eikna romance
Menu

Night & Day by Lily Seabrooke Review

Eikna Score: 7.5/10. Recommended.

Night & Day is a cosy sapphic roommates romance where a prickly coffee supplier and a relentlessly cheerful influencer share a flat, a business war and a crush one of them has been hiding for years. The domestic scenes are lovely and Cassie is a much better sunshine heroine than most, but at roughly 100,000 words the book is longer than its plot, and the villain is pure cartoon.

Read it if you love grumpy sunshine with a sunshine character who has real depth, or slow evenings on the sofa as romance. Skip it if you need a believable business plot, or a moustache-twirling antagonist will pull you out.

Night & Day by Lily Seabrooke book cover

Night & Day at a Glance

Night & Day is book 4 of Lily Seabrooke's Taste of Port Andrea series, self-published on April 9, 2022. It is a sapphic grumpy sunshine romance between two roommates, runs about 371 pages in ebook, includes open-door scenes, and like the rest of the series stands on its own with a new couple.

AuthorLily Seabrooke
SeriesTaste of Port Andrea, book 4 (new couple; reads as a standalone)
SubgenreSapphic contemporary romance
Main tropesGrumpy sunshine, roommates, forced proximity, secret crush, business alliance
Spice level3/5: Moderate, some open door
Content warningsHomophobia, threats of outing, debt, difficult family (full list below)
EndingHappy ending for the couple
PagesAbout 371 (ebook), roughly 100,000 words
AudiobookNone at time of writing
First publishedApril 9, 2022
PublisherSelf-published

What Is Night & Day About?

Night & Day is set in Port Andrea, the fictional city at the heart of Lily Seabrooke's series. Parker Ferris runs a coffee supply business, and it is in trouble: a rival named Gary Founders is squeezing her, money is tight, and her family depends on her. So she does something she hates. She advertises for a roommate.

The roommate is Cassie Peterson, an upbeat Instagram lifestyle influencer who has quietly had a crush on Parker for years. Cassie's followers do not know she is gay. What starts as a grudging living arrangement turns into an alliance to save Parker's business, and the closer the two get, the harder it becomes for either of them to keep what she has hidden.

What Makes This Grumpy Sunshine Romance Work

Night & Day works because its sunshine character is not a gimmick. Cassie is bright and kind and very online, but she is also hiding a large part of herself from the audience that pays her bills, and that gives her optimism a cost. Courtney at Courtney Reads Romance praised exactly this, calling the contrast compassionate and noting that Cassie's energy never turns cartoonish.

The other hook is the flat. A lot of the romance happens in ordinary evenings: cooking, sniping, watching each other across the living room. Readers who love forced proximity for the domestic texture rather than the one bed will find plenty here. And Parker's grumpiness is well judged: she stays sarcastic, she just turns out to care under it, and a StoryGraph reviewer valued that her personality is never sanded off to make the romance work.

My Review

Night & Day is the kind of romance I want on a tired weeknight: two women in a small flat, slowly realising they are the best part of each other's day. I liked it a lot when it stayed indoors. Every time it left the flat to deal with Gary Founders, I liked it less.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is a slow simmer in a shared kitchen. Parker is irritated by Cassie at first, then irritated that she is not irritated anymore, and Seabrooke gets a lot of quiet comedy out of that progression. The Sapphic Book Review reviewer called the chemistry sizzling and enjoyed how the two women make each other better, and that second part is the truer description. This is a romance about two people improving each other's lives in small, concrete ways.

Cassie's long crush gives the book a pleasant tension. The reader knows she has been carrying a torch, Parker does not, and every scene where Parker accidentally says something kind lands twice. Courtney did feel there were lulls in the romance, and she is right: the middle drifts, especially in stretches where the business plot takes over.

The Characters

Cassie is the standout, and I was not alone. Amy Marsden, reviewing an early copy on StoryGraph, admitted she came out preferring Cassie, and Courtney praised how the book handles her being closeted to her followers, with care rather than melodrama. Her fear of being outed is real and the book takes it seriously.

What I liked most is that the book never sneers at her job. Influencer heroines are often written as a joke the plot gets to puncture, all ring lights and empty captions. Cassie works hard, understands her audience and knows exactly what coming out could cost her income, and Parker's early contempt for the whole business is treated as one more thing Parker is wrong about. That choice makes the power balance between them more interesting. In the flat, Parker is the one with the lease and the opinions. Online, Cassie is the one with the reach, and an alliance between them means Parker has to start taking that seriously.

Parker is a solid grump. She started her business partly, the blurb jokes, so she would not have to get out of bed, and the book is honest about her money worries and her family obligations. I believed her stress. I did not always believe her business. One StoryGraph reader questioned how the coffee supply plot actually works and found the resolution of the family debt too convenient, and I had the same reaction.

Then there is Gary. Courtney called him a thoroughly hateable antagonist who gets what is coming to him, which is fair, and some readers will enjoy hating him. I found him flat. He exists to be awful, and the book's real conflicts, Cassie's secret and Parker's walls, are far more interesting than anything he does.

