eikna romance
Menu

Better Not Pout by Annabeth Albert Review

Eikna Score: 7.6/10. Recommended.

Better Not Pout is a warm, funny MM Christmas romance that pairs a gruff Army sergeant major a month from retirement with a cheerful charity organizer who refuses to let him sulk. The holiday details and Teddy's big family do most of the heavy lifting, and they carry the book past a slow first act and an ending you can see from the first chapter.

Read it if you want a grumpy sunshine age gap romance with real holiday texture, or a hero who quietly plays Santa while insisting he hates Christmas. Skip it if a predictable path to the HEA bores you, or a lead who keeps pushing after a no is a dealbreaker.

Better Not Pout by Annabeth Albert book cover

Better Not Pout at a Glance

Better Not Pout is Annabeth Albert's 2018 standalone MM holiday romance from Carina Press. It is set around an Army post in upstate New York and a small town called Mineral Spirits, follows a 46 year old sergeant major and a 28 year old charity worker, and ends with a happily ever after. The mass market paperback runs 304 pages.

AuthorAnnabeth Albert
SeriesStandalone holiday romance
SubgenreMM contemporary romance, Christmas
Main tropesGrumpy sunshine, age gap, holiday fling with a deadline, snowstorm, big warm family
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsAttempted armed robbery, sibling death, parental alcoholism, a heart attack (full list below)
POVNick and Teddy
EndingHEA
Pages304 (mass market paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Sean Crisden, about 6 hours (Harlequin Audio)
First publishedNovember 2018
PublisherCarina Press

What Is Better Not Pout About?

Better Not Pout opens with Sergeant Major Nick Nowicki, an Army military police veteran with almost thirty years in, counting down the last month before retirement and a move to Florida. He is roped into playing Santa at a charity event, which is about the last thing he wants to do.

That is how he meets Teddy MacNally, who runs a local charity called Helping Hands, has a huge family in Mineral Spirits and loves every inch of the holiday season. Teddy is cheerful, persistent and, in Nick's view, far too young for him. A snowstorm, a few favors and a lot of chemistry push them into a fling that both of them insist has an end date.

What Makes This Grumpy Sunshine Romance Work

Better Not Pout works because the grump is not really a grump. Nick complains about Christmas, then spends his free time quietly collecting presents for kids who will not otherwise get any. Teddy sees that almost immediately, and the grumpy sunshine pairing becomes less about thawing a cold man than about getting a stubborn one to admit what he already does.

The second hook is the setting. Smexy Books noted that the holiday here is more than wallpaper: there is a Santa suit, Thanksgiving, snow, an elf and an actual gift drive. The town and the MacNally clan feel lived in, and the charity work gives the romance something to do besides wait for the next kiss.

The third is the age gap, handled without much angst. Nick is 46 and Teddy is 28, and the book is more interested in what each of them wants from the next ten years than in who is older. If you like a seasoned hero and a younger partner who knows his own mind, this is an easy recommendation.

My Review

I went into Better Not Pout expecting fluff, and the first chapters gave me exactly that, slowly. Then the book found its feet. By the halfway point I cared less about whether Nick would stay (you know he will) and more about how Annabeth Albert would get a man this set in his plans to change them without making him look foolish. She mostly pulls it off.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is the best thing here. Nick and Teddy flirt in a way that is funny first and hot second, and their first night together comes earlier than the cozy cover suggests. Becca at Love Bytes called the chemistry dynamic, and I agree: these two spark from their first argument about whether Nick is allowed to hate Christmas.

What I liked more was how the fling turns into something serious through ordinary acts. Teddy drags Nick to family dinners and gift drives, and Nick keeps showing up. The romance is built on time spent together rather than on grand declarations, which suits a hero who would sooner fix your furnace than tell you how he feels.

The weakness is the deadline. Nick's retirement plan is the only real obstacle, and the book circles it for a long time. Becca admitted Nick's stubbornness about leaving made her want to strangle him, and I had the same urge around the two thirds mark.

The Characters

Nick is a good example of the soft grump done right. He is gruff, private and a little lost about who he is once the uniform comes off, and Stevie at The Good, the Bad and the Unread tied his resistance to that loss of identity. It is the most grown up thing in the book, and it makes his reluctance feel earned rather than contrived.

Teddy is harder to love on paper and easy to love on the page. He is relentlessly sunny, and some readers on StoryGraph felt he kept pursuing Nick after Nick said no. That criticism is fair. I read it as Teddy refusing to accept Nick's excuses rather than his boundaries, but the line is thin, and if persistence like that bothers you, it will bother you here.

The supporting cast is generous. Teddy's family is big and loud, there is grief in it, and the book gives two women in the family real leadership roles. Stevie singled that out, and it is one of the reasons the town feels like a place and not a set.

