Schuss by E.J. Noyes Review
Eikna Score: 7.3/10. Recommended.
Schuss is a tender, well-researched best friends to lovers romance set in the world of Olympic ski racing, told by two young women who are each sure the other could never feel the same. It is sweet and believable, but it is quieter and younger than most E.J. Noyes books, and the plot rarely surprises.
Read it if you want a gentle sapphic new adult romance with mutual pining, real sports detail and supportive queer parents, or you loved Aspen and Cate in Gold. Skip it if you want Noyes at her twistiest, or a romance between a high school senior and a twenty-year-old athlete is not something you want to read, even with both of age.
Schuss at a Glance
Schuss is E.J. Noyes's companion novel to Gold, published by Bella Books in November 2022. It follows Olympic skier Stacey Evans, 20, and her best friend Gemma Archer, 18, in alternating first person through a slow best friends to lovers romance with moderate open-door heat and a happy ending. Bella Books markets it as new adult.
| Author | E.J. Noyes |
|---|---|
| Series | Companion to Gold (2018); book 2 of 2, readable on its own |
| Subgenre | Sapphic new adult sports romance |
| Main tropes | Best friends to lovers, mutual pining, slow burn, elite athlete, coming of age |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Sports injury and fear, career pressure, a lead in another relationship at the start (full list below) |
| POV | First person, alternating Stacey and Gemma |
| Ending | Happy ending (most readers call it an HEA) |
| Pages | 276 (Bella Books paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Abby Craden (Audible Studios) |
| First published | November 17, 2022 |
| Publisher | Bella Books |
What Is Schuss About?
Stacey Evans is twenty, an alpine ski racer fresh off an Olympic medal, and her life is training, travel and an agent who wants her everywhere. Gemma Archer is eighteen, in her last year of high school and planning to study film. They are best friends, the easiest friendship either has, and each has been quietly in love with the other for a long time.
Neither will say so. Stacey has a girlfriend. Gemma is about to leave for college. And Gemma's stepmother, former Olympian Aspen Archer, is Stacey's coach, which makes the stakes of getting it wrong very high for everyone. The novel follows them over several years as they work out whether the friendship can survive becoming something more.
What Makes This Best Friends to Lovers Romance Work
Schuss works because its best friends to lovers romance gives both women a real reason to stay quiet. Losing Gemma would cost Stacey her best friend and complicate her relationship with her coach. Losing Stacey would cost Gemma the person she trusts most and the family peace at home. That makes every near-confession feel risky in a way most pining stories only claim.
The alternating first person is the second hook. We get both sides of the mutual pining, and Lex at LezReviewBooks credited the dual POV with letting readers know both leads properly. The dramatic irony is gentle but constant.
Then there is the skiing. Noyes knows this world, and the training blocks, race nerves and media pressure feel authentic. Women Using Words, reviewing on StoryGraph, praised the research that makes professional skiing believable. Readers who like sports romance with real sport in it will find that here.
My Review
Schuss is the softest book E.J. Noyes has written, and I mean that mostly as a compliment. After the isolation of Alone and the danger of Go Around, here is a story where nobody is in mortal peril and the biggest risk is saying "I love you" to your best friend.
Romance and Chemistry
The pining is excellent. Noyes gives us both heads, so we know long before Stacey and Gemma do that the feeling is mutual, and the book gets real tension out of near misses and misread signals. When they finally act on it, the payoff is tender, and Lex at LezReviewBooks said Noyes captured the feeling of first real love perfectly. That is right.
What holds the romance back is the girlfriend. Stacey is dating Bree, a college student, at the start, and several Goodreads readers felt Stacey was with her for shallow reasons or treated her poorly. It is not cheating, and it resolves, but it makes Stacey harder to root for early on. I wanted the book to be a little braver about that.
The Characters
Gemma is the better narrator. Her chapters are funnier and more watchful, and her film ambitions give her a life outside the romance. Stacey is driven and charming in public, emotionally avoidant in private, and some Goodreads readers, Leah among them, found her unlikable for much of the book. I found her believable for twenty.
The age question deserves a straight answer. Gemma is eighteen and a high school senior when the book opens; Stacey is twenty. Both are adults, and the story follows them over several years. Still, Gemma reads young, and Goodreads reviewers like Laure and Emily felt she sounded younger than a typical new adult heroine. If that bothers you, it will bother you throughout.
The parents steal scenes. Aspen and Cate from Gold are supportive, funny and visibly in love, and readers who loved Gold will be glad to see them.
Writing and Pacing
Noyes writes clean, confident prose and knows exactly how a race day feels. The pacing is steady rather than gripping. Lex at LezReviewBooks wished something unexpected had happened, since Noyes's other books are full of twists, and a Goodreads reader named Tere wanted more conflict around Stacey's career and Gemma's move. I agree. Schuss is pleasant all the way through and never really spikes.
Schuss is a sweet, authentic skiing romance with excellent pining and a low-key plot. Read it if you loved Gold or want a gentle new adult slow burn, and look elsewhere if you want E.J. Noyes at full intensity.
How Spicy Is Schuss?
Schuss is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. There are explicit scenes once Stacey and Gemma get together, but Lex at LezReviewBooks and Goodreads readers describe them as sweet and realistic for young love, and the book is noticeably less heated than E.J. Noyes's adult romances.
