eikna romance
Menu

Let It Snow by John Green, Maureen Johnson and Lauren Myracle Review

Eikna Score: 7.5/10. Recommended.

Let It Snow is three linked YA holiday romances set in one snowbound town, and Maureen Johnson's opening story is so good it carries the whole book. The humour has aged unevenly since 2008, and the final story asks you to forgive a lot, but the clever way the three stories interlock still makes it a December favourite.

Read it if you want quick, funny, clean holiday romances for teens, or you enjoyed the Netflix film and want the original. Skip it if dated jokes about girls and weight will spoil the fun, or you want one romance told at full length.

Let It Snow by John Green, Maureen Johnson and Lauren Myracle book cover

Let It Snow at a Glance

Let It Snow: Three Holiday Romances is a young adult book of three interlinked stories by Maureen Johnson, John Green and Lauren Myracle, first published in 2008. A Christmas Eve blizzard strands a train in the small town of Gracetown, and over the next two days three teen romances overlap at a Waffle House, all kisses only and all ending happily.

AuthorsMaureen Johnson, John Green, Lauren Myracle
StoriesThe Jubilee Express (Johnson), A Cheertastic Christmas Miracle (Green), The Patron Saint of Pigs (Myracle)
SeriesStandalone (three linked stories)
SubgenreYoung adult romantic comedy (holiday, small town)
Main tropesSnowed in, strangers meet cute, friends to lovers, second chance, interlinked stories
Spice level1/5: Kisses only / closed door
Content warningsStrong language, underage drinking references, dated sexist and homophobic jokes (full list below)
POVFirst person; a different narrator for each story
EndingHappy for now for all three couples (YA)
Pages368 (movie tie-in paperback)
AudiobookThree narrators: Rebecca Soler, Brandon Gill and Ali Ahn (movie tie-in edition)
First published2008 (movie tie-in edition October 2019)
PublisherPenguin; ages 12 and up

What Is Let It Snow About?

Let It Snow takes place over a Christmas Eve blizzard in Gracetown, a small town where a train full of travellers gets stuck in the snow. The three stories happen at roughly the same time, and characters from each wander into the others.

What Makes This Holiday Anthology Work

Let It Snow works because the three stories are woven together rather than just bound together. A minor character in one story is the lead in another, a Waffle House is the hub, and the final story pulls every couple together. Common Sense Media described the romances as intersecting, predictable and believable, which is a fair summary of the pleasure.

Each author brings a distinct voice. Johnson is dry and funny, Green is fast and full of banter, and Myracle is chatty and emotional. Kirkus praised the humour and the strong characters, and Teen Book Review found all three stories funny and compulsively readable.

The snow does the plotting. Everyone is stuck, nobody can get where they planned to be, and the people they end up with are not the people they expected. It is the classic forced proximity setup scaled up to a whole town.

My Review

Let It Snow is a book I would hand to a fourteen year old in December with very little hesitation and a couple of caveats. It is light, quick and funny, and the structure is genuinely clever. It is also a 2008 book, and some of its jokes now land with a thud.

The ranking most readers arrive at is the right one: Johnson first, Green second, Myracle third. Heart Full of Books preferred Johnson's opener, Teen Book Review found Myracle's story slightly less buoyant, and StoryGraph readers praise the first story far more often than the last.

Romance and Chemistry

Jubilee and Stuart are the best couple in the book. Their romance happens over about a day, and critics have noted it can read as instant love, but Johnson makes the conversation so specific and funny that I believed it. Jubilee's slow realisation that her boyfriend Noah treats her badly is handled with a light touch.

Tobin and the Duke are a classic friends to lovers pair, and Green writes the banter of a long friendship well. The romance arrives late in the story, which makes it sweeter. Addie and Jeb are a second chance couple, and their story is the weakest because so much of it depends on Addie changing in a few hours. Heart Full of Books valued the final reunion but found Addie's self absorption and the reconciliation hard to accept, and I agree.

The Characters

Jubilee is the standout: wry, a little lost and good company. The Duke is a strong secondary lead, a girl who is one of the guys and knows it. Addie is the most divisive. Her story is about her learning to think about other people, which means we spend a long time with her when she is not thinking about anyone else.

The supporting cast is fun, from Stuart's hospitable family to Addie's coworkers at Starbucks, and the interlocking cameos are a big part of the charm.

Writing and Pacing

Each story moves fast, and the whole book reads in an evening. The prose is very much of its moment, and that is where the reservations come in. Adele Is Reading found the collection cute but uneven and less memorable afterwards, and flagged gender hostile remarks, the not like other girls framing and an exoticising description of a Cherokee character. Common Sense Media noted repeated homophobic phrasing and sexual banter. Some StoryGraph readers simply found the humour dated. None of this ruins the book, but it is noticeable, and younger readers may benefit from a conversation about it.