Writing and Pacing

Albert writes clean, easy prose with good comic timing, especially in Nick's head. Publishers Weekly found the book tender and funny, and called it a pleasure from start to finish, if somewhat predictable at the end. That is the right summary.

Pacing is the catch. Smexy Books and Jules at The Novel Approach both found the opening slow, and I did too: the first few chapters spend a long time establishing Nick's mood before anything happens. Once the snow arrives, the book moves. The ending lands exactly where you expect it to, and I did not mind, because by then I wanted it to.

Better Not Pout is a warm, sexy and slightly slow Christmas romance with a grump worth rooting for and a town worth visiting. Read it if you want age gap holiday comfort; skip it if you need surprises.

How Spicy Is Better Not Pout?

Better Not Pout is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The leads sleep together early, and there are several open door scenes after that, with on-page talk about what each of them likes and about condoms. Smexy Books summed it up as lots of sexy time, which is accurate.

Consent is spoken and enthusiastic in the sex scenes themselves. The friction some readers flag is outside the bedroom, in how hard Teddy pushes for more time together. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from the publisher, reader reports and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Better Not Pout?

Better Not Pout suits readers who want a cozy, steamy MM Christmas romance with a gruff older hero, a sunny younger lead and a small town that feels real. It is less suited to readers who want a tight, surprising plot, or who are uncomfortable with a love interest who keeps pushing.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Better Not Pout drew warm reviews when it came out in 2018. Publishers Weekly called it tender and funny with a pleasant, if somewhat predictable, ending. MelanieM at Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words gave it five stars and said she could have stayed with the couple well past New Year's, and The Good, the Bad and the Unread gave it an A.

Where they agree. The chemistry and the holiday setting. Love Bytes, Smexy Books and The Novel Approach all praised the spark between the leads, and Smexy Books liked that the Christmas material is woven into the plot rather than sprinkled on top.

Where they split. The pacing and Teddy. Smexy Books, which gave it a B, and The Novel Approach both found the start slow. On StoryGraph, several readers questioned Teddy's pursuit after Nick turned him down and felt some emotions were told rather than shown. At Wicked Reads, two reviewers enjoyed the family contrast while a third found the romance circular.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Better Not Pout scores 7.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with strong marks for chemistry, characters and heat, and lower scores for a slow start and an ending that never surprises.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Dynamic chemistry, per Love Bytes, built through shared holiday work.
Characters (15%)4Nick's identity crisis is well drawn, per The Good, the Bad and the Unread; Teddy divides readers.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Funny and clean, per Publishers Weekly, with a slow opening noted by Smexy Books.
Emotional impact (15%)4Teddy's family grief and Nick's fear of a life after the Army land.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the steamy, open door heat it promises, with spoken consent.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A firm HEA that Publishers Weekly rightly calls predictable.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5A comfortable seasonal reread for fans, as The Good, the Bad and the Unread expects.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Better Not Pout sits comfortably in the upper middle of Annabeth Albert's holiday romances: cozier and steamier than most, though less tightly plotted than her best work, landing at a final Eikna Score of 7.6/10.

Is Better Not Pout a Standalone?

Better Not Pout is a standalone. Annabeth Albert wrote it as a single holiday romance for Carina Press, and Nick and Teddy's story is complete with no earlier book required.

If you want more of her Christmas stories, Albert has written several holiday standalones, including The Geek Who Saved Christmas and the later Catered All the Way. Best format: print or ebook if you want to skim the slow start, or Sean Crisden's audiobook, at about six hours, for a December commute. Our series order guide covers her connected books.

If You Loved Better Not Pout, Read These Next

If you loved Better Not Pout, look for MM romances with grumpy older heroes, snowy settings and families who take the love interest in, starting with more Albert.

Frequently Asked Questions

Better Not Pout prompts the same questions from most readers: how spicy it is, how big the age gap is and whether it stands alone. Short answers below.

Is Better Not Pout spicy?

Yes. Better Not Pout is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit open door scenes and an early first night together.

How old are Nick and Teddy in Better Not Pout?

Nick is 46 and Teddy is 28, an age gap of about eighteen years between two adults.

Is Better Not Pout a standalone?

Yes. Better Not Pout is a standalone holiday romance and needs no other Annabeth Albert book.

Does Better Not Pout have a happy ending?

Yes. Better Not Pout ends with a happily ever after for Nick and Teddy.

Where is Better Not Pout set?

Better Not Pout is set near an Army post in upstate New York and in a small town called Mineral Spirits, over the Thanksgiving to Christmas season.

Is there a Better Not Pout audiobook?

Yes. Harlequin Audio published an unabridged audiobook narrated by Sean Crisden, running about six hours.

The Bottom Line

Better Not Pout earns a 7.6/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a steamy, good natured MM Christmas romance with an older grump and a younger optimist, and who are happy to know the ending before they get there. The reason to pick it up is Nick: a man who says he hates Christmas and then spends the whole book being Santa anyway.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.