eikna romance
Menu

Perfect Rhythm by Jae Review

Eikna Score: 7.8/10. Recommended.

Perfect Rhythm is a thoughtful small town romance between a burned out pop star and an asexual nurse, built on friendship, caregiving and conversations about what intimacy means to each of them. It explains more than it needs to and the prose wobbles early, but Holly is one of the most self assured ace heroines in romance, and the book takes her seriously.

Read it if you want asexual representation in an adult romance, or you like a famous woman coming home to a town that does not care who she is. Skip it if repeated explanation in dialogue bothers you, or you would rather an ace romance stay entirely closed door.

Perfect Rhythm by Jae book cover

Perfect Rhythm at a Glance

Perfect Rhythm is a sapphic contemporary romance by Jae, published by Ylva Publishing in September 2017 and the first book in her Fair Oaks series. It alternates close third person between its two heroines, includes one explicit scene with an in-book content note, and ends with a happily ever after.

AuthorJae
SeriesFair Oaks, book 1 (followed by a free short story and Not the Marrying Kind)
SubgenreSapphic contemporary romance, small town
Main tropesHomecoming, celebrity and ordinary woman, friends to lovers, ace and allo romance, slow burn
Spice level3/5: Moderate, some open door
Content warningsA parent's stroke and serious illness, death of a parent, caregiving stress, early ignorant remarks about asexuality (full list below)
POVThird person, alternating between Leo and Holly
EndingHEA
Pages298 (paperback; about 107,000 words)
AudiobookNarrated by Angela Dawe, 11 hours 24 minutes (Tantor Media, March 2018)
First publishedSeptember 2017
PublisherYlva Publishing

What Is Perfect Rhythm About?

Leontyne Blake, known as Leo, is thirty two and a pop star who has stopped believing anyone sees past the image. When her father has a stroke, she leaves the tour circuit and goes home to Fair Oaks, Missouri, a town small enough that everyone remembers who she used to be.

Holly Drummond is the nurse helping to care for Leo's father. She is in her late twenties, unimpressed by fame and comfortable in her own skin, and she is asexual, which she makes clear early. The two women start out wary of each other and slowly become friends, and then Leo has to work out whether what she feels can fit with what Holly wants.

What Makes This Small Town Romance Work

Perfect Rhythm works because its small town homecoming is a cover for a harder question: how do two people with different relationships to sex build a romance together? Jae puts the asexual heroine's boundaries at the center and treats them as settled facts, not as an obstacle for love to overcome.

Tierney at the Lesbrary put it well, saying the book revitalizes a familiar romcom setup by making the love interest a homoromantic asexual woman. The celebrity returns home, meets the local who is not dazzled, slowly lets the town back in. You know the shape. What is new is that the courtship is also a negotiation, and Leo has to listen.

The family story gives it ballast. Leo's father's illness puts both women in the same rooms every day, and caregiving creates a kind of intimacy before either of them names it. Readers who like small town romance with real stakes at home will find the hook here.

My Review

Perfect Rhythm was published in 2017, before ace representation in romance was common, and some of it reads like a book that knows it may be a reader's first introduction to asexuality. That is both its great strength and its main weakness.

Sam, an ace reviewer writing on the Floral Cars blog, called Holly a favorite ace character because she is confident in her identity, has ace friends and learned about herself through online communities. I agree. Holly does not apologize for who she is, and the story never asks her to.

Romance and Chemistry

The romance is a slow burn built on friendship. Leo and Holly start out with some suspicion on both sides, and the turn into friendship is the best part of the book: small kindnesses around Leo's father, honest talk, Holly refusing to treat Leo as a celebrity. By the time romance enters, the foundation is solid.

The negotiation is where opinions split. Jae has Leo and Holly talk openly and repeatedly about boundaries, and Tierney praised that communication along with the book's view of intimacy and sensuality apart from sex. But Tierney also found Leo's attention to Holly's body overdone and at times unpleasant. Sam had a sharper objection: the explicit scene late in the book felt to her like it implied patience is eventually rewarded with sex, and she would have preferred it left open. I understand both points. Holly is clearly choosing what she wants, and asexuality is a spectrum, but the book's structure does make sex the climax of the relationship, and some ace readers will feel that.

The Characters

Holly is the standout. She is funny, steady and not remotely interested in Leo's fame, and her friends and community give her a life outside the romance. Tierney noted that because so much of the book belongs to Leo, Holly ends up less developed than she deserves, and I wish she had more chapters of her own.

Leo has the bigger arc. She starts the book worn out, guarded and occasionally clueless; some of her early remarks about asexuality are ignorant enough that Goodreads readers who are ace say they found them hard to read. She learns, in large part on the page, and Tierney called Leo's arc "absolutely moving and satisfying." Her family, especially her father, is a strong thread in its own right.

Writing and Pacing

The opening is rocky. Tierney found some of the prose clumsy and the plot predictable, and Love in Panels found the explanatory passages list-like. The middle drags too: Goodreads readers frequently mention the length and the repetition of the asexuality explanations, which sometimes stop the story to cover ground it has already covered.

