The Friend Zone by Abby Jimenez Review
Eikna Score: 8.4/10. Recommended.
The Friend Zone is the debut that made Abby Jimenez's name: a laugh-out-loud rom-com that turns, without warning, into one of the most painful books about infertility and grief in the genre. Kristen's silence drags the middle, and the epilogue divides readers, but the jokes, the tears and Josh Copeland's decency are all real.
Read it if you want sharp banter, a sweet firefighter hero and a story that will make you cry in public. Skip it if infertility or sudden loss is too raw for you right now, or a heroine who keeps a big secret from her partner drives you up the wall.
The Friend Zone at a Glance
The Friend Zone is Abby Jimenez's 2019 debut romance and book 1 of her Friend Zone series, published by Forever. It is a funny, emotional friends to lovers romantic comedy about infertility and loss, with moderate open-door heat and a happily ever after.
| Author | Abby Jimenez |
|---|---|
| Series | The Friend Zone, book 1 (works as a standalone) |
| Subgenre | Romantic comedy with heavy emotional themes |
| Main tropes | Friends to lovers, wedding party, best man and maid of honor, secret keeping, he wants kids and she cannot |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Infertility, planned hysterectomy, sudden death, grief, pregnancy (full list below) |
| POV | First person, alternating Kristen and Josh |
| Ending | HEA, with an epilogue |
| Pages | 384 (trade paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Erin Mallon and Teddy Hamilton, about 9 hours 30 minutes (Hachette Audio) |
| First published | June 11, 2019 |
| Publisher | Forever (Grand Central Publishing) |
What Is The Friend Zone About?
The Friend Zone follows Kristen Peterson, who is blunt, loyal, allergic to drama and busy planning her best friend Sloan's wedding. Kristen meets Josh Copeland in a minor car collision, and it turns out he is the best man: a funny, easygoing firefighter who works with Sloan's fiancé, Brandon.
Kristen has a boyfriend deployed overseas, so Josh goes straight into the friend zone. She also has a secret. A medical condition means she will soon need a procedure that makes pregnancy impossible, and Josh wants a big family more than almost anything. When their friendship turns physical, Kristen insists it can only ever be casual.
What Makes This Friends to Lovers Romance Work
The Friend Zone works as a friends to lovers romance because the obstacle is not a misunderstanding. It is a real, unfixable difference in what two people want from life. Kristen cannot have children, Josh wants them, and the book does not pretend that love cancels that out.
The second hook is the tonal whiplash, which is the whole point. The first half is a fast, filthy-mouthed rom-com with a giant dog named Stuntman Mike, and Library Journal praised its zingy dialog and laugh-out-loud humor. Then tragedy strikes the wedding party, and the book becomes something much heavier.
Publishers Weekly, in a starred review, said readers who have wrestled with infertility would find Kristen's anxieties and sorrows deeply relatable. That recognition is why so many readers press this book on their friends. For more stories where friendship turns into something bigger, see our friends to lovers hub.
My Review
I laughed harder at the first hundred pages of The Friend Zone than at most rom-coms I have read this year, and then I cried on a train. That is the Abby Jimenez experience, and this is where it started. The book is not perfectly built. It is honest in a way that makes the flaws easy to forgive.
Romance and Chemistry
Kristen and Josh are funny together from the first scene, and the banter does a lot of the early work. Josh is unbothered by her sarcasm and her temper, and he feeds her when she is hungry, which in this book counts as a love language. Kirkus said his easygoing resourcefulness balances Kristen's sharp, assertive personality, and that is the dynamic in a sentence.
The romance gets harder when it gets serious. Kristen keeps Josh at arm's length because she has already decided what he wants and that she cannot give it to him. That choice drives the middle of the book, and how you feel about it will decide how you feel about the romance.
The Characters
Kristen is a great comic heroine and a frustrating romantic one. Kirkus felt her refusal to be open made her seem more immature than self-sacrificing, and a StoryGraph reviewer, amanda_reads13, was frustrated that she sends mixed signals and denies Josh the chance to decide for himself. I agree, and I also understand her. The book is clear that her silence comes from grief about her own body, not game playing.
Josh is the reason the book works. He is patient, kind and wrecked by being shut out, and his chapters are where the heartbreak lands. Sloan, Kristen's best friend, is the other standout; the same StoryGraph reader praised how Sloan stays a strong, supportive friend through her own loss, and her story continues in The Happy Ever After Playlist.
Writing and Pacing
Jimenez's dialogue is the book's engine. It is quick, crude, specific and very funny, and Entertainment Weekly praised her zippy, instantly recognizable voice. The alternating first person keeps the momentum up, and the comic set pieces, many involving Stuntman Mike, are genuinely great.
The middle third sags under Kristen's back-and-forth, and the shift into grief is abrupt by design but still jolting. Then there is the epilogue. Without spoiling it, it takes the book's hard-won acceptance of one future and complicates it, and some readers, including amanda_reads13, felt it undercut the story's message about loving someone for who they are. I felt that too.
The Friend Zone is a hilarious, devastating debut with a hero you will want to protect and a heroine you will sometimes want to shake. Read it if you want to laugh and cry in the same chapter, and go in braced for an epilogue that splits readers.
How Spicy Is The Friend Zone?
The Friend Zone is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. There are several on-page sex scenes once Kristen and Josh start sleeping together, written with the same frank, funny voice as the rest of the book, but they are not the focus.
