My True Love Gave to Me Review
Eikna Score: 7.5/10. Recommended.
My True Love Gave to Me is a generous, mixed bag of twelve young adult holiday love stories, and its best entries by Rainbow Rowell, Gayle Forman, Matt de la Peña and Myra McEntire are worth the price on their own. The fantasy stories split readers sharply, and a few entries feel like sketches for longer books.
Read it if you want short, sweet YA romances to read one a night through December, or you want to sample a dozen big YA authors at once. Skip it if you want one sustained love story, or strange, dreamlike fantasy is not your thing.
My True Love Gave to Me at a Glance
My True Love Gave to Me: Twelve Holiday Stories is a young adult anthology edited by Stephanie Perkins and first published by St. Martin's in October 2014. Twelve authors each contribute one winter holiday romance, ranging from realistic New Year's Eve pining to Santa's workshop and a Krampus parade, all with kisses only content and hopeful endings.
| Editor | Stephanie Perkins |
|---|---|
| Contributors | Holly Black, Ally Carter, Matt de la Peña, Gayle Forman, Jenny Han, David Levithan, Kelly Link, Myra McEntire, Stephanie Perkins, Rainbow Rowell, Laini Taylor, Kiersten White |
| Series | Standalone anthology (Perkins later edited a summer companion) |
| Subgenre | Young adult contemporary and fantasy holiday romance |
| Main tropes | Snowed in, friends to lovers, meet cute, holiday magic, first love |
| Spice level | 1/5: Kisses only / closed door |
| Content warnings | Strong language, underage drinking, grief, poverty (full list below) |
| POV | Varies by story |
| Ending | Hopeful in every story; most are happy for now |
| Pages | 336 (paperback); 321 (first hardcover) |
| Audiobook | Listening Library, twelve narrators including Rebecca Lowman, Julia Whelan and Kim Mai Guest, about 12 hours 56 minutes |
| First published | October 14, 2014 (paperback October 2016) |
| Publisher | St. Martin's Press; paperback from St. Martin's Griffin |
What Is My True Love Gave to Me About?
My True Love Gave to Me collects twelve stories, each about a different pair of teenagers falling for each other somewhere around the winter holidays. There is no shared setting or frame. Instead, Stephanie Perkins asked a dozen popular young adult writers for one love story each and let them pick their holiday and their genre.
The result swings from the very real to the very strange. One story follows two kids across four New Year's Eve parties. Another is set on a near empty college campus at Hanukkah. Others take place at the North Pole, on a mysterious island and at a winter festival where Krampus walks the streets. The holidays covered include Christmas, Hanukkah, the Winter Solstice and New Year's.
What Makes This Holiday Anthology Work
My True Love Gave to Me works because it is a sampler, and a good sampler gives you a favourite you did not expect. Readers who come for Rainbow Rowell or Jenny Han often leave talking about Myra McEntire or Matt de la Peña. Kirkus praised the range of settings and the culturally specific protagonists, and the book does feel genuinely varied in who gets to fall in love.
The format suits the season. Twelve stories means one a night through the last stretch of December, and none of them asks for more than half an hour. Xpresso Reads found the stories satisfying in short sessions, and Publishers Weekly, quoted on Wikipedia, called the collection "a rare seasonal treat."
Not every entry is a romance in the usual sense. Several are about family, home or grief with a love interest at the edge. The Horn Book noted that the stories end hopefully, if not always happily, which is the honest promise: you get possibility, not twelve tidy weddings.
My Review
I read My True Love Gave to Me out of order, starting with the authors I knew and then circling back, and I would recommend the same. A front to back read gives the book an uneven rhythm, because the realistic stories and the fantasy stories are shuffled together and the shifts in tone can be jarring.
Here is how the twelve stories land for me, in the book's order, with notes on where critics and readers agree.
- "Midnights" by Rainbow Rowell: Mags and Noel across four New Year's Eves, from awkward strangers to something more. Short, funny and full of pining. Commas and Ampersands loved the pining here, and so did I. One of the best.
- "The Lady and the Fox" by Kelly Link: a strange, folkloric Christmas Eve story about a girl and a mysterious young man who appears in the snow. Beautiful and elusive; many readers, including Wonderfully Bookish, found it odd and in need of a reread.
- "Angels in the Snow" by Matt de la Peña: Shy, broke and stuck cat sitting in New York over Christmas, meets Haley from upstairs. Warm, grounded and good on money. A favourite.
- "Polaris Is Where You'll Find Me" by Jenny Han: a human girl raised by Santa at the North Pole wants to belong among the elves and has a crush on one of them. Sweet, a little sad, original.
