Fake It by Lily Seabrooke Review
Eikna Score: 7.7/10. Recommended.
Fake It is a sunny, very steamy restaurant romance that uses fake dating as a launch pad rather than a whole plot, and its trans heroine is written with ease and joy instead of pain. The villain is a cartoon and the book runs long, but Avery and Holly are a pleasure to root for.
Read it if you want a food and TV industry romance with open door heat and a trans lead whose story is not about suffering, or you like two women teaming up to take down a smug man. Skip it if you want classic fake dating beats from start to finish, or you need subtle antagonists and a tight page count.
Fake It at a Glance
Fake It is the first book in Lily Seabrooke's Taste of Port Andrea series, a self-published sapphic romance from August 2021. A TV chef and a struggling restaurant owner pretend to date for publicity, the heat is high and on the page, and the central romance ends happily in this book.
| Author | Lily Seabrooke |
|---|---|
| Series | Taste of Port Andrea, book 1 of 5 |
| Subgenre | LGBTQ romance, sapphic contemporary (restaurant and TV cooking show) |
| Main tropes | Fake dating, celebrity and ordinary person, business rivals turned allies, sunshine heroine, takedown of a villain |
| Spice level | 4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes |
| Content warnings | Open door sex with kink elements, a sabotaging and disrespectful ex, public deception (full list below) |
| POV | Dual, Avery and Holly |
| Ending | HEA for Avery and Holly; the town continues in later books |
| Pages | 464 (paperback) |
| Audiobook | None found |
| First published | August 6, 2021 |
| Publisher | Independently published |
What Is Fake It About?
Fake It follows Avery Lindt, who has finally opened her dream restaurant, Paramour, in the town of Port Andrea. The food is good. The dining room is empty. Then celebrity chef Mike Wallace decides her restaurant is a target and starts a campaign to shut it down.
Holly Mason hosts the TV makeover show Kitchen Rescue, and her ratings are sliding. Mike is also her ex, and he is angling to take her spotlight. Holly's agent has an idea: if Holly and Avery are seen dating, both get publicity and Mike gets a problem. The two women are already attracted to each other, which makes pretending far harder than planned.
What Makes This Fake Dating Romance Work
Fake It works as a fake dating romance because the lie is a tactical move in a fight both women care about, and the fake relationship gets them into the same kitchen, the same press coverage and the same war against one man. The fun is less in pretending and more in teaming up.
That distinction matters. Several StoryGraph readers pointed out that the classic fake dating beats fade fairly quickly, because Avery and Holly do not take long to want each other for real. If you want two hundred pages of public hand holding and private denial, look elsewhere. If you want a fake relationship that tips into a real one and then becomes a partnership against a bully, this is a good one.
The other hook is Avery herself. Library Journal noted that trans readers can enjoy the book without bracing for deadnaming or a trauma plot, and LezReviewBooks made a similar point: her identity is part of who she is without being the story. For readers who want a trans heroine in a fake dating romance that is simply fun, that is a real draw.
My Review
Fake It is a book with a lot of energy, and it knows exactly what it wants to be: a warm, horny, slightly over the top restaurant romance where the good guys cook well and the bad guy gets what he deserves. I had a good time with it, and I want to be clear about where it wobbles.
Jude at LezReviewBooks said there is an energy to Seabrooke's writing that makes you want to keep reading, and that is my experience too. The book is long, at 464 pages in paperback, but most of those pages move.
Romance and Chemistry
The attraction between Avery and Holly is there from the start, and the book does not pretend otherwise for long. Holly is confident and polished, Avery is optimistic and a little self conscious, and their scenes have the ease of two people who like each other before they admit they want each other. The banter is light. Jamie Rose singled out the early flirtation, and I agree it is the best stretch of the book.
Because the fake relationship turns real so quickly, the middle of the book is less about will they and more about how they protect what they have while the public plan plays out. That is a different shape than most fake dating romances, and it works for me better than it did for some StoryGraph readers, who felt the trope faded too soon. The emotional payoff is solid rather than devastating.
The Characters
Avery carries the book. She is hopeful about her restaurant to the point of stubbornness, self-conscious in ways that feel specific, and funny about it. She is a trans woman, written by a trans author, and the book lets her be a romance heroine first. Library Journal's note about the absence of deadnaming and microaggressions is the kind of thing that sounds small until you have read enough books that get it wrong.
Holly is more of a type, the glamorous TV personality with armor, but she softens convincingly. The villain is where the book loses me a little. Mike Wallace is a smug, entitled man who calls his ex babe and sabotages a stranger's restaurant for sport. He is satisfying to hate and has no other dimension, and StoryGraph readers who called the villains broad have a point. A sharper antagonist would have raised the stakes.
The Port Andrea supporting cast, the restaurant staff and the TV people, is lively, and you can see Seabrooke setting up the later books in the series.
Writing and Pacing
The prose is unfussy and quick, and the food writing is genuinely appetizing. Library Journal suggested Food Network fans would enjoy the behind the scenes look at a makeover show and the restaurant detail, and that rings true. Jude at LezReviewBooks noted a few editing issues, which is fair for a self-published book of this length; I noticed some too, though none that stopped me.
Pacing is uneven. The setup is efficient, the middle meanders through restaurant business and sex scenes, and the final act leans on convenient wins. Lavender Scribes flagged similar pressure points. I would cut eighty pages and lose nothing I loved.
Fake It is a generous, steamy, joyful sapphic romance with a trans heroine who gets to be happy and a villain who deserves a better writer. Read it if you want warmth and heat over a tight plot, and come for the food.
How Spicy Is Fake It?
Fake It is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. The publisher listing warns of open door sex scenes, some with kinky elements, and Library Journal mentions light BDSM. LezReviewBooks called the sex scenes very hot and the book steamy, with plenty of them. Everything on the page is between consenting adults.
