eikna romance
Menu

The Impossible Us by Sarah Lotz Review

Eikna Score: 6.8/10. Recommended with reservations.

The Impossible Us is a clever, funny, unsettling love story told largely through emails between two people who turn out to live in parallel versions of England. The banter is a joy and the premise is handled with real wit, but the book turns darker and stranger than its cover suggests and does not end like a conventional romance.

Read it if you love epistolary books, witty middle-aged leads and speculative premises that go somewhere unexpected. Skip it if you need a guaranteed happily ever after, or infidelity and manipulation between the leads will sink the romance for you.

The Impossible Us by Sarah Lotz book cover

The Impossible Us at a Glance

The Impossible Us is a standalone speculative love story by Sarah Lotz, published in the US by Ace in March 2022 and in the UK as Impossible. Nick, a struggling freelance editor, and Bee, who upcycles wedding dresses, fall for each other by email before discovering they live in different universes. It alternates their points of view, has very little heat and ends openly.

AuthorSarah Lotz
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreScience fiction romance, speculative love story
Main tropesPen pals, epistolary, parallel worlds, soulmates, older leads
Spice level1/5: Kisses only / closed door
Content warningsInfidelity, suicide, emotional abuse in a marriage, manipulation (full list below)
POVAlternating Nick and Bee, with emails and messages
EndingOpen and bittersweet, not a conventional HEA
Pages496 (US paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Olivia Dowd, Clifford Samuel and Paul Tyreman, about 13 hours
First publishedMarch 22, 2022 (US)
PublisherAce (Penguin Random House)

What Is The Impossible Us About?

Nick Belcher is 45, a freelance editor and failed novelist with a failing marriage. Bee Davies is 39, makes a living upcycling wedding dresses and is not looking for anything. An email meant for someone else lands in Bee's inbox, she replies with a spiky put-down, and Nick writes back.

Their messages become the best part of both their days, and soon they agree to meet. They pick a place and a time, both show up, and neither finds the other. The reason is not a missed train. They live in two versions of the world that are almost, but not quite, the same.

What Makes This Parallel Worlds Romance Work

The Impossible Us works because its parallel worlds premise turns the oldest romance obstacle, distance, into something literal and strange. Nick and Bee are separated by physics, and everything they do to close the gap raises the stakes.

The second hook is the emails. Kirkus praised the witty, romantic exchanges, and Jayne at Dear Author laughed through the opening screed and the early banter. Nima at That's What I'm Talking About gave the premise and writing an A plus. The voices are sharp, funny and unmistakably British.

Then there are the leads. Nick and Bee are older than most romance couples, flawed and funny, and Publishers Weekly found their connection sincere and tender. If you like your love stories clever and a little dangerous, this one delivers that.

My Review

The Impossible Us is not the book its cover promises, and I suspect that is why it splits readers. It starts as a sparkling email romance and turns into something stranger and darker, about what people will do to get what they want. I found it gripping and occasionally hard to like.

Romance and Chemistry

The romance is emotional rather than physical; Marlene Harris at Reading Reality described it as an emotional romance, if not a physical one. Through emails Nick and Bee become each other's confidants, and the writing makes you believe in the connection. Publishers Weekly called it simply delightful.

Then the plot complicates things. Nick is married, unhappily, and the book does not hide that what he and Bee are doing is a kind of infidelity. Later choices involve manipulation of other people, including other versions of themselves. Jayne at Dear Author found the lying and manipulation uncomfortable enough that she stopped sympathizing with their setbacks, and Marlene Harris felt the romance marketing would mislead readers. I would not call this a romance in the genre sense, and I would not want anyone to pick it up expecting one.

The Characters

Nick is self-pitying and very funny about it, a man whose life has stalled in almost every way. Bee is spiky, independent and warmer than she lets on. Jayne at Dear Author liked that both are well rounded, flawed and older than usual.

The supporting characters in both worlds are a highlight. Kirkus enjoyed them, and Publishers Weekly praised the quirky cast and sharp humor. The counterpart versions of familiar people are where the premise gets most unsettling.

Writing and Pacing

Lotz writes with real wit, and the epistolary structure gives the book momentum. Kirkus said she makes a confusing concept fun, which is fair: the science is hand-waved, but the rules are clear enough to follow.

