eikna romance
Menu

The Christmas Deal by Keira Andrews Review

Eikna Score: 7.9/10. Recommended.

The Christmas Deal is a holiday MM romance with more weight than its cover suggests: a broke, grieving stepdad, a lonely man who needs a family for a promotion, and a fake relationship that becomes a real household. Logan is hard work for the first third, but the payoff, especially with his stepson, is as warm as holiday romance gets.

Read it if you want a fake dating Christmas story with found family, a single parent and a bisexual awakening handled with care, or you like grumpy heroes who soften slowly. Skip it if you want a light, fluffy holiday read, or an abrasive lead with outdated views on bisexuality will put you off before he grows.

The Christmas Deal by Keira Andrews book cover

The Christmas Deal at a Glance

The Christmas Deal is book 1 of Keira Andrews's Festive Fakes series, a self-published MM holiday romance first released in November 2019. It pairs a jobless stepdad with a coworker who needs a fake live-in boyfriend, blends fake dating with a bisexual awakening and found family, runs steamy and ends happily ever after.

AuthorKeira Andrews
SeriesFestive Fakes, book 1 (each book follows a new couple)
SubgenreLGBTQ romance (MM holiday romance, contemporary)
Main tropesFake dating, forced proximity, single parent, bisexual awakening, found family
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsEviction and money trouble, death of a spouse and parent, child grief, homophobia (full list below)
EndingHEA, with an epilogue
Pages250
AudiobookNarrated by John Solo, 8 hours 13 minutes (KA Books, 2025)
First publishedNovember 2019
PublisherSelf-published by Keira Andrews

What Is The Christmas Deal About?

The Christmas Deal opens with Logan, an ex-Marine, out of work and about to be evicted, now the sole parent of a stepson who resents him. Connor, around thirteen, is grieving his mother, and Logan has no idea how to reach him.

Seth is lonely, well liked at work and up for a promotion with a new boss who prizes family men. He has no family to show her. So the two men make a deal: Logan and Connor move in with Seth for the holidays, and Logan plays the devoted boyfriend. Logan, who has always thought of himself as straight, adds one more term: he will teach Seth about no-strings sex. The arrangement does not stay simple.

What Makes This Fake Dating Romance Work

The Christmas Deal works because its fake relationship is built on need rather than whim. Logan needs a roof over his kid's head. Seth needs a family on paper. That makes the pretense matter from page one, and it makes every small domestic moment, a breakfast, a ride to school, an argument with a sullen preteen, part of the romance.

The second hook is Logan's bisexual awakening. Goodreads readers repeatedly praise Andrews for treating it as real self-discovery rather than a "gay for you" shortcut, and the slow way Logan has to unlearn his assumptions is the spine of the book.

And then there is Connor. The Novel Approach singled out Seth's patience and parenting advice as part of what makes him lovable, and the stepson thread gives the book an emotional payoff beyond the couple. Readers who like found family at Christmas will find this a natural pick.

My Review

The Christmas Deal surprised me. I expected a cozy fake dating novella with tinsel on it and got a book about grief, money and a man learning that he has been wrong about himself. It is still a Christmas romance with a happy ending. It just makes you earn it.

The Novel Approach gave it four stars and said, "Keira Andrews knows how to bring the feels." Love Bytes Reviews was cooler at three and a half hearts and admitted it struggled through the first third. Both are right, and they are describing the same book from two ends.

Romance and Chemistry

Logan and Seth start out badly matched on purpose. Logan is crude, gruff and quick to dismiss anything that does not fit his idea of himself. Seth is tightly wound, sincere and starved for affection. The no-strings arrangement pushes them together faster than their feelings can keep up, which is where the friction comes from and where the heat lives.

What makes it romantic, rather than just hot, is Seth's care for Connor. Watching Logan notice that care, and then notice what it does to him, is the real love story. By the time Logan understands what he feels, the book has shown you why. I found the last third genuinely moving, and the Novel Approach reviewer said they absolutely adored the ending.

The Characters

Logan is the risk. The Novel Approach found him hard to like for much of the book because of his gruffness and short-sighted views on bisexuality, and Love Bytes did not warm to him early either. I understand. He says things in the first chapters that made me wince. But the book is aware of that, and his growth, especially as a parent, is earned scene by scene rather than announced.

Seth is easy to love: kind, a little lonely, good with a grieving kid without trying too hard. The supporting cast is strong. Love Bytes named Jenna as its favorite character and liked the new boss, Angela, for her care and parenting advice, while noting that Angela sometimes objectifies the two men in ways that sat badly. A coworker's running gag, which the Novel Approach enjoyed, gives the office scenes some life.

Connor deserves his own mention. Goodreads readers single out his grief and his slow thaw as one of the most effective threads, and a few wished Logan had shown him affection sooner. I agree on both counts.

Writing and Pacing

Andrews writes clean, warm prose with a good ear for dialogue and humor. The pacing is the issue. The opening is slow and heavy, with eviction, debt and grief stacked up before the romance gets going, and Love Bytes and several Goodreads readers found that first stretch hard going. Some readers also found the money troubles and grief heavy for a Christmas book.