The non sexual material is mild: business sabotage, an unpleasant ex and the strain of keeping up a public lie.
Content warnings, drawn from the author's notes, publisher copy and reader reports:
- Explicit on-page sex between adults, including light kink and BDSM elements
- Workplace and business sabotage
- A disrespectful, manipulative ex-partner
- Public deception for publicity
- Financial pressure on a failing restaurant
Our spicy romance list collects more books in this heat range, and the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Who Should Read Fake It?
Fake It suits readers who want a sapphic fake dating romance with lots of heat, food industry detail and a trans heroine in a joyful story. It is less suited to readers who want the fake relationship to stay fake for most of the book or who need a nuanced villain.
Best for:
- Readers who want trans representation without a trauma plot
- Fans of food, restaurant and cooking show romances
- Readers who like explicit, kink adjacent heat
- Anyone who enjoys a teamwork takedown of a bully
- Readers starting a small town series they can binge
Not for:
- Readers who want closed door romance
- Anyone who wants long, classic fake dating tension
- Readers who dislike cartoonish villains
- Readers sensitive to small editing slips
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
Fake It has had more review attention than most self-published sapphic romances, including a Library Journal review, but much of the response still comes from review blogs and Goodreads and StoryGraph readers.
Where they agree. The trans representation and the chemistry. Library Journal praised a story trans readers can enjoy without the usual worries and liked the food and reality TV setting. Jude at LezReviewBooks gave it four stars for the banter, chemistry and energy. A StoryGraph reader called it a new and different lesbian romance and enjoyed its rare restaurant setting.
Where they split. The villain and the trope. StoryGraph critics found the antagonists broad and the plot convenient, and some felt the fake dating mechanism faded too soon. Readers who loved it tend to say they did not mind, because the couple was the point.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
Fake It scores 7.7 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top mark for heat, which delivers what the publisher listing promises, and its lowest for writing, emotional impact and reread appeal, held back by length and a one-note villain.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4 | Easy, flirty chemistry; Jamie Rose and LezReviewBooks praise the early banter. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Avery is a standout trans heroine per Library Journal; StoryGraph readers find the villain broad. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Energetic and appetizing; LezReviewBooks notes editing issues and the middle runs long. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3.5 | Warm and satisfying rather than wrenching; the stakes stay mostly professional. |
| Heat level (10%) | 4.5 | Delivers the open door, kink adjacent heat the publisher listing promises. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 4 | A happy ending with a satisfying takedown, though some wins arrive conveniently. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | Fun to revisit for the couple and the food; the plot holds fewer surprises. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: Fake It is the series opener and the natural entry point to Taste of Port Andrea, and it lands at a final Eikna Score of 7.7/10.
Taste of Port Andrea Reading Order
Taste of Port Andrea is a five book series of sapphic romances set in the same town, published between 2021 and 2022. Each book centers a different couple, so the romances resolve on their own, but start with Fake It: it introduces the town and recurring characters.
- Book 1: Fake It (2021): Avery Lindt and Holly Mason
- Book 2: Last Chance (2021)
- Book 3: One Step at a Time (2022)
- Book 4: Night & Day (2022)
- Book 5: Every Rose (2022)
Best format: the paperback or ebook; we could not find an audiobook of Fake It. For another Lily Seabrooke standalone, try Reach the Stars. Our series order guide covers more romance series.
If You Loved Fake It, Read These Next
If you loved Fake It, the closest matches are sapphic romances where the relationship starts as a performance for an audience and the women end up on the same team.
- In Development by Rachel Spangler: an actor and a pop star fake a romance for the press, with similar heat.
- Cover Story by Rachel Lacey: a Hollywood star and her bodyguard pose as a couple during awards season.
- Just for Show by Jae: a professional fake girlfriend arrangement with more slow burn.
- Night & Day by Lily Seabrooke: book four in Taste of Port Andrea, back in the same town.
- Written in the Stars by Alexandria Bellefleur: opposites fake a relationship for a family audience, with sharper banter.
Frequently Asked Questions
Fake It raises the same questions for most readers: how spicy it is, whether it stands alone, how the series runs and whether there is an audiobook. Short answers below.
Is Fake It by Lily Seabrooke spicy?
Yes. Fake It is a 4 out of 5 on our scale, with multiple explicit, consensual scenes, some with kink elements.
Is Fake It a standalone?
Fake It is book one of the Taste of Port Andrea series, but Avery and Holly's romance resolves in this book, so it reads well on its own.
What is the Taste of Port Andrea reading order?
Fake It, Last Chance, One Step at a Time, Night & Day, then Every Rose.
Is the main character in Fake It trans?
Yes. Avery Lindt is a trans woman, and reviewers including Library Journal praise the book for avoiding deadnaming and trauma plots.
Does Fake It have a happy ending?
Yes. Fake It ends with Avery and Holly together and happy.
Is there a Fake It audiobook?
We could not find one. Fake It is available in paperback and ebook.
The Bottom Line
Fake It earns a 7.7/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a steamy sapphic fake dating romance with good food, a sunny trans heroine and a villain you can boo. The one reason to pick it up is Avery: a heroine whose story is about wanting things and getting them, which is rarer than it should be.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- Fake It, Library Journal review
- Fake It, Bookshop.org listing (description, content warnings, edition)
- Fake It by Lily Seabrooke, LezReviewBooks (Jude)
- Fake It reader review, StoryGraph
- Taste of Port Andrea series, Fantastic Fiction
- Lily Seabrooke audiobooks, AudiobooksNow (no Fake It edition listed)
- Jamie Rose, Lavender Scribes and StoryGraph reader criticism
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.