At nearly 500 pages the book is long, and the second half shifts gears. Jayne at Dear Author felt it could not decide what it wanted to be, and Nima found the resolution more predictable than the build-up. The audiobook uses three narrators, Olivia Dowd, Clifford Samuel and Paul Tyreman, which suits the email format.

The Impossible Us is a witty, inventive love story across parallel worlds that turns darker than expected and ends without a neat bow. Read it for the emails and the premise; skip it if you need a genre romance with a guaranteed happy ending.

How Spicy Is The Impossible Us?

The Impossible Us is a 1 out of 5 on our scale: Kisses only / closed door. Most of the relationship happens in writing, and Marlene Harris at Reading Reality described it as emotional rather than physical.

The heavier content is in the choices people make. Jayne at Dear Author flagged infidelity, suicide and emotional abuse in a partnership, and the manipulation of other versions of people is a central ethical problem in the book.

Content warnings, drawn from critics and reader reviews:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and our heat levels guide explains the full scale.

Who Should Read The Impossible Us?

The Impossible Us suits readers who want a clever, funny, epistolary love story with a speculative twist and flawed older leads, and who are fine with an open ending. It is less suited to readers who want a genre romance with a clear happily ever after or leads who always behave well.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The Impossible Us drew warm trade reviews and a split among romance readers. Publishers Weekly called it simply delightful and Kirkus called it clever and thought-provoking, while romance-focused reviewers were more divided.

Where they agree. The emails and the premise. Kirkus, Nima at That's What I'm Talking About and Marlene Harris at Reading Reality all praised the banter. Joanne P at Booklover Book Reviews, Judith McKinnon and What Steph Is Reading enjoyed the originality, and Robert McGrath reviewed it warmly. Where they split. Whether it is a romance, and the ending. Jayne at Dear Author gave it a C plus and disliked the manipulation and the ending, though commenters there were warmer, and one called the ending ambiguous but hopeful. Marlene Harris found no shared happy ending. Nima found the resolution predictable but satisfying.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The Impossible Us scores 6.8 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with high marks for writing and fair marks for romance and characters, and lower marks for the ending and reread appeal.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Sincere, tender connection by email, per Publishers Weekly; infidelity complicates it.
Characters (15%)3.5Flawed, funny older leads and a strong cast, per Kirkus and Dear Author.
Writing and pacing (15%)4Witty epistolary writing, per Kirkus; a long second half.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Engrossing but uneasy, per Dear Author.
Heat level (10%)3Minimal heat, honestly emotional rather than physical.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3Open and bittersweet; romance readers split, per Reading Reality.
Reread appeal (10%)3The emails reread well; the plot loses its surprise.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Impossible Us is one of the most inventive speculative love stories of recent years and a weaker fit as a genre romance, with a final Eikna Score of 6.8/10.

Is The Impossible Us a Standalone?

Yes. The Impossible Us is a standalone novel, published outside North America as Impossible. Sarah Lotz is better known for horror and thrillers, and nothing else is needed to follow this story, so you can start here.

Best format: print or ebook, where the emails are easy to scan, or the three-narrator audiobook. Our HEA and HFN guide explains how we label endings like this one.

If You Loved The Impossible Us, Read These Next

If you loved The Impossible Us, try these love stories built on letters, time and impossible distances.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Impossible Us raises a few common questions about the ending, heat and genre. Short answers below.

Does The Impossible Us have a happy ending?

Not a conventional one. The Impossible Us ends openly and somewhat bittersweetly, and readers disagree on how hopeful it is.

Is The Impossible Us a romance?

It is a love story with a speculative premise, but it does not follow genre romance rules, and several reviewers felt the romance label misleads.

Is The Impossible Us spicy?

No. The Impossible Us is a 1 out of 5 on our scale; the relationship is mostly emotional and conducted by email.

Is there cheating in The Impossible Us?

Yes. Nick is married when he and Bee start writing, and infidelity is part of the story.

Is The Impossible Us the same book as Impossible?

Yes. Impossible is the title used outside the US and Canada.

Who narrates The Impossible Us audiobook?

Olivia Dowd, Clifford Samuel and Paul Tyreman narrate the audiobook, which runs about 13 hours.

The Bottom Line

The Impossible Us earns a 6.8/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a clever, funny, epistolary love story with a parallel worlds twist and flawed older leads, and who are comfortable with infidelity and an open ending. The reason to pick it up is the emails: Nick and Bee are two of the funniest correspondents in recent fiction.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

Spice level is our own reading of reviews describing an emotional rather than physical romance.

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.