eikna romance
Menu

Poppy Jenkins by Clare Ashton Review

Eikna Score: 8.0/10. Recommended.

Poppy Jenkins is a warm, funny sapphic romance about the only lesbian in a mid-Welsh village and the childhood best friend who left without a word and comes back in a sports car. The village, the family and the jokes are wonderful; the romance leans on interrupted confessions for longer than it needs to.

Read it if you want a cosy small-town sapphic romance with a big, nosy family and a strong sense of place, or you love childhood friends who reunite as adults. Skip it if repeated near-miss confessions make you want to throw the book, or you want a tight plot all the way through.

Poppy Jenkins by Clare Ashton book cover

Poppy Jenkins at a Glance

Poppy Jenkins is a standalone sapphic small-town romance by Clare Ashton, first published in June 2016. It reunites Poppy, the cheerful heart of a mid-Welsh village, with her estranged childhood best friend Rosalyn Thorn, mixes friends to lovers with second chance romance, carries moderate on-page heat and ends happily.

AuthorClare Ashton
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreSapphic romance, small town, contemporary
Main tropesFriends to lovers, second chance, childhood best friends, opposites attract, returning hometown girl
Spice level3/5: Moderate, some open door
Content warningsChildhood bullying, a parent's stroke, friendship rupture, drinking (full list below)
POVThird person, Poppy's point of view throughout
EndingHEA for Poppy and Rosalyn
Pages378 (US paperback)
AudiobookNo English-language audiobook listed; a German translation, Poppy Jenkins liebt das Leben, is on audio
First publishedJune 19, 2016
PublisherSelf-published (CreateSpace paperback)

What Is Poppy Jenkins About?

Poppy Jenkins is the sunny centre of Wells, a small village in mid-Wales. She runs a struggling café, lives with her loving, interfering family, a mischievous younger sister and an unruly dog, and she is the only gay woman for miles. She has not kissed anyone in a long time and has more or less made peace with that.

Then Rosalyn Thorn comes back. Rosalyn was Poppy's best friend at school until she cut Poppy off at sixteen and later left the village without explanation. Now she is a high-flier with an expensive car and a guarded manner, and her return stirs up both Poppy and every gossip in Wells. Neither woman can avoid the other, and neither can avoid what went wrong.

What Makes This Friends to Lovers Romance Work

Poppy Jenkins works as a friends to lovers romance because Clare Ashton sets it inside a whole community rather than a bubble. Poppy and Rosalyn are reunited in a village where everyone remembers them as girls, where Poppy's family has opinions about everything, and where the old hurt is common knowledge even if the reasons are not.

The opposites dynamic helps too. Poppy is open, kind and rooted; Rosalyn is sharp, polished and visibly uncomfortable being back. Readers on Goodreads keep naming that contrast as the reason the book works, and the Lesbrary's Jess van Netten called it a refreshing lesbian romance with authentic characters and a wonderful sense of humour.

And then there is Wales. This is not a generic village with hanging baskets. The countryside, Poppy's struggling café, her grandmother and the shaky small-town economy all feel specific. Curve's reviewer said the town of Wells works almost as a character, and that is exactly right. If you like small-town romance where the town is a character, Poppy Jenkins is one of the best sapphic examples.

My Review

Poppy Jenkins is the kind of book I recommend to people who say they do not read romance. It is funny in a gentle, observational way, it is kind to almost everyone in it, and it is full of small domestic scenes that have nothing to do with the love story and everything to do with why you want Poppy to be happy.

It won Best Lesbian Contemporary Romance at the Rainbow Awards, according to the author's site, and it has more than 3,800 ratings on Goodreads averaging well above 4 stars, which is a lot for a self-published sapphic novel from 2016. That longevity is earned. It is also, in places, more frustrating than it needed to be.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry between Poppy and Rosalyn starts as awkwardness and turns into banter quickly. They are funniest when sparring, and Ashton uses sexual innuendo for comedy more than heat, which the Lesbrary review enjoyed and so did I. There is a real ache underneath, because Poppy never stopped caring and Rosalyn clearly never stopped thinking about her.

My complaint is the same one a fair number of Goodreads readers raise. The book delays the big conversation through a run of interrupted confessions and misunderstandings, and by the third near miss I was more annoyed than anxious. Some readers also found Dai, a would-be love interest, more irritating than useful as an obstacle. These are not fatal problems, but they stretch the middle.

The Characters

Poppy is lovely without being a doormat. She has made a full life in a place that does not always know what to do with her, and her optimism has some steel in it. A few Goodreads readers found her passive. I read her as patient, which is a different thing, though I take their point that she lets Rosalyn set the pace for a long time.

Rosalyn is the more interesting character because she is the one with secrets, and because the whole book stays in Poppy's head we only see her from outside. Her coolness reads first as snobbery and then, slowly, as self-protection. Curve called the backstory of their split poignant, and when it comes out it changes how you read her early scenes.

The family is where Poppy Jenkins becomes special. Poppy's mother, her grandmother and her little sister Pip are funny and loving and a little exhausting, and the village subplots around them give the book its texture. The Lesbrary's reviewer singled out the supporting family and the funny side stories as highlights. One reader on StoryGraph felt the big ensemble crowded out time with Rosalyn, and I can see that, but I would not cut a single scene with the grandmother.

