Meet Me at the Lake by Carley Fortune Review
Eikna Score: 7.3/10. Recommended.
Meet Me at the Lake has the best premise of Carley Fortune's lake books, one perfect day in Toronto, a promise to meet a year later and a man who never showed, and the grief story about Fern's mother is the real reason to read it. The romance itself is held back by withheld secrets and a hero who communicates badly, so it lands as a lovely, slightly frustrating summer read.
Read it if you love dual timelines, a one-day meet cute that echoes for a decade and a heroine grieving a complicated mother. Skip it if emotional infidelity with existing partners bothers you, or a hero who keeps pulling away will make you want to throw the book.
Meet Me at the Lake at a Glance
Meet Me at the Lake is a standalone second chance romance by Carley Fortune, published by Berkley in May 2023. It follows Fern Brookbanks, who inherits her late mother's struggling lakeside resort in Ontario's cottage country, and Will Baxter, the man she spent one day with nine years earlier. It is told in first person by Fern across two timelines, has moderate open-door heat and ends happily.
| Author | Carley Fortune |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone |
| Subgenre | Contemporary romance with women's fiction depth |
| Main tropes | Second chance, dual timeline, one-day meet cute, missed connection, family business |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Death of a parent, grief, depression, alcohol misuse, emotional infidelity (full list below) |
| POV | First person, Fern, alternating past and present |
| Ending | Happy ending |
| Pages | 336 (paperback) |
| Audiobook | Penguin Audio, read by A.J. Bridel, 9 hours 56 minutes |
| First published | May 2, 2023 |
| Publisher | Berkley (Penguin Random House) |
What Is Meet Me at the Lake About?
Meet Me at the Lake begins with a day. At twenty-two, Fern Brookbanks spends twenty-four hours walking around Toronto with a stranger named Will Baxter, and by the end of it they have told each other more than they have told anyone. They agree to meet again in a year at her family's resort on the lake. Fern goes. Will does not.
Nine years later, Fern's mother has died and left her the resort, which is in financial trouble. Fern has a life and a partner in the city, and no plan to run the business she spent her youth escaping. Then she discovers that her mother hired a consultant to help, and the consultant is Will. The book moves between that first day and the present summer, as Fern decides what to do with the resort, her mother's memory and the man who stood her up.
What Makes This Second Chance Romance Work
Meet Me at the Lake works as a second chance romance because of how small the first chance was. Fern and Will had one day. It should not matter as much as it does, and the book is honest about how much she has built on so little. That makes the present-day tension richer: is this love, or is it a story she has been telling herself for nine years?
The dual timeline is the engine. Each past chapter adds a piece to that Toronto day, and each present chapter pushes Fern closer to an answer about why Will never came. Kirkus admitted the withholding feels a bit formulaic but said it keeps the pages turning, which is exactly right.
The setting does the rest. Fortune knows Ontario's lake country, the docks, the guests, the long evenings, and readers who loved Every Summer After will get the same summer-cottage pull here, with an adult heroine and a family business at stake.
My Review
Meet Me at the Lake made me cry about a mother and roll my eyes at a love interest, sometimes on the same page. That is a fair summary of the book. Its family story is better than its romance, and its romance is better than its reputation among frustrated readers.
Kirkus called it an entertaining romance and told readers to escape to the lakefront, while noting the formula. Harlequin Junkie gave it 4.5 stars and an HJ Recommends badge, praising the storytelling and the mother's journals but finding Will maddening. Smexy Books praised the chemistry. Speaking of Books found the pacing slow and the chemistry unconvincing. I sit with Harlequin Junkie.
Romance and Chemistry
The Toronto day is wonderful. Fortune writes it like a walking movie: two people who would never have met, an afternoon that keeps extending, the moment each realises the other is telling the truth. Will at twenty-something is open and funny, and their chemistry is immediate. If the book were only that day, it would be a five-star romance.
