Romantic Comedy by Curtis Sittenfeld Review
Eikna Score: 7.5/10. Recommended.
Romantic Comedy is Curtis Sittenfeld at her sharpest in the first half, a funny, insider look at a late-night sketch show and a writer who is sure a pop star could never want her, followed by a slower, softer pandemic romance told partly in emails. It is a smart, satisfying love story with a happy ending, but readers who want romance-novel momentum may find the middle long and the finish quick.
Read it if you like workplace comedy, a heroine who overthinks everything, and literary fiction that takes the romance genre seriously. Skip it if long email exchanges bore you, or you want the second half to move as fast as the first.
Romantic Comedy at a Glance
Romantic Comedy is Curtis Sittenfeld's 2023 standalone novel, published by Random House on April 4, 2023, and a Reese's Book Club pick. It follows a sketch-show writer and a pop star who meet when he hosts the show, lose touch, then reconnect during the 2020 lockdown. It ends happily. The US hardcover runs 320 pages.
| Author | Curtis Sittenfeld |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone |
| Subgenre | Romantic comedy and literary fiction, contemporary |
| Main tropes | Ordinary woman and celebrity, workplace romance, second chance after a missed connection, love letters (emails), insecure heroine |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Serious COVID illness in the family, pandemic isolation, crude humor, body image insecurity (full list below) |
| POV | First person, Sally |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 320 (US hardcover); 352 (US paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Kristen Sieh, 9 hours 5 minutes (Penguin Random House Audio) |
| First published | April 4, 2023 |
| Publisher | Random House |
What Is Romantic Comedy About?
Romantic Comedy follows Sally Milz, a 36-year-old writer on The Night Owls, a live late-night sketch show in the mold of Saturday Night Live. Sally has a theory: on her show, ordinary-looking men date glamorous women all the time, and it never happens the other way round.
Then Noah Brewster, a famous pop singer, hosts the show for a week in 2018, and he and Sally hit it off while writing a sketch together. She is certain it means nothing, and she makes sure of it. Two years later, with the world shut down and Sally at home with her stepfather, an email from Noah arrives, and the two start writing to each other.
What Makes This Ordinary Woman and Celebrity Romance Work
Romantic Comedy works because it puts the oldest fantasy in romance, the famous man who chooses the ordinary woman, in the hands of someone who does not believe it. Sally is funny, observant and convinced she is average, and the book lets her argue against her own love story for most of its length. That tension is the engine.
The second draw is the setting. The opening section is a week inside a sketch show, from pitch meeting to live broadcast, and Norah Piehl at Bookreporter singled out how lively and funny those scenes are. It reads like the work of someone who has studied how that machine runs, week by week.
Third, the emails. The middle of the book is a correspondence, and Publishers Weekly praised the vulnerability the format allows. It is where Sally and Noah actually get to know each other, slowly and in writing.
My Review
I loved the first hundred pages of Romantic Comedy without reservation. The show week is fast, specific and very funny, and Sally is the kind of narrator who notices everything and trusts nothing, including herself. The rest of the book is gentler and slower. I liked it, but differently.
Romance and Chemistry
The early chemistry is excellent because it comes from work. Sally and Noah are good at making each other laugh, and the scene where they build a sketch together is as romantic as anything later in the book. Then Sally talks herself out of it, and you understand exactly why.
The email section is where opinion divides. Publishers Weekly liked the vulnerability but thought the correspondence ran too long, and Ashley Hajimirsadeghi found it tedious. I enjoyed it, but I noticed the pages. Fruzsina Gál at Aniko Press admired the connection between the leads but found their talk over-scripted at times, and there are moments where both of them sound a little too emotionally fluent to be real. A reader on r/RomanceBooks loved Noah's respect for boundaries; another reply called him idealized. Both are right.
The Characters
Sally is the book. She is sharp, self-mocking and stubbornly insecure, and Sittenfeld does not resolve those insecurities just because a handsome man likes her. Kirkus praised how the book handles the way gender intersects with fame, youth and talent, and Sally is the vehicle for that argument. Bookreporter found her flatter in the pandemic section, which I felt too: she is at her most alive in the writers' room.
Noah is warm, thoughtful and patient, which bookishjen at The Bookself Blog felt made him too perfect to be convincing. The best supporting thread is Sally's relationship with her aging stepfather, which Piehl called out as one of the subplots that add depth.
Sally's friendships with two cast members are the other quiet pleasure. They give her someone to be wrong in front of, and they keep the book from becoming a two-hander. Bookreporter flagged those friendships too, and they are a reminder that Sittenfeld is as interested in Sally's working life as in her love life. If you come to Romantic Comedy only for the romance, those chapters may feel like detours. I thought they were the point: the love story matters because Sally has a full life to fit it into.
Writing and Pacing
Sittenfeld writes fast, clean, funny prose, and the dialogue in the show sections crackles. The structure is the issue. Three parts with three different speeds means the momentum of the opening never returns, and Sascha Darlington preferred the backstage opening and the early emails to the stillness that follows. Kirkus, in an otherwise admiring review, thought the resolution came too quickly. I agree: after hundreds of pages of doubt, the final turn feels brisk.
Romantic Comedy is a funny, intelligent love story with a brilliant first act and a slower, softer middle. Read it if you want a smart heroine and a behind-the-scenes setting; skip it if you need genre romance pacing from start to finish.
How Spicy Is Romantic Comedy?
Romantic Comedy is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. The sexual content arrives late, once Sally and Noah are together in person, and it is frank rather than lingering. The book discusses sexual health and exclusivity directly, which several reviewers noted, and the scenes are clearly consensual between adults.
Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Content warnings, drawn from reviews and our own read:
- COVID-19, including serious illness in the heroine's family
- Pandemic isolation and anxiety
- Scatological and crude humor
- Body image insecurity and social comparison
- Political discussion
- Open-door sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Romantic Comedy?
Romantic Comedy suits readers who like literary fiction with a love story at its center, a witty and anxious first-person heroine, and a workplace setting rendered in detail. It is less suited to readers who want steady romance-novel pacing or a celebrity romance played as pure fantasy.
Best for:
- Fans of workplace and showbiz settings
- Readers who like a self-aware, overthinking narrator
- Book clubs that want a romance to argue about
- Readers who enjoy epistolary sections and love letters
Not for:
- Readers who skim long letters or emails
- Anyone wanting high heat (try our spicy picks)
- Readers who want a pandemic-free contemporary
- Anyone who wants the hero to have visible flaws
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Romantic Comedy was a Reese's Book Club pick and a major critical release in 2023. Kirkus called it romance artfully and entertainingly deconstructed, and Publishers Weekly praised its characterization while questioning its length.
Where they agree. The opening and the writing. Norah Piehl at Bookreporter found the show sections lively and funny, Kirkus admired its handling of fame and gender, and Sascha Darlington loved the backstage start. Almost everyone enjoys Sally's voice.
Where they split. The emails and the ending. Publishers Weekly found the correspondence too long and the Cinderella shape less distinctive; Ashley Hajimirsadeghi was more interested in the career material than the romance and found the emails tedious. Kirkus thought the resolution quick. Fruzsina Gál at Aniko Press found the dialogue over-scripted. Bookishjen at The Bookself Blog did not believe the chemistry and found Noah too perfect, while a reader on r/RomanceBooks praised exactly that. Sittenfeld herself, in her book club letter, said she set out to write an enjoyable escape full of romance.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Romantic Comedy scores 7.5 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with top marks for writing and its heroine and lower scores for a long middle and a quick resolution.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Strong chemistry at the show; the emails run long, per Publishers Weekly. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Sally is a vivid narrator; Noah reads as too perfect to some, per The Bookself Blog. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4.5 | Fast, funny prose and a lively workplace, per Bookreporter and Kirkus. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | Sally's insecurity lands; the pandemic section is flatter. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Frank, adult and open door, as a literary romance should be. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A real HEA that Kirkus found too quick, and so did we. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | The show week is endlessly rereadable; the middle less so. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Romantic Comedy is among the best literary takes on the romance genre of the 2020s and Sittenfeld's warmest novel, landing at a final Eikna Score of 7.5/10.
Is Romantic Comedy a Standalone?
Yes. Romantic Comedy is a standalone novel with a complete love story and a happy ending. It is not connected to Curtis Sittenfeld's other books, so you can start here.
Best format: print or ebook makes the email section easier to scan. The audiobook, read by Kristen Sieh, runs 9 hours 5 minutes and suits Sally's conversational voice. Our series order guide covers connected romances if you want something longer.
If You Loved Romantic Comedy, Read These Next
If you loved Romantic Comedy, look for romances about writers and performers with sharp narrators and a little meta-commentary on the genre.
- Beach Read by Emily Henry: two novelists, one bet, and a book about whether romance can be serious.
- Book Lovers by Emily Henry: a literary agent who knows she is the wrong heroine for a love story.
- The Ex Talk by Rachel Lynn Solomon: two radio producers, a fake premise and a workplace rendered with care.
- Happy Place by Emily Henry: a missed connection years later, told across two timelines.
- Red, White and Royal Blue by Casey McQuiston: fame, secrecy and a love story built partly on emails.
Frequently Asked Questions
Romantic Comedy raises the same questions for most readers: whether it is really a romance, how spicy it is and how it ends. Short answers below.
Is Romantic Comedy a romance novel?
Mostly, yes. Romantic Comedy is literary fiction with a central love story and a happy ending, so it works as a romance.
Is Romantic Comedy spicy?
Moderately. Romantic Comedy is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with open-door scenes late in the book and frank talk about sex.
Does Romantic Comedy have a happy ending?
Yes. Sally and Noah end together, though some critics, including Kirkus, found the resolution quick.
Is The Night Owls based on Saturday Night Live?
Yes. The Night Owls in Romantic Comedy is a fictional sketch show clearly modeled on Saturday Night Live.
Is Romantic Comedy set during COVID?
Partly. Romantic Comedy opens in 2018 and resumes in the summer of 2020 during the pandemic shutdown.
Who narrates the Romantic Comedy audiobook?
Kristen Sieh narrates the Romantic Comedy audiobook, which runs 9 hours 5 minutes.
The Bottom Line
Romantic Comedy earns a 7.5/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a clever, funny love story with a heroine who does not believe she deserves one, and who can enjoy a slower middle. The reason to pick it up is the opening week at The Night Owls: it is the best writers' room in recent fiction.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Romantic Comedy, Penguin Random House (editions, Reese's Book Club)
- Romantic Comedy, Curtis Sittenfeld (author site)
- Romantic Comedy audiobook, Libro.fm (narrator, length)
- Romantic Comedy book club kit and author letter, Random House
- Romantic Comedy, Kirkus Reviews
- Romantic Comedy, Publishers Weekly review
- Romantic Comedy, Bookreporter (Norah Piehl)
- Romantic Comedy, Aniko Press (Fruzsina Gál)
- Review of Romantic Comedy, Sascha Darlington
- Romantic Comedy, Ashley Hajimirsadeghi
- Book review: Romantic Comedy, The Bookself Blog (bookishjen)
- Thoughts on Romantic Comedy, r/RomanceBooks discussion
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.