eikna romance
Menu

Kidnapped by the Pirate by Keira Andrews Review

Eikna Score: 7.6/10. Recommended.

Kidnapped by the Pirate is an unashamed old-school bodice ripper with two men in it, and it knows exactly what fantasy it is selling: a feared captain, a sheltered young captive and a cabin with one bed. The pirate plot is thinner than the cover promises, but the slow thaw between Hawk and Nathaniel is warm, sexy and better written than the premise needs it to be.

Read it if you want a captor and captive fantasy with a big age gap, or you miss the swashbuckling historicals of the 1980s and want one with a gay couple. Skip it if a 23-year age gap or a romance that begins with a kidnapping is a hard no, or you want a pirate book driven by battles rather than by the bedroom.

Kidnapped by the Pirate by Keira Andrews book cover

Kidnapped by the Pirate at a Glance

Kidnapped by the Pirate is a standalone historical MM romance by Keira Andrews, first released in October 2017. An 18-year-old governor's son is taken for ransom by a pirate captain in his forties; the book mixes enemies to lovers, forced proximity and first-time discovery, runs steamy and ends happily.

AuthorKeira Andrews
SeriesStandalone (the author lists it with her standalones)
SubgenreHistorical romance, MM, high seas adventure
Main tropesAge gap, captor and captive, enemies to lovers, forced proximity, only one bed, virgin hero
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsKidnapping and ransom, captivity, large age gap and power imbalance, violence, internalised and period homophobia (full list below)
AgesNathaniel is 18 and Hawk is 41, as reader reviews report; the publisher describes the captive as half the pirate's age
POVThe story follows both Nathaniel and Hawk
EndingHEA
Pages298 (2024 KA Books paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Cornell Collins, 10 hours 6 minutes (Tantor Audio, April 2018)
First publishedOctober 26, 2017
PublisherSelf-published by Keira Andrews (paperback reissued under KA Books in 2024)

What Is Kidnapped by the Pirate About?

Kidnapped by the Pirate follows Nathaniel Bainbridge, the son of the governor of Primrose Isle, a young colony in the New World. Nathaniel has two secrets: reading is a struggle for him, and he wants men. He is on his way to the colony to make a marriage that will serve his family when pirates take the ship.

The man who takes him is Hawk, the Sea Hawk, a captain with a grudge against Nathaniel's father and a ransom in mind. Locked in close quarters, captor and captive start to see past each other's reputations. The crew wants its money, though, and Hawk's revenge has a deadline.

What Makes This Captor and Captive Romance Work

Kidnapped by the Pirate works because Keira Andrews plays the captor and captive fantasy straight and then makes the captor the one with more to lose. Hawk has the ship, the weapons and the key to the cabin. Nathaniel has the thing Hawk cannot control: he is curious, stubborn and, once he understands what he wants, not ashamed of it.

That reversal is the hook. Lisa at The Novel Approach called it "pure category romance" with a pirate costume on, and that is a compliment as well as a warning. The conflict is mostly internal: a bitter man who thinks he does not deserve peace, a young man raised to hide everything, and a ransom that will separate them if it is paid.

The rest is trope furniture used with confidence. There is one bed. There is a sister, Susanna, waiting in the colony. There is a rival crew. If you came for the forced proximity and the slow surrender, the book gives you exactly that, and very little else gets in the way.

My Review

I went into Kidnapped by the Pirate expecting to be uncomfortable and came out mostly charmed, which I suspect is the experience Keira Andrews was aiming for. The setup is the kind of thing romance readers argue about for good reason. A forty-one-year-old pirate kidnaps an eighteen-year-old for ransom and then shares a bed with him. The book does not pretend that is innocent. It just asks you to enjoy the fantasy on its own terms, and it is honest about which terms those are.

Annika at Love Bytes compared it to the bodice rippers she read as a teenager, and that comparison is the right lens. This is a breeches ripper, as Tori at the same blog put it, and the pleasure comes from the familiar beats with the genders swapped out.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is the reason to read it. Hawk is gruff, guarded and far more decent than he wants anyone to know, and Nathaniel keeps prodding at that decency until it shows. The early scenes are tense in a good way. Nathaniel is frightened, but he is also furious, and he talks back. That keeps the power imbalance from turning into simple domination.

Consent is handled with more care than the premise suggests. The sex between them is framed as Nathaniel's discovery of what he wants, not something taken from him, and reviewers who loved the book keep coming back to how stubborn and self-possessed he is. Whether that resolves the captivity problem is up to you. It did not fully resolve it for me, since Nathaniel cannot leave the ship, but the book is aware of the question and keeps returning to the ransom as the thing that has to change.

The Characters

Nathaniel is better than the damsel the cover implies. The Novel Approach praised him as vulnerable without being weak, and I agree. His trouble with reading is handled with real tenderness, and it gives him a private shame that has nothing to do with sex, which makes him feel like a person rather than a prize. He is also funny when he is angry.

Hawk gets the deeper backstory, and his grudge against the governor carries what plot the book has. Lisa felt his history was more developed than Nathaniel's, and that matches my read. Susanna, Nathaniel's sister, is a welcome warm presence in the later chapters, and On Top Down Under singled her out as a supportive female character in a book that could easily have had none.

Writing and Pacing

The prose is clean and quick, with enough period texture to keep you on a ship and not in a modern apartment with a sea view. Keira Andrews does not overload the sailing detail. Dog-eared Daydreams praised the balance between swashbuckling and quieter introspection, and the quiet parts are where she is strongest.