The present is harder. Will has changed, and the book spends a long time keeping the reason from Fern and the reader. He pulls away, lets her think the worst and explains himself late. Harlequin Junkie found him frustrating, and several StoryGraph readers questioned whether his repair is equal to the hurt. I agree that the balance is off. The emotional payoff is there, and the open-door scenes are warm, but Fern does more of the work.
Then there are the partners. Both leads are attached to other people when they meet again, and the book handles that with less care than it needs. On r/RomanceBooks, some readers called the first day itself emotional cheating. I did not mind that, but I did mind how neatly the present-day partners are cleared out of the way.
The Characters
Fern is the best reason to read. She is grieving a mother she loved and resented, a woman who put the resort first and whose choices Fern only begins to understand through her journals. Those journal entries are the most affecting thing Fortune has written. Becca at Pretty Little Memoirs and Jen at Smexy Books both singled out the mother and daughter material, and it is where the book earns its tears.
Fern is also funny and capable in a way that makes the resort plot fun to follow. Watching her go from reluctant heir to someone with a plan for the place is quietly satisfying.
Will is a sketch for too long. We know the young version well and the older version barely, and the reasons for his change, when they come, are sympathetic but rushed. The supporting cast at the resort is small and pleasant; I wanted more of the staff and less of the partners.
Writing and Pacing
Fortune writes summer better than almost anyone in the genre. Water, heat, old wood, a dock at night. Her sentences are clean and her dialogue is natural. The dual timeline is handled with confidence, and the past chapters are the best paced.
The present-day middle sags. The resort business plot and the will-they-won't-they repeat themselves, and Allison Speakmon at Speaking of Books was right that it drags. The final act moves fast, maybe too fast for the amount of hurt it has to resolve. Whimsically Meghan loved the journals but felt the late repair was rushed, and so did I.
The audiobook, read by A.J. Bridel, who also narrated Every Summer After, is a strong option; the Blue Mood Cafe audio review praised her distinct voices across the cast.
Meet Me at the Lake is a moving grief story wrapped around a romance that withholds too much for too long. Read it for the Toronto day and Fern's mother, and be patient with Will.
How Spicy Is Meet Me at the Lake?
Meet Me at the Lake is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. There are a few open-door, consensual sex scenes in the present-day storyline, described with some detail but not at great length. Stefanie N on NetGalley and drsuzbark on StoryGraph both confirm open-door content. The first-day timeline is emotional rather than physical.
Content to know about: Fern's mother's death and the grief that follows run through the book, the book deals with depression, dark thoughts and alcohol misuse, and both leads have partners when they reconnect, which some readers see as emotional infidelity. Carley Fortune's book club kit discusses parenting and mental health themes. For more in this heat range, see our spicy romance list.
Content warnings, drawn from reader reports and reviews:
- Death of a parent and detailed grief
- Depression and dark thoughts
- Alcohol misuse
- Emotional infidelity; both leads have partners when they reconnect
- Cheating among secondary characters
- Open-door sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Who Should Read Meet Me at the Lake?
Meet Me at the Lake suits readers who want an emotional second chance romance with a dual timeline, a strong sense of place and a story about mothers and daughters. It is less suited to readers who dislike withheld secrets, existing partners or heroes who communicate poorly.
Best for:
- Fans of Every Summer After and Carley Fortune's lake settings
- Readers who love dual timeline romances
- Anyone drawn to grief and mother and daughter stories
- Readers who like a family business subplot
- Audiobook listeners who enjoyed A.J. Bridel
Not for:
- Readers who need clean, unattached leads
- Anyone who hates late explanations
- Readers who want a fast-moving plot
- People who want the hero to grovel more
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Meet Me at the Lake was a big follow-up to Every Summer After and a bestseller in its own right. Kirkus called it an entertaining lakefront escape, Publishers Weekly praised how the past and present reveal the characters' changing hearts, and Library Journal pointed to the tropes, the location and the secrets as draws.
Where they agree. The setting and the mother. Harlequin Junkie, Smexy Books and Pretty Little Memoirs all praised the journals and the grief story, and nearly everyone loves the Toronto day.
