eikna romance
Menu

The Roughest Draft by Emily Wibberley and Austin Siegemund-Broka Review

Eikna Score: 6.7/10. Recommended with reservations.

The Roughest Draft is a moody, writerly second chance romance about two co-authors who stopped speaking at the height of their success and must finish one last book together. The pining and the craft detail are excellent, but the leads talk to each other through manuscripts instead of out loud, and the emotional infidelity will lose some readers.

Read it if you love books about writing, long pining and two timelines that slowly explain a breakup, or you liked Beach Read and want something sadder. Skip it if you cannot root for a heroine who is engaged to someone else when the story begins, or you lose patience with leads who avoid one honest conversation for most of a book.

The Roughest Draft by Emily Wibberley and Austin Siegemund-Broka book cover

The Roughest Draft at a Glance

The Roughest Draft is a standalone contemporary romance by married co-authors Emily Wibberley and Austin Siegemund-Broka, published by Berkley in January 2022. Two estranged novelists return to the small Florida town where they wrote their last book to finish a contract. It alternates first person and past and present timelines, with mild heat and a happy ending.

AuthorsEmily Wibberley and Austin Siegemund-Broka
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreContemporary romance
Main tropesSecond chance, co-authors, forced proximity, pining, dual timeline
Spice level2/5: Mild, fade to black
Content warningsEmotional infidelity, depression and anxiety, therapy (full list below)
POVDual first person present, Katrina and Nathan
EndingHEA
Pages336 (US paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Dan Bittner and Imani Jade Powers, about 9 hours 56 minutes
First publishedJanuary 25, 2022
PublisherBerkley (Penguin Random House)

What Is The Roughest Draft About?

Katrina Freeling and Nathan Van Huysen wrote a bestseller together, and then something happened that made them stop speaking. Three years later they still owe their publisher one more book, and both of them need the money and the closure badly enough to try.

So they go back to the small Florida town where they wrote the first one, sit down at the same kind of table and start drafting. Katrina's life has moved on, Nathan's has too, and the story they are writing starts to look uncomfortably like the conversation they never had. The novel moves between that working summer and the years that led to the split.

What Makes This Second Chance Romance Work

The Roughest Draft works because its second chance is built into the job. Katrina and Nathan cannot avoid each other: they have a contract, a deadline and a manuscript that demands they agree on every sentence. That makes the forced proximity feel earned rather than contrived.

The second hook is craft. Wibberley and Siegemund-Broka are a married writing team, and it shows in the detail of how two people build a book together, argue over a scene and learn to trust each other's instincts. Books Teacup and Reviews valued that collaboration detail, and Shannon at Cocktails and Books enjoyed the creative process even as she questioned it.

Then there is the pining. Tree at Words About Words singled out the pining and a café scene, and the book is full of looks across tables and lines of dialogue that mean two things. If you like second chance romances with real hurt underneath, this one goes deeper than most.

My Review

The Roughest Draft is not the light publishing rom-com its cover suggests. It is a melancholy book about two people who were closer in the pages they wrote than in their lives, and who let that gap cost them years. I admired it more than I loved it.

Romance and Chemistry

The romantic tension is constant and quiet. Stephanie at That Bookish Life found considerable chemistry, and the shared work gives Katrina and Nathan an intimacy that most fictional couples never get. When they write well together the book glows.

The problem is how they choose to communicate. Much of the emotional conversation happens through the manuscript, in subtext, rather than in a direct talk, and Shannon at Cocktails and Books questioned exactly that. Kirkus disputed the delayed reveal of what broke them apart, and Sam Still Reading called the reveal overstretched. Asha Reads felt the middle tension went on too long and the last stretch was rushed. I agree with all of them in part: the withholding builds pressure, then holds it a little past the point of pleasure.

Katrina is engaged to someone else when the book opens. Tree at Words About Words disliked that setup, and Publishers Weekly objected strongly to the emotional infidelity. Your tolerance for that will decide whether the romance works for you.

The Characters

Katrina is anxious, guarded and very good at her job. Kate at Smexy Books valued the way the book treats her depression and anxiety, therapy included, and the repaired friendship between the leads. Nathan is warmer on the page than Katrina, and his ex-wife is handled without villainy, which Kate also praised.

Outside each other, neither lead has much of a life. Stephanie at That Bookish Life noticed the same thing, and Kirkus found the two voices insufficiently distinct. Publishers Weekly went further and found both leads unsympathetic, which is harsher than my read but not unfair to the opening chapters.