Writing and Pacing

Ashton's prose is easy and bright, with a good ear for Welsh speech and village chat. The opening third is close to perfect. The middle slows as the misunderstandings pile up, and several readers noticed a change in tone in the second half, when older pain comes to the surface and the book becomes more serious. I liked the shift more than some did. It makes the happy ending feel earned rather than handed over.

Poppy Jenkins is a generous, funny sapphic village romance with a terrific family at its heart and a slightly overextended middle. Read it if you want comfort with real feeling underneath, and forgive it the extra misunderstanding or two.

How Spicy Is Poppy Jenkins?

Poppy Jenkins is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. The first half runs on flirtation and innuendo, and later in the book there are several consensual, on-page sex scenes between Poppy and Rosalyn. Readers on Goodreads describe them as explicit but warm rather than graphic, and one reader felt the book did not need them at all.

Our romance heat levels guide explains how the scale works.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Poppy Jenkins?

Poppy Jenkins suits readers who want a cosy, funny sapphic romance with a strong sense of place, a big supporting cast and two women in their thirties settling an old score. It is less suited to readers who dislike miscommunication plots or want a fast, tightly focused romance.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Poppy Jenkins has little trade coverage beyond Curve, so most of the reception comes from sapphic review sites and readers on Goodreads and StoryGraph, where it is one of Clare Ashton's most popular books. It also won the Rainbow Awards prize for Best Lesbian Contemporary Romance, according to the author.

Where they agree. The setting, the humour and the family. Jess van Netten at the Lesbrary praised the Welsh countryside, the supporting cast and the love scenes for feeling genuine. Tara Scott at Smart Bitches, Trashy Books put it on her keeper shelf, praising the crackling chemistry and a mid-Wales that feels real, and Curve called it Ashton's best book. Goodreads readers repeatedly call it charming, warm and funny.

Where they split. The middle of the book and the romance mechanics. Some Goodreads readers wanted fewer misunderstandings and interrupted confessions, some found Poppy too passive, and a few felt the second half lost plot momentum as the tone darkened. Curve, while enthusiastic, admitted there is not much plot, and a StoryGraph reader thought the large ensemble left too little room for Rosalyn.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Poppy Jenkins scores 8.0 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top mark for reread appeal, since the village and family are a comfort to return to, and its lowest for heat, which is pleasant but secondary to the comedy and the community.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Real ache and good banter; Goodreads readers tire of the interrupted confessions.
Characters (15%)4The Lesbrary praises the family; some readers find Poppy passive.
Writing and pacing (15%)4Bright, funny prose with a strong sense of place; the middle sags.
Emotional impact (15%)4Curve calls the backstory of the split poignant; the tonal shift adds weight.
Heat level (10%)3.5Warm open-door scenes that suit the book; one reader found them unnecessary.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4Smart Bitches, Trashy Books calls it a perfect HEA; some found it slow to arrive.
Reread appeal (10%)4.5A comfort read; thousands of Goodreads ratings years after release.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Poppy Jenkins is Clare Ashton's warmest standalone and one of the best sapphic small-town romances we have covered, with a final Eikna Score of 8.0/10.

Is Poppy Jenkins a Standalone?

Yes. Poppy Jenkins is a standalone novel with a complete romance and no series attached, so you can start with it and need nothing else. Clare Ashton's later Oxford Romance series is unconnected and begins with Meeting Millie.

Clare Ashton books to try next, in the order we suggest:

  1. Poppy Jenkins (2016): standalone
  2. Meeting Millie (2023): Oxford Romance, book 1
  3. Tempting Olivia: Oxford Romance, book 2
  4. Discovering Nicola (2025): Oxford Romance, book 3

Best format: the paperback or ebook, since there is no English audiobook as of November 2026. Our series order guide covers more romance series.

If You Loved Poppy Jenkins, Read These Next

If you loved Poppy Jenkins, look for sapphic romances with reunions, close-knit communities and plenty of humour.

Frequently Asked Questions

Poppy Jenkins draws a few common questions from new readers: how spicy it is, whether it is part of a series, how it ends and whether there is an audiobook. Short answers below.

Is Poppy Jenkins spicy?

Moderately. Poppy Jenkins is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with several consensual, on-page sex scenes in the second half after a lot of flirtation.

Is Poppy Jenkins a standalone?

Yes. Poppy Jenkins is a standalone with a complete romance and is not connected to Clare Ashton's Oxford Romance series.

Does Poppy Jenkins have a happy ending?

Yes. Poppy Jenkins ends with a happily ever after for Poppy and Rosalyn, with no cliffhanger.

Where is Poppy Jenkins set?

Poppy Jenkins is set in Wells, a small village in mid-Wales, and the Welsh countryside and village life are a big part of its appeal.

How old are Poppy and Rosalyn?

Both are adults in their early thirties; reader reviews put them at 32. Their friendship broke apart when they were teenagers, and the romance happens years later.

Is there a Poppy Jenkins audiobook?

Not in English as of November 2026. A German translation, Poppy Jenkins liebt das Leben, is available as an audiobook.

The Bottom Line

Poppy Jenkins earns an 8.0/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a cosy, funny sapphic romance set in a real-feeling Welsh village, with a loud family, an old friendship and a heroine whose kindness is the point. The one reason to pick it up is the world Clare Ashton builds around Poppy: you will want to move to Wells by the end.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.