Snow Falls by Gerri Hill Review
Eikna Score: 6.7/10. Recommended with reservations.
Snow Falls is a classic snowbound cabin romance: an avalanche strands a writer with a reclusive stranger in the Colorado mountains for weeks, and the first half is as cozy and charged as that setup promises. Then the snow melts, the women separate, and the book loses most of its heat to evasions, a fiancé and a strange family subplot.
Read it if you want a gentle, quick snowed in romance with mountain scenery, or you like a heroine discovering her attraction to women for the first time. Skip it if you dislike long stretches of avoidable miscommunication, or the "I only ever dated men" coming out arc feels tired to you.
Snow Falls at a Glance
Snow Falls is a standalone sapphic romance by Gerri Hill, published by Bella Books in December 2012. It alternates third person between its two heroines, is set mostly in a snowbound Colorado cabin, has moderate heat by our reading and ends happily. It won a GCLS Goldie Award for Traditional Romance.
| Author | Gerri Hill |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone (Morgan and Reese from Hill's No Strings appear in supporting roles) |
| Subgenre | Sapphic contemporary romance |
| Main tropes | Forced proximity, snowed in, rescue, coming out, slow burn, hidden identity |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Avalanche danger, family and internalized homophobia, a fiancé, a disturbing family subplot (full list below) |
| POV | Third person, alternating between Jen and Catherine |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 224 (Bella Books listing; an earlier retail record listed 304) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Abby Craden, about 5 hours (Tantor Media, August 2021); an earlier recording by Sara Hawthorne runs about 5 hours 54 minutes |
| First published | December 2012 |
| Publisher | Bella Books |
What Is Snow Falls About?
Jennifer Kincaid is driving through the Colorado mountains on her way to a writing workshop when an avalanche blocks the road near Lake City and leaves her stranded. Catherine Ryan-Barrett, who goes by Ryan, has come to a high mountain cabin for one reason: to spend a winter alone, away from the famous family name she would rather nobody recognized.
Ryan rescues Jen, and with the roads closed until spring, the two women are stuck together for weeks. A guarded friendship grows into something more. Then the thaw comes, and Jen goes home to Santa Fe and to a man who wants to marry her, without knowing who her rescuer really is.
What Makes This Snowed In Romance Work
Snow Falls works, at least for its first half, because its forced proximity lasts long enough to matter. Most snowed in romances give their couple a weekend; Gerri Hill gives Jen and Ryan six to eight weeks in a small cabin, and the slow shift from strangers to friends to something more has room to breathe.
The setting does a lot of the work. Gaby at LezReviewBooks wrote that "nature is another character in Gerri Hill's books," and the frozen mountains here are both beautiful and genuinely dangerous. Weather and the simple question of how to fill a day carry more of the story than any big set piece.
The coming out element adds another layer. Jen has only dated men, and her realization that she is falling for a woman is the emotional spine of the book, for better and worse. Readers who like forced proximity in its purest form will find the hook here.
My Review
I loved the first half of Snow Falls and spent the second half wishing the snow had stayed. That is the short version, and it matches what most readers say. Anna M. at the Lesbrary called it "a solid romance" and a quick, enjoyable read, while noting it is not Hill's best. I agree with every part of that.
Gerri Hill has written a long list of sapphic romances for Bella Books, and her strengths are all on display in the cabin chapters: unhurried scenes, unforced conversation and a real feel for wild places. The weaknesses arrive when the plot has to do more than keep two women in one room.
Romance and Chemistry
Inside the cabin, the chemistry is quietly strong. Gaby at LezReviewBooks said the first half, with the women sharing a small cabin for about six weeks, builds real chemistry, and The Lesbian Review called it a gentle romance about two women unsure whether they can fall in love. The romance grows out of routine and conversation, and a gradual loosening of Ryan's reserve.
Outside the cabin, it falters. Once Jen returns to Santa Fe, the leads spend long stretches apart, and LezReviewBooks felt the bond never regained its intensity. Goodreads readers point to poor communication and to Ryan repeatedly running away, and Anna M. was frustrated that Ryan hides her identity and passes up chance after chance to come clean. I felt the same. A secret that made sense on day one makes much less sense on day forty.
