Catered All the Way by Annabeth Albert Review
Eikna Score: 7.2/10. Recommended.
Catered All the Way is a sweet, steamy brother's best friend Christmas romance whose best scenes come when Zeb and Atlas stop flirting and start running a holiday business together. The family conflict gets patched rather than repaired and the middle repeats itself, so it lands as a good December read rather than a great one.
Read it if you love a long held crush finally paying off, or a bi awakening for a capable military hero. Skip it if you need a hurtful sibling to earn his apology, or you came for the gaming and streaming details.
Catered All the Way at a Glance
Catered All the Way is Annabeth Albert's self-published 2023 MM Christmas romance, a standalone set in a small town called Kringle's Crossing. It pairs a 28 year old streamer with his older brother's 35 year old best friend, a Navy chief home on leave, and ends with a happily ever after. The paperback runs 284 pages.
| Author | Annabeth Albert |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone (grouped as An Annabeth Albert Christmas; ties to The Geek Who Saved Christmas) |
| Subgenre | MM contemporary romance, Christmas, small town |
| Main tropes | Brother's best friend, one bed, long held crush, bi awakening, secret holiday fling |
| Spice level | 4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes |
| Content warnings | Parental death and grief, verbal belittling by a sibling (full list below) |
| POV | Dual, Zeb and Atlas |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 284 (paperback); about 250 (Kindle) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Alexander Cendese, 6 hours 3 minutes |
| First published | December 4, 2023 |
| Publisher | Self-published (Annabeth Albert) |
What Is Catered All the Way About?
Catered All the Way follows Zeb Seasons, a gamer who streams for a living and still works in the family business, Seasons, a historic holiday gift shop and event space in Kringle's Crossing. Zeb has had a crush on Atlas Orion, his older brother Gabe's best friend, for years.
Atlas is a Navy chief who supports SEAL teams, and he is home on holiday leave to help the Seasons family through their busiest month. He is staying with Zeb. When the air mattress gives out, they end up sharing a bed, and a no strings holiday fling seems like a sensible idea to both of them. It stays sensible for about a week.
What Makes This Brother's Best Friend Romance Work
Catered All the Way works because the forbidden part is mostly in Zeb's head. Atlas is not off limits because of a rule; he is off limits because Zeb has spent years assuming he would never be seen as anything but Gabe's kid brother. Watching Atlas notice him, and then keep noticing, is the whole pleasure of the brother's best friend setup.
The second hook is that Atlas has never been with a man. The bi awakening is handled with curiosity rather than crisis, and it gives the steamy scenes a sense of discovery that suits a holiday fling.
The third is work. Seasons is a real small business with real deadlines, and Sadonna at Love Bytes singled out the holiday small business pressures as a strength. The couple are at their best hauling decorations and saving events, which is where the romance turns from attraction into partnership.
My Review
I liked Catered All the Way most when it stopped being about the crush. The first act is a lot of longing looks and an air mattress with suspiciously bad timing, which is fine. The second act, when Zeb and Atlas become a team keeping the family business afloat through December, is better than fine. Annabeth Albert is good at competence, and this book has plenty of it.
Romance and Chemistry
The chemistry builds fast once the bed situation arrives. Atlas is steady and attentive, Zeb is eager and funny, and their fling has an easy rhythm. Sadonna called them a dynamic duo, and the phrase fits: the best scenes have them solving a problem together and flirting while they do it.
The trouble is the middle. The book spends a long stretch on the fling itself, and Resch at Resch Reads and Reviews found the repeated sexual exploration a little samey and the serious conversation late in coming. I felt that too. The secrecy stretches on longer than the story can sustain, and the couple talk around their future when I wanted them to talk about it.
When they finally do, it works. Carrie G at All About Romance praised the believable compromises, and the ending is built on choices both men make about Atlas's career and Zeb's life in town, not on one of them giving everything up.
The Characters
Zeb is great company. He is energetic, a bit chaotic and much more capable than his family gives him credit for, and All About Romance liked his personality. He also carries real resentment toward his brother, and Geoff Whaley found it occasionally tiresome. I found it understandable, which is a different problem: it made me want Gabe to do better.
Gabe is the weak link. Melanie at Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words thought his verbal mistreatment of Zeb was resolved with a brief apology and a passing mention of therapy, and Sadonna did not find his change of heart fully convincing either. I agree with both. The book sets up a family wound and then closes it too quickly.
Atlas is the quiet success. Melanie called him terrific and realistic, especially the SEAL support background and the helicopter scenes, and I liked that the military detail is specific without turning into a thriller. He is a man with a plan for his next posting, and the book takes that plan seriously.
Writing and Pacing
Albert's prose is easy and warm, and the dual point of view lets both men explain themselves. All About Romance found some dialogue stiff and the premise familiar, and I would not argue. This is not a book trying to reinvent the holiday romance.
One more note for gamers: there is not much gaming here. Zeb is a streamer, but Melanie and Sadonna both noticed how little of that makes it onto the page. Come for the shop, the snow and the family, not for the stream.
What the book does well, in the end, is texture. Kringle's Crossing has neighbors who know everyone's business, Seasons has a calendar of events that cannot slip, and the town's small business worries give the plot a clock that the romance alone does not. Sadonna called it small town vibes, and that is the mood that stayed with me after I closed it.
Catered All the Way is a cozy, steamy holiday romance that is better at partnership than at family repair. Read it for the crush and the shop; skip it if you need a sibling's apology to be earned.
How Spicy Is Catered All the Way?
Catered All the Way is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The fling is open door from the start, and the blurb promises spicy first times for Atlas, which the book delivers across several scenes. Sadonna at Love Bytes described it as having enough steam to make it interesting.
