eikna romance
Menu

Float Plan by Trish Doller Review

Eikna Score: 8.0/10. Recommended.

Float Plan is a short, salt-stung romance about a woman sailing the trip her fiancé planned before he died by suicide, and the Irish sailor she hires when she cannot do it alone. Trish Doller handles grief with rare honesty and makes Keane one of the most likeable heroes in recent contemporary romance; the romance moves quickly for a heroine this fresh in mourning, but it earns its hopeful ending.

Read it if you want a grief romance that is honest without being bleak, a travel setting you can almost taste and a kind, funny hero. Skip it if suicide loss is too close to home, or you need a long, slow gap between grief and new love.

Float Plan by Trish Doller book cover

Float Plan at a Glance

Float Plan is book 1 of Trish Doller's loosely connected Beck Sisters series, published by St. Martin's Griffin in March 2021. It follows Anna Beck, who sets sail on the Caribbean voyage she and her late fiancé planned, and Keane Sullivan, the Irish professional sailor she hires to crew. It is told in first person by Anna, keeps the heat mild and ends hopefully.

AuthorTrish Doller
SeriesBeck Sisters, book 1 (each book stands alone)
SubgenreContemporary romance, travel and sailing romance
Main tropesGrief and new love, forced proximity on a boat, travel romance, disabled hero, friends to lovers pace
Spice level2/5: Mild, fade to black
Content warningsSuicide of a partner (before the story), grief, depression, references to an accident and amputation (full list below)
POVFirst person, Anna
EndingHappy, hopeful ending
Pages272 (paperback)
AudiobookMacmillan Audio, read by Sarah Naughton, 7 hours 18 minutes
First publishedMarch 2, 2021
PublisherSt. Martin's Griffin (Macmillan)

What Is Float Plan About?

Float Plan follows Anna Beck, whose fiancé Ben died by suicide about ten months before the book opens. They had planned to sail around the Caribbean together on his boat. Anna, who is not an experienced sailor, decides to take the trip anyway, alone, as a way of keeping a promise and of finding out whether she can keep living.

One rough night at sea is enough to show her she cannot do it solo. She hires Keane Sullivan, an Irish professional sailor from County Kerry who lost part of his leg in an accident and has been struggling to find racing work since. He is funny, capable and dealing with his own unexpected future. As they sail from Florida through the Bahamas and on into the Caribbean, Anna starts to wonder whether starting over means leaving Ben behind.

What Makes This Forced Proximity Romance Work

Float Plan works as a forced proximity romance because a small sailboat is the most forced proximity there is. Anna and Keane share a cramped cabin, every task and every bad weather night, and the book uses that closeness to build trust before it builds romance. Kirkus noted that the relationship grows through exactly that proximity.

The sailing is the hook. Trish Doller knows boats, and the details of navigation, provisioning, anchorages and island stops are specific without being technical. Kirkus praised the detailed travel content, and readers who have never sailed still come away feeling they have been somewhere.

The grief is the heart. Anna is not ready for a new love, and the book never pretends she is. Readers who like romances where the hard thing is not wrapped up neatly, such as The Simple Wild, will find the same honesty here.

My Review

Float Plan is a short book that does something difficult: it puts a suicide loss at the centre of a romance and does not flinch from it or exploit it. That alone would make it worth reading. That it is also funny, sunny and romantic is a small miracle.

Kirkus called its handling of a loved one's suicide rare in romantic fiction, and Kaetrin at Dear Author gave it an A minus. All About Romance said it took the reviewer by surprise and recommended it highly. I came to it expecting a sad book and found a hopeful one.

Romance and Chemistry

The romance between Anna and Keane is built on competence and humour. He teaches her to sail without condescension, she pushes back when he is wrong and their banter is easy from the start. Keane's prosthetic leg is part of his life, not a plot device; Kirkus noted that the book treats it as no big deal between lovers, and that is exactly right.

The pace is the one real question. Anna is ten months out from Ben's death, and the romance develops quickly on a short voyage. Some readers on StoryGraph felt it was too soon. I thought the book handled that well, because Anna asks the same question herself, repeatedly, and Keane gives her room to feel guilty. The intimacy, when it comes, is mostly off page, and it is about comfort and choice as much as desire.

What I liked most is that Ben never becomes the villain to make room for Keane. Anna loved him, and she is furious with him, and both are allowed to be true. The romance does not replace him. It sits beside the grief, which is how it tends to work in life and how it rarely works in romance novels. When Anna finally chooses something for herself, it feels like a decision about her own future rather than a verdict on her past.

The Characters

Anna is a good, prickly heroine. She is angry at Ben as well as grieving him, and Doller lets her be both. Her flashes of humour, her stubbornness about doing the trip and her slow realisation of how much she gave up for Ben's plans are written with real care. Kaetrin at Dear Author quoted her early insistence that she is not in the market for a new soul mate, and the book takes that seriously.

