The Happy Ever After Playlist by Abby Jimenez Review
Eikna Score: 7.4/10. Recommended.
The Happy Ever After Playlist is a funny, aching romance about a grieving artist and a touring musician who meet because his dog jumps into her car. Its portrait of grief is honest and its first half is close to perfect; its second half leans on separations, a deception and a secondary woman used mainly as an obstacle.
Read it if you want a love after loss story with real humor, a sweet dog and a musician hero, or you loved The Friend Zone. Skip it if repeated breakups and a hero who lies will frustrate you, or you want to avoid grief and self-harm themes.
The Happy Ever After Playlist at a Glance
The Happy Ever After Playlist is the second Friend Zone novel by Abby Jimenez, published by Forever on April 14, 2020. Sloan Monroe and musician Jason share the first person narration as she climbs out of grief and he chases a music career. Heat is mild and the book ends with a happily ever after epilogue.
| Author | Abby Jimenez |
|---|---|
| Series | The Friend Zone, book 2 (can be read alone, but book 1 is spoiled) |
| Subgenre | Contemporary romance, romantic comedy |
| Main tropes | Love after loss, musician hero, meet-cute with a dog, long distance, career versus love |
| Spice level | 2/5: Mild, fade to black |
| Content warnings | Grief, self-harm, unwanted sexual touching (full list below) |
| POV | Dual first person, Sloan and Jason |
| Ending | HEA with an epilogue |
| Pages | 400 (Forever paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Erin Mallon and Zachary Webber, 9 hours 17 minutes (Hachette Audio) |
| First published | April 14, 2020 |
| Publisher | Forever, an imprint of Grand Central Publishing (Hachette Book Group) |
What Is The Happy Ever After Playlist About?
Two years after her fiancé died, Sloan Monroe is still barely living. She has stopped painting, stopped going out and mostly stopped hoping. Then, stopped at a light, a big, scruffy dog jumps into her car and refuses to leave.
Sloan takes in the dog, Tucker, while she tracks down his owner. That owner turns out to be Jason, a musician who is on tour in Australia, and their calls and texts about the dog turn into something neither expected. When Jason comes home, Sloan has to decide whether she can risk loving someone again, and Jason has to decide what he will give up for a career that is about to take off.
What Makes This Love After Loss Romance Work
The Happy Ever After Playlist works because Abby Jimenez takes grief seriously without letting it smother the comedy. Sloan is funny even at her lowest, and the book shows the slow, uneven return of her appetite for life: painting again, laughing again, getting dressed for something. Kirkus valued that healing and the tension between Jason's touring and Sloan's return to art.
The meet-cute is the other draw. A runaway dog jumping into a stranger's car is a great romantic comedy opening, and the long-distance phase that follows, two people getting to know each other through texts, calls and playlists, is the strongest stretch of the book. Every chapter is headed with a song, which After the Last Page enjoyed.
Publishers Weekly praised the vulnerable characters and the humor, and Charlotte Elliott at All About Romance gave the love story a passionate recommendation. If you want a romance that can make you cry and laugh within a page, this is a strong pick.
My Review
I liked the first half of The Happy Ever After Playlist as much as almost any contemporary romance I have read in the last few years. Sloan's voice is sharp and sad and funny, Jason is charming over a long-distance phone line, and Tucker the dog deserves a spinoff. The book understands how grief makes a person rude, tired and strange, and it lets Sloan be all of those.
The second half is where I started arguing with it. Jimenez separates the couple more than once, gives Jason a secret he keeps far too long, and leans on a secondary woman, Lola, as a source of trouble. Charlotte Elliott at All About Romance summed it up in one line I agree with: the book "is not perfect." It is still worth reading.
Romance and Chemistry
Sloan and Jason have a lovely, slow-building chemistry while he is on the other side of the world. The romance works because Jason meets Sloan where she is, patient with her grief and serious about her art. All About Romance found the romance convincing and noted how willing both are to rearrange their lives for each other, and Jaclyn at Literary Treats valued the practical career conflict over celebrity melodrama.
