eikna romance
Menu

Chemistry Lessons by Jae Review

Eikna Score: 7.6/10. Recommended.

Chemistry Lessons is a sweet, low angst best friends to lovers romance in which two women who have known each other since kindergarten agree to three dates to prove there is nothing there. It is short on plot and long on science puns, but the ease between Ky and Regan feels like a real friendship of twenty five years, and that is harder to write than it looks.

Read it if you want a cozy sapphic friends to lovers story with almost no angst, or you like romances where the couple is already a family before they kiss. Skip it if you need conflict to stay interested, or a running joke repeated twenty times will drive you up a wall.

Chemistry Lessons by Jae book cover

Chemistry Lessons at a Glance

Chemistry Lessons is a sapphic contemporary romance by Jae, published by Ylva Publishing in 2021 as the fifth entry in her Unexpected Love series. It reads as a standalone, alternates close third person between its two heroines, has moderate open door heat and ends with a happily ever after.

AuthorJae
SeriesUnexpected Love, book 5 (the third novel; each novel has a new couple)
SubgenreSapphic contemporary romance
Main tropesBest friends to lovers, slow burn, a three date experiment, found family, everyone knew but them
Spice level3/5: Moderate, some open door
Content warningsPast parental death by overdose, an incarcerated parent, family estrangement, alcohol (full list below)
POVThird person, alternating between Ky and Regan
EndingHEA
Pages222 (paperback; about 73,000 words)
AudiobookNarrated by Abby Craden, 6 hours 30 minutes (Tantor Media, February 2022)
First publishedAugust 2021 (Ylva's own store listed the ebook in July 2021)
PublisherYlva Publishing

What Is Chemistry Lessons About?

Kylie Wells and Regan Romano have been best friends since kindergarten. Regan teaches chemistry; Ky works in the same school's cafeteria. They finish each other's sentences, share holidays and know each other's families better than their own exes ever did.

Their friends think they are a couple and have thought so for years. Tired of hearing it, Ky and Regan set up an experiment to settle the question: three proper dates, run like a lab protocol, after which they can tell everyone that the result was negative. The results do not cooperate. Looks linger, hand holding feels different with an audience of two, and a goodnight kiss goes much further than either expected.

What Makes This Friends to Lovers Romance Work

Chemistry Lessons works because its friends to lovers premise starts with a deep friendship already on the page, not a backstory the reader is asked to take on trust. Ky and Regan have twenty five years of shorthand, in jokes and family dinners, so the three date experiment reads as two people risking something real.

The Lesbian Book Blog put it neatly: Jae has taken one of lesfic's favorite tropes and given it "the perfect twist." The twist is the structure. A dating experiment with rules gives both women permission to try things they would never risk otherwise, and the rules start breaking in small, funny ways long before the big kiss.

It also helps that these are ordinary jobs and ordinary lives. Nobody is a billionaire or a rock star. One woman grades lab reports, the other serves lunch to teenagers, and their biggest problem is that their friends are right. Readers who like friends to lovers at its coziest will find the hook easily.

My Review

I read Chemistry Lessons in two sittings, which is about what it asks of you. At 222 pages it is one of Jae's shortest novels, and it has the shape of a comfort read: a warm friend group, a couple who are obviously right for each other and a few honest bumps on the way.

Tara Scott at Smart Bitches, Trashy Books gave it a B+ and admitted it kept her up two nights running. That is the right register. This is a book you enjoy rather than one you argue about, and the reader complaints I found are mostly about what it does not try to do.

Romance and Chemistry

The romance is lovely, and SBTB summed it up as having "zero angst and plenty of cute moments." That is almost literally true. The tension comes from fear of losing the friendship, not from misunderstandings, and Jae resists the urge to manufacture a big third act breakup. When the leads hit a problem, they talk about it. I found that refreshing; some Goodreads readers found it boring.

What I liked most is how the familiar touches change meaning. Ky and Regan have been hugging and leaning on each other for decades. Once they are on the clock as an experiment, the same gestures suddenly feel loaded, and Jae plays that beautifully across the dates. The goodnight kiss is the best scene in the book. A handful of readers on Goodreads thought the shift from friends to lovers happened too smoothly to be believable, and I can see the point: neither woman seems to have spent much of the previous twenty five years wondering.

The Characters

Ky is the more vivid of the two. Her father was a lawyer who went to prison for embezzlement, and her mother died of an overdose the day before Ky turned twenty one; she has built a careful, cheerful life on top of that, and the father's reappearance gives the book its only real friction.

Regan is warmer and a little flatter. She has a close family and a chemistry teacher's fondness for terrible puns, and that is most of her personality. Several Goodreads readers said they had trouble telling the two heroines apart in the alternating chapters, which surprised me less than I would like. The supporting cast is generous, including a cameo from Denny and Eliza of Wrong Number, Right Woman, though one strand of StoryGraph criticism found the friend group intrusive.

Writing and Pacing

Jae's prose is clean, light and funny. The pacing is brisk for a slow burn, because the book is short and the experiment gives it a built in structure: three dates, then fallout. There is not much plot outside the relationship and Ky's family thread, and the book does not pretend otherwise.

