eikna romance
Menu

Summer Romance by Annabel Monaghan Review

Eikna Score: 7.3/10. Recommended.

Summer Romance is a gentle, funny book about a worn-out mother who gets a summer to be a person again, and Annabel Monaghan writes Ali's grief and her small rebellions with real warmth. The romance is sweeter than it is tense, and a late conflict feels bolted on, but it is a lovely beach read for anyone who has ever disappeared into taking care of everyone else.

Read it if you want a low-angst, closed-door romance with a grown-up heroine and a hero who simply likes her, Skip it if you need high stakes and steam, or late third-act breakups drive you up the wall.

Summer Romance by Annabel Monaghan book cover

Summer Romance at a Glance

Summer Romance is a standalone contemporary romance by Annabel Monaghan, published by Putnam in June 2024. It follows Ali Morris, a recently separated mother of three still grieving her mother, and Ethan, a younger man from her past she meets at the dog park. The heat is mild and mostly off page, and the ending is happy.

AuthorAnnabel Monaghan
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreContemporary romance, romantic comedy with women's fiction warmth
Main tropesSummer fling, divorce and fresh start, younger man, single mom, small town summer
Spice level2/5: Mild, fade to black
Content warningsDeath of a parent and grief, divorce, a demeaning ex-husband, illness of an older neighbour (full list below)
POVAli's point of view
EndingHappy ending
Pages368 (paperback)
AudiobookPenguin Random House Audio, read by Kristen DiMercurio, 8 hours 27 minutes
First publishedJune 4, 2024
PublisherG.P. Putnam's Sons (Penguin Random House)

What Is Summer Romance About?

Summer Romance follows Ali Morris, a professional organiser whose own life has come apart. Her mother died two years ago, her husband Pete left her a year ago and she has spent the time since keeping three kids, a dog and a house running while barely remembering what she likes.

One morning she takes off her wedding ring, puts on real pants and goes to the dog park, where her dog makes an enthusiastic mess of a handsome stranger. He turns out to be Ethan, the younger brother of a high school friend, who once had a crush on her. He is back in town for the summer, and he is very clear that he is interested. Ali has to decide whether a summer fling is something a newly single mom is allowed to have.

What Makes This Summer Fling Romance Work

Summer Romance works because its summer fling is really a story about permission. Ali has spent years putting everyone else first, and the fling is the first thing in a long time that is only for her. Monaghan makes the reader want that for her before Ali can admit she wants it herself.

The book is light where it can be and honest where it has to be. Ali's kids, her ex and her grief all keep crowding in, and the romance has to fit around school runs and a messy co-parenting schedule. That is the fun of it: the fling is not an escape from real life, it is a small, sunny room inside it.

Ethan helps. He is kind without being a pushover, and Publishers Weekly described the relationship as a love affair with no reality check, which is exactly the fantasy on offer. Readers who liked Monaghan's Nora Goes Off Script will recognise the formula: a mother rediscovering joy, a man who sees her, and a lot of good jokes about domestic life.

My Review

Summer Romance is the book I would hand to a friend who has had a rough year and needs something kind. It is not a big book, and it does not try to be. It wants to make you laugh at a dog and cry a little about a mother, and it manages both.

Publishers Weekly called it the ideal beach read, and Lisa at Bookshelf Fantasies gave it five stars and told readers not to miss it. On the other side, Laurie at The Baking Bookworm found it repetitive and the grief material shallow. I land closer to the fans, with a few of Laurie's notes in my pocket.

Romance and Chemistry

The romance between Ali and Ethan is easy, and that is both its charm and its limit. Ethan likes Ali immediately and says so. He likes her kids. He notices when she is tired. There is no misunderstanding for most of the book, just two people having a good summer, and Monaghan writes their dates with real lightness.

The trouble is tension. Because Ethan is so steady, the obstacles all come from Ali's side, her guilt, her ex, her sense that she does not deserve this. That is honest, but it makes the late conflict feel forced. Several readers, including a long r/RomanceBooks review and The Baking Bookworm, called the late breakup unnecessary, and I agree. It exists because the genre expects a dark moment, not because the story needed one.

The Characters

Ali is the reason to read. She is funny about her own life, sharp about other people and slowly, visibly getting braver. Her job as a professional organiser is used well: she can sort anyone's chaos but her own, and the metaphor never gets too heavy. Phoebe Wright at Read and Wright praised how economically Monaghan sketches her.

The supporting cast is small and good. Frannie, Ali's best friend, is a scene stealer, and Read and Wright wanted more of her. The kids are real kids rather than props. Pete, the ex, is less interesting, and the book sometimes uses him as a convenient source of cruelty. An older neighbour subplot gives the book some of its best quiet moments.

Ethan is pleasant and a little thin. We learn that he has changed since his unreliable teenage years, but we mostly see him through Ali's eyes, and he exists to make her feel seen. That is fine for a fling and slightly less fine for a forever.