The trouble is the back half. All the Books I Can Read found the repeated separations exhausting, and rovinja on r/RomanceBooks enjoyed the early chemistry but rejected the later deception and reunion. All About Romance called Jason's dishonesty toward Sloan nearly unbelievable. I agree: the lie exists to generate a third act, and Jason is too decent elsewhere for it to feel like character. Romance Reader enjoyed watching them try to combine their lives but disliked how dependent the relationship becomes.
The Characters
Sloan is the book's triumph. Her grief is specific and unglamorous, and her friends, including Kristen and Josh from The Friend Zone, give her a believable support system. Lubnaa at Romance Library valued the grief portrayal, and After the Last Page found the grief more convincing than the romantic idealization, which is roughly where I land.
Jason is warm, funny and a little too good on paper until he is suddenly not. The real problem is Lola, a singer from Jason's past. All About Romance said she is mostly a plot device and treated unpleasantly until the final act, Lubnaa challenged how she is used, and mspilesofpaper on The StoryGraph objected to her portrayal and the speed of her redemption. The book means well by her eventually, but the late turn does not undo three hundred pages of her as an obstacle.
Writing and Pacing
Jimenez writes fast, funny dialogue and very good emotional scenes. The dual first person lets Jason's side of the career story breathe. Tree at Words About Words objected to the time jumps and how fast the relationship moves in places, and I felt the jumps most in the middle, when the book skips over periods I wanted to see.
At four hundred pages it is long for a rom com, and the length comes mostly from the cycle of separation and reunion. Sam Still Reading welcomed the emotional intensity and hopeful payoff, and the epilogue, which All About Romance praised, is satisfying on both the personal and the professional side.
The Happy Ever After Playlist is a funny, honest love after loss romance with a near-perfect first half and a frustrating, overlong second. Read it for Sloan, the dog and the long-distance courtship, and brace for the third act.
How Spicy Is The Happy Ever After Playlist?
The Happy Ever After Playlist is a 2 out of 5 on our scale: Mild, fade to black. There are a small number of sex scenes, brief and told from Sloan's side. All About Romance described the sex as minimal, and most of the book's heat lives in tension, phone calls and kissing.
Readers who want more heat from Abby Jimenez will find more of it in some of her later books. See our closed door romance list for more low-heat picks.
Content warnings, drawn from Tree at Words About Words and reader reviews:
- Grief after the death of a fiancé
- Self-harm, flagged by Tree at Words About Words
- Unwanted sexual touching, including unwanted public touching of a secondary character
- Celebrity harassment
- Deception within the relationship
- Brief sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.
Who Should Read The Happy Ever After Playlist?
The Happy Ever After Playlist suits readers who want a funny, emotional contemporary romance about grief and second chances at love, with a musician hero and a dog. It suits readers less well if they dislike repeated separations, deception or secondary characters used as obstacles.
Best for:
- Readers who loved The Friend Zone
- Fans of love after loss stories
- Anyone who loves musicians, playlists and long-distance courtships
- Dog lovers
Not for:
- Readers who dislike breakups and makeups in the third act
- Anyone who will not forgive a hero who lies
- Readers avoiding grief or self-harm themes
- Those who want high heat
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
The Happy Ever After Playlist drew some of the strongest trade reviews of its year for a romance: starred reviews from Publishers Weekly, Kirkus and Booklist, with Kirkus calling it "a perfect blend of smart, heart-wrenching, and fun." Reader opinion is warmer on the first half than the second.
Where they agree. Grief and humor. Publishers Weekly praised the vulnerable characters and humor, Kirkus valued Sloan's healing, and Lubnaa at Romance Library and Sam Still Reading both praised the emotional arc. Jaclyn at Literary Treats liked the grounded career conflict, and All About Romance strongly recommended the love story and its HEA epilogue.
Where they split. The second half and Lola. All the Books I Can Read found the separations exhausting, rovinja on r/RomanceBooks rejected the deception and reunion, and Tree at Words About Words disliked the time jumps. All About Romance, Romance Library and mspilesofpaper on The StoryGraph all criticized how Lola is used, and After the Last Page found the romance more idealized than the grief.