Where they split. Will, and the partners. Harlequin Junkie found him frustrating, Nichole Oxford felt the lasting attachment was unearned, and readers on StoryGraph and r/RomanceBooks questioned the communication and the existing relationships. Jeeves Reads Romance stopped about a hundred pages in over the partner drama. Others, like Becca at Pretty Little Memoirs, found the connection deeply romantic.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Meet Me at the Lake scores 7.3 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for writing and emotional impact, where the Toronto day and the grief story land, and its lowest for romance and characters, held back by a withholding hero.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | A perfect first day; Harlequin Junkie finds present-day Will frustrating. |
| Characters (15%) | 3.5 | Fern and her mother are vivid; Will stays a sketch too long. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4 | Kirkus praises the escape; the formula keeps pages turning. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | The journals hit hard, per Harlequin Junkie and Pretty Little Memoirs. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Warm open-door scenes, as NetGalley readers report. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A happy ending, but Whimsically Meghan finds the repair rushed. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | The Toronto day rewards rereading; the middle does not. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Meet Me at the Lake sits just behind Every Summer After among Carley Fortune's novels, with a stronger family story but a weaker hero, and lands at a final Eikna Score of 7.3/10.
Is Meet Me at the Lake a Standalone?
Yes. Meet Me at the Lake is a standalone. Carley Fortune's novels share a summer lake-country mood but follow new characters, so you can start with any of them.
Carley Fortune's novels in publication order: Every Summer After (2022), Meet Me at the Lake (2023), This Summer Will Be Different (2024) and One Golden Summer (2025).
Best format: print or ebook for the atmosphere, or the A.J. Bridel audiobook if you liked her reading of Every Summer After. Our series order guide covers connected romances.
If You Loved Meet Me at the Lake, Read These Next
If you loved Meet Me at the Lake, the closest matches are second chance romances with dual timelines, strong settings and a family story underneath.
- Every Summer After by Carley Fortune: summers at a lake, a first love and a reunion at a funeral.
- Love and Other Words by Christina Lauren: a dual timeline first love story with a long-buried hurt.
- People We Meet on Vacation by Emily Henry: ten summers of trips, told across two timelines.
- Happy Place by Emily Henry: an exes-at-a-cottage summer with old friends and secrets.
- Summer Romance by Annabel Monaghan: a grieving daughter and a summer fling, with lower heat and more jokes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Meet Me at the Lake raises the same questions for most new readers: how spicy it is, whether it connects to Every Summer After, whether it ends happily and whether there is cheating. Short answers below.
Is Meet Me at the Lake spicy?
Moderately. We rate it 3 out of 5, with a few open-door, consensual scenes in the present-day storyline.
Is Meet Me at the Lake connected to Every Summer After?
No. It is a standalone with new characters; the two books share a lake-country summer setting and mood.
Does Meet Me at the Lake have a happy ending?
Yes. Fern and Will get a happy ending, though some readers feel the final repair is rushed.
Is there cheating in Meet Me at the Lake?
Both leads have partners when they meet again, and some readers see their connection as emotional infidelity. Secondary characters also cheat.
Is there a Meet Me at the Lake audiobook?
Yes. Penguin Audio published it, read by A.J. Bridel, at about 9 hours 56 minutes.
Where is Meet Me at the Lake set?
At a family resort in Ontario's lake country, with flashbacks to one day in Toronto.
The Bottom Line
Meet Me at the Lake earns a 7.3/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a dual timeline second chance romance with a strong summer setting and a grief story that hurts in the right way. The one reason to pick it up is the Toronto day, which is as good a meet cute as the genre has produced lately.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Meet Me at the Lake, Kirkus Reviews
- Meet Me at the Lake, Library Journal
- Review: Meet Me at the Lake, Harlequin Junkie
- Meet Me at the Lake audiobook review, Blue Mood Cafe (narrator, length)
- Publishers Weekly review; Smexy Books, Speaking of Books, Whimsically Meghan, Pretty Little Memoirs, Nichole Oxford, Jeeves Reads Romance; NetGalley, StoryGraph and r/RomanceBooks reader reviews; Carley Fortune book club kit
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.