This Spells Love by Kate Robb Review
Eikna Score: 6.4/10. Recommended with reservations.
This Spells Love has one of the best hooks in recent rom-coms: a breakup spell that erases the wrong history and leaves the heroine a stranger to her best friend. The voice is quick and funny, but the friendship it is built on stays mostly off the page and the ending arrives in a rush.
Read it if you want a light, magical twist on friends to lovers, or you enjoy chatty first-person heroines who are rethinking their whole lives. Skip it if you need to see the years of friendship that the romance depends on, or you are uneasy with one partner knowing far more about the other than he knows about her.
This Spells Love at a Glance
This Spells Love is Kate Robb's 2023 romantic comedy, published by The Dial Press on December 5, 2023. It is a standalone told in first person by Gemma, set in Hamilton, Ontario, with a magical premise, moderate open-door heat and a happily ever after. Publishers Weekly gave it a starred review.
| Author | Kate Robb |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone |
| Subgenre | Romantic comedy with a magical twist, Hamilton, Ontario |
| Main tropes | Friends to lovers, alternate reality, magic spell gone wrong, one-sided memory, career reinvention |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Breakup, alcohol, fire, injury, explicit sex (full list below) |
| POV | First person, Gemma |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 352 (US paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Khaya Fraites, 9 hours 30 minutes (Random House Audio) |
| First published | December 5, 2023 |
| Publisher | The Dial Press (Penguin Random House) |
What Is This Spells Love About?
This Spells Love follows Gemma, a woman in Hamilton, Ontario who has just been dumped and wants the pain gone. She tries a love cleanse spell meant to wipe her ex out of her past, more as a joke than anything.
It works, sort of. Gemma wakes up in a version of her life where things have shifted, and the most important change is that Dax, her best friend since childhood, has no idea who she is. To get her friend back, and to figure out what she actually wants from her life and her heart, Gemma has to win over a man who has never met her.
What Makes This Friends to Lovers Romance Work
This Spells Love works as a friends to lovers romance by flipping the trope inside out. Usually both friends share the history and the question is whether to risk it. Here only Gemma remembers, so she gets to see Dax with fresh eyes while he gets to meet her for the first time.
That is a clever engine. It lets the book ask whether the friendship was holding Gemma back, and whether the life she built around safe choices was the life she wanted. Publishers Weekly praised exactly that reevaluation and the connection at the center. The magic is lightweight and never explained, which keeps the tone breezy. If you like friends to lovers with a twist, the premise alone is worth a look.
My Review
This Spells Love made me laugh more in its first fifty pages than most rom-coms manage in a whole book, and then it left me wanting the book its premise promised. Gemma is good company. Her voice is fast, self-deprecating and full of local detail, and the setup lands with a satisfying jolt.
The trouble is structural. Kirkus enjoyed the wit and the self-discovery but argued that the rapid wrap-up weakens the emotional work that came before, and I think that is right. Publishers Weekly was warmer, with a starred review that praised Gemma's rethinking of her choices. My view sits nearer to Kirkus. The book is fun. It is not as deep as it wants to be.
Romance and Chemistry
The romance depends on a friendship we mostly have to take on trust. We hear about Gemma and Dax's years together, but we see very little of them before the spell, so the new version of their relationship has nothing on the page to measure itself against. Silvia at Books Real When Shared expected more of the original friendship and questioned the chemistry, and Zoë Mahler at Book Club for Book Hoes, who otherwise liked the book, wanted more of it too.
There is also an imbalance that some readers find uncomfortable. Gemma knows Dax's habits, history and weak spots; he knows nothing about her. Sofia at Inked Odyssey enjoyed the attraction but questioned how the relationship carries over between versions, and a StoryGraph reader objected to intimacy without equal knowledge. The book does not fully reckon with that, though the attraction itself is lively and the sex scenes, as Zoë Mahler noted, carry real vulnerability.
The Characters
Gemma is the book. She is funny and anxious, and her arc toward taking risks in work as well as love is the most satisfying thread. Sarah O'Connor at Not Sarah Connor Writes enjoyed watching her confidence grow. She is also, at times, so absorbed in her own crisis that she barely notices other people, which Joya at Vellichor Vibes and a Reddit reader both flagged.
Dax is likable and thin. Joya felt he was underdeveloped beyond his role as love interest, and I agree: because the book is all Gemma, we rarely get a sense of who he is when she is not looking at him. The family scenes, especially the friction between Gemma and her sister, are livelier, though Sarah O'Connor found the aunt and sister a little too conveniently summoned.
Writing and Pacing
Kate Robb writes chatty, quick, contemporary comedy, and Kirkus praised the first-person wit. The Hamilton setting is a nice change from the usual big-city rom-com, and Sarah O'Connor liked the local texture. Purple People Readers praised the pacing and the link between career and romance.
The voice will not suit everyone. Eya's Book Nook strongly disliked the narrator and found both the opening and ending compressed, and one StoryGraph reader stopped at page 23 over the voice. The middle slows, and a Reddit reader found it dragged. Then the ending, as Kirkus noted, wraps up quickly. Fans of the voice will not mind; readers who want the premise explored fully will.
This Spells Love is a bright, funny premise in search of a deeper book. Read it for Gemma's voice and the clever twist on friends to lovers; skip it if you need the friendship and the ending to have room to breathe.
How Spicy Is This Spells Love?
This Spells Love is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. There are a few explicit sex scenes, all consensual, and Zoë Mahler at Book Club for Book Hoes found them expressive of the characters' vulnerability. They are not the focus of the book, and the tone around them stays light.