Because Atlas is new to sex with men, the scenes lean into exploration and check-ins, and consent is clear. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Content warnings, drawn from the publisher, reader reports and our own read:
- Death of a parent and ongoing family grief
- Verbal belittling of Zeb by his older brother
- Pressure and uncertainty around a military career and the next posting
- A secret relationship kept from family
- On-page sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Catered All the Way?
Catered All the Way suits readers who want a steamy, low drama MM Christmas romance with a brother's best friend, a bi awakening and a family business in holiday crunch. It is less suited to readers who need a family conflict fully resolved or who want lots of gaming content.
Best for:
- Fans of brother's best friend and long held crush romances
- Readers who like a bi awakening handled with warmth
- Anyone who loves small town Christmas shops and events
- Listeners who want a six hour holiday audiobook
Not for:
- Readers who need a hurtful sibling to properly earn forgiveness
- Anyone expecting a gaming or streaming focused romance
- Readers who dislike a fling stretched across the middle
- Anyone looking for closed door romance (try our closed door picks)
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Catered All the Way got friendly reviews from MM romance blogs on release in December 2023. Love Bytes gave it four hearts and Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words four out of five, and its Goodreads average sits just under four stars. Coverage is mostly blogs and reader reviews rather than trade outlets.
Where they agree. Zeb and Atlas as a team, and Atlas as a character. Love Bytes liked the couple and the small business storyline, Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words praised Atlas's realistic Navy work, and All About Romance's Carrie G liked the believable compromises in the ending.
Where they split. Gabe and the middle. Both Love Bytes and Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words felt the brother's apology came too easily, and Melanie found Albert's earlier The Geek Who Saved Christmas stronger. Resch Reads and Reviews found the shift into attraction abrupt and the fling repetitive, while Geoff Whaley enjoyed the humor and the measured sentiment.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Catered All the Way scores 7.2 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with good marks for chemistry and heat and lower scores for a repetitive middle and a family thread that resolves too neatly.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4 | A strong team dynamic, per Love Bytes, with believable compromises per All About Romance. |
| Characters (15%) | 3.5 | Atlas is terrific per Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words; Gabe is underwritten. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Warm and readable; the middle repeats itself, per Resch Reads and Reviews. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | Grief is handled well, but the sibling repair is too quick. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Delivers the steamy, exploratory heat the blurb promises. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A solid HEA built on mutual compromise, with a rushed family fix. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3 | Pleasant to revisit at Christmas, but rarely surprising. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Catered All the Way sits a step below The Geek Who Saved Christmas and Better Not Pout among Annabeth Albert's holiday romances, landing at a final Eikna Score of 7.2/10.
Is Catered All the Way a Standalone?
Catered All the Way is a standalone. Audible groups it with Annabeth Albert's other Christmas titles, and the blurb ties it to The Geek Who Saved Christmas, but Zeb and Atlas's story is complete and you can start here.
Albert's holiday romances in publication order, for readers who want them all:
- Better Not Pout (2018): Nick and Teddy
- The Geek Who Saved Christmas (2019)
- Catered All the Way (2023): Zeb and Atlas
Best format: Alexander Cendese's audiobook runs just over six hours and suits a December listen; the ebook is cheaper and quicker. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved Catered All the Way, Read These Next
If you loved Catered All the Way, look for MM holiday romances with forced proximity, bi awakenings and families who need winning over.
- The Geek Who Saved Christmas by Annabeth Albert: the holiday romance the blurb ties this one to, and many readers' favorite of the pair.
- Better Not Pout by Annabeth Albert: another military hero at Christmas, with an age gap and a gift drive.
- The Christmas Deal by Keira Andrews: holiday fake dating with a bi awakening and a family that matters.
- The Faker Rulebook by Baylin Crow: a one bed friends to lovers setup with a wedding instead of a shop.
- Conventionally Yours by Annabeth Albert: Albert at her best, with two gamers forced together on a road trip.
Frequently Asked Questions
Catered All the Way prompts the same questions from most readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how old the leads are and whether it ends happily. Short answers below.
Is Catered All the Way spicy?
Yes. Catered All the Way is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit open door scenes during the holiday fling.
Is Catered All the Way a standalone?
Yes. Catered All the Way is a standalone holiday romance, loosely tied to The Geek Who Saved Christmas.
How old are Zeb and Atlas?
Reviewers report that Zeb is 28 and Atlas is 35.
Does Catered All the Way have a happy ending?
Yes. Catered All the Way ends with a happily ever after for Zeb and Atlas.
Is there a Catered All the Way audiobook?
Yes. The audiobook is narrated by Alexander Cendese and runs 6 hours 3 minutes.
Is Atlas a Navy SEAL?
No. Atlas is a Navy chief who supports SEAL teams rather than serving as an operator.
The Bottom Line
Catered All the Way earns a 7.2/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a steamy, cozy MM Christmas romance with a long held crush, a capable older hero and a family shop in full holiday chaos, and who can forgive a brother who gets off easy. The reason to pick it up is the teamwork: Zeb and Atlas are never better than when they are saving Christmas for Seasons together.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- New release review: Catered All the Way, Love Bytes (Sadonna)
- Review: Catered All the Way, Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words (Melanie)
- Catered All the Way, All About Romance (Carrie G)
- Catered All the Way, Goodreads (release date, page count, reader ratings, ages)
- Catered All the Way audiobook, Libro.fm (narrator, length)
- Catered All the Way audiobook, Audiobooks Now
- An Annabeth Albert Christmas series, Audible
- Catered All the Way, Annabeth Albert (author site)
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.