eikna romance
Menu

Recommended for You by Laura Silverman Review

Eikna Score: 6.7/10. Recommended with reservations.

Recommended for You is a cheerful, bookish YA rom com with a Jewish heroine, a mall bookstore and a sales contest, and it is at its best when the bookstore staff are on the page together. The rivals to lovers turn comes too fast for one crowded week, and the ending ties up nearly everything a little too neatly.

Read it if you want a light holiday YA romance set in a bookstore, or you are looking for Jewish teen characters in a contemporary story. Skip it if you need a slow, convincing shift from rivals to sweethearts, or tidy endings bother you.

Recommended for You by Laura Silverman book cover

Recommended for You at a Glance

Recommended for You is a standalone young adult romantic comedy by Laura Silverman, published by Margaret K. McElderry Books in September 2020. It follows two Jewish teens competing for a holiday sales bonus at an independent bookstore, with kisses only romance and a happy, hopeful ending.

AuthorLaura Silverman
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreYoung adult romantic comedy (holiday, workplace)
Main tropesRivals to lovers (enemies to lovers lite), coworkers, bookstore setting, holiday rush, found family at work
Spice level1/5: Kisses only / closed door
Content warningsParents fighting and discussing divorce, an absent parent, money worries (full list below)
POVFirst person, Shoshanna
EndingHappy for now (YA)
Pages288 (paperback); 272 (hardcover)
AudiobookNarrated by Emily Lawrence, about 7 hours (Tantor Media)
First publishedSeptember 1, 2020 (paperback September 2021)
PublisherMargaret K. McElderry Books (Simon & Schuster); ages 12 and up

What Is Recommended for You About?

Recommended for You follows Shoshanna Greenberg, a teenager who loves her job at Once Upon, an independent bookstore in a Georgia shopping mall. The rest of her life is less lovable. Her two moms are fighting, money is tight and her car is barely running.

Then the store announces a holiday bonus for whoever sells the most books, and Shoshanna sees a way to fix at least one problem. The catch is Jake Kaplan, the new hire, who is annoyingly good at selling and, inconveniently, cute. The story opens on the last night of Hanukkah and runs through one chaotic week of Christmas shopping.

What Makes This Rivals to Lovers Romance Work

Recommended for You works because its rivals to lovers setup has real stakes for a teenager. Shoshanna does not want the bonus for fun; she wants it because it is the one thing in her life she can control. That makes her prickliness toward Jake understandable even when she is being unfair.

The bookstore does the rest. BookPage, in a starred review, called the book a whipped cream dollop of a rom com with an irresistible bookish setup, and that is a good description of the appeal. There are recommendations, displays, demanding customers, a mall Santa and a crowded food court. Kirkus noted the frequent references to favourite books, which will please bookish readers.

It is also a Jewish holiday rom com in a genre dominated by Christmas. Emily Schneider at the Jewish Book Council praised the bookstore comedy and the convincing bond between Shoshanna and Jake, and Kirkus singled out the contemporary Jewish representation as a strength.

My Review

Recommended for You is a pleasant book, and I mean that more warmly than Kirkus did when it used the phrase "perfectly pleasant." It is a quick, funny read with a lot of heart in its bookstore scenes. It also tries to fit a romance, a family crisis, a friendship arc, a car breaking down and a sales contest into about a week, and something had to give.

What gave was the romance. Abby Petree at The Young Folks objected to the overloaded one week timeline and felt the shift from rivals to love came too fast, and I agree. I liked Jake. I liked Shoshanna. I did not fully believe the speed.

Romance and Chemistry

The romance is sweet and the banter is good. Jake is kind and steady, he bakes, and he takes Shoshanna's competitiveness in stride. The Reading Book Fairy liked the rival coworker chemistry and especially the apologies, and that is a fair highlight: both characters say sorry and mean it, which is rarer in YA rom coms than it should be.

The problem is that Shoshanna spends a lot of the week actively hostile, and the turn to romance does not get enough room. A StoryGraph reader, sj_elli, found some of the conflicts unconvincing, and another, littlecornerreads, rejected the romantic development entirely. I land in the middle: enjoyable, not earned.

The Characters

Shoshanna is the book's engine. She is impulsive, loud, bookish and frequently wrong, and Abby Petree at The Young Folks found her believably mistaken rather than unlikeable. That is the right read. Readers who like a heroine with flaws will enjoy her; readers who need a likeable narrator may not.

The supporting cast is where opinions split. Kirkus found the secondary characters underdeveloped, though respectfully drawn, including Shoshanna's friends Geraldine and Cheyenne and a pair of goth coworkers. BookPage, on the other hand, loved the bookstore staff as a lively ensemble. I side with BookPage on the staff and with Kirkus on the friends. The family storyline about her moms is handled with care, and kristenreadswhat on StoryGraph enjoyed the family dynamics as much as the romance.