The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
The Happy Ever After Playlist scores 7.4 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its best marks for romance and emotional impact and its lowest for characters, writing and the ending, where Lola and a cycle of separations drag it down.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 4 | Convincing, warm romance per All About Romance; the late deception strains it. |
| Characters (15%) | 3.5 | Sloan is superb; several reviewers object to how Lola is used. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Funny and emotional; Words About Words dislikes the time jumps and the length shows. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 4 | Grief rendered honestly, praised by Kirkus and Romance Library. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Mild heat that fits the story, as All About Romance notes. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A satisfying HEA epilogue, reached through repeated separations readers found tiring. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3.5 | The first half is a joy to revisit; the second half less so. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Happy Ever After Playlist is the most emotional book in the Friend Zone series, more uneven than The Friend Zone but with a stronger heroine, and it earns a final Eikna Score of 7.4/10.
The Friend Zone Reading Order
The Happy Ever After Playlist is book 2 of Abby Jimenez's Friend Zone series. It can be read on its own, but its premise reveals the ending of The Friend Zone, and Sloan and the Friend Zone couple are introduced there. Read in order:
- Book 1: The Friend Zone (2019): Kristen and Josh
- Book 2: The Happy Ever After Playlist (2020): Sloan and Jason
- Book 3: Life's Too Short (2021): Vanessa and Adrian
Best format: the Hachette Audio edition splits the narration between Erin Mallon as Sloan and Zachary Webber as Jason. All About Romance rated Mallon's performance highly and Webber's less so, finding him too young-sounding for the adult men. Print is a safe choice if that matters to you. Our series order guide covers more connected series.
If You Loved The Happy Ever After Playlist, Read These Next
If you loved The Happy Ever After Playlist, look for romances that pair grief with humor, and for more of Abby Jimenez's connected books.
- The Friend Zone by Abby Jimenez: the first book, with Kristen, Josh and the events that shape Sloan's story.
- Part of Your World by Abby Jimenez: a doctor and a small-town carpenter, with Jimenez's mix of humor and heartache.
- Yours Truly by Abby Jimenez: a romance told partly through letters, with a heroine at a low point.
- Thank You for Listening by Julia Whelan: a narrator coming back to life after loss, with a voice-only flirtation.
- Love and Other Words by Christina Lauren: a romance shaped by grief and a long separation.
Frequently Asked Questions
The Happy Ever After Playlist draws a few common questions: is it spicy, do you need The Friend Zone first, how does it end and who narrates the audiobook. Short answers below.
Is The Happy Ever After Playlist spicy?
Only mildly. The Happy Ever After Playlist is a 2 out of 5 on our scale, with a few brief sex scenes told from Sloan's side.
Do I need to read The Friend Zone first?
Not strictly, but The Happy Ever After Playlist reveals how The Friend Zone ends, so read that first if you want to avoid the spoiler.
Does The Happy Ever After Playlist have a happy ending?
Yes. The Happy Ever After Playlist ends with a happily ever after and an epilogue.
Whose point of view is The Happy Ever After Playlist told from?
The book alternates first person chapters between Sloan and Jason.
Who narrates The Happy Ever After Playlist audiobook?
Erin Mallon and Zachary Webber narrate the Hachette Audio edition, which runs about 9 hours 17 minutes.
What are the content warnings for The Happy Ever After Playlist?
The main ones are grief after a partner's death, self-harm, unwanted sexual touching and deception in the relationship.
The Bottom Line
The Happy Ever After Playlist earns a 7.4/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a funny, honest romance about loving again after loss, and who can sit through a frustrating third act. The one reason to pick it up is Sloan, whose climb out of grief is as warm and believable as anything in Abby Jimenez's catalogue.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- The Happy Ever After Playlist audiobook, Libro.fm (narrators, length)
- The Happy Ever After Playlist audiobook, Blackstone Library (trade review quotes)
- The Happy Ever After Playlist, All About Romance (Charlotte Elliott)
- Abby Jimenez books in order, She Reads Romance Books
- The Friend Zone series guide, The Literary Lifestyle
- Publishers Weekly and Kirkus Reviews reviews
- Jaclyn, Literary Treats; Romance Reader; Tree, Words About Words; Lubnaa, Romance Library; All the Books I Can Read; Sam Still Reading; After the Last Page (blog reviews)
- rovinja on r/RomanceBooks and mspilesofpaper on The StoryGraph (reader reviews)
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.