eikna romance
Menu

P.S. I Loathe You by Isla Olsen Review

Eikna Score: 6.7/10. Recommended with reservations.

P.S. I Loathe You is a quick, snarky MM enemies to lovers romp in which two men who despise each other in person fall for each other by anonymous email. The banter and the heat are the draw; the feud itself is thin and the leads, both in their late thirties, often bicker like teenagers.

Read it if you want a short, steamy hate-to-love rom-com with an online identity mix-up, or you like couples who keep insulting each other after they fall into bed. Skip it if petty grown men wear on you fast, or you need the emotional side of a romance to keep pace with the physical one.

P.S. I Loathe You by Isla Olsen book cover

P.S. I Loathe You at a Glance

P.S. I Loathe You is a standalone contemporary MM romantic comedy by indie author Isla Olsen, published by her own Moonwalker Press in July 2022. Wes and Devon, the man who nearly married Wes's sister, hate each other in person and flirt by anonymous email. The book runs about 278 pages and ends with a guaranteed happily ever after.

AuthorIsla Olsen
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreMM romance, romantic comedy (contemporary)
Main tropesEnemies to lovers, sister's ex, anonymous pen pals, opposites attract, hate sex
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsExplicit sex, casual approach to condoms, pregnancy and infertility talk (full list below)
POVDual, Wes and Devon
EndingHEA
PagesAbout 278
AudiobookNarrated by Gary Furlong, about 5 hours 15 minutes (Moonwalker Press)
First publishedJuly 25, 2022
PublisherMoonwalker Press (independent); ebook in Kindle Unlimited at launch

What Is P.S. I Loathe You About?

P.S. I Loathe You starts with a cancelled wedding. Wes's sister called off her engagement to Devon Montgomery two weeks before the big day, and Wes thinks it is the best decision she ever made. In his view Devon is an overbearing, uptight snob, and Wes is relieved he will never have to sit across a family table from him again.

The feeling is mutual. What neither man knows is that the stranger he has been trading snarky emails with, and slowly flirting with, is the other one. Meanwhile they keep running into each other in person, the sniping keeps turning into something hotter, and the online friendship and the real-life feud are headed for a collision.

What Makes This Enemies to Lovers Romance Work

P.S. I Loathe You works because it gives the enemies to lovers trope two channels at once. In person, Wes and Devon can only fight. Online, without names attached, they can be curious, kind and funny with each other. Readers get to watch the same two men be terrible and lovely in alternating scenes, and wait for the moment they connect the dots.

The book is also built for readers who like the hate in hate sex. Olsen's own blurb promises hate-sex fantasies and plenty of heat, and MM Romance Reviewed's Jacquie loved that the teasing does not stop once the pair start sleeping together. If you have read Rule Breaker or Heated Rivalry and wanted something lighter and shorter in the same spirit, this is that book.

And it is short. At around 278 pages and just over five hours on audio, it is a one or two sitting read, which suits a premise this simple.

My Review

I liked P.S. I Loathe You most when it was being rude. The email exchanges are the best thing in it: sharp, quick and properly funny, and the scenes where Wes and Devon snipe at each other in public have real comic timing. I liked it least when it asked me to believe these two men are in their late thirties. The feud runs on very little, and the book never quite earns the hatred it advertises.

Romance and Chemistry

The physical chemistry is the strongest part of the romance. Jacquie at MM Romance Reviewed described it as a fast burn on the heat and a slower burn on the feelings, and that is exactly the shape: the two men are in bed well before they are honest with each other. I did not mind that. The anonymous emails carry the emotional load, so by the time the sex starts you already know they like each other, even if they do not.

The problem is the other half of the equation. Larissa at Love Bytes, who gave it 3 hearts, found the animosity childish, and I see why. Devon's crime is mostly being stiff and posh, and Wes's is being a slob who enjoys winding him up. That is a squabble, not a feud. When the real stakes arrive, they are about pride and family awkwardness rather than anything either man did, which keeps the book light but also keeps it small.

The Characters

Wes is the louder narrator, and the funnier one. Devon gets the better arc, because the emails let us see a warm, lonely man under the starch, and SNik at MM Romance Reviewed was right that the supporting best friends do a lot of good work around them. The sister situation, which could have been excruciating, is handled more gently than I expected.

Still, the leads did not stay with me. Julchen at the German blog Liebesromane lesen said almost exactly that: she enjoyed the dialogue and the slow turn from dislike to love, but the characters left no lasting impression. SNik, who rated it 4.5 stars, flagged the same thing I kept noticing, which is that two men pushing forty act like they are nineteen. Some of that is the joke. Some of it is just immaturity.

Writing and Pacing

Olsen writes clean, breezy rom-com prose, and the dual POV keeps things moving. There is very little padding, and the ending skips the manufactured last-act drama that sinks a lot of indie romance, which Julchen also praised. The email device is used well, with enough near misses to be fun and not so many that it gets silly.

