eikna romance
Menu

Just Playing House by Farah Heron Review

Eikna Score: 7.3/10. Recommended.

Just Playing House pairs a Toronto stylist facing a preventive double mastectomy with the rising movie star who ghosted her after prom, and its care for both of them is the best thing about it. The romance is sweet and slow rather than sharp, and a crowded plot keeps it from going as deep as it could.

Read it if you want a gentle, closed-door rom-com with a caretaking hero and a heroine facing a real medical decision, or you like celebrity romance with some industry bite. Skip it if you want intense chemistry and steam, or medical storylines are hard reading for you right now.

Just Playing House by Farah Heron book cover

Just Playing House at a Glance

Just Playing House is a standalone romantic comedy by Farah Heron, published by Forever in July 2024. It pairs a department store stylist with the actor who once ghosted her, puts them under one roof during her surgical recovery, keeps the sex scenes closed door and ends happily.

AuthorFarah Heron
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreRomantic comedy, celebrity romance
Main tropesSecond chance, forced proximity, caretaking hero, movie star and stylist, high school history
Spice level2/5: Mild, fade to black
Content warningsPreventive double mastectomy and reconstruction, BRCA gene mutation, past cancer death of a relative, racism (full list below)
POVFollows both Marley and Nik
EndingHappy ending
Pages384 (US trade paperback)
AudiobookThe US publisher lists print and ebook editions
First publishedJune 18, 2024 (UK, Piatkus); July 2, 2024 (US, Forever)
PublisherForever, an imprint of Hachette Book Group

What Is Just Playing House About?

Just Playing House follows Marley Kamal, a personal shopper at an upscale Toronto department store who finally lands her first celebrity client. The client is Nikhil Shamdasani, a rising actor just cast as a superhero, and also her old prom date, the boy who slept with her and then vanished.

Nik needs Marley to get him ready for a big public reveal at Comic-Con in two weeks. Marley has her own big date in that window: an elective double mastectomy and reconstruction. When Nik offers to move in and look after her while she recovers, the two strike a deal, and the feelings they buried after prom start to come back.

What Makes This Forced Proximity Romance Work

Just Playing House works as a forced proximity romance because the proximity has a purpose. Nik is not trapped in Marley's apartment by a snowstorm; he is there to help her shower, manage drains and get through the first weeks after major surgery. That gives every small kindness real weight, and it lets the romance grow out of care rather than banter.

Farah Heron sets that intimacy against the noise of Nik's new fame. Kirkus noted the racist fan scrutiny that greets his casting, and Publishers Weekly praised the timely look at racial inequities in Hollywood. Marley, meanwhile, is making a preventive health decision that the book treats with specificity and respect. Courtney Reads Romance and Culturess both singled out how well the medical storyline is handled.

For readers who like forced proximity with a soft, tender centre and a second chance twist, this is the hook: two people who hurt each other as teenagers learning how to be gentle as adults.

My Review

Just Playing House is the most tender of Farah Heron's romances that I have read, and also the most crowded. There is a medical story, a Hollywood story, two families, a career ambition, a history from high school and a romance, and they all want room. The tenderness wins out, mostly.

Romance and Chemistry

The heart of the book is the caretaking. Nik learning how to help Marley without taking over, and Marley learning to accept help without feeling diminished, is good, specific romance writing. Smart Bitches, Trashy Books gave it an A and called it cozy but with enough emotional twists to stay interesting, and its reviewer said the book felt like a warm hug. Kirkus called the romance slow and sweet, and that is accurate.

Where it falters is the history. Helena Ramsaroop enjoyed the chemistry but wanted more of the shared backstory and less idealisation, and a StoryGraph reader did not fully believe the present-day spark. I felt that too. The prom night betrayal is big, and the book resolves it more quickly than its weight suggests. I wanted one more raw conversation about why Nik disappeared.

The Characters

Marley is ambitious, funny and frightened in ways that feel true. Her decision to have surgery before cancer can find her is presented as a choice, not a tragedy, and Heron does not let the book become only about her body. Kirkus described the characters as lovingly drawn and richly layered, and I agree about Marley especially.

Nik is a mix of grumpy and earnest, as the SBTB review put it. He can be rude to people who are not Marley, including his costar, and he walks out on a studio when its demands become unreasonable. The book frames that as a response to racism and pressure, and it mostly earns it. His father's cooking and the people around him give Nik a found family that softens his edges.

Writing and Pacing

Heron's prose is clean and easy, and the book spends enough time with Nik to show his industry from the inside. Publishers Weekly called the book breezy but fairly surface-level, which is the fair version of the criticism: with so many threads, some only get a scene or two. A few StoryGraph readers found it slow to get going, and one gave up early. Others, Courtney Reads Romance among them, loved the detail of the recovery chapters, and those chapters are where the book is at its best.