Writing and Pacing

Seabrooke writes easy, funny dialogue and warm domestic scenes, and the returning Port Andrea characters add a sense of community that the Sapphic Book Review reviewer singled out. The weakness is length. Courtney noted it is the longest book in the series at around 100,000 words and felt it, and I agree that a tighter edit would have helped. It often feels like a shorter romance padded out with plot about coffee equipment.

The ending works. Amy Marsden responded well to it, and after all the business manoeuvring, the last chapters rightly come back to the two women and what they have been hiding.

Night & Day is a warm, funny roommates romance with a sunshine heroine worth meeting and a business plot that drags it out. Read it if you want domestic sapphic comfort; skip it if you need a tight plot and a believable villain.

How Spicy Is Night & Day?

Night & Day is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. The book's own content notes flag open-door sex scenes, and they are there once the relationship turns, but the romance leans on slow tension and domestic closeness more than heat. Courtney described the sexiness as slight, which matches our read of the balance.

Both women are adults and consent is clear. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from the author's notes, reader reports and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Night & Day?

Night & Day suits readers who want a cosy sapphic roommates romance with grumpy sunshine leads, moderate heat and a strong community cast. It is less suited to readers who want a fast pace, a credible business storyline or an antagonist with any nuance.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Night & Day has a small but very warm reader base, with Goodreads showing an average around 4.5 from a few hundred ratings. As a self-published title it has no trade reviews; coverage is mostly sapphic review blogs and reader reviews, including several from advance readers.

Where they agree. The pairing and the domestic scenes. Courtney Reads Romance gave it four stars as a sweet, cosy instalment with subtle humour and a careful handling of homophobia. Sapphic Book Review found it fun, sexy and sweet, and enjoyed the returning Port Andrea cast.

Where they split. The plot around the romance. Courtney found the Gary storyline less engaging and the book too long. A StoryGraph reviewer loved the domestic scenes and Parker's intact personality but found the villain familiar and the business and debt plots hard to believe.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Night & Day scores 7.5 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with strong marks for romance, characters and ending and lower scores for pacing and a villain who flattens the stakes.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Slow, domestic chemistry, per Courtney Reads Romance and Sapphic Book Review.
Characters (15%)4Cassie has real depth; Parker stays herself; Gary is a cartoon.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Easy dialogue, but around 100,000 words with lulls, per Courtney Reads Romance.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Cassie's secret carries weight; the business plot drains some of it.
Heat level (10%)3.5Delivers the moderate open-door heat its notes promise.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A satisfying finish that early readers responded to well.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5Cosy enough to revisit, long enough to skim.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Night & Day sits in the middle of the Taste of Port Andrea series: cosier than Fake It and longer than it needs to be, landing at a final Eikna Score of 7.5/10.

Taste of Port Andrea Reading Order

Night & Day is book 4 of Lily Seabrooke's Taste of Port Andrea series. Each book follows a new couple, so you can start here, but you will recognise more of the returning cast if you begin with Fake It.

  1. Book 1: Fake It (2021): Avery Lindt and Holly Mason
  2. Book 2: Last Chance (2021)
  3. Book 3: One Step at a Time (2022)
  4. Book 4: Night & Day (2022)
  5. Book 5: Every Rose (2022)

Best format: ebook, since there is no audiobook edition. Seabrooke's grumpy sunshine novella Reach the Stars is a quick palate cleanser between series books. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.

If You Loved Night & Day, Read These Next

If you loved Night & Day, look for sapphic romances with shared spaces, contrasting personalities and a warm community around the couple.

Frequently Asked Questions

Night & Day draws the same questions from most readers: how spicy it is, whether you need the earlier Port Andrea books, and whether there is an audiobook.

Is Night & Day by Lily Seabrooke spicy?

Moderately. Night & Day is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with open-door scenes once Parker and Cassie get together.

Do I need to read the Taste of Port Andrea books in order?

No. Night & Day is book 4 but follows a new couple, so it reads on its own; starting with Fake It just gives you more context for the returning cast.

Is Night & Day a grumpy sunshine romance?

Yes. Parker is the sarcastic, guarded grump and Cassie is the upbeat influencer who has had a crush on her for years.

Does Night & Day have a happy ending?

Yes. Night & Day ends happily for Parker and Cassie.

Is there a Night & Day audiobook?

No. Night & Day is available to read, but Lily Seabrooke's audiobooks so far cover only her Bayview series.

What are the content warnings for Night & Day?

The main ones are homophobia, threats of outing, debt and difficult family dynamics, plus open-door sex scenes.

The Bottom Line

Night & Day earns a 7.5/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a cosy, moderately steamy sapphic roommates romance and can forgive a long book and a flat villain. The reason to pick it up is Cassie, a sunshine heroine with a real secret and a lot of nerve, and the small, funny evenings she spends wearing down Parker.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.