eikna romance
Menu

The Seven Year Slip by Ashley Poston Review

Eikna Score: 7.6/10. Recommended.

The Seven Year Slip is a tender, slightly magical romance about grief, burnout and a man who lives in the same apartment seven years earlier. The summer in the past is lovely and the writing about loss is the best thing Ashley Poston has done, though the time rules wobble and the present-day payoff feels rushed.

Read it if you want a soft, sad-happy romance with a speculative twist, or you liked The Dead Romantics and want more of Poston on grief. Skip it if you need time-travel logic to hold up under pressure, or you want lots of heat and a long, slow final act.

The Seven Year Slip by Ashley Poston book cover

The Seven Year Slip at a Glance

The Seven Year Slip is a standalone contemporary romance with a magical-realist twist, published by Berkley in June 2023. Clementine West, a burned-out book publicist, finds that her late aunt's New York apartment opens onto a summer seven years in the past. The heat is mild and the ending is happy.

AuthorAshley Poston
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreContemporary romance with magical realism, speculative romance
Main tropesTime slip, magic apartment, grief and found family, publishing heroine, chef hero
Spice level2/5: Mild, fade to black
Content warningsDeath of a loved one by suicide (off page), grief, pregnancy of a secondary character (full list below)
POVFirst person, Clementine
EndingHEA
Pages352 (US hardcover)
AudiobookNarrated by Brittany Pressley, about 9 hours 43 minutes
First publishedJune 27, 2023
PublisherBerkley (Penguin Random House)

What Is The Seven Year Slip About?

Clementine West works in publicity at a New York publishing house and has organized her life around not feeling things too hard. Her aunt Analea, the free-spirited woman who taught her to love the city, has died, and Clementine has inherited the apartment where they used to eat lemon pie and dream about travel.

Analea always said the apartment was a little magic. Clementine finds out what she meant when she comes home to a stranger in the kitchen: Iwan, an aspiring chef with a Southern drawl, who is living in the same rooms in the summer seven years earlier. They can share the space for a while. They cannot share a future, or so it seems.

What Makes This Time-Slip Romance Work

The Seven Year Slip works because its magic apartment is really a machine for grief. Clementine meets Iwan in the one place that still holds her aunt, at a time when her aunt was still alive, and every scene in the past carries that ache along with the flirting.

The second hook is the clock. Clementine knows the summer will end and that the man she is falling for exists, somewhere, seven years on. Publishers Weekly singled out the apartment's timing as the heart of the story, and it is: every lovely evening is borrowed.

Then there is the food. Iwan cooks his way through the book, Clementine eats her way back to life, and the New York summer is full of lemon pie, late dinners and walks through the city. Andge at Down the Rabbit Hole called out food and memory as the rewards for readers who stay patient, and I agree. If you like a soft magical premise used for big feelings, this is a good one.

My Review

I put off The Seven Year Slip for a while because I expected a cute gimmick. It is not cute, or not only cute. It is a book about a woman who has stopped letting herself want things, and the time slip is the gentlest way Ashley Poston could find to make her start again.

Romance and Chemistry

The romance is tender rather than fiery. Clementine and Iwan begin as awkward roommates in two different years, and they fall for each other over dinners, small dares and a long list of places in the city he wants to see. Harlequin Junkie praised the respectful chemistry, and that is the right word: Iwan is kind in a way that never becomes bland.

My reservation is pacing in the present day. The summer section breathes; the final stretch, when the timelines need to meet, runs fast. Abby at Moms That Read felt the present-day romance and ending were abbreviated, and Jessica at A Few Pages In wanted fuller late scenes. I wanted one more chapter of the two of them in the same year, and I suspect most readers will too.

A couple of Reddit readers in r/RomanceBooks questioned why the present-day relationship hesitates the way it does, and others argued over the chronology. That debate tells you something: the rules of the slip are lovely as metaphor and a bit loose as mechanics.

The Characters

Clementine is prickly at first, which some readers do not enjoy; Jessica at A Few Pages In found her uninteresting before getting absorbed. I liked her more as she thawed. Her grief is written with real specificity, and her burnout at work is not played for laughs.

Analea is the presence that holds the book together even though she is gone. Angela at Smexy Books loved the aunt and niece relationship, and so did I. Clementine's friends add warmth and banter, and Tammy at Books Bones & Buffy noted a relationship between two women in the supporting cast. Iwan is sweet, steady and a little underwritten in his own right; he is mostly seen through Clementine's eyes.

Writing and Pacing

Poston writes feeling better than plot. The prose is warm, a little whimsical, and very good on how grief sits in ordinary objects. Joanne P at Booklover Book Reviews enjoyed the gravitas and banter while accepting that the time logic is imperfect, which is about where I landed.