The Characters
Jen is warm, a little naive and raised by conservative grandparents, and she is startled at first to learn that Ryan is a lesbian. Her slow realization about her own feelings is handled kindly, but Anna M. was tired of the "discovering I am a lesbian after only dating men" arc, and one Goodreads reader raised a concern about bisexual erasure. Both points stand. Several readers also felt Jen's engagement was set aside too easily.
Ryan is the more interesting of the two: wealthy, wary and tired of being a name rather than a person. The family thread around her is where the book goes wrong. Goodreads readers call the subplot involving her brother Charles bizarre and off-putting, and it sits awkwardly in a gentle romance. Morgan and Reese, the couple from Hill's No Strings, are a bright spot in the supporting cast.
Writing and Pacing
Hill's prose is plain and steady, with long descriptive passages of snow, sky and mountains that readers either love or skim. The pacing is the issue. The book is short, around 224 pages in Bella's listing, and still feels slow in places: the cabin chapters linger on purpose, while the Santa Fe chapters drag because the conflict depends on people not saying things.
On audio, readers have two options. Abby Craden narrates the Tantor edition, and many Goodreads listeners praise her; Gaby at LezReviewBooks reviewed Sara Hawthorne's recording, found it good but not remarkable, and missed Craden's voices for Morgan and Reese.
Snow Falls is a cozy, atmospheric snowbound romance that is at its best in the cabin and noticeably weaker once the women leave it. Read it if you want a quick, gentle winter read and can forgive a second half built on evasion.
How Spicy Is Snow Falls?
Snow Falls is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. The cabin chapters build slowly through kisses and growing attraction, and readers report open door, consensual love scenes once the relationship begins, though they disagree on how steamy they are: one Goodreads reader counts two spicy scenes, another found almost no heat. Expect brief, tender scenes rather than a sexy book.
Both leads are adults; readers place them in their late twenties to thirties.
Content warnings, drawn from reader reviews and the Lesbrary:
- Avalanche danger, isolation and risk of injury
- Family pressure from a wealthy, famous family
- Family and internalized homophobia
- A heroine leaving a relationship with a man who wants to marry her
- A disturbing subplot involving a brother, including remembered nonconsensual voyeurism
- Ableist humor, flagged by one Lesbrary reviewer
- Alcohol
- Open door sexual content
Our romance heat levels guide explains the scale, and our content warnings guide explains how we build these lists.
Who Should Read Snow Falls?
Snow Falls suits readers who want a gentle, quick sapphic snowed in romance with a strong sense of place and a coming out arc. It is less suited to readers who are tired of avoidable miscommunication, or who want the tension and chemistry of the first half to last to the end.
Best for:
- Readers who love snowed in and cabin romances
- Fans of slow, quiet relationship building
- Anyone who enjoys mountain and nature writing
- Readers who like a first sapphic relationship arc
- Gerri Hill readers who remember No Strings
Not for:
- Readers who dislike secrets kept for too long
- Anyone tired of the "only dated men" coming out trope
- Readers who want steady heat
- People who want the second half as strong as the first
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Snow Falls won a GCLS Goldie Award for Traditional Romance, according to Bella Books, and holds a 3.93 average from more than 3,200 ratings on Goodreads. Coverage is mostly sapphic review blogs and reader reviews.
Where they agree. The cabin half and the setting. Anna M. at the Lesbrary called it a nice take on being snowed in, LezReviewBooks praised the first half's chemistry and the mountain winter, and The Lesbian Review praised the well written characters and the shared perspectives. Goodreads readers enjoy the slow burn, the nature writing and the quick, cozy listen.
