eikna romance
Menu

The Dating Experiment by Briar Prescott Review

Eikna Score: 7.6/10. Recommended.

The Dating Experiment is a funny, warm MM boss and assistant romance in which a lawyer and the PA who dreads him fall for each other through an anonymous word game, without knowing who is on the other end. The texting is a delight and the chemistry is real; the 13-year age gap and workplace power imbalance are there on the page, and the last act reaches for a grand gesture that does not quite fit.

Read it if you love mistaken identity, pen pals who are secretly enemies, or a buttoned-up boss who softens. Skip it if a boss and employee age gap is a hard no, or early scenes of a boss belittling his assistant will put you off.

The Dating Experiment by Briar Prescott book cover

The Dating Experiment at a Glance

The Dating Experiment is book 2 of Briar Prescott's Better With You series, a self-published MM contemporary romance released in July 2021. Lawyer Connor Quinn and his personal assistant Jamie, who are 13 years apart, bond online under aliases before learning the truth. It runs 280 pages, has moderate heat and ends with a happily ever after.

AuthorBriar Prescott
SeriesBetter With You, book 2 (a new couple; works as a standalone)
SubgenreMM romance, romantic comedy (contemporary, workplace)
Main tropesBoss and assistant, secret identity pen pals, enemies to lovers, age gap, grumpy and sunshine
Spice level3/5: Moderate, some open door
Content warningsWorkplace power imbalance, 13-year age gap, belittling boss, grief (full list below)
POVDual, Jamie and Connor (mostly Jamie in the first half)
EndingHEA, with an epilogue set seven years later
Pages280 (paperback)
AudiobookNo audiobook edition found
First publishedJuly 2021
PublisherSelf-published

What Is The Dating Experiment About?

The Dating Experiment starts with a grandfather's last request. After his grandfather dies, Jamie is left an old phone and a letter asking him to finish one final game of Words With Friends with his grandfather's longtime opponent, a player called Seb.

Jamie does, and keeps playing, and soon he and Seb are chatting every night. Seb is funny, a little lonely and easy to talk to. Jamie's daytime life is less fun: for three years he has been personal assistant to Connor Quinn, a workaholic lawyer who is cold, demanding and impossible to please. Then the two pen pals decide to meet, and Jamie finds out exactly who Seb is. What comes next is an arrangement they agree to call an experiment, definitely not dating.

What Makes This Secret Identity Romance Work

The Dating Experiment works because readers get to love Connor twice. In the office he is the boss from hell; in the chat window he is Seb, who is witty, attentive and plainly starved for company. The book lets you watch Jamie fall for a man he already cannot stand, and wait for the moment the two halves meet.

The texts are the hook within the hook. Valerie at Love Bytes loved the anonymous exchanges between "J" and "Seb," and Caz Owens at All About Romance singled out the epistolary sections as a highlight. They are quick, playful and very funny.

If you liked the boss and PA warfare of Rule Breaker, this is the softer, sillier cousin. And if you read The Happy List, Connor's brother Gray and his boyfriend Kai turn up as supporting characters.

My Review

The Dating Experiment had me grinning at the text exchanges within a few chapters. Briar Prescott has a light touch with banter, and the word game setup gives the romance a sweetness that the office scenes badly need. I liked the book a lot. I did not love the way it ends, and I wanted more of the relationship shown rather than summarized.

Romance and Chemistry

Connor and Jamie have real chemistry, both online and off. Caz Owens called them a couple she liked a great deal, and the dynamic is a good one: Jamie makes Connor feel seen and pulls him out of his shell, while Connor pushes Jamie to take his own ambitions seriously. That mutual push is what makes this more than a boss fantasy.

The power imbalance is real, though. Connor is Jamie's boss and 13 years older, and in the early chapters he is genuinely belittling. One StoryGraph reader stopped at about 30 percent because those office scenes felt hostile, and I understand it. Once the truth about Seb comes out, the relationship gets much warmer, but you have to sit through some cold treatment first.

My bigger complaint is the experiment itself. Caz found it hard to tell apart from ordinary dating, and a lot of their time together is told rather than shown. I wanted more scenes and fewer summaries.

The Characters

Jamie is easy to love: warm, funny, grieving his grandfather and a little stuck in his own life. Connor is the better character, because the gap between the office tyrant and the lonely man behind Seb gives him somewhere to go. Watching him try to be spontaneous is often very funny.

The side cast is a mixed bag. Valerie praised the well-developed supporting characters, and I enjoyed the cameo from Gray and Kai, but Caz felt that Jamie's best friends Max and Anders sound like Jamie, and an old flame of Connor's who stirs up trouble late on felt unnecessary to her and to me.

Writing and Pacing

Prescott writes clean, funny prose and the book moves quickly. The first half sits mostly in Jamie's point of view, which Caz found odd, since Connor's voice is distinctive enough that you guess Seb's identity right away. That is fair, but dramatic irony is half the fun here.