Keane is the standout. He is warm, frank, very Irish in his speech and carrying his own frustration about a career that may be over. He is not there to fix Anna; he has his own decisions to make, and the book gives him a real arc. Readers on nearly every blog and StoryGraph thread single him out, and I would add him to any list of best recent contemporary heroes.

The supporting cast is small by design: other sailors, island locals and a few phone calls home, including to Anna's family. That keeps the focus where it belongs, on two people in a small space.

Writing and Pacing

Doller's prose is clean and unfussy, and she writes the sea with real affection. The book moves fast; at 272 pages it never outstays its welcome. The short length is part of why the emotional beats land.

If anything, it is a little too short. A few island stops pass in a paragraph, and one late conflict resolves faster than it should. I would have happily read another hundred pages of the voyage. The audiobook, read by Sarah Naughton, who narrates the whole Beck Sisters series, runs just over seven hours and suits the book's quick rhythm.

Float Plan is a short, honest and surprisingly sunny romance about grief, sailing and a very good Irish hero. Read it if you want a book that takes loss seriously and still believes in starting over.

How Spicy Is Float Plan?

Float Plan is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. Anna and Keane's relationship becomes physical partway through the voyage, but the scenes fade to black or are summarised. Phoebe Wright described the treatment as fade to black, and there is nothing explicit on page.

The serious content is about grief. Ben's suicide happened before the story begins and is discussed openly, including how he died and the aftermath for Anna. Depression is a theme throughout. Keane's accident and amputation are referenced. The Trigger Warning Database lists depression, suicide and grief. For more low-heat reads, see our closed door romance list.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reports and reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Who Should Read Float Plan?

Float Plan suits readers who want an honest, hopeful grief romance with a vivid sailing setting and a warm, disabled hero. It is less suited to readers who want steam, a long slow burn or a story without suicide at its centre.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Float Plan was a breakout for Trish Doller's adult romance career and drew strong reviews. Kirkus praised its humour and its handling of suicide, Publishers Weekly also reviewed it, and Dear Author gave it an A minus.

Where they agree. Keane and the setting. Kirkus, Dear Author and All About Romance all praise the hero and the sense of place, and readers repeatedly say they want to go sailing after reading it. The grief writing is widely admired.

Where they split. Timing and length. Some StoryGraph readers felt the romance came too soon after Ben's death, and a few wanted a longer book with more room for the voyage. Others found the short, quick shape exactly right.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Float Plan scores 8.0 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top marks for characters and emotional impact, where Keane and Anna's grief carry the book, and its lowest for heat, which stays mild.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Built on trust and humour; some readers find it too soon after the loss.
Characters (15%)4.5Keane is a standout; Dear Author and All About Romance agree.
Writing and pacing (15%)4Clean and quick; a few island stops pass too fast.
Emotional impact (15%)4.5Kirkus calls its handling of suicide rare in romantic fiction.
Heat level (10%)3Fade to black, per Read and Wright; fits the book but adds little.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A hopeful happy ending; one late conflict resolves fast.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5A short, sunny comfort reread for the voyage and Keane.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Float Plan is the strongest book in the Beck Sisters series and one of the best grief romances of its year, and it lands at a final Eikna Score of 8.0/10.

Beck Sisters Reading Order

Float Plan is book 1 of Trish Doller's Beck Sisters series. The books are loosely connected and each has its own couple and ending, so you can read them in any order, but publication order is best.

  1. Book 1: Float Plan (2021): Anna and Keane
  2. Book 2: The Suite Spot (2022): Rachel and Mason
  3. Book 3: Off the Map (2023): Carla and Eamon

Best format: the Macmillan audiobook, read by Sarah Naughton, who narrates all three books. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.

If You Loved Float Plan, Read These Next

If you loved Float Plan, the closest matches are romances about grief, travel and starting over, with warm heroes and strong settings.

Frequently Asked Questions

Float Plan raises the same questions for most new readers: how spicy it is, how it handles suicide, whether it ends happily and where it fits in the Beck Sisters series. Short answers below.

Is Float Plan spicy?

Only mildly. We rate it 2 out of 5: the relationship becomes physical, but scenes fade to black.

Does Float Plan deal with suicide?

Yes. Anna's fiancé died by suicide before the book begins, and her grief is the centre of the story. It is discussed openly but not sensationally.

Does Float Plan have a happy ending?

Yes. Anna and Keane get a hopeful, happy ending.

Is Float Plan part of a series?

Yes. It is book 1 of the Beck Sisters series, followed by The Suite Spot and Off the Map, but it stands alone.

Is there a Float Plan audiobook?

Yes. Macmillan Audio published it, read by Sarah Naughton, at about 7 hours 18 minutes.

Is Keane disabled in Float Plan?

Yes. Keane lost part of one leg below the knee in an accident and uses a prosthesis.

The Bottom Line

Float Plan earns a 8.0/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a short, honest, hopeful romance about grief, with a vivid sailing voyage and a hero who is easy to love. The one reason to pick it up is the way Trish Doller lets Anna mourn and fall in love at the same time without cheating either.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.