eikna romance
Menu

Set the Record Straight by Hannah Bonam-Young Review

Eikna Score: 7.6/10. Recommended.

Set the Record Straight is a short, sweet and surprisingly steamy sapphic holiday novella about two lifelong best friends who fake a relationship and find out it was never really fake. It is too brief to give the friendship the history it deserves, but the communication, the families and Evan's long-held crush make it an easy December pick.

Read it if you want best friends to lovers with no third-act breakup, or a cozy queer Christmas read you can finish in an evening. Skip it if you need a slow, gradual burn, or a late-blooming queer awakening that happens fast will feel too easy.

Set the Record Straight by Hannah Bonam-Young book cover

Set the Record Straight at a Glance

Set the Record Straight is a standalone sapphic holiday novella by Hannah Bonam-Young, first self-published as an ebook in December 2022 and reissued in paperback by Dell in September 2026. It is told in dual first person by best friends Clara and Evan, combines friends to lovers with fake dating, has open-door heat and ends happily.

AuthorHannah Bonam-Young
SeriesStandalone novella
SubgenreLGBTQ+ romance (sapphic), holiday, contemporary
Main tropesFriends to lovers, fake dating, long-held secret crush, late-blooming queer self-discovery, holiday party
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsHomophobia and religious bigotry in a family, family estrangement, a cheating ex, anxiety (full list below)
POVDual first person, Clara and Evan
EndingHappy ending, with no third-act breakup
Pages192 (2026 Dell paperback); the original ebook ran about 154
AudiobookNarrated by Lori Prince and Jenn Lee (Tantor, 2023)
First publishedDecember 2022 (ebook); Dell paperback September 29, 2026
PublisherSelf-published originally; Dell (Penguin Random House) for the 2026 paperback

What Is Set the Record Straight About?

Set the Record Straight follows Clara, a photographer who has just landed her dream job working for a woman she idolizes. In a nervous moment, Clara lets her new boss believe she will be bringing a girlfriend to an upcoming gallery opening. Clara is single, and as far as she knows, straight.

Her best friend Evan has her own problem. Her fiancée left her for a coworker, and the staff holiday party is coming. So the two of them agree to pretend to date for both events. What Clara does not know is that Evan has been in love with her for years, and as the holidays roll on, Clara starts having feelings she did not see coming.

What Makes This Best Friends to Lovers Romance Work

Set the Record Straight works as a best friends to lovers romance because one of the friends is already in love and the other is the last to know. Evan's years of quiet feeling give every fake-date moment a second meaning, and the dual first person lets you see both sides of the same hand-hold.

The fake dating setup is light and functional. It exists to put two people who already know everything about each other into situations where they have to touch, perform and then go home and think about it. That is exactly the right amount of contrivance for a novella.

The other hook is warmth. Goodreads and StoryGraph readers keep coming back to Clara's funny, supportive parents and to how plainly the two women talk to each other. In a genre that often runs on misunderstanding, a holiday romance where the leads actually say the thing feels like a treat.

My Review

Set the Record Straight is the kind of book I would hand someone on December 20 with a mug of something hot. It is short, it is kind, and it has more heat than its cozy cover suggests. It is also very obviously a novella, and almost every complaint I have comes back to length.

Goodreads readers rate it 3.75 from more than 12,000 ratings, and the spread tells the story: lots of fours, lots of threes, very few people who disliked it. That matches my reading. Nothing here goes wrong. Some things just do not get the room to go as right as they could.

Romance and Chemistry

The best part of the romance is how Bonam-Young handles Evan's side of it. She has wanted Clara for a long time and has made peace with not having her, and the fake relationship puts that peace under real strain. Those chapters have the ache the book needs.

Clara's side moves faster. She goes from probably straight to falling for her best friend within a very short page count, and several Goodreads reviewers felt her awakening was too easy, sexually and emotionally. I understand the objection. On the other hand, the book treats it as recognition rather than conversion, and the communication between them is excellent. One StoryGraph reviewer singled out how open and honest they are with each other, and that is the book's real romance engine: not obstacles, but two people being brave out loud.

The Characters

Clara and Evan are both easy to root for. Readers on Goodreads praise the ADHD representation in Clara and the autism representation in Evan, and both feel lived in rather than listed. Clara's parents steal every scene they appear in.

Evan's family is a different story. Her history with homophobia and religious bigotry at home is the book's heaviest material, and reader opinion splits on whether it is underexplored or takes over. For me it sat slightly awkwardly in a cozy holiday novella, not because it should not be there but because there is no space to deal with it fully. The friendship history has the same issue: we are told these two have been close forever, and a few more scenes of that history would have made the turn land harder.