The Hollywood material is sharper than I expected. The casting backlash, the publicity games and the tightrope Nik walks as a brown man in a superhero suit give the book a bite that offsets its sweetness.

Just Playing House is a gentle, caring second chance romance with an unusually thoughtful medical storyline and a busy plot that thins out its emotional history. Read it if you want warmth and care over heat and drama.

How Spicy Is Just Playing House?

Just Playing House is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. Publishers Weekly notes that the sex scenes are closed door, and the intimacy that is on the page is more about trust and recovery than desire. Smart Bitches, Trashy Books described the romance as a slow, sexy dance, which is about as far as the heat goes.

See our closed door romance list for more in this range, and the romance heat levels guide for the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from Farah Heron's content notes and reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Just Playing House?

Just Playing House suits readers who want a soft, closed-door romance built on care, with a heroine making a hard health decision and a hero navigating fame. It is less suited to readers who want heat, sharp banter or a tightly focused plot.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Just Playing House drew positive trade reviews and a strong recommendation from Smart Bitches, Trashy Books, with a more mixed spread among everyday readers. Kirkus called it a slow, sweet romance that explores the boundary between privacy and publicity, and Culturess described it as spectacularly crafted.

Where they agree. The medical storyline and the care. Publishers Weekly, Courtney Reads Romance, Culturess and Smart Bitches, Trashy Books all praised how Marley's surgery and recovery are handled, and Helena Ramsaroop valued the friendship and caregiving. The Hollywood racism thread also earns credit from Kirkus and PW.

Where they split. Depth and chemistry. Publishers Weekly found it fairly surface-level, and several StoryGraph readers felt too many threads competed for space or that the present-day chemistry did not convince. Smart Bitches, Trashy Books, by contrast, ranked it among its reviewer's favourite movie star romances.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Just Playing House scores 7.3 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for characters and emotional impact, and its weaker marks for a rushed past and a plot with more threads than room.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Tender caretaking romance; Helena Ramsaroop wants more backstory and less idealisation.
Characters (15%)4Kirkus calls the characters lovingly drawn and richly layered.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Clean and breezy; Publishers Weekly finds it fairly surface-level.
Emotional impact (15%)4The surgery and recovery are handled with care, per PW and Culturess.
Heat level (10%)3.5Delivers the closed-door warmth it promises, as PW notes.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A warm, happy close; the prom night history is settled a little fast.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5The recovery chapters reward a reread; the busier threads less so.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Just Playing House is Farah Heron's most tender romance and sits close to Jana Goes Wild in her catalogue, with a final Eikna Score of 7.3/10.

Is Just Playing House a Standalone?

Yes. Just Playing House is a standalone with a complete romance, so you can start here. Helena Ramsaroop reads it as a companion to Accidentally Engaged, and a StoryGraph reader enjoyed a cameo from Reena, that book's heroine. Farah Heron also says in her author's note that the story is a personal one.

If you want to read around it, Farah Heron's other romances reviewed on Eikna are:

  1. The Chai Factor
  2. Accidentally Engaged (2021)
  3. Kamila Knows Best (2022)
  4. Jana Goes Wild (2023)
  5. Just Playing House (2024)

Best format: print or ebook. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.

If You Loved Just Playing House, Read These Next

If you loved Just Playing House, try romances that mix fame, care and a hero who shows up when it matters.

Frequently Asked Questions

Just Playing House prompts a few common questions: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how it ends and how the mastectomy storyline is handled. Short answers below.

Is Just Playing House spicy?

Not very. Just Playing House is a 2 out of 5 on our scale, and Publishers Weekly notes that its sex scenes are closed door.

Is Just Playing House a standalone?

Yes. It is a complete standalone romance, with a cameo from Reena, the heroine of Accidentally Engaged.

Does Just Playing House have a happy ending?

Yes. Marley and Nik end the book together, and the story closes on a warm, hopeful note.

What is the medical storyline in Just Playing House?

Marley carries a cancer-linked gene and chooses a preventive double mastectomy with reconstruction. The book follows her surgery and recovery with care.

Who are the main characters in Just Playing House?

Marley Kamal, a personal shopper and stylist, and Nikhil Shamdasani, a rising actor and her former prom date.

The Bottom Line

Just Playing House earns a 7.3/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a gentle, closed-door romance with a caretaking hero, a thoughtful medical storyline and some sharp observations about fame and race. The one reason to pick it up is the recovery chapters: Farah Heron writes care as romance, and it works.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.