Writing and Pacing

Silverman writes snappy dialogue, as Kirkus noted, and the book reads fast. The opening is slower than it needs to be, which sj_elli also mentioned, and the final stretch resolves almost every problem at once. Kirkus called the endings implausibly happy almost all around, and Rachel J. Fremmer at the Sydney Taylor Shmooze described a mostly happy ending. That will be exactly right for some readers in December and too easy for others.

Some reviewers also questioned the representation. Emily Schneider wondered about the consistency of some Jewish cultural details, and Rachel Fremmer asked whether some of the diversity felt fully integrated. A couple of StoryGraph readers flagged moments of antisemitism and ableism in the text, which the story does not always examine.

Recommended for You is a fun, fast YA bookstore rom com whose romance moves too quickly and whose ending is a little too neat. Read it if you want a cheerful holiday read with Jewish leads and a great bookstore setting, and lower your expectations for the slow burn.

How Spicy Is Recommended for You?

Recommended for You is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. It is a young adult novel published for ages 12 and up, and the romance stays at banter, growing feelings and kisses.

No reviewer reports any sexual content. For more at this level, see our closed door romance list, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Content warnings, drawn from critics and reader reports:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Recommended for You?

Recommended for You suits teens and adults who want a light, bookish holiday rom com with Jewish characters and a workplace rivalry. It is less suited to readers who want a slow developing romance, a deep supporting cast or a realistic ending.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Recommended for You received a starred review from BookPage and a positive but measured review from Kirkus, with bloggers and readers ranging from delighted to unconvinced. Most agree on the bookstore and split on the romance.

Where they agree. The setting and the representation. BookPage praised the bookish premise, the funny staff and the use of the mall. Kirkus praised the snappy dialogue and Jewish representation, and the Jewish Book Council found the bookstore comedy and the central bond convincing. The Reading Book Fairy liked the growth and Jake's kindness.

Where they split. The pace and the ending. The Young Folks found the timeline overloaded and the romance too fast. Kirkus thought the endings implausibly happy, and The Reading Book Fairy found the story slight. On StoryGraph, kristenreadswhat called it fun rather than exceptional, while littlecornerreads disliked the characterisation, dialogue and pop culture references.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Recommended for You scores 6.7 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard. Its best mark is for delivering the clean, sweet YA romance it promises, and its weakest are for characters, emotional impact and reread appeal, where reviewers found the cast thin and the story slight.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Sweet banter and real apologies; The Young Folks finds the turn too fast.
Characters (15%)3A vivid heroine but underdeveloped friends, per Kirkus.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Snappy dialogue per Kirkus; a slow start and crowded week.
Emotional impact (15%)3The family story touches; The Reading Book Fairy finds the book slight.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers exactly the clean YA romance it promises.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5Happy and festive, but Kirkus calls it implausibly tidy.
Reread appeal (10%)3A pleasant one time holiday read rather than a yearly ritual.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Recommended for You sits in the middle of the YA holiday rom com shelf, warmer than many and less memorable than the best, with a final Eikna Score of 6.7/10.

Is Recommended for You a Standalone?

Recommended for You is a standalone novel with no series and no required reading. Laura Silverman's other YA novels are separate stories, so you can start here.

Best format: the Tantor Media audiobook, narrated by Emily Lawrence and running about seven hours, suits a dialogue driven, first person story. The paperback is the easiest print edition to find. Our series order guide covers longer series if you want one next.

If You Loved Recommended for You, Read These Next

If you loved Recommended for You, look for YA rom coms with rivals, holiday settings and bookish or family business backdrops.

Frequently Asked Questions

Recommended for You raises a few common questions about age range, holidays and how the romance ends. Short answers below.

What age is Recommended for You for?

The publisher lists it for ages 12 and up, and Kirkus suggests ages 12 to 16. It has kisses only romance and no sexual content.

Is Recommended for You a Hanukkah book?

Partly. It opens on the last night of Hanukkah and follows Jewish leads through the Christmas shopping rush at a bookstore.

Is Recommended for You enemies to lovers?

It is closer to rivals to lovers. Shoshanna and Jake compete for a holiday sales bonus at work, and the rivalry turns into romance over one week.

Does Recommended for You have a happy ending?

Yes. Reviewers describe a happy, mostly tidy ending for the couple and the family storylines.

Is there a Recommended for You audiobook?

Yes. Tantor Media published an audiobook narrated by Emily Lawrence that runs about seven hours.

Where is Recommended for You set?

It is set at Once Upon, an independent bookstore inside a shopping mall in Georgia.

The Bottom Line

Recommended for You earns a 6.7/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a quick, cheerful, clean holiday rom com with Jewish leads and a bookstore full of personality. The one reason to pick it up is Once Upon itself: a mall bookstore in December, staffed by people who love books and drawn with enough affection that you will want to work a shift there.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.