eikna romance
Menu

His Cocky Valet by Cole McCade Review

Eikna Score: 6.9/10. Recommended with reservations.

His Cocky Valet is a lush, intense MM age gap romance in which a 23-year-old heir hands control of his crumbling life to a British valet nearly twice his age. The prose and the D/s heat are strong, but the timeline is fast, the corporate plot is thin, and the kink sometimes outruns the conversation it needs.

Read it if you want a dominant, competent older hero who takes care of everything, and a heavy BDSM romance written with real style. Skip it if pain play, a wide age gap with "young master" address, or a love story that moves at insta-love speed are not for you.

His Cocky Valet by Cole McCade book cover

His Cocky Valet at a Glance

His Cocky Valet is book 1 of Cole McCade's Undue Arrogance series, an independently published MM romance from May 2018. Reckless heir Ash Harrington hires valet Brand Forsythe while his father is dying, and the job becomes a dominant and submissive relationship with very explicit content.

AuthorCole McCade
SeriesUndue Arrogance, book 1 (each book follows a new couple)
SubgenreMM romance, contemporary, BDSM romance
Main tropesAge gap, boss and employee (in reverse), dominant caretaker, billionaire, live-in proximity
Spice level5/5: Very explicit, sex central to the plot
Content warningsTerminal illness of a parent, BDSM with pain play, age gap of about twenty years, unprotected sex (full list below)
POVAlternating, Ash and Brand
EndingHappy ending with an epilogue (some readers call it closer to HFN)
Pages348 (paperback); about 347 in the Kindle edition
AudiobookNarrated by Joel Leslie, 8 hours 41 minutes (Tantor Media, December 2018)
First publishedMay 2018
PublisherIndependently published by Cole McCade

What Is His Cocky Valet About?

His Cocky Valet starts with Ash Harrington, 23, a rich young man who has spent his life partying, suddenly put in charge of a vast global company because his father is dying and his mother has walked out. He is not ready, and everyone can see it.

The fix someone recommends is Brand Forsythe, a cool, exacting British valet nearly twice Ash's age. Brand takes over Ash's schedule, his wardrobe, his meals and very quickly his nights. For Ash, giving up control to someone who knows exactly what to do is the first relief he has felt in months. The question the book asks is whether what he has with Brand can carry him through the hardest decisions of his life.

What Makes This Age Gap Romance Work

His Cocky Valet works as an age gap romance because it leans all the way into the fantasy of competence. Brand is the man who irons your shirt, fixes your board meeting and tells you when to sleep, and for a young man whose world is collapsing, that is intoxicating. Goodreads readers who loved it keep coming back to Brand; one review title is simply a plea for a Brand Forsythe of their own.

The reversal is the clever part. Ash is the employer on paper, but Brand holds all the power that matters, and the book plays with that gap in every scene. The D/s relationship grows out of the job instead of being bolted onto it.

There is also a backstory readers enjoy. The title and series were Cole McCade's tongue-in-cheek answer to the 2018 trademark row over the word "cocky" in romance titles, and McCade's author's note and afterword about it are a favorite with Goodreads reviewers.

My Review

His Cocky Valet is a better written book than its title suggests and a messier romance than its prose suggests. Cole McCade can write a sentence. Some of Brand's scenes have a slow, almost formal elegance that suits a man who folds pocket squares for a living, and Ash's chaos reads as real panic rather than brattiness.

Where I struggled is with the speed and with the space the kink leaves for everything else.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is hot from the first meeting. Brand's dominance is quiet, which is more effective than shouting, and Ash's relief at being told what to do is written with real tenderness. Goodreads readers who rate it highly praise the care in the D/s scenes and the softer moments between them.

But the timeline is very short, and insta-love is the most common complaint in critical Goodreads reviews. I felt it too. Brand moves from new employee to dominant partner in a hurry, and I wanted more conversation on the page about limits and pain before the scenes escalated. The book tells you Brand reads Ash perfectly; I would rather have watched them negotiate. One reader called the dependency between them consensual but not obviously healthy, and that is close to my view.

The Characters

Brand is the reason to read. He is the fantasy of the man who has a plan for everything, and McCade gives him enough stiffness and enough private loneliness to keep him from being a robot. Some Goodreads readers find his competence too broad to believe, since he seems able to solve every corporate and personal problem in reach, and I agree he edges into wish fulfilment.

Ash is easier to like than I expected. He is 23 and drowning, with a father in hospice and a mother gone, and the book takes his grief seriously even when the plot does not give it much room. Several readers felt the father's illness was underused, resolving off to the side of the romance, and that matches my experience.

The age gap is large and the book does not hide it. Brand is nearly twice Ash's age, and he calls Ash "young master," which one Goodreads reviewer found especially uncomfortable in the audiobook. Both men are adults throughout.

Writing and Pacing

The prose is lyrical, sometimes beautifully and sometimes too much; a handful of readers found it overwrought or tiring over a long book. The business plot is the weakest strand. Ash's sudden job running a multinational is mostly a backdrop for his stress, and the corporate logic does not survive scrutiny. The pacing is quick through the first half and then very scene-heavy, with the sex carrying much of the middle.

Joel Leslie narrates the audio, and several readers praise it, though the "young master" refrain lands harder out loud.

