eikna romance
Menu

Birding with Benefits by Sarah T. Dubb Review

Eikna Score: 7.2/10. Recommended.

Birding with Benefits is a gentle, grown-up debut about a divorced mom in her forties and a reserved birder who team up, then pretend to be a couple, for a six-week birding contest in Tucson. The birding is lovely and the leads feel like real adults, but the pacing is unhurried and Celeste's choices divide readers, so it suits patient readers more than trope-hunters.

Read it if you want romance between mature adults, a desert setting full of birds and a slow, kind fake relationship. Skip it if you need fast pacing, or a third-act breakup and a lot of parenting and divorce material will wear on you.

Birding with Benefits by Sarah T. Dubb book cover

Birding with Benefits at a Glance

Birding with Benefits is Sarah T. Dubb's 2024 debut, a standalone contemporary romance published by Gallery Books on June 4, 2024. It pairs a recently divorced 42-year-old mother with a quiet birder during a six-week birding competition in Tucson, Arizona, and it ends happily. The trade paperback runs 336 pages.

AuthorSarah T. Dubb
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreContemporary romance
Main tropesFake relationship, friends with benefits, romance after divorce, older leads, competition setting
Spice level3/5: Moderate, some open door
Content warningsDivorce, an ex's past infidelity, parenting strain, a third-act breakup (full list below)
POVThird person
EndingHEA
Pages336 (trade paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Mia Hutchinson-Shaw and Evan Sibley, 9 hours 57 minutes (Simon and Schuster Audio)
First publishedJune 4, 2024
PublisherGallery Books

What Is Birding with Benefits About?

Birding with Benefits follows Celeste Johanssen, a 42-year-old teacher who has left an unhappy marriage and is about to see her daughter off to college. For the first time in years, she wants to do something for herself.

John is a reserved, expert birder who needs a teammate for Tucson's big six-week birding competition so he can launch a guiding business. Through a misunderstanding, Celeste ends up agreeing to be both his teammate and his pretend girlfriend, though she knows nothing about birds. Out in the desert, the fake relationship starts to feel real, and the two strike a deal: a short-term arrangement that ends when the contest does. Then they have to decide whether it should.

What Makes This Fake Relationship Romance Work

Birding with Benefits works because the leads are adults with full lives. Celeste has a teenager, an ex-husband and a job; John has a business plan and a breakup he has not got over. The fake relationship gives them an excuse to spend time together, and the contest gives that time a shape. Kirkus called it a lovely debut about mature characters, comforting and sexy.

The second draw is the birding. Dubb clearly knows the hobby, and the competition is full of real birds, early mornings and desert landscapes. Kirkus praised the balance of birding detail and romance, and Kayne Spooner at All About Romance loved John's patient knowledge and his wish to help other people notice wildlife.

Third, it is about starting over. Celeste is not a young woman finding herself for the first time; she is a woman finding herself again, and the book takes that seriously.

My Review

Birding with Benefits is a quiet book, and I mean that mostly as praise. Sarah T. Dubb has written a romance in which a middle-aged woman learns to look at birds, at a man and at herself more carefully, and the pace matches the hobby: early starts, long waits, sudden flashes of color. It will not suit everyone. It suited me more often than not.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry is slow and grown-up. Celeste is chatty and eager; John is quiet and precise; and the contest throws them together for long days in the car and the field. The attraction grows out of watching each other be good at things, and that is a lovely way for a romance to build. Jessisreading at Cannonball Read, who discloses a friendship with the author, enjoyed the unhurried attention to the leads' inner lives, and that is the book's real register.

The friction comes from Celeste. Spooner at All About Romance had reservations about some of her behavior, and trow125 at The Saturday Reader noted her habit of pushing a partner's ambitions. An All About Romance commenter, nblibgirl, read the same behavior as enthusiasm rather than overbearing. I sat in between: Celeste's energy is endearing until it isn't, and the book knows it. There is a third-act breakup; faintingviolet at Cannonball Read found it earned, and so did I.

The Characters

Celeste is a well-drawn woman in transition, funny and a little reckless, with a daughter and an ex who keep pulling her back into old roles. John is the gentler pleasure: shy, expert and kind, the sort of hero who would rather point out a bird than talk about his feelings. Faintingviolet found their shared avoidance of relationships one-note after a while, and some of the dialogue sounded younger than the characters to her. I noticed that too.

The divorce and parenting material is substantial. Jeeves Reads Romance stopped around page 150, finding that focus and the third-person narration distancing. If you want romance front and center at all times, that is a fair warning.

