eikna romance
Menu

This Could Be Us by Kennedy Ryan Review

Eikna Score: 8.5/10. Highly recommended.

This Could Be Us is a divorce novel that earns its romance: Soledad Barnes has to lose the life she curated before she can want anything for herself, and Kennedy Ryan makes that loss feel as large as the love story. It runs long and a little overstuffed, and the villain is drawn in thick marker, but the payoff is one of the warmest in recent contemporary romance.

Read it if you want a grown woman rebuilding after betrayal, a patient single dad hero and a romance that takes its time. Skip it if you need a light rom-com, or a cheating spouse and financial ruin on page are too close to home.

This Could Be Us by Kennedy Ryan book cover

This Could Be Us at a Glance

This Could Be Us is book 2 of Kennedy Ryan's Skyland series, published by Forever in March 2024. It follows Soledad Barnes, an Atlanta wife and mother of three whose marriage collapses, and Judah Cross, the forensic accountant tied to her husband's downfall. It is told in dual first person, has steamy open-door scenes and ends happily.

AuthorKennedy Ryan
SeriesSkyland, book 2 (each book has a new couple)
SubgenreContemporary romance with women's fiction depth
Main tropesSecond chance at life, single parents, divorce romance, slow burn, found family of friends
Spice level4/5: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes
Content warningsInfidelity, emotional abuse, embezzlement, parental death, racism, seizures (full list below)
POVDual first person, Soledad and Judah
EndingHappy ending for Soledad and Judah, with Hendrix set up for book 3
Pages416 (trade paperback)
AudiobookHachette Audio, read by Ines del Castillo, Jakobi Diem and Kennedy Ryan, 12 hours 20 minutes
First publishedMarch 5, 2024
PublisherForever, an imprint of Grand Central Publishing (Hachette Book Group)

What Is This Could Be Us About?

This Could Be Us follows Soledad Barnes, who has spent nearly two decades running a beautiful house in Atlanta, raising three daughters and making her husband Edward's life look effortless. Then Edward's betrayal lands all at once, and it is financial as well as personal. The money is gone, the friends in their circle go quiet and Soledad has to provide for Lupe, Inez and Lottie with skills nobody ever paid her for.

Judah Cross is the forensic accountant whose work exposed Edward. He is also a divorced father raising twin sons, Adam and Aaron, who are autistic and need very different kinds of care. He wants Soledad from early on. Soledad, who has never had time to want anything, has to decide whether she can trust a man again, and whether she can trust herself to choose.

What Makes This Second Chance Romance Work

This Could Be Us works as a second chance romance because the second chance is Soledad's, not the couple's. She is not reuniting with an old flame. She is getting a second run at her own adult life, and the romance is what happens when she finally has the space to notice she is wanted.

That framing changes the pace. Judah is patient on purpose, and the book lets him be. There is no grand misunderstanding manufactured to keep them apart, just two parents with full calendars, real money problems and kids who come first. Readers who loved Yasmen and Josiah in Before I Let Go will recognise the method: Ryan takes a romance plot and runs it through therapy sessions, school pickups and business plans until it feels lived in.

The friend trio adds the rest. Soledad, Hendrix and Yasmen talk like women who have known each other for years, and their scenes give the book its humour. It is a found family story as much as a love story, and that is a big part of why readers come back to Skyland.

My Review

This Could Be Us is the kind of book I recommend with a caveat attached and then hear back about for weeks. It is long, it is heavy and it is not in a hurry. It is also the most complete portrait of a woman starting over that I have read in a romance in a while.

Kirkus was cool on it, arguing that the novel is stuck between romance and mainstream fiction and that the split weakens the energy of the plot. I understand the complaint and I still disagree with where it lands. The split is the point. Soledad's recovery is the plot, and the romance is her reward for doing the work.

Romance and Chemistry

The chemistry between Soledad and Judah is slow, adult and specific. He notices what she does for other people and starts doing it for her, and those small acts of attention say more than speeches would. Ryan writes desire well, and once the relationship turns physical the scenes are frank and plainly about consent and choice, which matters for a heroine coming out of a marriage where her wants were never asked about.

The tension is mostly external. Judah's job is tangled up with Edward's crimes, there are children on both sides and Soledad is not ready for a relationship when Judah is ready for one. The book respects that gap. Romance in Color gave it an A+ and called it one of the best stories the reviewer read that year; I would not go quite that far, but the payoff is earned, and the last act is warm without being sugary.

The Characters

Soledad is the reason to read. She is organised, proud, generous and very tired, and Ryan never mocks her for the years she spent on her family. Watching her work out how to provide for her girls on her own terms, using strengths nobody ever credited, is the most satisfying thread in the book. Her daughters feel like separate people, especially Lupe, the eldest.

Judah is a quieter hero than Josiah in book one. His relationship with his sons is the most moving material in the novel, and Ryan writes Adam and Aaron as individuals rather than as plot devices. Several bloggers singled out the autism representation as careful, and Lady Geeks Media called Ryan careful, precise and respectful in the way she handles hard subjects.

The weak link is Edward. Kirkus called him cartoonishly evil, and that is fair. He is useful as a force of chaos and almost never surprising. A messier, more human Edward would have made Soledad's choices harder and the book better.

Hendrix and Yasmen deserve a mention too. Hendrix in particular, a sharp, loyal entertainment manager, gets enough page time here to make her own book in the series feel inevitable.