- "It's a Yuletide Miracle, Charlie Brown" by Stephanie Perkins: Marigold, an aspiring animator, meets a boy selling Christmas trees. Fast and charming, with an ending that Perkins later continued in her summer anthology.
- "Your Temporary Santa" by David Levithan: a boy plays Santa for his boyfriend's family. Short, tender and the collection's queer romance. Some readers wanted more of it.
- "Krampuslauf" by Holly Black: a girl invites a mysterious guy to a Krampus party, and the night turns uncanny. Sharp, but readers unfamiliar with the folklore can feel lost.
- "What the Hell Have You Done, Sophie Roth?" by Gayle Forman: a lonely Jewish girl at a remote college gets an unexpected Hanukkah with a boy named Russell. Funny, sarcastic and one of the strongest.
- "Beer Buckets and Baby Jesus" by Myra McEntire: a troublemaker serving community service on a church nativity play, where everything goes wrong. The comic highlight of the book.
- "Welcome to Christmas, CA" by Kiersten White: a small town called Christmas, too small for most maps, where a newcomer shakes things up. Quiet, family centred and very festive.
- "Star of Bethlehem" by Ally Carter: a girl gives away her plane ticket and lands somewhere she never planned to spend Christmas. The twist is clever, but several readers found it confusing.
- "The Girl Who Woke the Dreamer" by Laini Taylor: a lush fantasy on an island with its own gods and rules. Gorgeous to Taylor fans, baffling to others. It closes the book on its strangest note.
Romance and Chemistry
The romances are short by necessity, and the best ones know it. Rowell spreads hers over four years so the attraction has time. De la Peña and Forman confine theirs to a day or two and focus on conversation. The weaker ones rush from meeting to devotion in a few pages, and a StoryGraph reader complained about exactly that compressed, instant romance. It is a fair hit on maybe a third of the book.
The Characters
The characters are where the collection is strongest. Commas and Ampersands praised how efficiently the authors sketch people, and the range is real: a Latino boy short on money, a Jewish girl far from home, a Korean girl at the North Pole, a gay couple, kids from small towns and big cities. The Horn Book highlighted that variety of race, sexuality and background as a strength of the book.
Writing and Pacing
The writing is consistently professional and occasionally excellent. The pacing is the issue. Stay Bookish found some stories flat, confusing or dragging, A Bookish Escape found substantial unevenness in romance pacing and endings, and The Great Book Wyrm thought the holiday frame felt forced in places and several entries forgettable. I agree that four or five stories would not survive on their own. That still leaves seven or eight good ones, which is a strong rate for an anthology.
My True Love Gave to Me is an uneven but generous YA holiday anthology whose best stories are small gems. Read it if you want a story a night through December and can skip past the ones that do not land for you.
How Spicy Is My True Love Gave to Me?
My True Love Gave to Me is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. This is a young adult anthology with teenage leads, and the romance stays at crushes, conversations, hand holding and kisses. Audiobook Accomplice described the content as hugs and kisses, with sweetness varying by story.
Junior Library Guild notes mild sexual themes in a few stories, but nothing is described on the page. For more at this level, see our closed door romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Content warnings, drawn from Junior Library Guild notes, critics and reader reports:
- Strong language
- Underage drinking and substance use
- Grief and family loss
- Poverty and financial hardship
- Bullying and family conflict
- A parent in prison (one story)
- Sexual harassment and cheating (individual stories)
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read My True Love Gave to Me?
My True Love Gave to Me suits teen and adult readers who want short, clean holiday love stories and enjoy discovering new authors. It is less suited to readers who want a single romance with depth, or who dislike genre switching between realism and fantasy.
Best for:
- Teens and adults who like sweet YA romance
- Readers who want a story a night through December
- Fans of Rainbow Rowell, Stephanie Perkins or Gayle Forman
- Anyone looking for varied holidays and diverse leads
- Audiobook listeners who enjoy a different narrator per story
Not for:
- Readers who want adult heat or long romances
- Anyone who dislikes surreal or folkloric fantasy
- Readers frustrated by open or abrupt endings
- Those who want every story to be a standout
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
My True Love Gave to Me was warmly received by trade reviewers and remains a perennial December pick, while bloggers and readers are far more divided story by story. Ellen Hopkins, reviewing for The New York Times Book Review, praised its diverse characters and smart storytelling.
Where they agree. The range and the best stories. Kirkus praised the settings and culturally specific protagonists and noted both M/F and M/M couples. Publishers Weekly valued the mix of cozy realism and speculative stories. Stay Bookish, Commas and Ampersands and Wonderfully Bookish all named Forman, Rowell and de la Peña among their favourites, and McEntire's comic story comes up again and again.