Writing and Pacing

The prose is the strongest part. Kirkus praised its poetic quality, and there are lines about writing and grief that I underlined. The dual first-person present tense keeps things intimate, though the two narrators can blur.

Pacing is the weak point: a strong opening, a long middle that circles the same wound, and an ending that arrives quickly. The audiobook with Dan Bittner and Imani Jade Powers, just under ten hours, helps separate the two voices and is my recommended format.

The Roughest Draft is a beautifully written, slightly frustrating second chance romance about co-authors who say everything in their book and nothing to each other. Read it if you love writerly pining; skip it if emotional infidelity or a long withheld reveal will wear you out.

How Spicy Is The Roughest Draft?

The Roughest Draft is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. The heat is mostly tension, with brief, non-graphic intimacy late in the book, as the StoryGraph reader thebiglittlelibrary noted.

The heavier content is emotional rather than sexual. Katrina is engaged when the story begins, and the closeness between her and Nathan reads as emotional infidelity to many readers, including Publishers Weekly. Depression and anxiety are treated seriously, with therapy on the page.

Content warnings, drawn from critics and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Who Should Read The Roughest Draft?

The Roughest Draft suits readers who want a melancholy, literary second chance romance with lots of pining and a detailed look at how writers work together. It is less suited to readers who want a light rom-com, frank communication or leads with no romantic entanglements elsewhere.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Roughest Draft split critics and readers more sharply than most rom-coms. Kirkus praised the poetic prose while questioning the characterization and the delayed reveal, and Publishers Weekly was strongly negative about the emotional infidelity and the leads.

Where they agree. The writing and the pining. Tree at Words About Words loved the longing and a café scene. Kate at Smexy Books valued the mental health thread and the repaired friendship. Books Teacup and Reviews and Shannon at Cocktails and Books enjoyed the collaboration detail. Where they split. Communication and the setup. Sam Still Reading found the working partnership more convincing than the romance. Asha Reads felt the middle dragged. StoryGraph readers layansasa and ollygoose found the attraction frustrating and disputed the central conflict, while thebiglittlelibrary praised the symbolism and reported a happy ending.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Roughest Draft scores 6.7 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with fair marks for romance, writing and emotional impact, and lower marks for the characters and reread appeal.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Real chemistry, per That Bookish Life; subtext stands in for honest talk.
Characters (15%)3Katrina's mental health is handled well, per Smexy Books; thin lives outside the couple.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Poetic prose, per Kirkus; a long middle, per Asha Reads.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5The pining lands, per Words About Words.
Heat level (10%)3Mild, late heat that suits a melancholy book.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A happy ending reported by readers, reached a little quickly.
Reread appeal (10%)3The craft scenes reread well; the withheld reveal does not.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Roughest Draft is one of the more serious publishing romances of recent years and the most divisive book by this writing duo, with a final Eikna Score of 6.7/10.

Is The Roughest Draft a Standalone?

Yes. The Roughest Draft is a standalone novel with a complete arc and an ending for Katrina and Nathan. It is not tied to the authors' other books, so you can start here.

Best format: the audiobook, narrated by Dan Bittner and Imani Jade Powers, which makes the alternating first-person chapters easier to follow. Our series order guide covers connected romances if you want something longer.

If You Loved The Roughest Draft, Read These Next

If you loved The Roughest Draft, try these romances about writers, collaboration and second chances.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Roughest Draft raises a few common questions about heat, cheating and the ending. Short answers below.

Is The Roughest Draft spicy?

Not very. The Roughest Draft is a 2 out of 5 on our scale, with brief, non-graphic intimacy late in the book.

Is there cheating in The Roughest Draft?

There is emotional infidelity. Katrina is engaged to someone else when the story begins, and many readers flag her closeness with Nathan as emotional cheating.

Does The Roughest Draft have a happy ending?

Yes. Readers report a happily ever after for Katrina and Nathan.

Is The Roughest Draft a standalone?

Yes. It is a standalone novel by Emily Wibberley and Austin Siegemund-Broka.

Who narrates The Roughest Draft audiobook?

Dan Bittner and Imani Jade Powers narrate the audiobook, which runs about 9 hours 56 minutes.

The Bottom Line

The Roughest Draft earns a 6.7/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a melancholy, writerly second chance romance full of pining and craft, and who can live with emotional infidelity and a long-withheld reveal. The reason to pick it up is the writing: few romances show two people building a book together this well.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

Spice level is our own reading of reader reports; the authors do not publish a heat rating.

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.