Writing and Pacing

Ryan writes big feelings in big scenes, and she is very good at the moment a character finally says the thing. Kirkus credited her with angsty, even melodramatic stories, and that is the register here. The friend chats are quick and funny; the therapy and grief passages slow everything down, sometimes too much.

At 416 pages it sags in the middle. A few subplots could lose a chapter each. I never wanted to stop reading, but I did check how much was left. The audiobook helps: Ines del Castillo and Jakobi Diem split the dual first person, and Ryan is credited as a reader too, which suits a book this personal.

This Could Be Us is a long, generous divorce romance that cares more about a woman getting her life back than about speed. Read it if you loved Before I Let Go or want a heroine over forty, and give it the time it asks for.

How Spicy Is This Could Be Us?

This Could Be Us is a 4 out of 5 on our scale: Steamy, multiple explicit scenes. There are several explicit, consensual open-door scenes once Soledad and Judah get together, and they arrive after a long build. Ryan uses them to show Soledad learning to ask for what she wants, so they carry character weight as well as heat.

The darker material is not sexual. Edward's emotional cruelty, the fallout of his crimes and the grief Soledad carries all sit on page. Kennedy Ryan provides her own content guidance for the book, and Read and Wright and StoryGraph readers add to it. For more in this heat range, see our spicy romance list.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reports and reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and the romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Who Should Read This Could Be Us?

This Could Be Us suits readers who want a mature contemporary romance with a heroine rebuilding after divorce, a gentle single dad hero and plenty of friendship. It is less suited to readers who want a fast rom-com or a story without a cheating spouse in the background.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

This Could Be Us landed as one of the most discussed romances of spring 2024, and reader reception has been very warm. Romance in Color and Lady Geeks Media both called it one of the best books of their year, and She Reads Romance Books gave it five stars.

Where they agree. Almost everyone praises Soledad. Kirkus credited her steely determination to keep her family together, Publishers Weekly highlighted the family story and Judah's autistic twin sons, and Romance in Color gave the book an A+. Readers on StoryGraph and Goodreads talk about the friend group as much as the couple, and many say they cried.

Where they split. Genre and length. Kirkus felt the book was stuck between romance and mainstream fiction, and readers who wanted more romance per page agree that the first third moves slowly. Some, like Read and Wright, flag the heavy content load. Edward divides opinion less than he should: most readers simply hate him, which is part of the fun and part of the problem.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

This Could Be Us scores 8.5 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its top mark for emotional impact, where Soledad's recovery hits hardest, and its lowest for writing and pacing, which Kirkus and slower-reading fans fault for a long middle.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4.5Patient, adult chemistry; Romance in Color calls it one of the year's best.
Characters (15%)4.5Soledad and the twins are vivid; Kirkus finds Edward cartoonish.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Strong scenes, but Kirkus says the split focus drains plot energy.
Emotional impact (15%)5Grief, rebuilding and friendship; Lady Geeks Media calls it a must-read.
Heat level (10%)4Open-door scenes deliver after a long build, tied to Soledad's growth.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4A warm, earned happy ending; Romance in Color reads it as HFN.
Reread appeal (10%)4StoryGraph readers revisit it for the friend group and Judah.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: This Could Be Us sits just behind Before I Let Go in the Skyland series, slightly longer and less focused but with a more original heroine, and lands at a final Eikna Score of 8.5/10.

Skyland Series Reading Order

This Could Be Us is book 2 of Kennedy Ryan's Skyland series. Each book follows a different woman from the same Atlanta friend group and has its own happy ending, so you can start here, but reading in order shows the friendships growing.

  1. Book 1: Before I Let Go (2022): Yasmen and Josiah
  2. Book 2: This Could Be Us (2024): Soledad and Judah
  3. Book 3: Can't Get Enough (2025): Hendrix's story

Best format: the Hachette audiobook, with Ines del Castillo voicing Soledad and Jakobi Diem voicing Judah, suits the dual first person. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.

If You Loved This Could Be Us, Read These Next

If you loved This Could Be Us, the closest matches are emotional contemporary romances about adults rebuilding, with strong friendships and real family stakes.

Frequently Asked Questions

This Could Be Us raises the same questions for most new readers: whether it stands alone, how spicy it is, whether it ends happily and what to read before it. Short answers below.

Is This Could Be Us a standalone?

It is book 2 of the Skyland series but has its own couple and a complete ending. You can read it first, though Before I Let Go introduces the friend group.

Is This Could Be Us spicy?

Yes. We rate it 4 out of 5, with several explicit, consensual open-door scenes after a slow build.

Does This Could Be Us have a happy ending?

Yes. Soledad and Judah end together, and the book closes on a warm note with Hendrix set up for the next book.

Who is the hero of This Could Be Us?

Judah Cross, a forensic accountant and divorced father of autistic twin sons, Adam and Aaron.

Is there a This Could Be Us audiobook?

Yes. Hachette Audio published it, read by Ines del Castillo, Jakobi Diem and Kennedy Ryan, at about 12 hours 20 minutes.

What comes after This Could Be Us?

Can't Get Enough, Skyland book 3, follows Hendrix, Soledad's best friend.

The Bottom Line

This Could Be Us earns a 8.5/10 and a Highly recommended badge. It is for readers who want a long, emotional divorce romance with a heroine finding herself and a hero who waits for her to be ready. The one reason to pick it up is Soledad: few romance heroines get this much room to rebuild a whole life.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.