Total Creative Control by Joanna Chambers and Sally Malcolm Review
Eikna Score: 7.9/10. Recommended.
Total Creative Control is a witty, pining MM workplace romance that gets something most books about television get wrong: what it feels like to make a show with someone whose brain fits yours. Lewis is ruder for longer than some readers can stand, and the ending is tidier than the angst before it, but the slow burn is excellent.
Read it if you love grumpy boss and sunshine assistant romances, or you have ever written fanfic and want a book that takes it seriously. Skip it if a hero who is curt with the man he loves for half the book will make you throw it, or you want steam from the start.
Total Creative Control at a Glance
Total Creative Control is the first Creative Types novel by Joanna Chambers and Sally Malcolm, self-published in October 2021. A fanfic writer turned personal assistant and the abrasive creator of a hit TV show fall for each other during a terrible corporate retreat. It is a British MM slow burn with moderate heat and a happy ending.
| Author | Joanna Chambers and Sally Malcolm |
|---|---|
| Series | Creative Types, book 1 of 3 (each book follows a new couple) |
| Subgenre | LGBTQ+ romance (MM contemporary, workplace) |
| Main tropes | Grumpy sunshine, boss and assistant, slow burn, forced proximity, hurt and comfort |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Boss and employee power imbalance, verbal rudeness, workplace bullying, grief and family history, alcohol (full list below) |
| POV | Dual, Aaron and Lewis, third person |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | About 360 (364 per The Novel Approach; paperback listings vary) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Simon Goldhill, about 9 hours 26 minutes (2023) |
| First published | October 28, 2021 |
| Publisher | Self-published by the authors |
What Is Total Creative Control About?
Total Creative Control follows Aaron Page, a fanfic writer who took a temp job with television creator Lewis Hunter for a week and is still there three years later. He is Lewis's personal assistant, his sounding board and, quietly, the biggest fan of Lewis's hit show Leeches. He also has plans to leave for a teaching job and a boyfriend who is not Lewis.
Lewis is brilliant, brusque and entirely focused on the show. He has never let anyone close except his brother and, without quite admitting it, Aaron. When a deal for an American version of Leeches drags Lewis to a dreadful corporate retreat outside London, Aaron is the only ally he has, and the line between work and something else gets harder to hold.
What Makes This Grumpy Sunshine Romance Work
Total Creative Control works because its grumpy sunshine pairing is built on shared work, not just opposite moods. Aaron and Lewis are creative partners before they are anything else, and their best scenes are about a script, a character or a plot problem. The attraction grows out of that, which makes it feel earned.
Lisa at The Novel Approach summed it up as "a sweet and angsty love story full of pining and tension," and pining is the right word. For most of the book, both men want more than they can say, and the power gap between a boss and his assistant means neither can easily say it.
The fandom thread adds another layer. Aaron writes fic about Leeches, and The Novel Approach called the parallels between his fic and the show's characters a highlight. Readers on Goodreads repeatedly praise the book's respectful treatment of fanfiction, which is rarer than it should be. If you like grumpy sunshine romances with a creative workplace at the center, this is a strong pick.
My Review
I have read plenty of boss and assistant romances, and Total Creative Control is one of the few where I believed the job. Lewis and Aaron argue about episodes. They know each other's work habits. Aaron understands the show well enough to make it better, and Lewis knows it even when he will not say so. That is the foundation of the romance, and it holds.
Like most self-published MM romance, Total Creative Control was reviewed mainly by romance blogs rather than trade magazines. The Novel Approach gave it four stars, Love Bytes Reviews gave the ebook four hearts and the audiobook four and three quarters, and Goodreads readers average about four stars from more than 3,700 ratings. My own view lands in the same place: very good, with a couple of clear flaws.
Romance and Chemistry
The slow burn is the book's reason to exist. For a long stretch, Aaron and Lewis are simply very good at working together, and the tension lives in small things: a late night over a script, a glance at the retreat, a moment of jealousy that neither man can justify. Sadonna at Love Bytes adored Aaron from his first conversation, and I understood why. He is warm without being a doormat.
