Chick Magnet by Emma Barry Review
Eikna Score: 7.6/10. Recommended.
Chick Magnet is a warm, quietly serious small-town romance about a chicken influencer and a struggling vet, and it is far better on depression, money worries and pandemic burnout than its cute title suggests. The romance burns slowly and the ending is more realistic than triumphant, so it rewards readers who want grown-up feelings more than pure comedy.
Read it if you like small-town neighbors, an animal-mad heroine and a hero whose grumpiness turns out to be depression handled with care. Skip it if you want a light rom-com escape, or a book that leaves COVID out entirely.
Chick Magnet at a Glance
Chick Magnet is Emma Barry's 2023 contemporary romance, a standalone published by Montlake on January 24, 2023. It pairs a chicken-keeping social media star with the gruff veterinarian next door in small-town Virginia during the pandemic, and it ends happily. Publishers Weekly lists the trade paperback at 322 pages.
| Author | Emma Barry |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone |
| Subgenre | Contemporary romance, small town |
| Main tropes | Neighbors to lovers, gruff hero and sunny heroine, influencer heroine, starting over after a public breakup, slow burn |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Depression, grief, COVID, financial strain, online harassment, gaslighting ex (full list below) |
| POV | Dual, Nic and Will |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 322 (trade paperback, per Publishers Weekly) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by CJ Bloom and Aaron Shedlock (Brilliance Audio) |
| First published | January 24, 2023 |
| Publisher | Montlake |
What Is Chick Magnet About?
Chick Magnet follows Nicole "Nic" Jones, known online as Chick Nic, who has built an audience on her flock of backyard chickens. After a YouTuber boyfriend dumps her publicly for the attention, she moves with the birds to Yagerstown, Virginia, to start over.
When one of her hens has an emergency, Nic meets Will Lund, the town veterinarian, who is handsome, short with her and openly critical of the way her videos promote chicken keeping. He also turns out to be her neighbor. Late-night talks over the fence, backyard mishaps and a struggling vet practice slowly turn two wary people into something more.
What Makes This Neighbors to Lovers Romance Work
Chick Magnet works because the neighbors setup is used for intimacy, not slapstick. Nic and Will keep running into each other because they live next door, and the best scenes are quiet ones: a porch, a fence, a conversation that goes on later than either planned. Angela at Smexy Books liked exactly that slow development.
The other hook is honesty. Will's gruffness is not a personality quirk; he is depressed, his practice is in trouble and he does not know how to ask for help. Publishers Weekly praised how carefully the book handles seeking treatment for mental illness, and that care is what lifts it above the usual grumpy hero.
And then there are the chickens. Nic's flock is funny, specific and plot-relevant, and the book is clearly written by someone who knows backyard poultry. Kirkus summed it up as a comforting small-town romance, with chickens.
My Review
I picked up Chick Magnet for the chickens and stayed for Will. Emma Barry has written a romance about two people who are each a bit broken by the last few years, and she lets them be sad, cranky and slow to trust without making the book a slog. It is not the comedy the cover promises. It is better than that, most of the time.
Romance and Chemistry
This is a slow burn, and the heat builds through conversation. Nic is warm and performs warmth for a living; Will is blunt and does not perform anything. Their early clashes over her videos have real content, since he worries that influencers make chicken keeping look easier than it is, and that disagreement turns into respect before it turns into attraction. Lisa Fernandes at All About Romance found the couple warmly written, and I agree.
The catch is balance. Holly at The Smut Report felt the business plot overshadowed the romance and did not feel much spark between the leads. I felt the spark, but I understand the complaint: Will's fight to keep his practice open takes a lot of page space, and the couple only sleeps together about two thirds of the way in.
The Characters
Nic is a lovely heroine because her online persona is not a lie, just an edited version of her. She is lonely, burned by a boyfriend who used her for content, and unsure whether anything she has built is real work. Will is the standout: a taciturn man who loves animals, is failing at the part of his job that is about money, and slowly admits that he needs more than willpower to get better.
The secondary cast does a lot of quiet work, from the vet clinic staff to Nic's friends, and Jen at That's What I'm Talking About praised the repair of friendships along with the individual growth. Holly called the character work the book's greatest strength, and it is.
One thing I appreciated more on reflection: Nic's public breakup is not just a launching device. The damage from it shapes how she reads Will's kindness, and her slowness to trust him is a consequence rather than a plot device. That makes the moment she lets him help feel like a real step, not a beat on a checklist.
Writing and Pacing
Barry writes clean, observant prose with a good ear for small talk. The content-creation details feel researched; CJ at A Well-Read Tart enjoyed how realistic they are. The book is set in 2022 with COVID shaping everyone's work lives, and Angela at Smexy Books admitted she might have skipped it had she known.
The weaker spots are tonal. Kirkus noted abrupt shifts between light and heavy material, and Miss Bates thought the opening less witty than Barry's earlier books. The ending is realistic and not a fairy-tale rescue, which Holly found disappointing and I found refreshing. Either way, it is earned.
Chick Magnet is a tender, thoughtful small-town romance with a depressed vet, a lonely influencer and a flock of very funny chickens. Read it if you want grown-up feelings and slow heat; skip it if you came for a breezy comedy.
How Spicy Is Chick Magnet?
Chick Magnet is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. Emma Barry describes it as open door but not erotic, and the love scenes arrive late, around two thirds of the way through, after a long build. They are consensual, tender and focused on emotion. Barry offers a steamier alternate version of one chapter as bonus content on her website.
Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Content warnings, drawn from the author's own notes and reviews:
- Depression, therapy and seeking treatment
- Grief and family strain
- A gaslighting ex and online harassment and stalking
- Financial trouble and a failing small business
- The COVID pandemic and its effects on work
- Animal medical emergencies (no animal deaths on page; illness and death mentioned in passing)
- On-page sex, alcohol use and profanity
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Chick Magnet?
Chick Magnet suits readers who want a gentle, character-driven small-town romance with a mental health thread handled carefully, moderate heat and plenty of animals. It is less suited to readers who want comedy throughout or a romance with no pandemic setting.
Best for:
- Fans of slow-burn small town romance
- Readers who like a hero working through depression with real support
- Animal lovers, especially anyone who keeps backyard chickens
- Readers interested in influencer and content-creator heroines
Not for:
- Readers looking for a laugh-a-minute rom-com
- Anyone avoiding COVID in fiction
- Readers who want the romance to dominate every chapter
- Anyone wanting high heat (try our spicy picks)
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Chick Magnet was named one of The New York Times' best romances of 2023, according to Emma Barry, and the trade reviews were warm. Publishers Weekly called it sexy and uplifting; Kirkus gave it a comforting small-town verdict with a note about tone.
Where they agree. The characters. Publishers Weekly praised the care taken with both leads and the mental health thread. Lisa Fernandes at All About Romance found the couple warmly written, Jen at That's What I'm Talking About valued the growth and emotional prose, and even the more critical Holly at The Smut Report called the character work the book's strength.
Where they split. Tone and payoff. Kirkus found the shifts between light and heavy abrupt. Fernandes noted the book was darker than she expected. Holly felt the business plot crowded the romance and found the ending realistic but deflating, and she disputed the grumpy sunshine label. Miss Bates enjoyed the literary allusions and later courtship but found the opening less sparkling than Barry's earlier work.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Chick Magnet scores 7.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with top marks for characters and emotional depth and lower scores for a romance that shares the stage and an ending some readers find too practical.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Warm and believable per All About Romance; the business plot crowds it, per The Smut Report. |
| Characters (15%) | 4.5 | Praised by every reviewer, including The Smut Report, as the book's strength. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4 | Clean, researched prose; abrupt tonal shifts per Kirkus. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | Will's depression is handled with care, as Publishers Weekly noted. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Open door but not erotic, exactly as the author promises; it arrives late. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A real HEA with a practical, not magical, career resolution. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | Comforting to revisit, though the pandemic setting will date it. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Chick Magnet sits among the more emotionally serious small-town romances of 2023, kinder than most and slower than some, with a final Eikna Score of 7.6/10.
Is Chick Magnet a Standalone?
Yes. Chick Magnet is a standalone contemporary romance with a complete love story and a happy ending, and it needs no other Emma Barry book. It is not part of a series.
Best format: print or ebook if you like to linger over the quieter conversations. The audiobook from Brilliance uses two narrators, CJ Bloom and Aaron Shedlock, which suits a book that gives Nic and Will equal weight. Our series order guide covers connected romances if you want something longer.
If You Loved Chick Magnet, Read These Next
If you loved Chick Magnet, look for contemporary romances where the mental health thread is as important as the meet-cute.
- The Heart Principle by Helen Hoang: burnout, grief and a love story that takes mental health seriously.
- Get a Life, Chloe Brown by Talia Hibbert: a heroine rebuilding her life and a guarded neighbor with his own history.
- Part of Your World by Abby Jimenez: a doctor, a small town and a romance that weighs real-life obligations.
- Teach Me by Olivia Dade: two high school teachers, a quiet slow burn and a lot of kindness.
- Float Plan by Trish Doller: grief after a partner's death and a hired sailor on a long voyage toward healing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Chick Magnet raises the same questions for most readers: how spicy it is, whether it is a rom-com and whether the pandemic setting is central. Short answers below.
Is Chick Magnet spicy?
Moderately. Chick Magnet is a 3 out of 5 on our scale; the author calls it open door but not erotic, and the love scenes arrive late in the book.
Is Chick Magnet a standalone?
Yes. Chick Magnet is a standalone romance by Emma Barry with a complete story.
Does Chick Magnet have a happy ending?
Yes. Nic and Will get a happily ever after, though the career resolution is practical rather than a fairy tale.
Is Chick Magnet set during COVID?
Yes. Chick Magnet is set during the pandemic, and its effects on small businesses shape the plot.
Where is Chick Magnet set?
Chick Magnet is set in the small town of Yagerstown, Virginia, per Publishers Weekly.
Is there a Chick Magnet audiobook?
Yes. Brilliance Audio published an audiobook narrated by CJ Bloom and Aaron Shedlock.
The Bottom Line
Chick Magnet earns a 7.6/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a slow, warm small-town romance with real stakes, a hero facing depression and a heroine rebuilding after a public humiliation. The reason to pick it up is Will: few romance heroes are allowed to be this low and still this lovable.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Chick Magnet, Emma Barry (author site: premise, heat, NYT best of 2023)
- Content warnings, Emma Barry (author site)
- Chick Magnet, Publishers Weekly review
- Chick Magnet, Kirkus Reviews
- Chick Magnet audiobook, Audible (narrators)
- Chick Magnet, All About Romance (Lisa Fernandes)
- Review: Chick Magnet, Smexy Books (Angela)
- Review: Chick Magnet, The Smut Report (Holly)
- Review: Chick Magnet, Miss Bates Reads Romance
- Chick Magnet, A Well-Read Tart (CJ)
- Review: Chick Magnet, That's What I'm Talking About (Jen)
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.