eikna romance
Menu

Glitterland by Alexis Hall Review

Eikna Score: 8.4/10. Recommended.

Glitterland is a beautifully written, sometimes painful MM romance about a depressed, snobbish writer and the cheerful Essex man who refuses to be dismissed by him. Darian's phonetic dialect will split readers and Ash is hard work for a while, but the prose and the honesty about mental illness make it one of Alexis Hall's essential books.

Read it if you love grumpy sunshine with real stakes, or a romance that treats depression honestly without promising a cure. Skip it if written-out accents drive you mad, or frank discussion of suicide and self-harm is too close to home right now.

Glitterland by Alexis Hall book cover

Glitterland at a Glance

Glitterland is Alexis Hall's debut novel and book 1 of the Spires series, an MM contemporary romance first published by Riptide Publishing in August 2013 and reissued in a revised, expanded edition by Sourcebooks Casablanca on January 17, 2023. Ash Winters is a depressed writer; Darian Taylor is his opposite. It has steamy heat and ends happy for now.

AuthorAlexis Hall
SeriesSpires, book 1 (connected standalones, a new couple in each)
SubgenreMM romance, British contemporary
Main tropesGrumpy sunshine, opposites attract, class clash, hookup to relationship, mental illness representation
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsBipolar depression, past suicide attempt, suicidal ideation, self-harm discussion, panic attacks (full list below)
POVFirst person, Ash
EndingHFN
Pages304 (Sourcebooks Casablanca paperback, 2023)
AudiobookNarrated by Nicholas Boulton, 9 hours 5 minutes (Dreamscape Media, 2024 recording with the bonus material)
First publishedAugust 2013 (Riptide Publishing); revised edition January 17, 2023
PublisherSourcebooks Casablanca (current edition)

What Is Glitterland About?

Glitterland is narrated by Ash Winters, once a bright name in English literary circles and now a clinically depressed writer of pulp crime novels who has more or less given up on being happy. He lives inside his own head, which is an exhausting, funny and frightening place to be.

Then he meets Darian Taylor, a sunny, sparkly, Essex-born man who is everything Ash has been taught to look down on. Ash judges him instantly and wants him anyway. Darian makes him laugh and pulls him out of his anxiety for whole hours at a time. The question the book asks is whether Ash can trust happiness long enough to fight for it, and whether he can stop being cruel to the person offering it.

What Makes This Grumpy Sunshine Romance Work

Glitterland works because the grump is not cute. Ash is a snob, and his depression is not a quirk. The book puts you inside a mind that sabotages every good thing, and makes the romance about whether love can coexist with that rather than cure it. Mimi Koehler at The Nerd Daily praised exactly this: Ash is not magically fixed by a boyfriend.

The second hook is Darian. He is warm, funny, unpretentious and much sharper than Ash gives him credit for, and the class gap between them is the real conflict. Watching Ash's contempt crack is the pleasure of the book.

And the prose. Dabney Grinnan at All About Romance called it beautiful and moving, and this is where Hall's later, glossier books began. If you came to Hall through Boyfriend Material, Glitterland is the sadder, rawer grumpy sunshine book underneath it.

My Review

I read Glitterland after Boyfriend Material and expected a rougher draft of the same jokes. It is a different book: sadder, sexier and more ambitious, and in places better. Ash's voice got under my skin within a chapter, and I spent the rest of the book wanting to protect Darian from him, which is not a feeling romance often gives you.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry starts physical and turns tender, and the book is honest about how uneven that is. Ash wants Darian and is embarrassed by wanting him. Darian wants Ash and is not embarrassed by anything. Kirkus praised the clear passion between the two men and the emotional connection that grows out of it, and I would add that the funniest scenes are the ones where Darian simply refuses to be insulted.

The romance is not balanced, though. Dabney Grinnan, who gave the original edition an A minus, felt Darian's emotional life was so effortless and cheerful that he seemed almost too good to be true, and his easy acceptance of Ash's illness a little facile. I agree. Darian is a wonderful character who is not given enough of his own trouble.

The Characters

Ash is the triumph and the obstacle. He is cutting, self-loathing and very clever, and his depression is written from the inside with a precision that Kirkus called blunt but sensitive. Publishers Weekly praised the handling of his bipolar disorder too, but doubted how far his personality shifts once the relationship starts. It is a fair point. Ash does change a lot, and quickly.

Darian is the part of the book that divides readers most, mainly because of how he talks. Hall writes his Essex accent phonetically, and Publishers Weekly called the dialect overdone to the point of caricature. Mandi at Smexy Books, who gave it a B minus, found the replaced "th" sounds distracting enough to force rereading. Kirkus warned the voice "isn't for all readers, but it is remarkably consistent." I got used to it within a few chapters and ended up hearing Darian's voice clearly, but I understand anyone who bails.

Writing and Pacing

The sentences are the reason to read. Hall's prose is lush, wry and full of startling images, and Ash's narration swings between hilarious and devastating within a paragraph. Kirkus felt it was a bit clumsy compared with Hall's later books and found the dialogue formatting confusing at times. Both true, and neither ruined it for me.