The problem is Lewis, or at least how long Lewis stays difficult. Goodreads readers who disliked the book almost all say the same thing: he is rude and self-absorbed for too long, and his change of heart arrives faster than the setup suggests. I think that is partly fair. The Novel Approach made a point I liked, though: Aaron does not fix Lewis. Lewis is allowed to be vulnerable and still be loved, which is a more grown-up idea than the redemption arc it could have been.
When the lines are finally crossed, the payoff is satisfying and the romance moves quickly afterward. Some readers found the grand declaration near the end over the top. I found it a little much and enjoyed it anyway.
The Characters
Aaron is lovely, and that is both a strength and a weakness. Lisa at The Novel Approach wanted more of his backstory, describing him as arriving fully formed and practically perfect. I agree. We learn a lot about what Aaron does for Lewis and less about what Aaron wants for himself, apart from the teaching job and his writing.
Lewis gets the deeper treatment. His backstory, which The Novel Approach found touching, explains a lot about why he keeps everyone at arm's length. Sadonna at Love Bytes noted his blind spots and snap judgements, and they are real, but the book makes clear they come from somewhere. The secondary cast, especially Toni and Owen, gets warm mentions from readers, and the retreat's host is a memorable villain: Valerie at Love Bytes found the way he bullies Lewis hard to tolerate, which I think is the point.
Writing and Pacing
The prose is polished and funny, and the two authors' voices blend so well that The Novel Approach praised how seamlessly they work together. The TV office scenes are vivid; Love Bytes called the sense of the workplace a highlight.
The pacing has a soft spot in the middle. The retreat section, at a new age venue called Safehaven, is both the book's comic set piece and its slowest stretch. Valerie at Love Bytes found the pace slowed there and wrote that "the strange body movement workshop became annoying after twenty pages." I laughed at it longer than she did, but not much longer. The ending also resolves a few threads, including a subplot tied to the retreat, more conveniently than the angst before it deserves.
Total Creative Control is a smart, pining workplace romance whose creative partnership is more convincing than most, even if its hero stays prickly too long. Read it if you love slow burns and grumpy sunshine pairings and can wait for the thaw.
How Spicy Is Total Creative Control?
Total Creative Control is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. Most of the book is unresolved tension and pining. Once Aaron and Lewis get together, their first time is on the page, and readers on Goodreads describe the steam overall as medium rather than high. All intimacy is between consenting adults.
Because Lewis is Aaron's boss, the power imbalance is part of the story, and the book is aware of it. For more books in this range, our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Content warnings, drawn from reader and critic reviews:
- Boss and employee relationship with a power imbalance
- Verbal rudeness and emotional distance from a love interest
- Workplace bullying at a corporate retreat
- Grief, loss and a difficult family history, including poverty
- Conflict over creative ownership of a show
- Alcohol
- On-page sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Total Creative Control?
Total Creative Control suits readers who want a slow-burn MM romance with a British workplace setting, a creative partnership at its heart and a grumpy hero worth waiting for. It suits readers less well if they want early heat, a hero who is nice from the start or a fast-moving plot.
Best for:
- Fans of grumpy boss and sunshine assistant romances
- Readers and writers of fanfiction
- Anyone who likes slow burns full of pining and jealousy
- Readers who enjoy books about television and the creative process
- Audiobook listeners: Love Bytes found Simon Goldhill's voices distinct and believable
Not for:
- Readers who cannot tolerate a hero who is curt for much of the book
- Anyone uncomfortable with boss and employee power dynamics
- Readers who want explicit scenes early
- Readers who dislike a love interest beginning the book in another relationship
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Total Creative Control was covered mostly by romance review blogs rather than trade magazines. The Novel Approach gave it four stars, Love Bytes Reviews rated the ebook four hearts and the audiobook four and three quarters, and Goodreads readers average about four stars from more than 3,700 ratings.
Where they agree. The pining, the banter and the writing. The Novel Approach, both Love Bytes reviewers and many Goodreads readers praise the slow burn, the TV workplace, the fanfic thread and the way the two authors' voices blend.