Where they split. The fantasy and the endings. Link's and Taylor's stories delight some readers and baffle others. A Bookish Escape and The Great Book Wyrm found the collection uneven, with forgettable entries and a forced holiday theme. Commas and Ampersands found one ending abruptly incomplete. Audiobook Accomplice, on the other hand, praised the twelve narrators and the varied sweetness.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
My True Love Gave to Me scores 7.5 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard. Its strongest marks are for characters, writing and heat fit, and its weakest are for romance and endings, which several reviewers found compressed or abrupt.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Some lovely slow pining; a StoryGraph reader finds other romances rushed. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Diverse, efficiently drawn leads, praised by Kirkus and The Horn Book. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4 | Strong authors throughout; A Bookish Escape notes uneven pacing. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | A handful of stories really land; others are forgettable, per The Great Book Wyrm. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4 | Delivers the sweet, kisses only YA romance it promises. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | Hopeful endings, per The Horn Book; some feel abrupt. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 4 | Easy to dip back into for favourite stories every December. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: My True Love Gave to Me is one of the best known YA holiday anthologies and stronger than most, though uneven by nature, with a final Eikna Score of 7.5/10.
Is My True Love Gave to Me a Standalone?
My True Love Gave to Me is a standalone anthology, and every story can be read on its own in any order. Stephanie Perkins later edited a companion, Summer Days and Summer Nights (2016), which includes a continuation of her own story about Marigold.
Best format: the Listening Library audiobook gives each story its own narrator, which suits an anthology well and makes the shifts in tone feel deliberate. In print, the paperback is easy to find and easy to read one story a night. Our series order guide covers longer series if you want something to follow it.
If You Loved My True Love Gave to Me, Read These Next
If you loved My True Love Gave to Me, look for YA holiday romances and other collections with short, sweet love stories.
- Let It Snow by John Green, Maureen Johnson and Lauren Myracle: three linked YA holiday romances in one snowed in town.
- Dash & Lily's Book of Dares by Rachel Cohn and David Levithan: a notebook of dares passed around New York at Christmas, with more of Levithan's warmth.
- Tweet Cute by Emma Lord: a funny YA rivals romance with anonymous messaging and family businesses.
- Recommended for You by Laura Silverman: a YA bookstore rivals romance set over one hectic Hanukkah and Christmas week.
- Make the Yuletide Gay by Ivy L. James: a queer holiday romance for readers who loved Levithan's story most.
Frequently Asked Questions
My True Love Gave to Me raises the same questions for most readers: who wrote what, whether it suits teens and whether any of the stories continue. Short answers below.
Who wrote the stories in My True Love Gave to Me?
Twelve authors: Rainbow Rowell, Kelly Link, Matt de la Peña, Jenny Han, Stephanie Perkins, David Levithan, Holly Black, Gayle Forman, Myra McEntire, Kiersten White, Ally Carter and Laini Taylor. Perkins also edited the collection.
Is My True Love Gave to Me appropriate for teens?
Yes. It is a young adult anthology with kisses only romance. Some stories include strong language and underage drinking, so it suits young teens and up.
Is My True Love Gave to Me spicy?
No. It is a 1 out of 5 on our scale, with crushes, hugs and kisses and nothing explicit.
What holidays are in My True Love Gave to Me?
Mostly Christmas, plus Hanukkah, New Year's Eve, the Winter Solstice and a Krampus festival.
Is there an LGBTQ story in My True Love Gave to Me?
Yes. David Levithan's "Your Temporary Santa" is about a boy and his boyfriend at Christmas.
Is there a sequel to My True Love Gave to Me?
Yes, in a sense. Stephanie Perkins edited a summer companion, Summer Days and Summer Nights, which continues her own Marigold story.
Is there a My True Love Gave to Me audiobook?
Yes. Listening Library published an audiobook with a different narrator for each of the twelve stories.
The Bottom Line
My True Love Gave to Me earns a 7.5/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers of any age who want sweet, short holiday love stories and like discovering authors they would not otherwise pick up. The one reason to pick it up is the handful of stories, Rowell's, Forman's, de la Peña's and McEntire's above all, that are as good as anything these writers have done at full length.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- My True Love Gave to Me, Wikipedia (story list, publication, Publishers Weekly and New York Times reception)
- Review of My True Love Gave to Me, The Horn Book
- My True Love Gave to Me audiobook, Audible (narrators)
- My True Love Gave to Me review, Wonderfully Bookish
- Kirkus Reviews and Junior Library Guild notes on My True Love Gave to Me
- Reviews by Stay Bookish, Commas and Ampersands, Xpresso Reads, A Bookish Escape, The Great Book Wyrm, Use Your Words and Audiobook Accomplice
- StoryGraph reader reviews
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.