom Line

Fool Hearts earns a 8.1/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a slow, deeply felt MM friends to lovers romance on a Texas ranch and do not mind spending half the book on friendship before the romance starts. The one reason to pick it up is the waiting itself: Sanders makes thirty years of unspoken love feel heavy enough that the first kiss means something.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.