The pacing is slower in the middle, where Mandi felt the dialogue-heavy stretches dragged. The book picks up for its last act and stops at a hard-won happy for now. The revised 2023 edition adds annotations, a new scene and bonus material, which is worth having if you already love the book.

Glitterland is a gorgeously written, unflinching MM romance about depression, snobbery and the stubborn joy of a man who will not be dimmed. Read it if you want honesty over comfort; skip it if phonetic dialect is a dealbreaker.

How Spicy Is Glitterland?

Glitterland is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. Ash and Darian start with a hookup, and sex stays part of how they connect throughout. Kirkus singled out the explicit writing as a strength, and All About Romance rated the original edition hot on its sensuality scale.

The scenes are consensual and often funny, and the book is unusual in showing a character with serious mental illness having a full, active sex life, a point Publishers Weekly praised. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, from the author's own content guidance (which notes it is not exhaustive):

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Glitterland?

Glitterland suits readers who want a literary, emotionally serious MM romance with grumpy sunshine, a class clash, steamy heat and honest depression representation. It is less suited to readers who dislike written accents, need a light read, or want a definitive happily ever after.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Glitterland has been praised since 2013 and was reviewed again by the trade press for its 2023 reissue. Library Journal gave the new edition a starred review, per the author's site, and Kirkus, Publishers Weekly and long-running romance blogs all covered it. Most agree on the writing; they split on Darian's voice.

Where they agree. The mental health writing and the prose. Kirkus praised the blunt but sensitive treatment of Ash's illness. Publishers Weekly wrote: "Still, Hall's trademark humor and heart shine through." All About Romance's Dabney Grinnan gave the original an A minus and wrote, "I liked it tremendously." The Nerd Daily's Mimi Koehler gave it 9 out of 10.

Where they split. The dialect and Ash's turn. Publishers Weekly found Darian's Essex speech close to caricature and Ash's change hard to believe. Smexy Books gave it a B minus for a dragging middle and a distracting accent, though Mandi ended up finding it a very convincing love story. Kirkus felt the writing was clumsier than Hall's later work but consistent.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Glitterland scores 8.4 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with top marks for writing and emotional impact, strong marks for romance, heat and characters, and a lower score for a happy for now ending that some readers will want firmer.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4.5Clear passion and a real emotional connection, per Kirkus.
Characters (15%)4Ash is brilliantly drawn; Darian is a little too effortless, per All About Romance.
Writing and pacing (15%)4.5Beautiful, wry prose; dialect and dialogue formatting divide readers, per Kirkus and Publishers Weekly.
Emotional impact (15%)4.5Honest, unflinching depression writing, praised by The Nerd Daily.
Heat level (10%)4Explicit and integral, as Kirkus notes; delivers the heat it promises.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A hard-won HFN, per All About Romance, rather than a full HEA.
Reread appeal (10%)4The 2023 annotated edition adds reasons to come back.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Glitterland is the foundation of Alexis Hall's Spires series and one of the most emotionally serious MM romances of its decade, with a final Eikna Score of 8.4/10.

Spires Reading Order

Glitterland is book 1 of Alexis Hall's Spires series, a set of connected standalones that each follow a new couple. You can read them in any order, but publication order starts here.

  1. Glitterland
  2. Waiting for the Flood
  3. For Real (2015): Laurie and Toby
  4. Pansies

Sourcebooks reissued the original four books from 2023 and has added new standalones since. Best format: the revised paperback or ebook if you want the annotations; Nicholas Boulton's audiobook is an excellent alternative, because hearing Darian's voice performed takes the sting out of the written dialect. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.

If You Loved Glitterland, Read These Next

If you loved Glitterland, look for MM and queer romances with witty, wounded narrators, opposites who refuse to be scared off and mental health handled with care.

Frequently Asked Questions

Glitterland by Alexis Hall prompts the same questions from most readers: how spicy it is, how it ends, how it handles mental health and which edition to buy. Short answers below.

Is Glitterland spicy?

Yes. Glitterland is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit scenes that are central to Ash and Darian's relationship.

Does Glitterland have a happy ending?

It has a happy for now ending. Ash and Darian end the book together and committed to trying, but it is not a tidy happily ever after.

Is Glitterland a standalone?

Yes. It is book 1 of the Spires series, but each Spires book follows a different couple.

What mental illness does Ash have in Glitterland?

Ash has bipolar depression, and the book includes his past suicide attempt, suicidal ideation and panic attacks.

What is different in the 2023 edition of Glitterland?

The Sourcebooks Casablanca edition is revised and expanded, with author annotations, a new scene, an in-universe extra and a letter from the author.

Is there a Glitterland audiobook?

Yes. Nicholas Boulton narrates the 2024 recording from Dreamscape Media, which runs about 9 hours and includes the bonus material.

What order should I read the Spires series in?

Publication order is Glitterland, Waiting for the Flood, For Real and Pansies.

The Bottom Line

Glitterland earns an 8.4/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a literary, steamy MM romance with a depressed, snobbish narrator and a sunny man who will not let himself be dismissed, and who can live with a happy for now. The reason to pick it up is Ash's voice: funny, cruel, frightened and, by the end, braver than he thinks.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.