Reach the Stars by Lily Seabrooke Review
Eikna Score: 6.9/10. Recommended with reservations.
Reach the Stars is a short, bright sapphic novella about a sunny singer and an icy reigning champion forced to perform as a pair on a televised song contest, with fans shipping them before they have admitted anything to themselves. The opening is funny and the contrast is sharp, but the length rushes the turn, and Emmy's habit of ignoring Kat's requests for space will bother some readers more than the book seems to expect.
Read it if you want a quick grumpy sunshine romance with an ice queen and fan shipping, in one sitting. Skip it if a heroine pushing past a clear request for space is a dealbreaker, or you need the contest rules to make sense.
Reach the Stars at a Glance
Reach the Stars is a standalone sapphic novella by Lily Seabrooke, self-published in 2021. It runs about 30,000 words (174 pages in paperback), alternates between its two heroines in first person, pairs a cheerful singer with a guarded champion on a televised song contest, and includes open-door content.
| Author | Lily Seabrooke |
|---|---|
| Series | Standalone novella |
| Subgenre | Sapphic contemporary romance, music and reality TV |
| Main tropes | Grumpy sunshine, ice queen, forced partnership, fan shipping, opposites attract |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Boundary pushing, past abuse mentioned, career burnout (full list below) |
| POV | Dual first person, Emmy and Kat |
| Ending | Happy ending for the couple |
| Pages | 174 (paperback), about 30,000 words |
| Audiobook | None at time of writing |
| First published | 2021 (ebook spring 2021; paperback July 31, 2021) |
| Publisher | Self-published (independently published paperback) |
What Is Reach the Stars About?
Reach the Stars opens with Emmy Montford, a cheerful, easygoing singer, landing unexpectedly on a televised song contest. She is paired with the reigning champion, Katarina Jackson, known as Kat, who has gone cold and detached and cares about one thing: winning.
Emmy is friendly with everyone. Kat is friendly with no one. The pairings keep throwing them together, Emmy keeps trying to find the person under the frost, and the audience at home starts shipping them online long before either woman is ready to admit anything. The novella follows the competition and the slow thaw between them.
What Makes This Grumpy Sunshine Romance Work
Reach the Stars works on contrast. Emmy is all warmth and Kat is all edges, and the book alternates between them in first person, so you get both the sunshine view of the grump and the grump's horror at being liked. Jude at LezReviewBooks praised how distinct the two voices are and compared Kat to Han Solo, which is not wrong.
The fan shipping is the second hook. Having a public decide you are a couple before you have decided anything is a lovely pressure device, and LGBTQ+Reader singled out the shipping as part of the fun. The contest itself is the third: it forces repeated contact, and Amy Marsden, reviewing an early copy on StoryGraph, valued the repeated pairings as a natural reason to keep the two together. I Heart SapphFic readers also nominated it in their 2022 poll for best sapphic grumpy sunshine.
My Review
Reach the Stars is a pleasant hour and a half that I wanted to be a novel. The setup is good, the leads are clearly drawn and the first few chapters made me laugh. Then the book has to compress a thaw that needs room, and it shows.
Romance and Chemistry
The chemistry comes from friction. Kat is caustic and isolated, Emmy refuses to be put off, and their early exchanges are sharp and funny. LGBTQ+Reader enjoyed the move from tentative friendship to admitted feelings, and that arc is the novella's best thread: the moment Kat starts caring about something again is earned.
My reservation is how Emmy gets there. More than once, Kat asks to be left alone and Emmy carries on talking. Amy Marsden objected to exactly this, and so did I. The book frames it as Emmy's persistence paying off, and in a longer story there might have been room to show Kat choosing to let her in. At novella length, it can read as Emmy simply not listening. Jude at LezReviewBooks felt some of the romance was a tad rushed, and the boundary problem is part of why.
The Characters
Kat is the more interesting woman, and I am not alone. Amy Marsden liked her more, and a StoryGraph reader, rogue_lurker, described the vulnerability beneath her caustic manner. She is a champion who has stopped enjoying her own success, and that burnout is the most grown-up idea in the book.
Emmy is sweet, maybe too sweet. Jude said she was too sweet to hate, rogue_lurker found some of the sweetness effective and some of it excessive, and that split matches my experience. When Emmy's optimism is pointed at Kat, it works. When it is pointed at everyone, she starts to feel less like a person than a mood.
The secondary characters barely register. Jude wished for more of them, and at 30,000 words there simply is not space.
Writing and Pacing
Seabrooke writes clean, efficient prose and good banter, and the dual first person is handled well. The setting is the weak spot. LGBTQ+Reader was initially confused by a contest that features experienced performers with existing fan bases rather than unknowns, and rogue_lurker also found the professional setup underexplained. I had the same question and the book never really answers it. The show is a machine for putting two women on a stage together, which is fine, but it never feels like a real show.
To be fair to the format, the short length does some things well. There is no padding, no third-act breakup manufactured to fill pages, and no subplot about anybody's family. A novella can be a palate cleanser, and for a reader between two long, heavy books, an evening with Emmy and Kat is a genuinely nice way to spend the time. I just kept wanting scenes to run longer, and the stage scenes most of all. In a book about two singers, the music is where the romance should come alive, and I wanted more of it.
The pace is brisk to a fault. Several reviewers, including Amy Marsden and Jude, wished it were a full novel, and that is the fairest summary of its strengths and its limits.
Reach the Stars is a sharp, funny little grumpy sunshine romance that needs more pages than it has. Read it for Kat and a quick fan-shipping fix; skip it if persistence after a clear no is a limit for you.
How Spicy Is Reach the Stars?
