eikna romance
Menu

What You Wish For by Katherine Center Review

Eikna Score: 7.2/10. Recommended.

What You Wish For is Katherine Center's most earnest book, a story about a school librarian who chooses joy and the rigid new principal who has forgotten how. Its heart is in exactly the right place and its librarian heroine is a delight, but the romance is chaste and slow, and the message about joy is delivered with very little subtlety.

Read it if you want a sweet, closed-door workplace romance about kindness, community and a long-held crush. Skip it if you need heat or moral complexity, or school safety and violence are hard topics for you right now.

What You Wish For by Katherine Center book cover

What You Wish For at a Glance

What You Wish For is a standalone contemporary romance by Katherine Center, first published by St. Martin's Press in July 2020. It follows Samantha Casey, an elementary school librarian in Galveston, Texas, whose long-ago crush Duncan Carpenter becomes her new principal and starts turning her joyful school into a fortress. It is told in first person, kisses only, and ends happily.

AuthorKatherine Center
SeriesStandalone (Duncan first appeared in Happiness for Beginners)
SubgenreContemporary romance with women's fiction warmth
Main tropesUnrequited crush, workplace romance (boss and employee), slow burn, grumpy sunshine, school community
Spice level1/5: Kisses only / closed door
Content warningsDeath of a beloved mentor, grief, epilepsy and seizures, school shooting trauma in a character's past (full list below)
POVFirst person, Sam
EndingHappy ending
Pages320 (2020 hardcover); 368 (2021 paperback)
AudiobookMacmillan Audio, read by Katherine Center and Thérèse Plummer, 11 hours 13 minutes
First publishedJuly 14, 2020
PublisherSt. Martin's Press (paperback from St. Martin's Griffin)

What Is What You Wish For About?

What You Wish For follows Samantha Casey, an elementary school librarian in Galveston, Texas, who loves her students, her colleagues and her quirky school in an old Victorian building with a butterfly garden. Sam has built a good life there, and she has worked hard at being the kind of person who chooses happiness.

When the school loses its beloved principal, the replacement turns out to be Duncan Carpenter, a man Sam knew years ago at a different school and quietly loved while nobody noticed him. Back then Duncan was funny and a little wild. The new Duncan wears suits, enforces rules and is fixated on security, and his plans could turn Sam's cheerful school into something closer to a prison. Sam has to work out what happened to him, and whether the person she fell for is still there.

What Makes This Grumpy Sunshine Romance Work

What You Wish For works as a grumpy sunshine romance because both the grump and the sunshine have reasons. Sam's cheerfulness is a practice, not a personality quirk; she chooses joy because she knows what the alternative feels like. Duncan's rigidity is fear dressed up as policy. The romance is really a long argument between those two ways of facing danger.

The school setting gives that argument stakes. Duncan's changes, from new rules to security measures that make the building feel like a fortress, land on children and teachers the reader quickly comes to care about. Readers who love workplace stories where the whole community gets involved will find the book easy to settle into.

There is also the pleasure of the old crush. Sam has carried a torch for Duncan for years, and Center lets the reader enjoy her mortification at having to work for him. Fans of slow burn romances will get a very slow one here.

My Review

What You Wish For is the Katherine Center book I admire more than I love. Its intentions are lovely, its heroine is wonderful and its setting is the most charming in Center's catalogue. It also tells you what it means several times, out loud, and the romance never quite catches fire.

Kirkus gave it a starred review and called it a timely, uplifting read about finding joy in the midst of tragedy. People made it a Book of the Week. Romance readers have been a little cooler; many on StoryGraph enjoyed the book but wanted more love story. I sit in the middle.

Romance and Chemistry

The romance between Sam and Duncan is chaste and slow. For most of the book they are on opposite sides of an argument about the school, and their scenes together are prickly in a way that is fun to read. The crush angle works: Sam knows exactly who Duncan used to be, and the reader watches her try to find that person under the suit.

Where it falls short is in the turn. Duncan's change of heart depends on a late, dramatic event that forces the issue, and once it arrives the romance resolves quickly. All About Romance reported kissing as the extent of the physical side, and GoodeyReads mentioned some heavier making out; either way, the love story stays in the background of a book that is more interested in the school than the couple. If you want Center's best romance, read The Bodyguard.

I want to be fair to what the book is attempting, though. A romance in which the obstacle is a man's fear for other people's children is unusual, and Center refuses to make Duncan a cartoon tyrant. Even at his most infuriating he is trying to protect someone. That gives the eventual thaw a decency I liked, even when I wished it would hurry up.

The Characters

Sam is the best thing in the book. She is funny, self-aware and stubbornly kind, and she has epilepsy, which Center writes with care as part of Sam's life rather than a plot twist. Her optimism is never naive; it is something she works at every day, and the book is clear about what it costs her.

Duncan is harder. He is supposed to be frustrating, and he is, but for long stretches the book keeps his reasons offstage, so he reads as a set of bad policies rather than a person. When his history comes out, involving violence at a previous school, it explains everything and makes him sympathetic, but it arrives late. Readers who know Happiness for Beginners will recognise him as Helen's younger brother, which adds a nice layer.