Writing and Pacing

Dubb's prose is clean and observant, and her best writing is in the field, where the desert and the birds are vivid and specific. The pacing is gentle to a fault in the middle, and the six-week contest structure means some days blur together. The competition format is a smart engine for a slow romance, because it gives every chapter a small goal, a species to find or a place to be at dawn, even when the relationship is barely moving. It also gives Celeste a learning curve the reader shares; you come out knowing more about birding than you went in, without ever feeling lectured. The ending is warm and earned. Dubb later published a bonus epilogue on her Substack, which readers who want more of the couple can find after finishing.

Birding with Benefits is a warm, unhurried debut with real adults, real birds and a fake relationship that grows into something true. Read it if you want mature leads and a nature-rich setting; skip it if you need speed or a heroine who never oversteps.

How Spicy Is Birding with Benefits?

Birding with Benefits is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. All About Romance rated the sensuality warm, and a StoryGraph reader reported explicit sex. The love scenes come once the leads agree to their short-term arrangement and are consensual and affectionate.

Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Content warnings, drawn from reviews and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.

Who Should Read Birding with Benefits?

Birding with Benefits suits readers who want a gentle romance with leads in their forties, a fake relationship that turns real and a setting full of birds and desert light. It is less suited to readers who want quick pacing, a romance-only focus or no third-act breakup.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Birding with Benefits was well received as a debut. Kirkus gave it a Get It verdict and called it a lovely debut about mature characters, and All About Romance reviewed it warmly with reservations. Reader coverage is mostly blogs and StoryGraph reviews.

Where they agree. The birding and John. Kirkus praised the balance of birding and romance and a conflict rooted in emotional risk. Kayne Spooner at All About Romance loved John's knowledge and patience. Jessisreading at Cannonball Read enjoyed the attention to the leads' inner lives.

Where they split. Celeste and the pace. Spooner had reservations about Celeste's behavior, while an All About Romance commenter defended it. Trow125 at The Saturday Reader described the differences between the leads and the parenting tension. Faintingviolet at Cannonball Read found the avoidance plot one-note but the breakup earned. Jeeves Reads Romance did not finish, citing the divorce and parenting focus and the distancing narration.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Birding with Benefits scores 7.2 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for emotional impact and steady scores elsewhere for a gentle debut that some readers find slow.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5A slow, adult build praised by Kirkus; Celeste's choices split readers.
Characters (15%)3.5John charms per All About Romance; avoidance gets one-note per Cannonball Read.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Vivid field scenes; a soft middle and distancing narration for some.
Emotional impact (15%)4A conflict rooted in emotional risk, per Kirkus.
Heat level (10%)3.5Warm and open door, as All About Romance rated it.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5An earned HEA after a third-act breakup, per faintingviolet.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5A comforting reread for birders; less pull for others.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Birding with Benefits is one of the more thoughtful romances with older leads from 2024 and a promising debut, with a final Eikna Score of 7.2/10.

Is Birding with Benefits a Standalone?

Yes. Birding with Benefits is a standalone contemporary romance with a complete love story and a happy ending. Sarah T. Dubb has since shared a bonus epilogue for Celeste and John on her Substack, but it is optional reading, not part of the novel.

Best format: the audiobook works well, with Mia Hutchinson-Shaw and Evan Sibley sharing the narration over 9 hours 57 minutes, though print readers may enjoy looking up the birds as they go. Our series order guide covers connected romances if you want something longer.

If You Loved Birding with Benefits, Read These Next

If you loved Birding with Benefits, look for romances with grown-up leads, outdoor settings and relationships that start as arrangements.

Frequently Asked Questions

Birding with Benefits raises the same questions for most readers: how old the leads are, how spicy it is and how it ends. Short answers below.

How old is the heroine in Birding with Benefits?

Celeste is 42 in Birding with Benefits, a recently divorced mother whose daughter is leaving for college.

Is Birding with Benefits spicy?

Moderately. Birding with Benefits is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with open-door scenes that All About Romance rated warm.

Does Birding with Benefits have a happy ending?

Yes. Celeste and John get a happy ending after a third-act breakup.

Where is Birding with Benefits set?

Birding with Benefits is set in and around Tucson, Arizona, during a six-week birding competition.

Is Birding with Benefits a fake dating romance?

Yes. Celeste agrees to pose as John's girlfriend during the contest, and the arrangement turns real.

Is there a Birding with Benefits audiobook?

Yes. Mia Hutchinson-Shaw and Evan Sibley narrate the audiobook, which runs 9 hours 57 minutes.

The Bottom Line

Birding with Benefits earns a 7.2/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a gentle, sensual romance between grown-ups, a fake relationship that deepens slowly and a desert full of birds. The reason to pick it up is John, whose patient delight in showing someone a bird is one of the most romantic things in the book.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.