Once the family story takes over, though, the book finds its rhythm. Jae is good at small town texture, and Tierney singled out the portrayal of a queer woman finding acceptance in her hometown. The audiobook, narrated by Angela Dawe, is praised by Goodreads listeners and gives the book a gentler pace than print.

Perfect Rhythm is a sincere, sometimes over explained romance with an asexual heroine who knows exactly who she is. Read it if you want ace representation in an adult love story and can accept a book that occasionally stops to teach.

How Spicy Is Perfect Rhythm?

Perfect Rhythm is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. Most of the book is about emotional intimacy, affection and talking through boundaries. There is one explicit, consensual sex scene late in the book, and Jae puts a content note before it so readers who prefer to skip it can. One Goodreads reader notes some further sexual content in the following chapter without a separate note.

Both leads are adults: Leo is thirty two and Holly is in her late twenties. Holly's asexuality is respected throughout, and consent is explicit, though some ace readers have mixed feelings about how the book places the sex scene.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reviews and the Lesbrary:

Our romance heat levels guide explains the scale, and our content warnings guide explains how we build these lists.

Who Should Read Perfect Rhythm?

Perfect Rhythm suits readers who want an adult sapphic romance with an asexual heroine, a small town homecoming and a family story with real weight. It is less suited to readers who dislike didactic dialogue, or ace readers who want a romance with no sex on the page at all.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Perfect Rhythm is one of Jae's most discussed books because of its ace heroine. It holds a 4.23 average from more than 3,500 ratings on Goodreads. Most coverage comes from sapphic and queer review blogs and readers rather than trade journals.

Where they agree. The representation matters and the friendship works. Tierney at the Lesbrary praised the intimacy and the open communication, Gaby at LezReviewBooks gave it four stars and wrote that "This book fills that gap in lesfic," and Sam at Floral Cars called the portrayal of asexuality positive and gentle. Goodreads readers praise the chemistry, the family storyline and Angela Dawe's narration.

Where they split. The handling of sex and the amount of explanation. Sam docked a star for the explicit scene; Tierney found Leo's focus on Holly's body heavy-handed. Love in Panels found the explanatory passages list-like, and Goodreads readers mention slow pacing, repetition and Leo's early ignorance. Some ace readers felt the ending reads as compromise; others found it true to Holly.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Perfect Rhythm scores 7.8 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top mark for the romance, a friendship that turns into a carefully negotiated relationship, and its lowest for writing and pacing, where reviewers fault clumsy early prose and repetition.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4.5Built on friendship and open talk; the Lesbrary praises the communication about boundaries.
Characters (15%)4Holly is a confident ace heroine; Tierney finds her less developed than Leo.
Writing and pacing (15%)3Tierney calls some prose clumsy; Love in Panels finds the explanations list-like.
Emotional impact (15%)4Tierney calls Leo's arc moving; the family story lands hard.
Heat level (10%)3.5One noted, skippable scene; Sam at Floral Cars questions how it is framed.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A warm HEA that Sam calls fairy tale like; some ace readers feel it compromises.
Reread appeal (10%)4A comfort read for many; Goodreads listeners revisit it on audio.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Perfect Rhythm sits in the upper middle of Jae's contemporary catalogue, below Just a Touch Away and above Chemistry Lessons, with a final Eikna Score of 7.8/10.

Fair Oaks Reading Order

Perfect Rhythm is the first book in Jae's Fair Oaks series, so it is the place to start. The romance is complete in this book; the free short story Facing the Music revisits Leo and Holly, and Not the Marrying Kind returns to the town with a new couple.

Best format: the Tantor audiobook, narrated by Angela Dawe, runs about 11 and a half hours and is a favorite with listeners. Our series order guide covers other connected romances.

If You Loved Perfect Rhythm, Read These Next

If you loved Perfect Rhythm, the closest matches are sapphic romances with a slow build, a strong friendship and careful attention to what each partner needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Perfect Rhythm raises a few common questions: whether Holly is asexual, how much sex is on the page, whether it is part of a series and whether it ends happily. Short answers below.

Is Holly asexual in Perfect Rhythm?

Yes. Holly Drummond is a homoromantic asexual woman, and she tells Leo early in the book. Her identity is treated as settled, not as a problem to fix.

Is Perfect Rhythm spicy?

Moderately. Perfect Rhythm is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with one explicit, consensual scene preceded by an in-book content note so readers can skip it.

Is Perfect Rhythm part of a series?

Yes. Perfect Rhythm is book 1 of Jae's Fair Oaks series, followed by the free short story Facing the Music and the novel Not the Marrying Kind.

Does Perfect Rhythm have a happy ending?

Yes. Perfect Rhythm ends with a happily ever after for Leo and Holly.

How old are Leo and Holly in Perfect Rhythm?

Leo is thirty two, and Holly is in her late twenties. Both are adults throughout.

Is there a Perfect Rhythm audiobook?

Yes. Tantor Media released it in March 2018, narrated by Angela Dawe, running about 11 hours 24 minutes.

The Bottom Line

Perfect Rhythm earns a 7.8/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want an adult sapphic romance with an asexual heroine, a small town homecoming and a family story that matters. The one reason to pick it up is Holly: a woman who knows exactly who she is, in a love story that lets her stay that way.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.