Then there are the chemistry jokes. Tara Scott at SBTB found the science references overdone in the second half, to the point of pulling her out of the story, and Goodreads readers raise the same complaint. I agree. The first dozen are charming. By the last act I was rolling my eyes at each new one. It is a small flaw, but it is the one you will notice.

The audiobook is a good way in. Gaby at LezReviewBooks gave Abby Craden's narration five stars and said Craden caught the book's playful tone, and at six and a half hours it is an easy listen.

Chemistry Lessons is a short, sunny friends to lovers romance that trades drama for warmth and mostly gets away with it. Read it if you want comfort rather than catharsis, and are willing to forgive a few too many chemistry puns.

How Spicy Is Chemistry Lessons?

Chemistry Lessons is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. The build is slow and mostly about kisses and charged touches, and there is open door sexual content concentrated in one chapter later in the book, which reader content notes flag. It is frank but not long, and fully consensual.

Both leads are adults in their thirties. They met in kindergarten, have been friends for twenty five years, and both work at the same school.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reviews and Smart Bitches, Trashy Books:

Our romance heat levels guide explains the scale, and our content warnings guide explains how we build these lists.

Who Should Read Chemistry Lessons?

Chemistry Lessons suits readers who want a cozy, quick, low angst sapphic romance between lifelong best friends, with a warm family and friend group around them. It is less suited to readers who need high stakes, steamy heat or a strong external plot.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Chemistry Lessons was well received in the sapphic romance community and won a 2022 Goldie Award from the Golden Crown Literary Society, according to Ylva. It holds a 3.97 average from more than 2,500 ratings on Goodreads, a little lower than several of Jae's other books. Trade journal coverage is thin; the conversation is mostly blogs and readers.

Where they agree. Warmth and comfort. Smart Bitches, Trashy Books praised the believable HEA and the cute moments, The Lesbian Book Blog praised the twist on a beloved trope, and Gaby at LezReviewBooks called it light, upbeat and never contrived. Rainbow Moose's Reviews was also supportive, and Goodreads readers return to the low angst tone, the cameos and the family scenes.

Where they split. Whether sweet is enough. Goodreads readers who rated it lower call it too nice, light on conflict or forgettable, and a strand of StoryGraph criticism found it boring or overly cute. The science jokes divide people too: SBTB found them overdone, while other readers list the puns as a highlight.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Chemistry Lessons scores 7.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top mark for the ending, a believable and earned HEA, and its lowest for characters, writing and emotional impact, where readers fault thin conflict and overused puns.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4A real friendship turning into desire; SBTB praises the cute, angst free romance.
Characters (15%)3.5Ky's family history gives depth; Goodreads readers find the two leads hard to tell apart.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Brisk and funny, but SBTB says the chemistry references are overdone.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5The father thread lands; StoryGraph critics want more complex emotion.
Heat level (10%)3.5One open door chapter that fits a gentle book, as reader content notes flag.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4.5SBTB calls the HEA believable because of the couple's long history.
Reread appeal (10%)4Short and comforting; LezReviewBooks recommends the audiobook as an easy listen.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Chemistry Lessons is one of Jae's lightest books, below Just a Touch Away and Perfect Rhythm for depth but an easy recommendation for a cozy weekend, with a final Eikna Score of 7.6/10.

Unexpected Love Reading Order

Chemistry Lessons is book 5 in Jae's Unexpected Love series by the author's own count, which includes short stories. Each novel follows a different couple, so you can start with Chemistry Lessons; reading Wrong Number, Right Woman first only adds a little extra pleasure to one cameo.

Best format: the Tantor audiobook, narrated by Abby Craden, is about six and a half hours and suits the book's playful tone. Our series order guide covers other connected romances.

If You Loved Chemistry Lessons, Read These Next

If you loved Chemistry Lessons, the closest matches are sapphic romances where a long friendship or a shared home slowly turns into something more.

Frequently Asked Questions

Chemistry Lessons raises a few common questions: where it sits in Jae's series, how spicy it is, whether it has a happy ending and how long the audiobook runs. Short answers below.

Do you need to read the Unexpected Love series in order?

No. Chemistry Lessons has its own couple and reads as a standalone. Reading Wrong Number, Right Woman first only adds context to a cameo.

What is the Unexpected Love reading order?

Under a Falling Star, Partners, Wrong Number, Right Woman, Lucky Yellow Shoes, Chemistry Lessons, then The Principal's Office.

Is Chemistry Lessons spicy?

Moderately. Chemistry Lessons is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with open door, consensual sexual content concentrated in one chapter.

Does Chemistry Lessons have a happy ending?

Yes. Chemistry Lessons ends with a happily ever after for Ky and Regan.

Is Chemistry Lessons low angst?

Yes. The main tension comes from Ky's estranged father and the fear of losing the friendship, and there is no dramatic breakup.

Is there a Chemistry Lessons audiobook?

Yes. Tantor Media released it in February 2022, narrated by Abby Craden, running about 6 hours 30 minutes.

The Bottom Line

Chemistry Lessons earns a 7.6/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a quick, warm, low angst sapphic friends to lovers romance and do not need a dramatic plot to stay hooked. The one reason to pick it up is the friendship: Jae makes twenty five years of closeness feel lived in, so the moment it tips over into romance feels inevitable.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.