The school community is lovely, a staff room full of distinct people who care about the children and about each other. Several of them steal scenes from the leads.

Writing and Pacing

Center's style is warm, quick and full of small jokes, and the Galveston setting is drawn with real affection. The butterfly garden, the old building and the heat all feel specific. She is good at short chapters that leave you wanting the next one.

The weakness is the message. The book is about joy as a choice, and characters say so in speeches more than once. Published in July 2020, it reached readers in a frightening year, and many found that directness comforting. I found it heavy-handed in places, especially in a final act that wraps things up with a public moment of the kind Center favours.

The audiobook is a good option: Thérèse Plummer reads most of it and Center herself reads part. Booklist called it a warm-hearted listen with an energetic narrator.

What You Wish For is a sweet, sincere school romance with a terrific heroine and a love story that takes a back seat. Read it if you want comfort, kindness and no steam, and start with The Bodyguard if you want Center's best romance.

How Spicy Is What You Wish For?

What You Wish For is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. Sam and Duncan's relationship is limited to kissing and some making out on page, with nothing explicit. All About Romance and GoodeyReads both describe it as clean, and it is suitable for readers who prefer closed-door romance.

The serious content is about safety and grief. Duncan's rigidity comes from a traumatic event at a school, which is described in the course of the book, and Sam has a seizure on page. One StoryGraph reader raised a concern about a scene involving impaired consent to a kiss; it is brief, but worth knowing. For more low-heat reads, see our closed door romance list.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reports and reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Who Should Read What You Wish For?

What You Wish For suits readers who want a clean, heartfelt workplace romance about community, kindness and a long-held crush. It is less suited to readers who want steam, subtlety or a romance at the centre of every chapter.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

What You Wish For received strong trade reviews: a starred review from Kirkus, a Book of the Week pick from People, and praise from Booklist for the audiobook. Reader reception is warm but more divided than for Center's bigger hits.

Where they agree. Sam and the school. Kirkus praised the uplifting treatment of joy and tragedy, and readers on StoryGraph and book blogs consistently mention the Galveston setting and the staff room cast.

Where they split. The romance and the message. All About Romance reported a chaste romance limited to kissing, several StoryGraph readers wanted more of Duncan's inner life earlier, and some found the joy theme preachy. Others found it exactly the comfort read they needed.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

What You Wish For scores 7.2 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for characters and emotional impact, where Sam and the school community shine, and its lowest for heat, which stays at kisses.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Fun crush dynamic, but the romance stays chaste and secondary.
Characters (15%)4Sam is a delight; Duncan stays opaque for too long.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Warm and quick, but the joy message is stated repeatedly.
Emotional impact (15%)4Kirkus calls it uplifting; grief and fear are handled with care.
Heat level (10%)3Kisses only, as promised, with little romantic charge on page.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A happy ending, reached through a dramatic, convenient final act.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5A comfort reread for the setting more than the couple.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: What You Wish For sits in the middle of Katherine Center's catalogue, behind The Bodyguard and Things You Save in a Fire but ahead of her earliest books for warmth, and lands at a final Eikna Score of 7.2/10.

Is What You Wish For a Standalone?

Yes. What You Wish For is a standalone with a complete ending. Duncan Carpenter first appeared as Helen's younger brother in Happiness for Beginners (2015), years earlier in his life, so reading that first adds context but is not required.

Katherine Center novels with Eikna reviews, in publication order: Happiness for Beginners (2015), How to Walk Away (2018), Things You Save in a Fire (2019), What You Wish For (2020), The Bodyguard (2022), Hello Stranger (2023) and The Rom-Commers (2024).

Best format: the Macmillan audiobook, read by Thérèse Plummer with Katherine Center. Our series order guide covers connected romances.

If You Loved What You Wish For, Read These Next

If you loved What You Wish For, the closest matches are warm, low-heat contemporary romances with kind heroines and strong communities.

Frequently Asked Questions

What You Wish For raises the same questions for most new readers: how spicy it is, whether it is connected to Happiness for Beginners, whether it ends happily and what its heavy themes are. Short answers below.

Is What You Wish For spicy?

No. We rate it 1 out of 5: kissing and some making out, with nothing explicit.

Is What You Wish For connected to Happiness for Beginners?

Loosely. Duncan Carpenter is Helen's younger brother from Happiness for Beginners, but What You Wish For stands alone.

Does What You Wish For have a happy ending?

Yes. Sam and Duncan end together, and the school community gets a hopeful ending too.

Where is What You Wish For set?

At an elementary school in Galveston, Texas, housed in an old Victorian building with a butterfly garden.

Is there a What You Wish For audiobook?

Yes. Macmillan Audio published it, read by Thérèse Plummer and Katherine Center, at about 11 hours 13 minutes.

Does What You Wish For deal with school shootings?

Yes, as backstory. Duncan's security fixation comes from a traumatic event at a previous school, which is described during the book.

The Bottom Line

What You Wish For earns a 7.2/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a clean, kind, community-centred romance with a heroine who chooses joy on purpose. The one reason to pick it up is Sam, whose bright outfits and stubborn optimism make a frightening subject bearable.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.