One consent-adjacent point readers raise is the knowledge gap: Gemma remembers a whole shared history that Dax does not. Nothing on the page is coercive, but some readers find the imbalance uneasy. For more in this heat range, see our spicy romance list.
Content warnings, drawn from reviewer and reader reports:
- A painful breakup
- Alcohol use
- A fire
- Injury
- Explicit, consensual sex scenes
- Unequal memory and knowledge between partners
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and the romance heat levels guide explains the 0 to 5 scale.
Who Should Read This Spells Love?
This Spells Love suits readers who want a quick, funny rom-com with a magical premise and a heroine reinventing her life. It is less suited to readers who need deep friendship history on the page or a slow, careful resolution.
Best for:
- Fans of magical what-if romances
- Readers who enjoy chatty first-person narrators
- Anyone who likes stories about career reinvention alongside love
- Readers who want a Canadian setting outside the usual big cities
Not for:
- Readers who want the friendship shown before the romance
- Anyone uncomfortable with one-sided memory in a relationship
- Readers who dislike rushed endings
- People who find self-absorbed heroines hard to root for
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
This Spells Love got a starred review from Publishers Weekly and a more measured one from Kirkus, and blog and reader reaction divides sharply over the narrator and the premise.
Where they agree. The hook and the humor. Publishers Weekly praised Gemma's reevaluation and the central connection, Kirkus praised the first-person wit and self-discovery, and Kirkus's audiobook review praised Khaya Fraites for making Gemma witty and warm. Purple People Readers liked the pacing, and Inked Odyssey confirmed a happily ever after.
Where they split. The friendship and the ending. Books Real When Shared and Book Club for Book Hoes both wanted more of the original friendship. Vellichor Vibes found Dax underdeveloped and Gemma inattentive to others. Kirkus and a Reddit reader both found the ending rushed, and Eya's Book Nook disliked the voice outright, as did a StoryGraph reader who stopped early.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
This Spells Love scores 6.4 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for writing, emotional impact and heat, and its lowest for romance, characters and ending, which reviewers fault for thin friendship history and a rushed finish.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3 | Lively attraction but little shared history on the page; Books Real When Shared questions the chemistry. |
| Characters (15%) | 3 | Gemma is vivid; Vellichor Vibes finds Dax underdeveloped. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Witty first-person voice praised by Kirkus; the middle drags. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | Gemma's self-discovery lands, per Publishers Weekly. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Open-door scenes that suit the tone, per Book Club for Book Hoes. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3 | A happy ending, per Inked Odyssey, that Kirkus finds too quick. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3 | The twist is spent after one read. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: This Spells Love sits in the lighter half of the magical rom-com shelf, more fun than The Ex Hex in its premise and less satisfying in its follow-through, and lands at a final Eikna Score of 6.4/10.
Is This Spells Love a Standalone?
Yes. This Spells Love is a standalone novel with a single couple and no required prequel or sequel, so you can start here.
Best format: the Random House Audio edition, narrated by Khaya Fraites, runs about nine and a half hours, and Kirkus praised how well she captures Gemma's wit. The voice-driven style suits audio. Our series order guide covers connected romance series if you want something longer.
If You Loved This Spells Love, Read These Next
If you loved This Spells Love, the closest matches are light romances with a magical or time-bending twist and a heroine rethinking her life.
- The Ex Hex by Erin Sterling: a drunken curse on an ex causes chaos, with a cozy small-town witch setting.
- The Seven Year Slip by Ashley Poston: a magical apartment and a love story where one partner knows more than the other.
- People We Meet on Vacation by Emily Henry: friends to lovers with the shared history fully on the page.
- The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna: warm, funny magic and a heroine learning to let people in.
- The Dead Romantics by Ashley Poston: an impossible premise used to explore grief and a life in a rut.
Frequently Asked Questions
The questions readers ask most about This Spells Love are about heat, the ending, the friends to lovers setup and whether it connects to other books.
Is This Spells Love spicy?
Moderately. This Spells Love is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with a few explicit, consensual open-door scenes.
Does This Spells Love have a happy ending?
Yes. This Spells Love ends with a happily ever after for Gemma and Dax.
Is This Spells Love friends to lovers?
Yes, with a twist. A spell means Gemma remembers her lifelong friendship with Dax, but he has never met her.
Where is This Spells Love set?
This Spells Love is set in Hamilton, Ontario.
Is This Spells Love part of a series?
No. This Spells Love is a standalone romantic comedy.
Is there a This Spells Love audiobook?
Yes. Khaya Fraites narrates the Random House Audio edition, which runs about 9 hours 30 minutes.
The Bottom Line
This Spells Love earns a 6.4/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a quick, funny magical rom-com and can live with a friendship that is told more than shown. The reason to pick it up is the premise: a best friend who has to be won over from scratch is a fresh idea, and Gemma's voice makes it fun.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- This Spells Love, Penguin Random House
- Kate Robb, official books page
- This Spells Love, Penguin UK
- This Spells Love, Kirkus Reviews
- This Spells Love audiobook, Kirkus Reviews (narrator, length)
- This Spells Love, Publishers Weekly
- Review, Inked Odyssey
- Review, Not Sarah Connor Writes
- Review, Books Real When Shared
- Review, Book Club for Book Hoes
- Review, Purple People Readers
- Review, Vellichor Vibes
- Review, Eya's Book Nook
- r/RomanceBooks discussion
- StoryGraph reader reviews
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.