The Neighbor Favor by Kristina Forest Review
Eikna Score: 7.2/10. Recommended.
The Neighbor Favor is a sweet, bookish slow burn about a shy editor and the charming neighbor who turns out to be the fantasy author she used to email. The leads and the Greene family are lovely and the ending is kind, but the start is slow and the secret identity plot runs on dread for too long.
Read it if you love pen pals, publishing settings and gentle, low-heat romance between two introverts, or you want the first Greene Sisters book. Skip it if you want early heat or a fast plot, or a hero hiding his identity from the heroine makes you anxious rather than intrigued.
The Neighbor Favor at a Glance
The Neighbor Favor is book 1 of Kristina Forest's Greene Sisters series, published by Berkley in February 2023. Lily Greene, an editor in training, asks her new neighbor Nick to help her find a date for her sister's wedding, not knowing he is the fantasy author she once emailed. It alternates Lily and Nick, has mild heat and ends happily.
| Author | Kristina Forest |
|---|---|
| Series | The Greene Sisters #1 |
| Subgenre | Contemporary romance, romantic comedy |
| Main tropes | Pen pals to lovers, secret identity, neighbors, slow burn, friends to lovers |
| Spice level | 2/5: Mild, fade to black |
| Content warnings | Ghosting and deception, a neglectful and toxic parent, emotional abuse in the past (full list below) |
| POV | Dual, Lily and Nick |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 416 (US paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Keylor Leigh and Malik Rashad, about 10 hours 6 minutes |
| First published | February 28, 2023 |
| Publisher | Berkley (Penguin Random House) |
What Is The Neighbor Favor About?
Lily Greene is shy, bookish and working her way up in publishing. For a while she traded emails with the author of her favorite fantasy series, and the conversation felt like the realest thing in her life. Then he stopped writing back, with no explanation.
Now her sister is getting married and Lily needs a date. Her charming new neighbor, Nick, offers to help her find one, and the favor turns into dinners, long talks and the kind of ease Lily rarely feels with anyone. What she does not know is that Nick is the author who went silent on her, and he knows exactly who she is.
What Makes This Pen Pals Romance Work
The Neighbor Favor works because its secret identity gives the reader a front-row seat to a slow-motion collision. We know Nick wrote those emails; Lily does not. Every sweet moment between them carries the question of what happens when she finds out.
The second hook is the bookishness. Both leads love books and work around them, and Andrea Reid at The Nerd Daily singled out the publishing setting and the near-soulmate connection between two introverts. Maggie Boyd at All About Romance liked how naturally the relationship grows through shared reading.
Then there is the family. Lily is one of three Greene sisters, and the wedding plot gives Kristina Forest room to set up the rest of the series. If you like gentle slow burn romances with a warm family around them, this one delivers.
My Review
The Neighbor Favor is a cozy book, and I mean that as praise. It is about two quiet people who find it easier to be honest in writing than out loud, and about what it costs when one of them stops being honest at all.
Romance and Chemistry
Lily and Nick are good together. Their conversations are easy, their tastes overlap and they make each other braver. Andrea Reid at The Nerd Daily described a connection where both can simply be themselves, and that is the book at its best.
The ghosting and the secret are the sticking points. Maggie Boyd at All About Romance could not quite see why Nick needed to ghost Lily in the first place, and the reader beckyyreadss on StoryGraph wanted more groveling and more romantic gestures once the truth came out. Andrea Reid found the wait for the fallout created a sense of dread. I liked that Lily reacts in a measured way when she learns the truth, which Maggie Boyd also praised, and that the book avoids a long third-act breakup.
The Characters
Lily is kind, close to her family and willing to take risks after being hurt, and she grows a lot over the book. Nick is socially easy on the surface and running from a painful past underneath. Maggie Boyd praised his slow turn toward facing that past, and readers note an estranged, neglectful father in the background.
The Greene family is the warm center. Lily's sisters, Violet and Iris, are distinct enough that you will want their books, and the family scenes are funny without being cartoonish. Dini at dinipandareads and Joanna at The Geekish Brunette both enjoyed the cast.
Writing and Pacing
Forest writes clean, light prose that handles serious material with a soft touch; Maggie Boyd called it funny without being silly. The emails are a pleasure, though Andrea Reid felt they took up too much of the first quarter.
Pacing is the main weakness. At 416 pages the book is long for a light romance, the start is slow and the plot is, as Andrea Reid put it, more Hallmark than action. Maggie Boyd found the ending a bit too neat. The audiobook with Keylor Leigh and Malik Rashad, about ten hours, gives each lead a voice and helps the slower chapters move.
The Neighbor Favor is a gentle, bookish romance with lovely leads, a warm family and a secret that hangs over it a little too long. Read it for the pen pal magic and the Greene sisters; skip it if you need heat or speed.
How Spicy Is The Neighbor Favor?
The Neighbor Favor is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. The reader beckyyreadss on StoryGraph noted that the first intimate scene comes around chapter 20 and is discreet and closed door, while Andrea Reid at The Nerd Daily said only that there is some spice. Either way, this is a low-heat book.
The heavier material is family history and trust. Reviewers flag an estranged, toxic father, abandonment and past emotional abuse, and the central conflict is about deception and ghosting.
Content warnings, drawn from critics and reader reviews:
- Ghosting and deception in a relationship
- A neglectful, toxic parent and abandonment
- Past emotional abuse
- Fainting from heat, dehydration and stress
- Discreet sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Who Should Read The Neighbor Favor?