The premise itself is far-fetched, and the Novel Approach called parts of the plot slightly far-fetched too. A boss who needs her managers partnered, a fake boyfriend with a ready-made kid, a mandatory company retreat just before Christmas: it is a romance contraption. I minded less than I expected, because the feelings inside the contraption are real.

The epilogue is the cherry on top, and Goodreads readers like it as much as I did. It is the rare holiday coda that adds something: a look at the household the deal accidentally built, instead of one more kiss under the mistletoe.

The Christmas Deal is a heartfelt, steamy MM holiday romance that turns a contrived deal into a real family, once you get past a prickly hero and a heavy opening. Read it if you want Christmas with some grief and growth in it, not pure fluff.

How Spicy Is The Christmas Deal?

The Christmas Deal is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The book is marketed as a steamy gay romance, and the no-strings arrangement between Logan and Seth puts several explicit, consensual scenes on the page, with dirty talk that some Goodreads readers found too much.

Connor is a child and is never part of any sexual content; the romance is strictly between the two adult men. For more in this heat range, see our spicy romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reviews and reader reports:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read The Christmas Deal?

The Christmas Deal suits readers who want an MM holiday romance with real stakes: a fake relationship born of need, a single parent, a bisexual awakening and a found family by Christmas. It is less suited to readers who want pure festive fluff or need to like the hero from page one.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Christmas Deal has about 4,700 ratings on Goodreads with an average of roughly 4.15, and coverage comes from MM romance blogs and readers rather than trade reviewers.

Where they agree. The heart. The Novel Approach gave it four stars, loved Seth from the start and adored the ending. Love Bytes Reviews found the resolution satisfying and praised the side characters. Goodreads readers most often praise the bisexual awakening, the found family, Connor's arc and the warm epilogue.

Where they split. Logan and the opening. Love Bytes gave three and a half hearts after struggling with the first third and not connecting with most characters early on, and it was uneasy with how the boss character objectifies the men. The Novel Approach found Logan hard to like for much of the book and the plot slightly far-fetched. Goodreads critics add that the money troubles and grief feel heavy for Christmas and that the sex scenes and dirty talk were not for them.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Christmas Deal scores 7.9 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with steady 4s across romance, characters, writing, emotion, heat and ending, and a slightly lower mark for reread appeal because of its heavy, slow opening.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Earned slow turn from deal to love; the Novel Approach adored the ending.
Characters (15%)4Seth and Connor shine; reviewers find Logan hard to like early.
Writing and pacing (15%)4Warm dialogue and humor; Love Bytes struggled with the first third.
Emotional impact (15%)4Grief and parenting give it weight, per Goodreads readers.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the steamy content it is marketed on, with explicit scenes.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4Satisfying resolution and a well-liked epilogue, per Love Bytes and Goodreads readers.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5A good seasonal reread, though the heavy opening slows a return trip.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Christmas Deal is the anchor of the Festive Fakes series and one of the stronger MM holiday fake dating romances we have reviewed, landing at a final Eikna Score of 7.9/10.

Festive Fakes Reading Order

The Christmas Deal is book 1 of Keira Andrews's Festive Fakes series and works as a standalone with a complete HEA. Each book is a separate holiday fake relationship with a new couple, so you can read them in any order, though publication order is easiest.

  1. The Christmas Deal (2019): Logan and Seth
  2. The Christmas Leap
  3. The Christmas Veto

Best format: the John Solo audiobook, released in 2025, runs about eight hours and suits a book this driven by dialogue and family scenes. Our series order guide covers more MM series.

If You Loved The Christmas Deal, Read These Next

If you loved The Christmas Deal, the closest matches are fake relationships that grow into shared homes and families, plus a holiday pick or two.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Christmas Deal raises the usual questions: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how old the stepson is and how it ends. Short answers below.

Is The Christmas Deal spicy?

Yes. The Christmas Deal is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit, consensual scenes between the two adult leads and some dirty talk.

Is The Christmas Deal a standalone?

Yes. The Christmas Deal is book 1 of Festive Fakes but has a complete story and HEA; The Christmas Leap and The Christmas Veto follow new couples.

Does The Christmas Deal have a happy ending?

Yes. The Christmas Deal ends happily ever after for Logan and Seth, with an epilogue.

How old is Connor in The Christmas Deal?

Connor is Logan's grieving stepson, described as a preteen in the blurb and around thirteen in reader reviews. He is never involved in any romantic or sexual content.

Is Logan bisexual in The Christmas Deal?

Yes. Logan believes he is straight at the start, and his realization that he is bisexual is a central thread that readers praise for avoiding the "gay for you" trope.

Is there a Christmas Deal audiobook?

Yes. The Christmas Deal audiobook is narrated by John Solo and runs about 8 hours 13 minutes.

The Bottom Line

The Christmas Deal earns a 7.9/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a steamy MM holiday romance with real stakes: grief, money worries, a stepson who needs someone and a hero who has to rethink who he is. The one reason to pick it up is the family that forms around Seth's table; by Christmas morning it feels earned, not handed out.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.