eikna romance
Menu

Beyond the Sea by Keira Andrews Review

Eikna Score: 8.2/10. Recommended.

Beyond the Sea is a castaway romance that takes the survival part seriously, which is both why it works and why its first third tests your patience. Once the friendship between Troy and Brian turns into something neither of them planned, it becomes one of the most tender age gap romances in MM.

Read it if you love a real slow burn, survival detail and two men falling for each other because nobody else is there to watch. Skip it if you need the romance to start early, or you get bored by fishing, water collection and weather.

Beyond the Sea by Keira Andrews book cover

Beyond the Sea at a Glance

Beyond the Sea is a standalone MM romance by Keira Andrews, first published in March 2016. A boy band singer and the pilot of his crashed plane are stranded on a South Pacific island; it is a slow burn with an age gap and a bisexual awakening, told from both men's points of view, with steamy scenes and a happy ending.

AuthorKeira Andrews
SeriesStandalone (the author lists it with her standalones)
SubgenreContemporary romance, MM, survival and castaway
Main tropesForced proximity, slow burn, age gap, bisexual awakening, hurt and comfort, friends to lovers
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes (all in the second half)
Content warningsPlane crash, death of other passengers, injury, isolation and hunger, grief, internalised homophobia (full list below)
AgesGoodreads readers give Troy's age as 26 and Brian's as 39; the author tags the book as an age gap
POVDual, Troy and Brian
EndingHEA
Pages274 (2024 KA Books paperback; the ebook lists 275)
AudiobookNarrated by Greg Boudreaux, 8 hours 42 minutes (Tantor Audio)
First publishedMarch 9, 2016
PublisherSelf-published by Keira Andrews (paperback reissued under KA Books in 2024)

What Is Beyond the Sea About?

Beyond the Sea starts with a small plane going down over the South Pacific. Troy Tanner is a member of a boy band, used to being looked after and photographed. Brian is the pilot. When the plane crashes near a jungle island a thousand miles from anything, they are the only two who walk away.

What follows is the slow work of staying alive: finding water, learning to fish, keeping a fire going, waiting for a rescue that does not come. Two men with nothing in common become each other's only company. Over the months, need turns into friendship, and friendship turns into something that frightens them both.

What Makes This Forced Proximity Romance Work

Beyond the Sea works because its forced proximity is total. There is no office to escape to, no friend to call, no other person within a thousand miles. Every feeling Troy and Brian have for each other has to be dealt with face to face, on a beach, with nowhere to hide.

Keira Andrews also lets the friendship come first. The romance does not begin with a spark. It begins with two frightened people being decent to each other, then with a routine, then with inside jokes. Amber at Love Bytes Reviews wished the romance had started earlier, and I understand why, but by the time it arrives it feels earned in a way that instant attraction never does.

Then there is the bisexual awakening, which the author lists alongside the age gap. Desire turns up in a place one of these men did not expect it, and the book takes that confusion seriously instead of rushing past it. Readers who like a slow burn with real emotional stakes will find this one hard to put down once it gets going.

My Review

Beyond the Sea is a book I would hand to someone who says they do not like slow burns, with a warning to push past the first third. The opening chapters are almost entirely survival: the crash, the dead, the first nights, the long practical business of not dying. It is good survival writing. It is also a lot of it before anything romantic happens.

Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words, who gave the book 4.25 stars in the end, said the first forty percent moved at a snail's pace and admitted to nearly giving up more than once. I did not come as close to quitting, but I recognised the feeling. And then, somewhere in the middle, the book becomes something else.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is quiet before it is hot. Troy and Brian start as strangers stuck together, get through grief and fear side by side, and slowly realise that the person they look for first in the morning is the other one. Keira Andrews is patient with that turn. There is a lot of unresolved tension in the middle chapters, and Scattered Thoughts found it a little overdone. I thought it was the point: two men who cannot walk away from each other, and cannot afford to get it wrong.

When it does tip over, the payoff is warm and sexy and, crucially, still tender. The age gap matters less than the experience gap. One of them has more life behind him, and the other has more confidence about what he wants, and the book makes good use of both.

The Characters

Troy is better than the pop star cliché. He becomes capable, funny and brave on the island in ways that make sense for someone whose old life did not prepare him for any of it. Brian is the steadier of the two, older and more guarded, and the book is good on what it costs a self-contained man to admit he needs someone.

The dual point of view is the right choice. Scattered Thoughts praised it for showing both men's fears and hopes, and it lets the reader see each of them misreading the other in ways that hurt. With no supporting cast for most of the book, these two have to carry everything, and they do.

Writing and Pacing

Andrews writes survival detail with conviction. Amber at Love Bytes Reviews said the author clearly did her research on plane crashes, and Scattered Thoughts praised the weather, routines, food and clothing as credible. Small things, like shaving with no razor or bathing in the sea, become oddly intimate. There are nods to Cast Away and to the song the book is named after, and they land without feeling cute.

