eikna romance
Menu

A Distant Heart by Sonali Dev Review

Eikna Score: 7.7/10. Recommended.

A Distant Heart is a sweeping friends to lovers romance between a sheltered heiress who survived a heart transplant and the window washer's son who became a policeman, set against a black market organ trade in Mumbai. The years of friendship are beautiful and the class divide is sharp; the suspense plot is harsher and clumsier than the love story it serves.

Read it if you want a long, emotional friends to lovers story with real class stakes, or you liked the organ trafficking thread in A Change of Heart. Skip it if heavy medical content, violence against the heroine or long flashbacks will wear on you, or you want a light romance.

A Distant Heart by Sonali Dev book cover

A Distant Heart at a Glance

A Distant Heart is the fourth novel in Sonali Dev's Bollywood series, published by Kensington on December 26, 2017. Kimi Patil, sheltered by illness as a child, and Rahul Savant, who has protected her since they were young, finally face their feelings as adults when an organ trafficking ring puts her in danger. It ends with a HEA.

AuthorSonali Dev
SeriesBollywood series, book 4 (interconnected standalones)
SubgenreContemporary romance, romantic suspense
Main tropesChildhood friends to lovers, class divide, protector hero, cop hero, past and present timelines
Spice level3/5: Moderate, some open door
Content warningsSerious illness, heart transplant, organ trafficking, violence and kidnapping (full list below)
POVThird person, Kimi and Rahul, moving between past and present
EndingHEA
Pages310 (Kensington paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Soneela Nankani and Neil Shah, about 10.5 hours (Blackstone Audio)
First publishedDecember 26, 2017
PublisherKensington Books

What Is A Distant Heart About?

Kimaya Patil, called Kimi, was the first child her parents managed to keep after several miscarriages, and they named her for a miracle. At eleven she develops a rare illness and has to live in a sterile room in the family's hilltop mansion in Mumbai. Rahul Savant, fourteen and already supporting his family, comes to clean her windows. Through the plastic barrier, they become friends.

Over the years Rahul becomes her window on the world, and she pushes him to join the police. Years later, as adults, Kimi has a new heart and the chance at a real life, and Rahul is investigating a black market organ ring. When the ring's leader turns his attention to Kimi, what they mean to each other can no longer stay unspoken.

What Makes This Friends to Lovers Romance Work

A Distant Heart works because the friendship is built from the ground up. We watch Kimi and Rahul meet as children, grow up on opposite sides of a plastic sheet and a class divide, and become each other's most important person. Feed Your Fiction Addiction called it the best book in the Bollywood series so far and loved how the chemistry grows out of their history.

The second draw is Mumbai. Mandi at Smexy Books praised the detail of the city, the gap between Kimi's wealth and Rahul's poverty and the specifics of Kimi's health limits. Kirkus called the book's exploration of family, class and guilt both distinctly Indian and universal.

Finally, it has a thriller attached. Newcity praised the simmering romance and the turn into crime story, and readers of A Change of Heart will recognize the organ trafficking thread that ties the two books together.

My Review

The first half of A Distant Heart is one of the best things Sonali Dev has written. A sick girl in a glass room and a working boy outside it could have been pure Bollywood melodrama, and it is a little melodramatic, but the friendship feels real. Kimi laughs at her own situation, Rahul is stiff and proud, and their talks through the barrier are funny and sad at once.

The second half is where I started to argue with it. The suspense plot takes over, the villain gets very cruel, and the romance has to compete for space. Kirkus called the book "another beautiful, breathtaking novel," and I agree about the beauty. I am less sure the crime story earns its brutality.

Romance and Chemistry

The romance is slow and grown from years of friendship, and that history gives it weight. Once Kimi is healthy and an adult, Rahul pulls away, and Kimi is frustrated that he will not admit what he feels. That push and pull, rooted in class and in guilt about their families' shared past, drives the present-day story.

Mandi at Smexy Books gave it a B+ and wished Rahul showed more passion toward Kimi by the end, and I felt the same. He is so controlled that the big romantic beats land softer than they should. Feed Your Fiction Addiction, on the other hand, found the chemistry convincing from the start.

The Characters

Kimi is wonderful: bright, stubborn and determined not to be defined by her illness. Tart Sweet's reviewer, who gave the book an A, singled her out for laughing at her circumstances. Rahul is stoic and proud, and his sense of duty to Kimi's family, tied to his father's death protecting her father, makes him more interesting than a standard cop hero.

The families around them are richly drawn, which Smexy Books praised, and the book is good at showing how money shapes every choice. The villain is the weak point: Wendy the Superlibrarian questioned the balance between melodrama and suspense, and the crime boss sometimes feels like he wandered in from a different, darker book.

Writing and Pacing

Dev's prose is lush and emotional, and the Mumbai setting is vivid. The structure moves between past and present, and Tart Sweet warned that the chapter-length flashbacks may bother some readers. Smexy Books thought the book spent too long in the past.

Newcity found the early exposition clunky, and Feed Your Fiction Addiction noted that the mystery's answer is clear early. Smexy Books also called the suspense ending a little harsh. I agree on all three counts, and the book is still worth reading for the friendship alone.