Both leads are adults and consent is clear throughout. Our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Content warnings, drawn from the publisher, Kirkus and reader reports:
- Infertility and a medically necessary hysterectomy
- Sudden death of a major secondary character
- Grief and mourning on page
- Pregnancy
- A heroine with a partner deployed overseas at the start
- Strong language throughout
- On-page sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists.
Who Should Read The Friend Zone?
The Friend Zone suits readers who want a funny, emotional friends to lovers rom-com that takes infertility and grief seriously, with a warm firefighter hero and moderate heat. It is less suited to readers who need a light, low-stakes read or who are currently living through fertility struggles or a fresh loss.
Best for:
- Readers who love a rom-com with real emotional weight
- Fans of friends to lovers with sharp banter
- Anyone who wants an honest look at infertility in romance
- Readers who like kind, patient heroes
Not for:
- Readers for whom infertility or sudden death is a current trigger
- Anyone who hates a heroine keeping a major secret
- Readers who want a purely light romantic comedy
- Anyone who wants high heat (try our spicy picks)
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
The Friend Zone was one of the most praised romance debuts of 2019. Booklist and Publishers Weekly gave it starred reviews, Kirkus called it an excellent debut that combines wit, humor and emotional intensity, and Library Journal, Entertainment Weekly and NPR all praised it, according to the publisher. Harlequin Junkie named it a Top Pick.
Where they agree. The mix of humor and heartbreak. Almost every review comes back to the same thing: Jimenez makes you laugh and then flattens you. Kirkus praised how she handles hard issues with depth and sensitivity, and the audiobook got its own praise, with Kirkus describing narrators Erin Mallon and Teddy Hamilton as bursting with chemistry. Where they split. Kristen and the epilogue. Kirkus thought Kristen's lack of openness made her seem immature. Reader reviewers, like amanda_reads13 on StoryGraph, found her mixed signals frustrating and the epilogue predictable and far-fetched, asking why women's worth so often comes back to having children. Other readers find the same epilogue cathartic.The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
The Friend Zone scores 8.4 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with top marks for emotional impact and writing and lower marks for heat and an ending that splits readers.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4.5 | Funny, warm chemistry; Kristen's distance strains the middle, per Kirkus. |
| Characters (15%) | 4 | Josh and Sloan shine; Kristen frustrates, per Kirkus and amanda_reads13 on StoryGraph. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 4.5 | Zingy, laugh-out-loud dialogue, per Library Journal; a saggy middle. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 5 | Infertility and grief written with real depth, per Publishers Weekly and Kirkus. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Moderate open-door heat that suits the story without leading it. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A true HEA, but the epilogue divides readers, per amanda_reads13 on StoryGraph. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 4 | The comedy rereads well; the grief is hard to revisit. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Friend Zone is the book that launched Abby Jimenez and remains one of her most emotional, sitting near the top of her catalogue and landing at a final Eikna Score of 8.4/10.
The Friend Zone Series Reading Order
The Friend Zone is book 1 of Abby Jimenez's Friend Zone series. Each book follows a different couple and finishes its own romance, but book 2 picks up Sloan's story after the events of this one, so reading in order matters more than usual.
- Book 1: The Friend Zone (2019): Kristen and Josh
- Book 2: The Happy Ever After Playlist (2020): Sloan and Jason
- Book 3: Life's Too Short (2021): Vanessa and Adrian
Best format: audio is excellent here, with two narrators who Kirkus praised for comic timing and emotional delivery; print works just as well. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved The Friend Zone, Read These Next
If you loved The Friend Zone, look for romantic comedies that mix big laughs with real grief or illness, starting with the rest of the series.
- The Happy Ever After Playlist by Abby Jimenez: Sloan's story, about grief, a musician and a dog that brings them together.
- Life's Too Short by Abby Jimenez: book 3, a funny, sad romance about illness and living now.
- Part of Your World by Abby Jimenez: a doctor and a small-town carpenter, with Jimenez's trademark mix of humor and hurt.
- Yours Truly by Abby Jimenez: a letters romance between two doctors, with a kidney donation at its heart.
- Before I Let Go by Kennedy Ryan: a second chance romance about two people rebuilding after devastating loss.
Frequently Asked Questions
The Friend Zone prompts the same questions from most readers: how spicy it is, whether it is sad, whether it stands alone and how it ends. Short answers below.
Is The Friend Zone by Abby Jimenez spicy?
Moderately. The Friend Zone is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with several open-door scenes that are not the main focus.
Is The Friend Zone sad?
Yes, in parts. The Friend Zone starts as a comedy and then deals with infertility and the sudden death of a major character, so expect to cry.
Is The Friend Zone a standalone?
It completes Kristen and Josh's romance, but it is book 1 of a series and sets up Sloan's story in The Happy Ever After Playlist.
Does The Friend Zone have a happy ending?
Yes. Kristen and Josh get a happily ever after, though the epilogue divides readers.
Is there an audiobook of The Friend Zone?
Yes. Hachette Audio published it with Erin Mallon and Teddy Hamilton narrating, running about 9 hours 30 minutes.
What order should I read the Friend Zone series in?
Read The Friend Zone, then The Happy Ever After Playlist, then Life's Too Short.
The Bottom Line
The Friend Zone earns an 8.4/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a sharp, funny friends to lovers rom-com that is not afraid to break their heart over infertility and loss, and who can forgive a heroine who hides too much for too long. The reason to pick it up is the mix: few debuts are this funny and this sad at once.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.