Writing and Pacing

The prose is plain, warm and funny, and the dual first person keeps things moving. A StoryGraph reviewer noted frequent time jumps that felt like skipped moments, and that is the cost of fitting a full arc into under two hundred pages. Some Goodreads readers also found the two narrating voices too similar. The second half slows a little once the main obstacles are gone, but it is so short that it never drags for long.

Set the Record Straight is a warm, steamy and kind sapphic holiday novella that does a lot in very few pages. Read it if you want a cozy evening read with real heat and do not mind a romance that moves faster than the friendship behind it.

How Spicy Is Set the Record Straight?

Set the Record Straight is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. Goodreads reviewers describe several open-door, explicit sex scenes, which is a lot for a novella. Some readers call it a perfect amount of spice; others say it is too much for the length.

Both leads are adults throughout and every scene is consensual. Our romance heat levels guide explains the scale, and there is more in this range on our spicy romance list.

Content warnings, drawn from Goodreads and StoryGraph reader reports:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Set the Record Straight?

Set the Record Straight suits readers who want a short, cozy, sapphic Christmas romance with best friends, a fake relationship, open-door heat and leads who communicate. It is less suited to readers who need a slow burn, a deeply developed backstory or a low-heat holiday read.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Set the Record Straight is a reader-driven book, and coverage is mostly Goodreads and StoryGraph reviews rather than trade critics. It averages 3.75 on Goodreads from more than 12,000 ratings, and its 2026 Dell paperback is marked a bestseller by the publisher.

Where they agree. It is sweet, funny and well communicated. Goodreads readers praise the childhood friends to lovers setup, the lack of a third-act breakup, Clara's parents and the neurodivergent representation. A StoryGraph reviewer called it sensitive and sweet and said the 150 or so pages felt full.

Where they split. Length and speed. The most common Goodreads complaint is that the novella is too short, so the romance feels rushed and the friendship history thin. Readers also disagree on the heat, with some loving it and others finding it too much for the length, and on whether Evan's family trauma gets too little room or too much.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Set the Record Straight scores 7.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for romance, emotional impact, heat and the ending, and lower scores for characters and writing because the novella length leaves the backstory thin.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Evan's long crush gives the fake dating real stakes; readers praise the honest communication.
Characters (15%)3.5Likable leads and great parents, but Goodreads readers find the friendship history thin.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Warm and quick; a StoryGraph reviewer notes time jumps, others find the voices similar.
Emotional impact (15%)4Evan's side of the story carries real ache; readers call it sweet and emotional.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the open-door heat its readers expect, per Goodreads, though some want less.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A happy ending with no third-act breakup, as Goodreads readers point out.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5Short enough for a yearly December reread, with little depth left to discover.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Set the Record Straight sits comfortably among sapphic holiday novellas, warmer than most and spicier than many, and it lands at a final Eikna Score of 7.6/10.

Is Set the Record Straight a Standalone?

Yes. Set the Record Straight is a standalone holiday novella with no series connection, so you can start here. Hannah Bonam-Young's full-length romances, including Next of Kin, Out on a Limb, Out of the Woods and People Watching, are separate books.

Which edition to pick: the 2026 Dell paperback is the easiest to find in print, and the original ebook is still around. The audiobook, narrated by Lori Prince and Jenn Lee with one voice per lead, is a good fit for the dual first person. For more December reading, our LGBTQ+ romance hub collects queer romances by subgenre.

If You Loved Set the Record Straight, Read These Next

If you loved Set the Record Straight, the closest matches are sapphic romances with a fake relationship, a best friend or a holiday setting.

Frequently Asked Questions

Set the Record Straight raises a few common questions: how spicy it is, how long it is, whether it is part of a series and whether it is a Christmas book. Short answers below.

Is Set the Record Straight spicy?

Yes. Set the Record Straight is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with several explicit, consensual open-door scenes in a short book.

How long is Set the Record Straight?

It is a novella. The 2026 Dell paperback runs 192 pages, and the original ebook was about 154 pages.

Is Set the Record Straight a Christmas book?

Yes. The fake relationship covers a gallery opening and a staff holiday party, and the story runs through the holiday season.

Is Set the Record Straight part of a series?

No. It is a standalone novella with no series connection.

Does Set the Record Straight have a happy ending?

Yes. Clara and Evan end together, and readers note there is no third-act breakup.

Is there a Set the Record Straight audiobook?

Yes. The Tantor audiobook is narrated by Lori Prince and Jenn Lee.

The Bottom Line

Set the Record Straight earns a 7.6/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a cozy, steamy sapphic holiday novella about best friends who communicate, and who are happy to trade depth for warmth. The one reason to pick it up is Evan: her years of quiet love make every fake date feel like something real is at stake.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.