Age note: Gemma is eighteen and Stacey twenty when the book opens, and both are adults in every romantic and sexual scene. Bella Books publishes it as new adult; one StoryGraph reviewer read it as young adult, but it is written for adult readers. Our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Content warnings, drawn from the publisher, the author and reader reports:
- Elite sport pressure, training stress and media scrutiny
- Fear of injury, and a past career-ending crash for a secondary character
- One lead in a relationship with someone else at the start
- A coach who is also a family member, and the boundary questions that creates
- College separation and long distance
- Celebrity social media attention
- Sexual content between young adults (18 and 20)
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Schuss?
Schuss suits readers who want a gentle, low-angst sapphic new adult romance with mutual pining, real skiing and supportive queer parents. It is less suited to readers who want a twisty plot, older leads or the intensity of E.J. Noyes's other books.
Best for:
- Fans of best friends to lovers and mutual pining
- Readers who loved Gold and want more of Aspen and Cate
- Anyone who wants winter sports done with real detail
- Readers who like dual first person POV
- People who want low angst and a warm family
Not for:
- Readers uncomfortable with an eighteen-year-old lead, even in new adult
- Anyone who needs a fast or twisty plot
- Readers who dislike a lead starting the book in another relationship
- People looking for high heat
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Schuss holds a 4.02 average from more than 1,000 Goodreads ratings and was a Goldie Award finalist in New Adult Fiction, according to Bella Books. Coverage is mostly sapphic review blogs and reader reviews.
Where they agree. The pining, the dual POV and the skiing. Lex at LezReviewBooks enjoyed the alternating chapters and the sweet, realistic intimacy; Women Using Words on StoryGraph praised the research and the tender romance; Rainbow Reflections called it a charming first love new adult romance. Readers who loved Gold are happy to see Aspen and Cate again. Where they split. Stacey and the plot. Goodreads readers who were less keen found Stacey immature or unfair to her girlfriend, felt Gemma read too young for new adult, or wanted more happen; Lex wished for the twists Noyes usually delivers. Readers also disagree on whether the ending is a full HEA or a hopeful HFN, and several want a sequel.The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Schuss scores 7.3 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for writing and emotional impact, where the skiing detail and first love feelings land, and middling marks where readers fault Stacey's early choices and a low-event plot.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Lovely mutual pining; Goodreads readers find Stacey's early relationship choices off-putting. |
| Characters (15%) | 3.5 | Gemma and the parents shine; Goodreads readers split on Stacey and on how young Gemma reads. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4 | Women Using Words on StoryGraph praises the skiing research; clean, confident prose. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | LezReviewBooks says it captures the feeling of first real love perfectly. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Delivers the sweet, explicit but restrained heat reviewers describe. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A happy ending, though some Goodreads readers found it abrupt and want more. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | A warm reread for Gold fans; low on surprises for anyone else. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Schuss sits in the middle of E.J. Noyes's catalogue, gentler and less gripping than Alone or Go Around, and lands at a final Eikna Score of 7.3/10.
Gold and Schuss Reading Order
Schuss is a companion to E.J. Noyes's Gold and brings back its supporting characters. Bella Books and reviewers say it works as a standalone, but reading Gold first adds weight to Aspen and Cate's scenes:
- Book 1: Gold (2018): Aspen Archer and Cate Tierney
- Book 2: Schuss (2022): Stacey Evans and Gemma Archer (this book)
Where to start: with Gold if you have time, with Schuss if you only want Stacey and Gemma. Best format: both books have Abby Craden audiobooks, and her narration suits the alternating first person. No third book has been announced. For more E.J. Noyes, try the standalones Alone and Go Around, and see our series order guide for other series.
If You Loved Schuss, Read These Next
If you loved Schuss, look for sapphic romances with long friendships, sport and a slow, mutual realization.
- Cleat Cute by Meryl Wilsner: professional soccer, a rookie and a veteran, and more heat.
- On the Same Page by Haley Cass: a decade of best friendship and a slow, mutual realization.
- Chemistry Lessons by Jae: best friends to lovers with the same low angst.
- Alone by E.J. Noyes: Noyes in a darker, tenser key, with forced proximity.
- Go Around by E.J. Noyes: a second chance romance with suspense and more heat.
Frequently Asked Questions
Readers ask about Schuss's connection to Gold, the characters' ages, the heat and the ending most often. Short answers below.
Do I need to read Gold before Schuss?
No. Schuss works as a standalone, but reading Gold first gives you more of Aspen and Cate, who are major supporting characters.
How old are Stacey and Gemma in Schuss?
Stacey is 20 and Gemma is 18, a high school senior, when the book opens. Both are adults, and the story follows them over several years.
Is Schuss young adult or new adult?
Bella Books publishes Schuss as new adult, and it includes explicit scenes between adult characters.
Is Schuss spicy?
Moderately. Schuss is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with sweet, explicit scenes and less heat than E.J. Noyes's adult romances.
Does Schuss have a happy ending?
Yes. Schuss ends happily for Stacey and Gemma; most readers call it an HEA, a few a hopeful HFN.
Is there a Schuss audiobook?
Yes. The Schuss audiobook is narrated by Abby Craden and published by Audible Studios.
The Bottom Line
Schuss earns a 7.3/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a gentle sapphic new adult romance with mutual pining, real skiing and parents worth rooting for, more than a twisty plot. The one reason to pick it up is the pining: two best friends, two points of view and a lot of almost.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Schuss, Bella Books (blurb, edition, Goldie finalist)
- Schuss, Goodreads (ratings and reader reviews)
- Gold, Goodreads (publication date, characters)
- Schuss review, LezReviewBooks (Lex)
- Schuss review by Women Using Words, StoryGraph
- Schuss: a review, Rainbow Reflections
- Schuss audiobook, Audible (narrator)
- Schuss, Open Library
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.