Pacing is uneven. The opening takes a few chapters to settle (Andge at Down the Rabbit Hole said the same), the summer is the best part, and the ending is quick. Brittany Pressley's audiobook, at just under ten hours, suits the soft first-person voice.

The Seven Year Slip is a gentle, grief-soaked love story whose magic apartment matters more as feeling than as physics. Read it for the summer in the past and the aunt who haunts it; go elsewhere if you need airtight time travel or a long final act.

How Spicy Is The Seven Year Slip?

The Seven Year Slip is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. The romance is mostly kisses, longing and late-night dinners, with a small amount of intimacy that is handled briefly rather than in explicit detail.

Ashley Poston publishes her own content notes for the book and warns that they contain mild spoilers. Grief is the main emotional weight: Clementine is mourning an aunt whose death was by suicide, and that loss is discussed often.

Content warnings, drawn from the author's own content notes and reader reports:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Who Should Read The Seven Year Slip?

The Seven Year Slip suits readers who want a gentle, bittersweet romance with a magical premise and a lot of feeling about loss. It is less suited to readers who want heat, a fast pace or time-travel rules that survive close inspection.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Seven Year Slip had broad and warm reception. Publishers Weekly praised the emotionally engaging romance and the way it handles bereavement. Angela at Smexy Books gave it an A, loved the aunt and niece thread and called the ending close to perfect.

Where they agree. The grief writing, the food and the summer. Tammy at Books Bones & Buffy enjoyed the dialogue, the friends and the book's thinking about careers. Harlequin Junkie praised the respectful chemistry and supportive cast, and Joanne P at Booklover Book Reviews liked its gravitas and banter. Where they split. The ending and the mechanics. Abby at Moms That Read and Jessica at A Few Pages In wanted more from the present-day romance. Reddit readers argued about the chronology and the hero's hesitation, and one r/Indianbooks reader found the attraction abrupt and the description repetitive.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Seven Year Slip scores 7.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for writing, emotional impact and ending, and lower marks for heat and the hero's depth.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Tender, respectful chemistry, per Harlequin Junkie; the present-day stretch is rushed.
Characters (15%)3.5Clementine and Analea shine, per Smexy Books; Iwan is thinner.
Writing and pacing (15%)4Warm, specific prose; Booklover Book Reviews forgives the loose time logic.
Emotional impact (15%)4Grief handled with care, per Publishers Weekly.
Heat level (10%)3Mild heat that fits the book, without much on the page.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A happy ending that Smexy Books loved; some readers wanted it longer.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5The summer chapters reread well, especially on audio.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Seven Year Slip is the strongest of Ashley Poston's adult romances for emotional impact and sits near the top of recent magical-realist rom-coms, with a final Eikna Score of 7.6/10.

Is The Seven Year Slip a Standalone?

Yes. The Seven Year Slip is a standalone novel. Ashley Poston's adult romances share a tone, grief plus a touch of magic plus publishing, but they are not connected, so you can read them in any order. In publication order:

  1. The Dead Romantics (2022): a ghostwriter and the ghost of her editor
  2. The Seven Year Slip (2023): a publicist and a chef seven years apart
  3. A Novel Love Story (2024): a reader stranded in the town from her favorite series

Best format: Brittany Pressley's audiobook, or print if you like to flip back and check the timeline. Our series order guide covers connected romances.

If You Loved The Seven Year Slip, Read These Next

If you loved The Seven Year Slip, try these romances with grief, letters across time or a touch of magic.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Seven Year Slip draws a handful of common questions about heat, the ending and the time slip. Short answers below.

Is The Seven Year Slip spicy?

Not very. The Seven Year Slip is a 2 out of 5 on our scale, mostly kisses and longing with brief intimacy.

Does The Seven Year Slip have a happy ending?

Yes. The Seven Year Slip ends with a happily ever after for Clementine and Iwan.

Is The Seven Year Slip a standalone?

Yes. It is a standalone; Ashley Poston's other adult romances are separate stories.

Is The Seven Year Slip time travel?

Sort of. The apartment connects Clementine to the same rooms seven years earlier, so she meets Iwan in the past while living in the present.

Is The Seven Year Slip sad?

It is sad in places. Clementine is grieving her aunt, whose death was by suicide, but the tone is hopeful and the ending is happy.

Who narrates The Seven Year Slip audiobook?

Brittany Pressley narrates the audiobook, which runs about 9 hours 43 minutes.

The Bottom Line

The Seven Year Slip earns a 7.6/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a gentle, bittersweet romance about grief and second chances, wrapped in a magical apartment, and who will forgive a rushed final act. The reason to pick it up is the summer in the past: lemon pie, a kind chef and an aunt who is still, briefly, in the room.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

Spice level is our own reading of reader reports; the author's content notes do not rate heat.

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.