Where they split. Lewis and the ending. A vocal group of Goodreads readers found Lewis too mean for too long and his turnaround sudden, and some called the ending rushed and the grand gesture over the top. The Novel Approach wanted more of Aaron's backstory, and Love Bytes found the retreat section slow.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Total Creative Control scores 7.9 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard. Its best mark is for writing and pacing, which The Novel Approach praises for the seamless co-writing, and its lowest are for heat and the ending, which some Goodreads readers found rushed after a long slow burn.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4 | Sweet and angsty pining, per The Novel Approach; Lewis's thaw comes late. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Lewis is layered; The Novel Approach wanted more of Aaron's backstory. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4.5 | Polished, funny co-writing; Love Bytes notes a slower retreat section. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | Lewis's history and the long pining land, as The Novel Approach found. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | A satisfying open-door payoff after the slow burn, medium steam per readers. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A warm HEA, but Goodreads readers call parts of it rushed and convenient. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 4 | The workplace banter and pining reward a second read. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Total Creative Control is the book that launched Creative Types and a high point among British MM workplace romances, at a final Eikna Score of 7.9/10.
Creative Types Reading Order
Creative Types has three books, each following a different couple connected to the same world of television and acting. Start with Total Creative Control. The romance is complete in this book, but recurring characters carry over, so reading in publication order gives the best experience.
- Total Creative Control (2021): Aaron and Lewis
- Home Grown Talent (2022)
- Best Supporting Actor (2023)
Best format: the audiobook, narrated by Simon Goldhill and released in 2023, runs about 9 hours 26 minutes. Sadonna at Love Bytes found his narration engaging, with distinct voices for each character. Our series order guide covers more romance series.
If You Loved Total Creative Control, Read These Next
If you loved Total Creative Control, look for MM and workplace romances with sharp banter, a prickly hero and a slow burn that makes you wait.
- Rule Breaker by Lily Morton: a British boss and assistant pairing with a sharper, funnier contrast between the two.
- After Felix by Lily Morton: another British MM contemporary that mixes humor with grief and restraint.
- Boyfriend Material by Alexis Hall: a London MM romance with a prickly partner and plenty of comic set pieces.
- Egotistical Puckboy by Eden Finley and Saxon James: high-friction MM chemistry with professional stakes, also co-written.
- The Hating Game by Sally Thorne: the office tension classic, for readers happy to try a different pairing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Total Creative Control readers most often ask about its spice, its series order, its ending, its narrator and whether it can be read alone. Short answers below.
Is Total Creative Control spicy?
Moderately. It is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: a long slow burn, then consensual open-door scenes once Aaron and Lewis get together.
Can you read Total Creative Control as a standalone?
Yes. It is book 1 of Creative Types and its romance is complete, though later books bring back familiar characters.
What is the Creative Types reading order?
Read Total Creative Control (2021), then Home Grown Talent (2022), then Best Supporting Actor (2023).
Does Total Creative Control have a happy ending?
Yes. Aaron and Lewis get a happily ever after, and there is no cliffhanger.
Who narrates the Total Creative Control audiobook?
Simon Goldhill narrates the audiobook, released in 2023, which runs about 9 hours 26 minutes.
What show does Lewis make in Total Creative Control?
Lewis Hunter is the creator of Leeches, a hit TV show that Aaron loves and writes fanfiction about.
The Bottom Line
Total Creative Control earns a 7.9/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who love slow-burn MM romance, grumpy sunshine pairings and books that take creative work seriously. The one reason to pick it up is the partnership between Aaron and Lewis, which makes their eventual romance feel like the natural next draft rather than a twist.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Total Creative Control, Joanna Chambers (author page)
- Total Creative Control review, The Novel Approach
- Release day review, Love Bytes Reviews
- Audiobook review, Love Bytes Reviews
- Total Creative Control, Goodreads (ratings and reader reviews)
- Creative Types series, Goodreads
- Total Creative Control, FantasticFiction
- All About Romance and StoryGraph reader criticism
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.