Writing and Pacing

Monaghan's sentences are clean and quick, and her comic timing is very good. The grief passages are short and plain, which I liked; she trusts the reader to fill in the size of the loss. Lisa at Bookshelf Fantasies singled out the way the book catches the exhaustion of domestic life, and that is where the writing is strongest.

Pacing is gentle. The first third is setup and the middle drifts pleasantly through the summer. If you want plot, this will feel slow. If you want company, it is just right. The audiobook, read by Kristen DiMercurio, runs under eight and a half hours and suits a book this conversational.

One more thing in the book's favour: it is honest about the logistics of a newly single mother in a way many summer romances skip. Co-parenting with an ex who is still unkind, three kids with three sets of needs, a house that has to keep running. None of it is played for misery, and none of it is waved away either. That texture is what separates Summer Romance from a generic beach read, and it is why the ending, rushed as it is, still feels like it belongs to real people.

Summer Romance is a warm, funny, low-stakes book about a mother allowed one good summer. Read it if you want comfort and closed-door sweetness, and forgive the late breakup.

How Spicy Is Summer Romance?

Summer Romance is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. Ali and Ethan's relationship becomes physical, but the sex happens off the page. Mollie Reads described it as closed door, and what is on page is kissing, flirting and the aftermath. There is nothing explicit.

The emotional content is heavier than the heat. Grief for Ali's mother runs through the whole book, and her ex-husband's demeaning way of speaking to her is shown in flashback and present scenes. For more low-heat romances, see our closed door romance list.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reports and reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Who Should Read Summer Romance?

Summer Romance suits readers who want a cosy, funny, closed-door romance about a mother finding herself again. It is less suited to readers who want steam, high drama or a hero with an arc as large as the heroine's.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Summer Romance had a strong summer 2024 run with readers, and trade coverage was friendly. Publishers Weekly called it the ideal beach read, and blogs such as Harlequin Junkie and Bookshelf Fantasies were enthusiastic.

Where they agree. Ali. Publishers Weekly found the courtship believable and heartwarming, Michele at Harlequin Junkie praised the mutual compassion between the leads, and The Book Dutchesses liked watching Ali find her voice again. Lisa at Bookshelf Fantasies loved the family dynamics and the small-town summer.

Where they split. Pace and the third act. The Baking Bookworm found the book repetitive and the grief handled lightly, and readers on StoryGraph and r/RomanceBooks were divided on the slow romance and the late breakup. The Time for Change enjoyed the ending but questioned whether the couple's sacrifices would last.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Summer Romance scores 7.3 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for characters and emotional impact, where Ali's grief and recovery land, and its lowest for the romance tension and the ending, which several readers found forced.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Sweet, believable courtship per PW; little tension until a forced late conflict.
Characters (15%)4Ali and Frannie shine; Read and Wright wanted even more Frannie.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Clean, funny prose; The Baking Bookworm found it repetitive.
Emotional impact (15%)4Quiet grief and domestic fatigue land, as Bookshelf Fantasies notes.
Heat level (10%)3.5Closed-door heat matches what a gentle book promises.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5Happy ending, but readers call the late breakup unnecessary.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5A comfort reread for summer, though not one you return to for plot.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Summer Romance sits just behind Nora Goes Off Script among Annabel Monaghan's adult novels, warmer but slighter, and lands at a final Eikna Score of 7.3/10.

Is Summer Romance a Standalone?

Yes. Summer Romance is a standalone with a complete ending and no required prequel. Annabel Monaghan's adult novels, Nora Goes Off Script (2022), Same Time Next Summer (2023) and Summer Romance (2024), are all standalones and can be read in any order.

Best format: the audiobook, read by Kristen DiMercurio, is a breezy listen at under eight and a half hours and suits Ali's chatty voice. Our series order guide covers connected romance series if you want something longer.

If You Loved Summer Romance, Read These Next

If you loved Summer Romance, the closest matches are warm, funny contemporary romances about women rebuilding after loss or divorce.

Frequently Asked Questions

Summer Romance raises the same questions for most new readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, whether it ends happily and how it compares to Nora Goes Off Script. Short answers below.

Is Summer Romance spicy?

Not really. We rate it 2 out of 5: the relationship is physical, but sex scenes happen off the page.

Is Summer Romance a standalone?

Yes. It is a complete standalone with no prequel or sequel.

Does Summer Romance have a happy ending?

Yes. Ali and Ethan get a happy ending, after a late conflict that some readers found unnecessary.

Who is Ethan in Summer Romance?

Ethan is the younger brother of Ali's high school friend. He had a crush on her as a teenager and meets her again at the dog park.

Is there a Summer Romance audiobook?

Yes. Penguin Random House Audio published it, read by Kristen DiMercurio, at about 8 hours 27 minutes.

Should I read Nora Goes Off Script first?

No. The books are not connected. Read either first; Nora is a little sharper, Summer Romance a little warmer.

The Bottom Line

Summer Romance earns a 7.3/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a cosy, closed-door romance about a tired mother who gets one good summer, with jokes, a dog and a hero who is easy to like. The one reason to pick it up is Ali, whose return to herself is funny and moving in equal measure.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.