Where they split. Nearly everything after the thaw. LezReviewBooks gave it 3.5 stars and doubted the couple's happy ending because they spend so long apart. Goodreads readers object to the poor communication, the brother subplot and how easily Jen's engagement is handled, and Danika Ellis at the Lesbrary raised objections about identity representation, ableist humor and the family storyline. StoryGraph reviews include similar complaints.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Snow Falls scores 6.7 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for the cabin romance, the heat and rereadability, and its lowest for emotional impact and the ending, which reviewers find weakened by a long separation and evasive leads.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Strong cabin chemistry per LezReviewBooks; the bond fades once the women separate. |
| Characters (15%) | 3.5 | Likable leads, but Anna M. tires of Ryan hiding her identity. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Lovely nature writing; Goodreads readers say the second half drags. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3 | LezReviewBooks was not invested; the coming out arc feels familiar. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Brief, tender open door scenes that suit a gentle romance, per reader reports. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3 | An HEA that LezReviewBooks doubted after long stretches apart. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | A quick, cozy winter comfort read for Goodreads readers. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Snow Falls is mid table Gerri Hill, a pleasant snowbound romance that readers and reviewers rank below her best, with a final Eikna Score of 6.7/10.
Is Snow Falls a Standalone?
Yes. Snow Falls is a standalone romance with a new couple, so you can start here. Morgan and Reese, the couple from Gerri Hill's earlier novel No Strings, appear in supporting roles, and readers who know them will enjoy the cameo, but nothing in No Strings is required to follow this story.
Best format: the audiobook. At around five to six hours it is an easy winter listen, and many Goodreads listeners praise Abby Craden's Tantor recording. Our series order guide covers connected romances if you want something longer.
If You Loved Snow Falls, Read These Next
If you loved Snow Falls, the closest matches are sapphic romances with snow, confinement or a slow, quiet build between two women.
- Alone by E.J. Noyes: a remote compound, an injured stranger and a far darker, more intense version of isolation romance.
- Kiss Her Once for Me by Alison Cochrun: a snowed in family chalet at Christmas and a fake engagement to the wrong sibling.
- Make the Season Bright by Ashley Herring Blake: a queer second chance Christmas romance with more heat and more hurt.
- Just a Touch Away by Jae: two women forced to share a building for ninety-two days, with a guarded heroine who thaws.
- The Roommate Arrangement by Jae: a quiet, kind slow burn about two women sharing a home.
Frequently Asked Questions
Snow Falls raises a few common questions: whether it is a standalone, how spicy it is, whether it ends happily and how it connects to No Strings. Short answers below.
Is Snow Falls by Gerri Hill a standalone?
Yes. Snow Falls has its own couple and can be read alone, though Morgan and Reese from No Strings appear in supporting roles.
Is Snow Falls spicy?
Moderately. Snow Falls is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with brief open door scenes; readers disagree on how steamy they are.
Does Snow Falls have a happy ending?
Yes. Snow Falls ends with a happily ever after for Jen and Ryan, after a long stretch apart.
How long are they snowed in during Snow Falls?
Jen and Ryan are stranded together for roughly six to eight weeks, until the roads reopen in spring.
Is Snow Falls a coming out story?
Partly. Jen has only dated men before, and her growing feelings for Ryan are a central thread of the book.
Is there a Snow Falls audiobook?
Yes. Abby Craden narrates a Tantor Media edition released in August 2021, and an earlier recording narrated by Sara Hawthorne also exists.
The Bottom Line
Snow Falls earns a 6.7/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a quick, gentle sapphic snowed in romance and are happy to settle for a weaker second half. The one reason to pick it up is the cabin: few romances commit to snowbound proximity for this long, and those weeks in the mountains are lovely.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Snow Falls, Bella Books (date, pages, description, award, review excerpts)
- Anna M. reviews Snow Falls by Gerri Hill, the Lesbrary
- Snow Falls by Gerri Hill, LezReviewBooks (Gaby)
- Snow Falls audiobook, Tantor Media (narrator, release date)
- Snow Falls audiobook, xigxag (length, audiobook ISBN)
- Snow Falls, Goodreads (ratings and reader reviews)
- Danika Ellis at the Lesbrary, a librarians' write-up and StoryGraph reader reviews; Bookshop.org paperback record for the earlier 304 page listing
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.