A Distant Heart is a beautiful, heavy friends to lovers romance with a suspense plot that is darker and clumsier than it needs to be. Read it for Kimi and Rahul's years of friendship, and brace for the violence in the final act.

How Spicy Is A Distant Heart?

A Distant Heart is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. There are a small number of sex scenes once Kimi and Rahul are adults, and they arrive late, as the culmination of a long build. Feed Your Fiction Addiction rated the book 18+ for explicit sex, while Goodreads readers were split on whether the love scene worked.

The childhood and teenage chapters are friendship only. The intimacy is between consenting adults in the present-day story.

Content warnings, drawn from Smexy Books, Kirkus and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Who Should Read A Distant Heart?

A Distant Heart suits readers who want a long, emotional friends to lovers romance with class stakes, an Indian setting and a suspense plot. It suits readers less well if they want a light read, dislike long flashbacks or are sensitive to medical trauma and violence.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

A Distant Heart drew strong reviews from fans of the series. Kirkus called it beautiful and breathtaking, Tart Sweet gave it an A and Feed Your Fiction Addiction named it the best Bollywood book yet, while Smexy Books and Newcity had reservations about the past-heavy structure and the suspense. It averages about 3.6 on Goodreads.

Where they agree. The friendship and the setting. Kirkus praised the treatment of family, class and guilt, Smexy Books praised the Mumbai detail and the characters, Tart Sweet valued Kimi and the emotional depth, and Feed Your Fiction Addiction praised the childhood friends to lovers arc.

Where they split. Structure and suspense. Smexy Books found too much time spent in the past and the suspense ending harsh, Newcity found the early exposition clunky, Wendy the Superlibrarian questioned the mix of melodrama and suspense, and Feed Your Fiction Addiction noted the mystery is easy to solve.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

A Distant Heart scores 7.7 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best mark for emotional impact and its lowest for writing, heat, the ending and reread appeal, where the suspense plot weighs on the love story.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4A friendship built over years, praised by Feed Your Fiction Addiction; Smexy Books wanted more passion.
Characters (15%)4Kimi shines and the families are rich, per Smexy Books and Tart Sweet.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Lush prose; clunky early exposition per Newcity and long flashbacks per Tart Sweet.
Emotional impact (15%)4.5Illness, class and guilt hit hard, per Kirkus.
Heat level (10%)3.5Late, explicit scenes that readers split on, per Goodreads.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A HEA reached through a suspense ending Smexy Books found harsh.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5The friendship chapters are worth revisiting; the violence less so.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: A Distant Heart is the most emotional book in Sonali Dev's Bollywood series and, for many readers, the best, though its suspense is weaker than its romance, and it earns a final Eikna Score of 7.7/10.

Bollywood Series Reading Order

A Distant Heart is book 4 of Sonali Dev's Bollywood series. Each book follows a different couple and stands alone, but A Distant Heart shares its organ trafficking thread with A Change of Heart, so reading that one first adds context. Read in order:

  1. Book 1: A Bollywood Affair (2014): Mili Rathod and Samir Rathod
  2. Book 2: The Bollywood Bride (2015): Ria Parkar and Vikram Jathar
  3. Book 3: A Change of Heart (2016): Nikhil Joshi and Jess Koirala
  4. Book 4: A Distant Heart (2017): Kimi Patil and Rahul Savant

Best format: the Blackstone audiobook, with Soneela Nankani as Kimi and Neil Shah as Rahul. Kirkus praised how both narrators age their characters, with Shah's Rahul gaining authority as he rises in the police force. Our series order guide covers more connected series.

If You Loved A Distant Heart, Read These Next

If you loved A Distant Heart, look for more of Sonali Dev's books and romances built on long friendships and class divides.

Frequently Asked Questions

A Distant Heart draws a few common questions: is it spicy, do you need to read the other Bollywood books, does it end happily and how old are Kimi and Rahul. Short answers below.

Is A Distant Heart spicy?

Moderately. A Distant Heart is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with a small number of explicit scenes late in the book.

Do I need to read A Change of Heart before A Distant Heart?

No, but A Distant Heart shares the organ trafficking storyline with A Change of Heart, so reading that first adds context.

Does A Distant Heart have a happy ending?

Yes. A Distant Heart ends with a happily ever after for Kimi and Rahul.

How old are Kimi and Rahul in A Distant Heart?

They meet as children, when Kimi is eleven and Rahul is fourteen, and their romance happens years later when both are adults.

Who narrates the A Distant Heart audiobook?

Soneela Nankani and Neil Shah narrate the Blackstone Audio edition, which runs about 10 and a half hours.

What are the content warnings for A Distant Heart?

The main ones are serious illness, a heart transplant, organ trafficking, murder and a violent attack on the heroine.

The Bottom Line

A Distant Heart earns a 7.7/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a long, emotional friends to lovers romance with class stakes and a crime plot, and who can handle medical trauma and violence. The one reason to pick it up is the friendship between Kimi and Rahul, built over years and across a divide that never quite disappears.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.