His Cocky Valet is a stylish, very explicit D/s fantasy with a hero many readers will fall for on sight. Read it if you want kink and caretaking above plot, and go in knowing the romance moves faster than the trust it describes.

How Spicy Is His Cocky Valet?

His Cocky Valet is a 5 out of 5 on our scale: Very explicit, sex central to the plot. The dominant and submissive relationship is the spine of the book, with frequent explicit MM scenes that include pain play and control, and several Goodreads readers felt the kink took the front seat over the romance and plot.

Both leads are adults: Ash is 23 and Brand is nearly twice his age. The relationship is consensual, but the power dynamics are layered, with Ash as Brand's employer on paper and Brand as the dominant partner, and the negotiation of limits on the page is lighter than some readers will want. Readers also note that protection is never discussed. Our heat levels guide explains the scale.

Content warnings, drawn from the publisher description and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read His Cocky Valet?

His Cocky Valet suits readers who want a very explicit MM BDSM romance with a commanding older caretaker and lush prose. It is less suited to readers who need slow trust building, a strong plot outside the bedroom or careful on-page negotiation.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

His Cocky Valet has no trade press coverage we could find, so its reception lives with readers. On Goodreads it averages 3.72 from about 3,700 ratings as of November 2026, a split result for an MM romance, with most ratings at 3 or 4 stars.

Where they agree. The writing and the heat. Goodreads readers praise the prose, the steamy D/s scenes and the tender moments between Ash and Brand, and many enjoyed the cocky trademark backstory and McCade's afterword. Brand himself is a favorite.

Where they split. Almost everything else. Critical readers point to insta-love and a compressed timeline, a father's illness that feels underused, kink that crowds out the romance, a hero who is too good at everything, the lack of any talk about protection, and prose that some find overwrought. The age gap and the "young master" address are a dealbreaker for some listeners and a draw for others.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

His Cocky Valet scores 6.9 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, which puts it in Recommended with reservations. Its writing and heat score well, backed by consistent reader praise, while its ending and reread appeal score lowest because of the rushed timeline and thin side plots.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Intense D/s chemistry; insta-love is the top Goodreads complaint.
Characters (15%)3.5Brand is a reader favorite; Goodreads readers find his competence implausible.
Writing and pacing (15%)4Lyrical prose praised widely, though some readers call it overwrought.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Ash's grief is real; readers say the father's illness is underused.
Heat level (10%)3.5Delivers heavy kink as promised; limits and protection get little discussion.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3Happy, with an epilogue, but readers find side threads closed in a line or two.
Reread appeal (10%)3Strong for kink fans; Goodreads ratings cluster at 3 and 4 stars.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: His Cocky Valet sits in the middle of age gap MM BDSM romance, more stylish than most and less patient than the best, and it earns a final Eikna Score of 6.9/10.

Undue Arrogance Reading Order

His Cocky Valet is book 1 of Cole McCade's Undue Arrogance series and the place to start. Each book follows a new couple with a dominant and submissive dynamic, so the later books can be read alone, but reading in order lets the connected cast build.

  1. Book 1: His Cocky Valet (2018): Ash and Brand
  2. Book 2: His Cocky Cellist (2018)
  3. Book 3: His Cocky Prince (2021)

There is also a short follow-up, His Cocky Valet: After Story, for readers who want more of Ash and Brand. Best format: print or ebook if the "young master" address bothers you, since readers say it is more noticeable in audio; otherwise Joel Leslie's narration, about 8 hours 41 minutes, is well liked. Our series order guide covers more series.

If You Loved His Cocky Valet, Read These Next

If you loved His Cocky Valet, the best next reads are MM romances with an age gap, a power dynamic built into the job, or a dominant older partner. These Eikna reviews are the closest matches.

Frequently Asked Questions

His Cocky Valet raises the same questions for most new readers: how old Ash and Brand are, how explicit it is, whether it ends happily, where it sits in the series and who narrates the audio. Short answers below.

How old are Ash and Brand in His Cocky Valet?

Ash Harrington is 23, and the publisher describes Brand Forsythe as nearly twice his age, so the gap is about twenty years.

Is His Cocky Valet spicy?

Yes. His Cocky Valet is a 5 out of 5 on our scale, with a dominant and submissive relationship, pain play and frequent explicit scenes.

Does His Cocky Valet have a happy ending?

Yes. Ash and Brand end together, with an epilogue, though some readers feel a few side threads close very quickly.

Is His Cocky Valet part of a series?

Yes. It is book 1 of Undue Arrogance, followed by His Cocky Cellist and His Cocky Prince, each with a new couple.

Who narrates the His Cocky Valet audiobook?

Joel Leslie narrates the Tantor Media audiobook, which runs 8 hours 41 minutes.

Why is it called His Cocky Valet?

Cole McCade chose the title in response to the 2018 dispute over trademarking the word "cocky" in romance titles, and explains it in an author's note.

The Bottom Line

His Cocky Valet earns a 6.9/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a very explicit MM age gap romance with a commanding older valet and prose that takes itself seriously. The one reason to pick it up is Brand Forsythe, a caretaker fantasy written with enough style that you may forgive the speed of everything around him.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.