The cost is pace. The middle stretches, and some of the internal monologue goes round the same worries more than once. The final act moves faster and resolves well. I closed the book happy and a bit wrung out, which is about right for this kind of story.

Greg Boudreaux narrates the audiobook, and Erryn at Rainbow Gold Reviews gave it a perfect score, saying he made an improbable situation feel believable.

Beyond the Sea is a tender, patient castaway romance that rewards you for sticking with its slow first third. Read it if you want an MM slow burn where survival and intimacy grow together, and be ready for the opening to take its time.

How Spicy Is Beyond the Sea?

Beyond the Sea is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. There is nothing explicit in the first half. Once the relationship turns physical, the scenes are open door and detailed, and Keira Andrews describes them as scorching first times. Everything between the leads is consensual.

Both leads are adults; Goodreads readers give their ages as 26 and 39. See our heat levels guide for the full scale and our spicy romance list for more at this level.

Content warnings, drawn from the author's description and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Beyond the Sea?

Beyond the Sea suits readers who want a slow burn MM romance built on survival, friendship and a late but intense payoff. It is less suited to readers who want early chemistry, a busy cast or fast pacing.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Beyond the Sea is one of Keira Andrews's best-loved standalones, with an average of 4.09 from more than 7,700 ratings on Goodreads. Coverage comes mostly from MM romance blogs and reader reviews rather than trade critics, which is typical for a self-published romance.

Where they agree. The emotional payoff and the survival realism. Amber at Love Bytes Reviews gave it 4.5 hearts and called it beautiful and sad, praising the attention to detail. Scattered Thoughts and Rogue Words praised the setting and the dual point of view. Erryn at Rainbow Gold Reviews gave the audiobook a perfect score.

Where they split. The pace of the opening. Scattered Thoughts nearly did not finish the book in its first forty percent and found some of the internal dialogue dull. Amber's only complaint was that the romance started late. Readers who love slow burns tend to call that build the best part of the book; readers who want early heat call it a slog.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Beyond the Sea scores 8.2 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with top marks for the romance and its emotional impact, and its lowest for writing and pacing, where reviewers fault a very slow opening.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4.5A deeply earned slow burn; Amber at Love Bytes calls it beautiful and sad.
Characters (15%)4Two well-drawn leads carry the book alone; Scattered Thoughts praises the dual point of view.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Convincing survival detail, but the first forty percent drags, per Scattered Thoughts.
Emotional impact (15%)4.5Grief, fear and tenderness hit hard once the relationship turns.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the scorching late payoff the author promises, after a long wait.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A satisfying HEA after a final act that picks up speed.
Reread appeal (10%)4A favourite reread for slow burn fans; Rainbow Gold Reviews rates the audio perfect.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Beyond the Sea is the more emotionally ambitious of Keira Andrews's two age gap standalones we cover, a notch above Kidnapped by the Pirate, and it lands at a final Eikna Score of 8.2/10.

Is Beyond the Sea a Standalone?

Yes. Beyond the Sea is a standalone novel with a complete story and a happy ending, and Keira Andrews lists it among her standalones. It has no prequel or sequel, so you can start here.

Keira Andrews has written other standalone age gap romances. Kidnapped by the Pirate (2017) is the closest in mood, swapping the island for a pirate ship and the slow burn for a faster, steamier fantasy. The two books are unconnected, so read them in any order.

Best format: the Tantor audiobook narrated by Greg Boudreaux runs under nine hours, and the survival chapters are easier to settle into when someone is reading them to you. Our series order guide covers longer series.

If You Loved Beyond the Sea, Read These Next

If you loved Beyond the Sea, the closest matches are romances built on isolation, slow trust and characters with nobody else to turn to.

Frequently Asked Questions

Beyond the Sea gets the same questions from most new readers: how spicy it is, how slow the start is, how old the leads are and whether it has a happy ending.

Is Beyond the Sea by Keira Andrews spicy?

Yes. Beyond the Sea is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with explicit, consensual scenes that all come in the second half after a long slow burn.

How old are Troy and Brian in Beyond the Sea?

Goodreads readers give Troy's age as 26 and Brian's as 39. Both are adults, and the author tags the book as an age gap romance.

Does Beyond the Sea have a happy ending?

Yes. Beyond the Sea ends with a happily ever after for Troy and Brian.

Is Beyond the Sea part of a series?

No. Beyond the Sea is a standalone novel with no prequel or sequel.

Is the start of Beyond the Sea slow?

Yes, for many readers. The first third focuses on surviving the crash, and some reviewers found it slow before the romance takes hold.

Is there a Beyond the Sea audiobook?

Yes. The Tantor audiobook is narrated by Greg Boudreaux and runs 8 hours 42 minutes.

The Bottom Line

Beyond the Sea earns a 8.2/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want an MM slow burn where the romance grows out of survival and friendship, and who can wait a while for the heat. The one reason to pick it up is the payoff: by the time Troy and Brian admit what they feel, you will believe every word of it.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.