The ending is where the book wobbles. The public grand gesture is big, romantic and, to Caz, out of character for Connor; Valerie, by contrast, loved it. The epilogue then jumps seven years ahead, which Valerie found sweet but too far. I land in the middle: the gesture made me smile and made me wince, about equally.

The Dating Experiment is a sweet, funny MM secret identity romance with charming texts, a real age gap and an ending that tries a little too hard. Read it if you love pen pals and softened bosses; skip it if workplace power imbalance is a dealbreaker.

How Spicy Is The Dating Experiment?

The Dating Experiment is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. All About Romance rated it warm, and the book includes on-page intimacy, with a phone sex scene that Love Bytes' Valerie singled out as especially hot. Caz Owens noted that much of their time in bed is summarized rather than shown.

Both men are adults, with Connor 13 years older than Jamie and his direct boss. The relationship is consensual, but the boss and employee dynamic and the early belittling are worth knowing about. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from critic and reader reports and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read The Dating Experiment?

The Dating Experiment suits readers who want a low-angst, funny MM workplace romance with a secret identity twist, a softening grump and moderate heat. It is less suited to readers who avoid boss and employee romances, age gaps or a cold hero in the early chapters.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Dating Experiment is self-published, so most of its coverage comes from reader reviews and MM review blogs rather than trade magazines. The two longest reviews, from Love Bytes and All About Romance, are both positive with reservations about the ending.

Where they agree. The texting and the chemistry. Valerie at Love Bytes gave it 5 hearts and called it near perfection, praising the mistaken identity twist and the humor. Caz Owens at All About Romance gave it a B, enjoying the banter, the epistolary sections and a low-angst, sexy romance.

Where they split. The ending and the office scenes. Valerie loved the grand gesture but felt the seven-year epilogue jump was too long; Caz found the gesture out of character and the late conflict unnecessary. On StoryGraph, at least one reader stopped early because Connor's treatment of Jamie felt too hostile.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Dating Experiment scores 7.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with strong marks for romance, characters, writing and heat, and lower marks for an ending that divides reviewers.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Real chemistry, per All About Romance, though much is told not shown.
Characters (15%)4Connor's two sides give him a real arc; side friends blur, per All About Romance.
Writing and pacing (15%)4Funny, quick prose and great text exchanges, per Love Bytes.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Grief and loneliness give it warmth; the angst stays low.
Heat level (10%)4Warm heat with a standout phone sex scene, per Love Bytes.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5An HEA, but the grand gesture and seven-year epilogue split reviewers.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5The texts are worth revisiting; the office scenes less so.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Dating Experiment is one of the stronger books in Briar Prescott's Better With You series and a fun pick in MM secret identity romance, landing at a final Eikna Score of 7.6/10.

Better With You Reading Order

The Dating Experiment is book 2 of Briar Prescott's Better With You series. Each book follows a new couple from the same family and friend circle, so it stands alone, but Connor's brother Gray and his boyfriend Kai from book 1 appear here.

  1. The Happy List (2020): Gray and Kai
  2. The Dating Experiment (2021): Jamie and Connor
  3. The Underdog (2021)
  4. The Inconvenient Love (2022)

Start with The Happy List if you want the family context, or jump in here if the secret identity hook is what drew you. Best format: ebook or paperback, since the text exchanges read best on a page and there is no audiobook. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.

If You Loved The Dating Experiment, Read These Next

If you loved The Dating Experiment, look for MM romances with bosses, rivals and secret identities.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Dating Experiment prompts the same questions from most readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how old the leads are and how it ends. Short answers below.

Is The Dating Experiment spicy?

Moderately. The Dating Experiment is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with on-page intimacy including a much-praised phone sex scene.

Is The Dating Experiment a standalone?

Yes. It is book 2 of Better With You, but Jamie and Connor's story is complete, with cameos from The Happy List couple.

Does The Dating Experiment have a happy ending?

Yes. It ends with a happily ever after and an epilogue set seven years later.

Is there an age gap in The Dating Experiment?

Yes. Connor is 13 years older than Jamie and is also his boss. Both are adults.

What game do they play in The Dating Experiment?

Words With Friends. Jamie takes over his late grandfather's game with a player called Seb.

Is there a The Dating Experiment audiobook?

We found no audiobook edition. It is available in paperback and ebook.

What order should I read Better With You in?

The Happy List, The Dating Experiment, The Underdog and The Inconvenient Love, though each book follows a new couple.

The Bottom Line

The Dating Experiment earns a 7.6/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a funny, low-angst MM romance where a cold boss turns out to be the warm stranger on the other end of a word game, and who are comfortable with a real age gap and a workplace imbalance. The reason to pick it up is the texting: those late-night messages between J and Seb are some of the most charming pages in indie MM romance.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.