My one real complaint about the writing is a choice rather than a sentence. A conversation about skipping condoms is handled very casually. Larissa called the portrayal of safe sex unacceptable, and Julchen found it questionable too. It is a small scene, but it jarred me out of an otherwise easy read.

P.S. I Loathe You is a fun, filthy, forgettable hate-to-love rom-com with great emails and a feud that never feels real. Read it on a lazy afternoon if you want snark and heat; skip it if you need your enemies to have a reason.

How Spicy Is P.S. I Loathe You?

P.S. I Loathe You is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The author's blurb promises a ton of sex, and it delivers, with on-page scenes that lean into the hate-sex dynamic and keep the insults going. Sex arrives early and drives a lot of the middle of the book, which one StoryGraph reader felt crowded out the relationship.

Everything is between consenting adults, and the bickering is mutual and playful rather than cruel. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reports and our own read:

A StoryGraph reader reported no cheating. Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read P.S. I Loathe You?

P.S. I Loathe You suits readers who want a short, steamy MM enemies to lovers comedy with an anonymous pen pal twist and a guaranteed happy ending. It is less suited to readers who want a feud with real stakes, slow emotional development or adults who behave like adults.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

P.S. I Loathe You is an indie release, so most coverage comes from reader reviews and MM review blogs rather than trade magazines. On Goodreads it averages a little over 4 stars from several thousand ratings, which is strong for a self-published standalone.

Where they agree. The banter and the heat. MM Romance Reviewed's three reviewers all praised the snark; Heather called it a hilarious, steamy enemies to lovers story that does not take itself too seriously. StoryGraph reader svjak gave it 3.75 stars and liked watching both men question their assumptions about each other.

Where they split. Depth and maturity. Love Bytes' Larissa found the hatred childish and the safe-sex handling a real misstep. Julchen at Liebesromane lesen liked it but forgot the characters quickly. Lower-rated StoryGraph reviews question the emotional depth and how natural the dialogue is, and at least one reader stopped about halfway, feeling the relationship was mostly sex.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

P.S. I Loathe You scores 6.7 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for heat and banter, and lower marks for characters and emotional impact that never go very deep.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Great emails and fast-burn heat, per MM Romance Reviewed; the feud itself is thin.
Characters (15%)3Devon has a real arc, but Liebesromane lesen found the leads forgettable.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Breezy dual POV with little padding; the condom scene jars.
Emotional impact (15%)3Light and low-angst; Love Bytes did not connect with the leads.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the steamy hate sex the blurb promises.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A guaranteed HEA without forced last-act drama, per Liebesromane lesen.
Reread appeal (10%)3Fun once, but short on scenes you would go back for.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: P.S. I Loathe You is a solid mid-tier entry in Isla Olsen's catalogue and a light pick in indie MM enemies to lovers, landing at a final Eikna Score of 6.7/10.

Is P.S. I Loathe You a Standalone?

P.S. I Loathe You is a true standalone. Olsen bills it as a stand-alone romantic comedy, it is not part of any of her series, and you do not need to have read anything else by her first.

If you like it, Olsen has several longer-running MM series, including Love & Luck and Suits and Sevens, each following a different couple. Best format: ebook, since the email exchanges read best on a page, though Gary Furlong's audiobook is a quick listen at just over five hours. Our series order guide covers connected romances.

If You Loved P.S. I Loathe You, Read These Next

If you loved P.S. I Loathe You, look for MM romances where rivals hide their feelings behind insults, aliases or a very public feud.

Frequently Asked Questions

P.S. I Loathe You prompts the same handful of questions: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how it ends and whether there is an audiobook. Short answers below.

Is P.S. I Loathe You spicy?

Yes. P.S. I Loathe You is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with multiple explicit scenes and a lot of hate sex.

Is P.S. I Loathe You a standalone?

Yes. Isla Olsen published it as a stand-alone romantic comedy, and it is not part of a series.

Does P.S. I Loathe You have a happy ending?

Yes. P.S. I Loathe You ends with a happily ever after for Wes and Devon, and the author guarantees it in the blurb.

Who is Devon in P.S. I Loathe You?

Devon Montgomery is the ex-fiance of Wes's sister, who called off their wedding two weeks before it was due to happen.

How old are Wes and Devon?

Both leads are adults in their late thirties, according to MM Romance Reviewed.

Is there a P.S. I Loathe You audiobook?

Yes. Moonwalker Press released an audiobook narrated by Gary Furlong, running about 5 hours 15 minutes.

How long is P.S. I Loathe You?

About 278 pages, so most readers finish it in one or two sittings.

The Bottom Line

P.S. I Loathe You earns a 6.7/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a short, steamy MM rom-com where two grown men insult each other in person and fall in love by email, and who will forgive a thin feud and some childish behavior for the payoff. The reason to pick it up is the emails: anonymous, snippy and sweet, they do the romantic heavy lifting the in-person scenes skip.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.