The weak spot is the adventure itself. If you want boarding actions and cannon fire, there is some pirate on pirate conflict, but most of the book happens in the captain's cabin. Annika at Love Bytes felt the explicit scenes made the middle drag and found the ending anticlimactic. I did not mind the bedroom focus, but I agree that the final act resolves the external danger quickly and a little too neatly. The romance ending is satisfying; the plot ending is a formality.

The audiobook is worth flagging. Cornell Collins gets five stars from Karen at On Top Down Under for his narration, and his British accent suits a book full of ships and governors.

Kidnapped by the Pirate is a confident, steamy captor and captive romance that delivers its fantasy without apology. Read it if the age gap and the kidnapping setup are a draw for you, because the book never tries to talk you out of either.

How Spicy Is Kidnapped by the Pirate?

Kidnapped by the Pirate is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. Once the physical relationship starts, the sex is frequent, detailed and central to Nathaniel's arc, since much of it is about his first experiences with a man. Every scene between the leads is consensual on the page, but it all happens while Nathaniel is a captive, and readers should weigh that context.

Both leads are adults. Reader reviews put Nathaniel at 18 and Hawk at 41, and the publisher's description calls the captive half the pirate's age. Our heat levels guide explains the scale, and there is more at this level on our spicy romance list.

Content warnings, drawn from the author's description, Trigger Warning Database and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Kidnapped by the Pirate?

Kidnapped by the Pirate suits readers who love an age gap, a captor and captive setup and a lot of heat in a historical setting. It is a poor fit for readers who want a plot-heavy adventure or who cannot enjoy a romance that starts with an abduction.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Kidnapped by the Pirate has had mostly warm reviews from MM romance blogs since its 2017 release, and very little mainstream critical coverage, which is normal for a self-published title. Most of the conversation sits on blogs and on Goodreads.

Where they agree. Readers like Nathaniel. The Novel Approach gave it four stars and praised him as vulnerable but never a damsel; Tori at Love Bytes gave it five hearts and called him strong and feisty. Dog-eared Daydreams went further, giving it five plus stars and praising how slowly trust is built. The chemistry and the sex get near-universal praise from readers who came for them.

Where they split. The plot and the amount of sex. Annika at Love Bytes, reviewing the audiobook, liked the nostalgia but felt the explicit scenes dragged and found the ending anticlimactic. Karen at On Top Down Under enjoyed it but said there was more sex than she wanted. Tori admitted it is predictable and fluffy and loved it anyway. The age gap and the captivity split readers outside those blogs too: some treat them as the whole point, others as the reason they will not pick it up.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Kidnapped by the Pirate scores 7.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for romance, characters, heat and the ending, and its lowest for writing, emotional depth and reread value, where reviewers point to a thin adventure plot.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Warm, charged slow surrender; Tori at Love Bytes and Dog-eared Daydreams both rate the chemistry highly.
Characters (15%)4Nathaniel is vulnerable but never weak, per The Novel Approach; Hawk gets the richer backstory.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Clean and quick, but Annika at Love Bytes found the middle draggy and the plot thin.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Tender in places, especially the reading subplot; the external stakes rarely bite.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the frequent, explicit first-time heat the blurb promises.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A satisfying romantic HEA; the external threat wraps up too fast.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5A comfort reread for trope fans; On Top Down Under rates the audio especially highly.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Kidnapped by the Pirate sits a step below Beyond the Sea in Keira Andrews's standalone catalogue for emotional weight, but it is the more purely fun of the two, and it lands at a final Eikna Score of 7.6/10.

Is Kidnapped by the Pirate a Standalone?

Yes. Kidnapped by the Pirate is a standalone novel with a complete story and a happy ending, and Keira Andrews lists it among her standalones. You do not need to read anything else first.

If you want more Keira Andrews in a similar mood, her other age gap standalone Beyond the Sea (2016) swaps the pirate ship for a desert island and a slower burn. Read them in either order.

Best format: the Tantor audiobook narrated by Cornell Collins runs just over ten hours and is the version blog reviewers praise most. Our series order guide covers longer series if you want something to binge afterwards.

If You Loved Kidnapped by the Pirate, Read These Next

If you loved Kidnapped by the Pirate, look for romances with captive or rival setups, historical settings and a power gap the book takes seriously.

Frequently Asked Questions

Kidnapped by the Pirate raises the same handful of questions for most readers: how spicy it is, how old the leads are, whether it ends happily and whether there is an audiobook.

Is Kidnapped by the Pirate spicy?

Yes. Kidnapped by the Pirate is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with frequent explicit scenes between the leads once their relationship begins.

How old are Hawk and Nathaniel in Kidnapped by the Pirate?

Reader reviews give Nathaniel's age as 18 and Hawk's as 41, a gap of 23 years. The publisher describes the captive as half the pirate's age.

Does Kidnapped by the Pirate have a happy ending?

Yes. Kidnapped by the Pirate ends with a happily ever after for Hawk and Nathaniel.

Is Kidnapped by the Pirate part of a series?

No. Kidnapped by the Pirate is a standalone historical romance and can be read on its own.

Is there a Kidnapped by the Pirate audiobook?

Yes. The Tantor audiobook is narrated by Cornell Collins and runs 10 hours 6 minutes.

Is Kidnapped by the Pirate a dark romance?

Not really. It uses a captor and captive setup and a large age gap, but the tone is warm and the sex between the leads is consensual on the page. It reads as a classic historical fantasy rather than a dark romance.

The Bottom Line

Kidnapped by the Pirate earns a 7.6/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a steamy MM historical built on a captor and captive fantasy and a big age gap, and who would rather spend the book in the captain's cabin than on deck. The one reason to pick it up is Nathaniel, a captive who keeps talking back until the man holding the key has to listen.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.