eikna romance
Menu

Accidentally Engaged by Farah Heron Review

Eikna Score: 7.6/10. Recommended.

Accidentally Engaged is a warm, hungry-making fake engagement romance about a Toronto bread baker, her meddling family and the neighbor her parents have already picked out for her. It is Farah Heron at her most confident, though the middle loses the couple to a job subplot and the ending ties up faster than its secrets deserve.

Read it if you love food romances, fake engagements and big, nosy families, or you want an East African Indian Muslim community written from the inside. Skip it if you need the hero's point of view, or rushed final reconciliations spoil a book for you.

Accidentally Engaged by Farah Heron book cover

Accidentally Engaged at a Glance

Accidentally Engaged is a standalone 2021 Forever romantic comedy by Farah Heron, set in Toronto. Reena Manji fakes an engagement with her new neighbor Nadim, the man her parents want her to marry, to enter a couples cooking contest. It has mild, mostly fade-to-black heat and ends happily.

AuthorFarah Heron
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreRomantic comedy, contemporary
Main tropesFake engagement, neighbors across the hall, parental matchmaking, cooking competition, forced proximity
Spice level2/5: Mild, fade to black
Content warningsEating disorder (secondary character), alcohol abuse, depression and anxiety, overbearing parents (full list below)
POVReena only
EndingHEA
Pages368 (trade paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Soneela Nankani (Hachette Audio)
First publishedMarch 2, 2021
PublisherForever, an imprint of Grand Central Publishing

What Is Accidentally Engaged About?

Accidentally Engaged follows Reena Manji, who works in finance, bakes sourdough on the side and is tired of her parents meddling in her love life. When a handsome new neighbor, Nadim, moves in across the hall, she is interested until she learns he works for her father and that their parents have more or less arranged for them to marry. That is the end of that, she decides.

Then Reena wants to enter a family cooking competition that needs a couple, and Nadim is available. A fake engagement gets them on the show. Cooking side by side, on camera and off, starts to make the arrangement feel less fake, while Nadim's past and the tangled business between their fathers threaten to come out.

What Makes This Fake Engagement Romance Work

Accidentally Engaged works because it gives the fake engagement a stage. A televised couples cooking contest turns every scene into a performance with an audience and a judge, and it lets the romance grow through something the two of them do with their hands. Publishers Weekly praised the chemistry on camera and off.

The food is the other hook. Kiki at Smart Bitches, Trashy Books gave it an A minus and said she could not stress enough how hungry the book makes you. Reena's bread, and the Indian and East African dishes of her family, are written with real love.

Underneath sits a family story about parents who push too hard and a daughter learning where she fits. Readers who like fake dating with an arranged-marriage twist will be well served.

My Review

Accidentally Engaged is the book where Farah Heron found her balance. The issues that crowd The Chai Factor are still here, family pressure, mental health, an eating disorder in the background, but they live inside a romantic comedy rather than on top of one. I finished it hungry and happy.

Publishers Weekly called it equally sweet and spicy and sure to leave readers smiling, and that is a fair summary. It was named among the best romances of 2021 by Entertainment Weekly, NPR and Vulture, and the praise is earned.

Romance and Chemistry

Reena and Nadim are adorable together in an everyday way, which is harder to write than big drama. They cook together, tease each other and show up for each other. Kiki at Smart Bitches singled out those small moments, and Llama Reads Books read the arc as friends to lovers as much as fake engagement. Courtney at Courtney Reads Romance also enjoyed the pairing.

The limitation is perspective. The book is told only by Reena, so Nadim's past arrives as a reveal rather than something we understand from inside, and Smart Bitches commenters found his handling frustrating. Melanie at Smexy Books confirmed the HEA but felt the reconciliation was rushed, and I agree. The final stretch resolves a lot very quickly.

The Characters

Reena is a great romantic comedy heroine: competent at work, gifted in the kitchen, insecure about her family's approval and prone to drinking more than she should when stressed. Smart Bitches praised her growth in how she relates to her family and culture, which is the real arc of the book.

The family is loud, funny and sometimes painful. The author's notes flag overbearing parents and depression, and Llama Reads Books noted a distant parent and an off-page parental death in the background. Reena's sister Saira and her preoccupation with health food are handled with care, though Smart Bitches felt that thread was never fully resolved.

The setting is specific in a way that makes the book feel lived in. Publishers Weekly praised its rich picture of Toronto's Indian Muslim community, and Smart Bitches noted the families' roots in India and Tanzania, which show up in the food, the gossip and the expectations Reena keeps bumping into. None of it is explained for an outside reader, and the book is better for that.