Reach the Stars is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. The book's listing flags open-door sex scenes, but they are a small part of the whole. Most of the novella is banter and slow thaw, and reviewers mostly describe it as cute and sweet rather than steamy.
Both leads are adults. The intimate scenes themselves are consensual; the boundary concerns readers raise are about Emmy pushing conversations, not about sex. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Content warnings, drawn from the book's listing, reader reports and our own read:
- A character continuing to engage after being asked for space
- Past abuse mentioned
- Professional burnout and isolation
- Unpleasant, caustic exchanges
- Open-door sex scenes
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read Reach the Stars?
Reach the Stars suits readers who want a quick sapphic grumpy sunshine romance with an ice queen, a music setting and fans shipping the couple. It is less suited to readers who want a fully developed novel-length arc, believable reality TV logistics, or a sunshine heroine who backs off when asked.
Best for:
- Readers who want a one-sitting sapphic romance
- Fans of ice queen heroines who thaw
- Anyone who loves fan shipping and public speculation
- Readers sampling Lily Seabrooke before a longer series
Not for:
- Readers for whom ignored requests for space are a hard limit
- Anyone who wants a slow burn with room to breathe
- Readers who need the competition setting to feel real
- Audiobook-only readers, since there is no audio edition
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Reach the Stars has a modest but positive reader response, and as a self-published novella its coverage is mostly sapphic review blogs and reader reviews. Most call it cute and fun; the disagreements are about boundaries and length.
Where they agree. The opening and the pairing. LezReviewBooks gave it four stars and called it an incredibly cute novella with distinct narrators. LGBTQ+Reader rated it 3.5, enjoying Emmy's optimism, the banter and the fan shipping.
Where they split. Emmy's persistence and the setup. Amy Marsden liked Kat more and objected to Emmy carrying on after being asked to leave her alone. LGBTQ+Reader and rogue_lurker both found the contest under-explained. Amy Marsden and Jude both wanted it longer.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Reach the Stars scores 6.9 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard: good marks for its pairing and heat, and lower ones for a rushed arc, a sketchy setting and a boundary problem that limits rereads.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Sharp contrast and real friction, but a boundary problem, per Amy Marsden. |
| Characters (15%) | 3.5 | Kat is layered, per rogue_lurker; Emmy and the side cast stay thin. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Clean dual first person; the setting is underexplained, per LGBTQ+Reader. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | Kat's thaw lands; the rush blunts it, per LezReviewBooks. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Moderate open-door heat that fits a sweet novella. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A happy ending that arrives quickly. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3 | Easy to revisit for Kat; the persistence issue reads worse the second time. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Reach the Stars sits below Lily Seabrooke's full-length Port Andrea romances and in the middle of sapphic grumpy sunshine novellas, landing at a final Eikna Score of 6.9/10.
Is Reach the Stars a Standalone?
Reach the Stars is a standalone novella with no series. If you like Lily Seabrooke's voice here, her Taste of Port Andrea series is the natural next step: start with Fake It or jump to the grumpy sunshine roommates of Night & Day. Best format: ebook, since there is no audiobook and the story suits a single sitting. Our series order guide covers connected romances.
If You Loved Reach the Stars, Read These Next
If you loved Reach the Stars, look for sapphic romances with public pressure, contrasting temperaments and a reserved heroine who lets someone in.
- Night & Day by Lily Seabrooke: Seabrooke again, with a full-length grumpy sunshine roommates romance.
- Breaking Character by Lee Winter: performance, public speculation and a warm woman meeting a reserved one.
- Cleat Cute by Meryl Wilsner: rivals under competitive pressure, with a lot more room to develop.
- Just for Show by Jae: a controlled heroine negotiating intimacy, far from a TV studio.
- Fake It by Lily Seabrooke: a celebrity and an ordinary woman in a fake relationship.
Frequently Asked Questions
Reach the Stars prompts a few common questions: how long it is, how spicy it is, whether it is part of a series and whether there is an audiobook.
How long is Reach the Stars?
Reach the Stars is a novella of about 30,000 words, 174 pages in paperback, and most readers finish it in one sitting.
Is Reach the Stars spicy?
Moderately. Reach the Stars is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with some open-door content in a mostly sweet story.
Is Reach the Stars part of a series?
No. Reach the Stars is a standalone novella and is not connected to Lily Seabrooke's Taste of Port Andrea series.
Who are the main characters in Reach the Stars?
Emmy Montford, a cheerful singer, and Katarina Jackson, the guarded reigning champion she is paired with on a televised song contest.
Is there a Reach the Stars audiobook?
No. Reach the Stars is available as an ebook and paperback, with no audiobook edition.
Is Reach the Stars a grumpy sunshine romance?
Yes. Kat is the icy grump and Emmy the relentless sunshine, and readers nominated it in an I Heart SapphFic grumpy sunshine poll.
The Bottom Line
Reach the Stars earns a 6.9/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a quick, cute sapphic grumpy sunshine romance with an ice queen and a shipping fandom, and who can live with a rushed arc and a heroine who does not always take no for an answer. The reason to pick it up is Kat, a burnt-out champion whose slow return to caring is the best thing in the book.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Lily Seabrooke official site (book list, blurb, ebook link)
- Reach the Stars paperback, Blackwell's (ISBN, pages, date, word count)
- Reach the Stars, Margins (listing content notes)
- An incredibly cute grumpy/sunshine novella, LezReviewBooks (Jude)
- Reach the Stars, LGBTQ+Reader
- StoryGraph reader review (amymarsdenauthor)
- StoryGraph reader review (rogue_lurker)
- Vote for best sapphic grumpy sunshine, I Heart SapphFic (2022 reader poll)
- Lily Seabrooke audiobooks, Audible (no Reach the Stars edition)
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.