The Neighbor Favor suits readers who want a soft, bookish, low-heat romance between two introverts, with pen pals, a secret identity and a loving family. It is less suited to readers who want spice, pace or a hero with no deception in his past.
Best for:
- Readers who love publishing and book-world settings
- Fans of pen pal and secret identity romances
- Anyone who wants a low-heat, cozy read
- Readers starting the Greene Sisters series
- Audiobook listeners who like dual narrators
Not for:
- Readers who want early or explicit heat
- Anyone who dislikes a slow start
- Readers stressed by secret identity plots
- Anyone who wants high drama
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
The Neighbor Favor was warmly received, with most praise for its sweetness and its leads. Maggie Boyd at All About Romance called it a quick, cheery read, Andrea Reid at The Nerd Daily gave it 7 out of 10, and Dini at dinipandareads and Joanna at The Geekish Brunette both enjoyed it.
Where they agree. The leads and the bookish setting. Reviewers liked Lily's kindness, Nick's charm and the way books bring them together. beckyyreadss on StoryGraph praised the characters, the family and the publishing world. Where they split. Pace and the secret. Andrea Reid found the email section too long and the plot slow. Maggie Boyd found the ending too neat and the ghosting unconvincing. beckyyreadss wanted more heat and more groveling. Later readers, including Nacia Jackson at Lavender Bliss and Taylor Ceraolo's book club, kept the conversation going after release.The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
The Neighbor Favor scores 7.2 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with high marks for the characters and the ending, and lower marks for heat and pace.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | A natural, bookish connection, per The Nerd Daily; the secret drags. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Kind, likable leads and a warm family, per All About Romance. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Clean, light prose; a slow first quarter, per The Nerd Daily. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | Gentle rather than devastating. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3 | Discreet heat, per StoryGraph readers; fine for the tone. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 4 | A kind, happy ending, if a bit neat, per All About Romance. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | Cozy enough to revisit, especially on audio. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Neighbor Favor is a strong, gentle opener for the Greene Sisters and one of the cozier bookish romances of 2023, with a final Eikna Score of 7.2/10.
The Greene Sisters Reading Order
The Neighbor Favor is book 1 of Kristina Forest's Greene Sisters series, which follows each of the three Greene sisters in turn. Each book has its own couple and happy ending, so they work as connected standalones, but reading in order lets you watch the family grow.
- Book 1: The Neighbor Favor (2023): Lily Greene and Nick Brown
- Book 2: The Partner Plot (2024): Violet Greene and Xavier Wright
- Book 3: The Love Lyric (2025): Iris Greene and Angel Hughes
Where to start: right here, with Lily. Best format: the dual-narrator audiobook. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved The Neighbor Favor, Read These Next
If you loved The Neighbor Favor, try these bookish and letter-driven romances.
- The Partner Plot by Kristina Forest: Violet Greene wakes up married to her high school ex in the next Greene Sisters book.
- Yours Truly by Abby Jimenez: two doctors fall for each other through handwritten letters.
- By the Book by Jasmine Guillory: a publishing assistant and the reluctant author she has to coax into writing.
- Book Lovers by Emily Henry: an agent and an editor clash, then fall, in a small town.
- The Flatshare by Beth O'Leary: two flatmates who never meet fall for each other through notes.
Frequently Asked Questions
The Neighbor Favor raises a few common questions about heat, the series and the ending. Short answers below.
Is The Neighbor Favor spicy?
Not very. The Neighbor Favor is a 2 out of 5 on our scale, with discreet intimacy late in the book.
Is The Neighbor Favor part of a series?
Yes. It is book 1 of the Greene Sisters series, followed by The Partner Plot and The Love Lyric, and it reads as a standalone.
Does The Neighbor Favor have a happy ending?
Yes. The Neighbor Favor ends happily for Lily and Nick.
What is the secret in The Neighbor Favor?
Nick is the fantasy author Lily used to email before he stopped replying, and he knows who she is before she knows who he is.
Who narrates The Neighbor Favor audiobook?
Keylor Leigh and Malik Rashad narrate the audiobook, which runs about 10 hours 6 minutes.
The Bottom Line
The Neighbor Favor earns a 7.2/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a cozy, low-heat, bookish romance with pen pals, a secret identity and a family you will want to visit again, and who can be patient with a slow start. The reason to pick it up is Lily and Nick: two quiet people who were always more honest on the page.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- The Neighbor Favor, Penguin Random House (Berkley)
- The Greene Sisters series, Penguin Random House
- The Neighbor Favor, Kristina Forest official page
- The Neighbor Favor UK edition, Penguin
- The Neighbor Favor audiobook, Libro.fm (Keylor Leigh and Malik Rashad)
- The Neighbor Favor, Kirkus Reviews
- The Neighbor Favor, Publishers Weekly
- Review, The Nerd Daily (Andrea Reid)
- Review, All About Romance (Maggie Boyd)
- Review, dinipandareads (Dini)
- Review, The Geekish Brunette (Joanna)
- Reader review, StoryGraph (beckyyreadss)
- Review, Lavender Bliss (Nacia Jackson)
- Review, Quick Reads Only Book Club (Taylor Ceraolo)
- Review, She's Reading Now (Shawnerly)
Spice level is our own reading of reader reports; the author does not publish a heat rating.
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.