Alone by E.J. Noyes Review
Eikna Score: 8.4/10. Recommended.
Alone is an absorbing, unsettling sapphic romance about a woman three years into a paid isolation experiment who finds an injured hiker outside her compound and has to decide whether to trust her, and whether to trust her own mind. The solitary stretches drag and the trust repair will split readers, but Celeste is one of the most vivid narrators in sapphic romance and the book is unlike anything else on the shelf.
Read it if you want a romance braided with psychological suspense, or you like a single, intense point of view that you live inside. Skip it if heavy angst and a slow opening wear you out, or a love interest with secrets makes you uneasy.
Alone at a Glance
Alone is a standalone sapphic romance by E.J. Noyes, published by Bella Books in May 2019. It is told in first person present tense by Celeste Thorne, mixes forced proximity with psychological suspense, has moderate open door heat and ends happily. It won a GCLS Goldie Award in the Romantic Blend category.
| Author | E.J. Noyes |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone |
| Subgenre | Sapphic romance with psychological suspense |
| Main tropes | Forced proximity, isolation, hurt and comfort, stranger with secrets, slow burn |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Extreme isolation, hallucinations, deception, childhood abuse, parental drug addiction (full list below) |
| POV | First person present, Celeste |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 288 (paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Abby Craden (Audible Studios, 2019) |
| First published | May 2019 |
| Publisher | Bella Books |
What Is Alone About?
Celeste Thorne has agreed to spend four years completely alone in a remote compound as part of a psychological study. No visitors, no outside contact, and half a million dollars at the end. More than three years in, she talks to herself, hears voices that are not there and sees faces she knows are imagined.
Then she finds a real person: Olivia Soldano, an injured hiker near the compound. Helping her means breaking the study's rules and risking everything Celeste has endured for. Not helping her is not something Celeste can live with. As the two women grow closer, Celeste has to work out what she can trust, including what she sees with her own eyes.
What Makes This Forced Proximity Romance Work
Alone works because its forced proximity is extreme: one woman who has not seen another human in over three years, and a stranger who suddenly needs her. E.J. Noyes turns a familiar trope into a psychological puzzle, where every moment of closeness is also a question about what is real.
Readers who pick it up usually do so for the premise, and Bella Books readers keep reaching for the same word: different. One Goodreads reviewer quoted by the publisher called it different and weird, "but in a good way." C-Spot Reviews praised how Noyes builds a sinister atmosphere, and that unease is part of the romance. You want Celeste to have this connection, and you are not sure she should.
It is also a hurt and comfort story in both directions. Olivia is physically hurt; Celeste is starved of contact and carrying a brutal childhood. Readers who like forced proximity pushed to its limit will find the hook here.
My Review
I have read a lot of forced proximity romances. I had not read one where the heroine had spent three years talking to the walls before the love interest arrived. Alone is a strange book, and the strangeness is what makes it memorable.
Tere at LezReviewBooks gave it five stars and singled out the first person narration, and that is where the book lives. Noyes puts you so deep inside Celeste's head that her loneliness becomes physical. When she first touches another person after years without contact, it is a big moment, and the book earns it.
Romance and Chemistry
The romance is a slow burn shaped by suspicion. Celeste wants Olivia to be real, wants her to stay and also wants to protect the study she has given up years of her life for. Olivia is warm and curious, and Celeste has no easy way to check her story. The pull between them is strong, and the early embrace that LezReviewBooks called sweet and heartfelt is a highlight.
Where Alone splits readers is the trust question. A strand of critical StoryGraph reviews calls Olivia's intrusions selfish or even creepy and doubts the way trust is rebuilt, and some Goodreads readers found the power dynamic uncomfortable. I think that tension is the point, but I also think the repair comes faster than the damage deserves. If secrets between partners are a dealbreaker for you, know that going in.
The Characters
Celeste is the reason to read this. Her backstory, a childhood marked by physical and emotional abuse from a mother addicted to methamphetamine, comes through in auditory hallucinations rather than tidy flashbacks, and LezReviewBooks found that technique effective. So did I. Her past is not explained to you; it intrudes on her, the way it would.
Olivia is harder to see clearly, partly by design: we only know her through Celeste. That limits her, and some Goodreads readers call a secondary character underdeveloped. But the confinement of the viewpoint is also what keeps the suspense alive. You know only what Celeste knows, and Celeste is not sure what she knows.
Writing and Pacing
Noyes writes with real control. The first person present tense gives the isolation an unbroken, airless quality, and the prose is clean and specific. Goodreads readers praise the writing as some of the best in her catalogue.
The pacing is the weakness. The solitary opening section is slow, and the LezReviewBooks audiobook reviewer said the story drags during Celeste's solitary scenes and drops perhaps too many hints about the mystery. Goodreads readers raise the same points: repetition in the isolation sections, and twists some saw coming. I guessed part of it too. It did not matter as much as I expected, because the book is less about the reveal than about how Celeste handles it.
The audiobook is excellent. The same LezReviewBooks reviewer said Abby Craden brings every character to life and gave the narration the highest marks; Goodreads listeners agree.
Alone is an intense, original romance that uses isolation to make every touch feel enormous. Read it if you want suspense and heavy emotion with your love story, and can live with a trust repair that some readers find too quick.
How Spicy Is Alone?
Alone is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. The romance builds slowly, and later in the book there are open door, consensual sex scenes that readers describe as steamy and intimate. They are not the focus of the story, but they are on the page.
Both leads are adults. The book's heavier material is psychological rather than sexual: isolation, hallucinations, deception and Celeste's history of abuse.