Let It Snow is a clever, fast and funny trio of linked YA holiday romances, with a standout opening story and some jokes that have not aged well. Read it if you want a clean, light December read for teens or adults, and go in knowing it is a 2008 book.

How Spicy Is Let It Snow?

Let It Snow is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. It is a young adult book for ages 12 and up, and Common Sense Media reports kisses without detail, references to past making out and some sexual banter, with no sex on the page.

For more at this level, see our closed door romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Content warnings, drawn from Common Sense Media, critics and reader reports:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Let It Snow?

Let It Snow suits teens and adults who want a quick, clean, funny holiday read with interlocking stories. It is less suited to readers sensitive to dated humour, or those who want a single, deeply developed romance.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Let It Snow was well reviewed on release and has become a perennial December pick, with a second wave of readers after the 2019 Netflix film. Today the reception is warm but more critical of its dated humour.

Where they agree. The structure and the first story. Kirkus credited all three authors and praised the humour and characters. Common Sense Media found the voices distinct and the resolutions safe. Teen Book Review called all three stories compulsively readable, and Heart Full of Books and many StoryGraph readers named The Jubilee Express their favourite.

Where they split. The third story and the humour. Heart Full of Books could not quite accept Addie's change or her reconciliation, and some StoryGraph readers agreed. Adele Is Reading found the book uneven and flagged sexist remarks and the description of a Cherokee character. Others on StoryGraph simply found it cosy and comforting, which is how it is mostly read.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Let It Snow scores 7.5 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard. Its best marks are for writing, heat fit, endings and reread appeal, and its weakest are for romance, characters and emotional impact, where the final story and dated humour hold it back.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Jubilee and Stuart charm; Heart Full of Books doubts the third reconciliation.
Characters (15%)3.5Strong voices, per Kirkus; Addie divides readers.
Writing and pacing (15%)4Fast and funny, per Teen Book Review; some humour has dated.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Light and cosy rather than moving; Adele Is Reading finds it less memorable.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the clean, kisses only YA romance it promises.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4Safe, happy resolutions that tie all three stories together, per Common Sense Media.
Reread appeal (10%)4A December reread for many readers; the cameos reward a second pass.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Let It Snow remains one of the defining YA holiday books, better structured than most anthologies but showing its age, with a final Eikna Score of 7.5/10.

Is Let It Snow a Standalone?

Let It Snow is a standalone book of three linked stories, with no sequel and no series. Read the stories in printed order: they can be read separately, but the final story pays off threads from the first two.

Best format: the audiobook uses a different narrator for each story (Rebecca Soler, Brandon Gill and Ali Ahn in the movie tie-in edition), which suits the shifting voices. In print, the movie tie-in paperback is widely available. Our series order guide covers longer series to try next.

Adaptation status: Netflix released a film adaptation of Let It Snow on November 8, 2019, directed by Luke Snellin, with Isabela Merced, Shameik Moore, Kiernan Shipka, Odeya Rush, Mitchell Hope, Liv Hewson, Jacob Batalon and Joan Cusack. The film reworks several characters and storylines, so the book is a different experience.

If You Loved Let It Snow, Read These Next

If you loved Let It Snow, look for YA holiday romances and collections with funny voices and snowy settings.

Frequently Asked Questions

Let It Snow raises the same few questions for most readers: who wrote what, what age it suits and how it compares with the film. Short answers below.

Who wrote each story in Let It Snow?

Maureen Johnson wrote The Jubilee Express, John Green wrote A Cheertastic Christmas Miracle, and Lauren Myracle wrote The Patron Saint of Pigs.

What age is Let It Snow appropriate for?

The publisher lists it for ages 12 and up. It has kisses only romance, but also strong language, underage drinking references and some dated sexist and homophobic jokes.

Is Let It Snow spicy?

No. It is a 1 out of 5 on our scale, with kisses and no sex on the page.

Do you have to read the Let It Snow stories in order?

It is best to. The stories are linked, and the last one brings characters from all three together.

Is the Let It Snow movie like the book?

Loosely. The 2019 Netflix film keeps the snowstorm, the Waffle House and several couples, but changes characters and storylines.

Is there a Let It Snow audiobook?

Yes. The movie tie-in audiobook uses three narrators, one per story: Rebecca Soler, Brandon Gill and Ali Ahn.

The Bottom Line

Let It Snow earns a 7.5/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for teens and adults who want a light, clean, funny holiday read that can be finished in one snowy evening. The one reason to pick it up is The Jubilee Express, a near perfect short romance about a girl, a stalled train and the stranger who invites her in from the cold.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.