Writing and Pacing

Heron's prose is brisk and the dialogue snaps. The middle is the weak stretch: Smart Bitches noted the romance slides into the background while Reena's job search takes over, and I felt that sag too. The StoryGraph reader actually_juliette did not enjoy the book at all, while ratetheromance found the intimacy non-graphic but sensual and the whole thing charming. Kirkus praised Soneela Nankani's audiobook for its energy and distinct voices, and said she takes listeners "on an emotional roller-coaster ride."

Accidentally Engaged is a warm, funny fake engagement romance with food writing that will send you to the kitchen and a family worth meeting. Read it if you want a cosy rom-com with real cultural texture; skip it if you need both leads' voices and a slower, fuller ending.

How Spicy Is Accidentally Engaged?

Accidentally Engaged is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. Marie Landry at Ramblings of a Daydreamer describes the intimate scenes as closed door, and Smart Bitches readers described them as fade to black or a step beyond, but never very explicit. The StoryGraph reader ratetheromance called them non-graphic but sensual.

Content warnings, drawn from Farah Heron's own content notes and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Who Should Read Accidentally Engaged?

Accidentally Engaged suits readers who want a cosy fake engagement rom-com full of food, family and a cooking contest, with low heat. It is less suited to readers who want dual POV, explicit scenes or a slower ending.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Accidentally Engaged was one of 2021's most praised romances, with best-of nods from Entertainment Weekly, USA Today, NPR and Vulture and a positive Publishers Weekly review. Readers agree on the food and the chemistry and split on the second half.

Where they agree. The food, the families and the leads. Publishers Weekly praised the chemistry and the community, Smart Bitches gave it an A minus, and Llama Reads Books, Courtney Reads Romance and Peruse with Coffee all enjoyed the romance.

Where they split. The middle and the ending. Smart Bitches noted the romance fades during the job search, Smexy Books found the reconciliation rushed, commenters wanted more on Nadim's past, and actually_juliette on StoryGraph was not won over.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Accidentally Engaged scores 7.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with high marks for romance, characters and emotional impact, and lower marks for the middle stretch and a rushed ending.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Smart Bitches loves the everyday chemistry; PW praises it on camera and off.
Characters (15%)4Reena's growth with her family lands, per Smart Bitches; Nadim stays partly hidden.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Snappy dialogue and great food writing; the job-search middle sags.
Emotional impact (15%)4Family pressure and mental health add real weight, per the author's notes.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the warm, mostly fade-to-black heat readers describe.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A clear HEA, per Smexy Books, which finds the reconciliation rushed.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5The cooking contest and the food are a pleasure to revisit.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Accidentally Engaged is one of Farah Heron's strongest adult romances and a clear step up from The Chai Factor, with a final Eikna Score of 7.6/10.

Is Accidentally Engaged a Standalone?

Yes. Accidentally Engaged is a standalone with no required reading. It is also set in Toronto, like Farah Heron's debut The Chai Factor, but follows a different family. Heron's adult romances on Eikna:

Best format: the Soneela Nankani audiobook, which Kirkus praised, or print if you want to follow along with the food. Our series order guide has more.

If You Loved Accidentally Engaged, Read These Next

If you loved Accidentally Engaged, try romances with fake relationships, food and families that will not stay out of it.

Frequently Asked Questions

These are the most common questions about Accidentally Engaged.

Is Accidentally Engaged spicy?

Only mildly. Accidentally Engaged is a 2 out of 5 on our scale; readers describe the sex scenes as fade to black or close to it.

Is Accidentally Engaged a standalone?

Yes. Accidentally Engaged is a standalone and needs no other Farah Heron book.

Does Accidentally Engaged have a happy ending?

Yes. Reena and Nadim get a happily ever after, though some readers found the reconciliation rushed.

Is Accidentally Engaged dual POV?

No. Accidentally Engaged is told from Reena's point of view only.

Who narrates the Accidentally Engaged audiobook?

Soneela Nankani narrates the audiobook, and Kirkus praised her energetic performance.

What are the content warnings for Accidentally Engaged?

Farah Heron lists an eating disorder in a secondary character, alcohol abuse, overbearing parents, depression and anxiety.

The Bottom Line

Accidentally Engaged earns a 7.6/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a cosy, funny fake engagement romance with a cooking contest, a loud family and low heat. The one reason to pick it up is the food: Farah Heron writes bread the way other authors write kisses.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.