Content warnings, drawn from LezReviewBooks and reader reviews:
- Extreme isolation, monitoring and surveillance
- Auditory and visual hallucinations
- Deception and manipulation
- Physical injury
- Childhood physical and emotional abuse
- Parental methamphetamine addiction
- Anxiety, panic and trauma responses
- Explicit sexual content
Our romance heat levels guide explains the scale, and our content warnings guide explains how we build these lists.
Who Should Read Alone?
Alone suits readers who want a sapphic romance with psychological suspense, a single intense narrator and an unusual premise. It is less suited to readers who want a light read, a fast opening or a love interest with nothing to hide.
Best for:
- Readers who love forced proximity at its most extreme
- Fans of romance mixed with psychological suspense
- Anyone who likes a deep first person narrator
- Audiobook listeners who enjoy Abby Craden
- Readers who like hurt and comfort
Not for:
- Readers who want a low angst romance
- Anyone for whom secrets between partners are a dealbreaker
- Readers sensitive to depictions of childhood abuse or addiction
- People who need a fast first act
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Alone is one of E.J. Noyes's most acclaimed books. It won a GCLS Goldie Award in the Romantic Blend category and the Tee Corinne Award for its cover, according to Bella Books, and it holds a 4.27 average from more than 4,100 ratings on Goodreads. Coverage is mostly sapphic review blogs and readers rather than trade journals.
Where they agree. Originality and emotional power. Tere at LezReviewBooks gave it five stars and advised, "I would definitely recommend, but beware of the angst." Kitty Kat's Book Review Blog called it an addictive romantic psychological story, C-Spot Reviews praised the sinister atmosphere, and The Romantic Reader Blog praised the chemistry. Goodreads readers single out Celeste's characterization and Abby Craden's narration.
Where they split. Pace and trust. The LezReviewBooks audiobook review and many Goodreads readers found the solitary sections slow and some reveals predictable. StoryGraph critics questioned Olivia's behavior and the trust repair, some Goodreads readers found the power dynamic uncomfortable, and at least one found the angst exhausting.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Alone scores 8.4 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top mark for emotional impact, where Celeste's isolation and history hit hard, and its lowest for heat and reread appeal, since much of the payoff depends on suspense.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4 | Strong pull and a sweet first embrace; StoryGraph critics doubt the trust repair. |
| Characters (15%) | 4.5 | Celeste is vivid and complex; LezReviewBooks praises how her past surfaces. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4.5 | Controlled first person present; LezReviewBooks notes the solitary scenes drag. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 5 | Intense and memorable; Tere at LezReviewBooks warns of the angst. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Steamy, intimate scenes per Goodreads readers, kept secondary to the story. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 4 | A happy ending, though some readers find the repair too fast. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | The suspense is spent on first read, though Celeste's voice and the praised audio reward a revisit. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Alone is among E.J. Noyes's strongest and most original books, an award winner with a premise no one else has tried, with a final Eikna Score of 8.4/10.
Is Alone a Standalone?
Yes. Alone is a standalone novel with no series connections, so you can start right here. If you want more E.J. Noyes afterward, her Winter Olympics skiing romance Schuss is a good next step, though be aware it is a sequel to her earlier book Gold.
Best format: the Audible Studios audiobook narrated by Abby Craden. LezReviewBooks gave the narration its highest praise, and first person present tense suits audio. Our series order guide covers connected romances if you want something longer.
If You Loved Alone, Read These Next
If you loved Alone, the closest matches are sapphic romances with confinement, slow trust and a lot of feeling under the surface.
- Snow Falls by Gerri Hill: two women snowbound in a mountain cabin for weeks, gentler and much lower in angst.
- Schuss by E.J. Noyes: Noyes in a very different key, set around skiing and the Winter Olympics.
- The Roommate Arrangement by Jae: a wounded ex-cop slowly lets someone into her home and her life.
- Just a Touch Away by Jae: a woman who avoids touch and a professional cuddler, forced to live together.
- Here We Go Again by Alison Cochrun: a sapphic road trip romance that is also about grief and old wounds.
Frequently Asked Questions
Alone raises the same questions for most new readers: whether it is a standalone, how spicy it is, whether it has a happy ending and how dark it gets. Short answers below.
Is Alone by E.J. Noyes a standalone?
Yes. Alone is a standalone novel with no series connections.
Is Alone spicy?
Moderately. Alone is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with open door, consensual scenes later in the book that readers describe as steamy.
Does Alone have a happy ending?
Yes. Alone ends happily for Celeste and Olivia, though the road there involves secrets and a lot of angst.
Is Alone a thriller?
Not exactly. Alone is a romance first, with psychological suspense about what is real and whom Celeste can trust.
How dark is Alone?
Alone deals with extreme isolation, hallucinations and Celeste's history of childhood abuse by a mother addicted to methamphetamine. It is heavy, but not graphic about the abuse.
Is there an Alone audiobook?
Yes. Abby Craden narrates the Audible Studios audiobook, released in 2019, and reviewers praise her performance highly.
The Bottom Line
Alone earns an 8.4/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a sapphic romance with real psychological tension, a narrator you cannot shake and a premise unlike any other. The one reason to pick it up is Celeste: three years of silence, written so closely that the first human touch lands like an earthquake.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Alone, Bella Books (pages, description, awards, review excerpts)
- Alone, NetGalley (publication date, ISBN, description)
- Alone paperback record, Past Forward (pages, ISBN, date)
- Not Alone in praising Noyes, LezReviewBooks (Tere)
- An extraordinary lesbian romance audiobook: Alone, LezReviewBooks
- Alone audiobook, Audible (narrator, publisher)
- Alone, Goodreads (ratings and reader reviews)
- Schuss by E.J. Noyes, LezReviewBooks (sequel to Gold)
- The Romantic Reader Blog and StoryGraph reader reviews. Audiobook running time not confirmed.
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.