The Love Wager by Lynn Painter Review
Eikna Score: 6.6/10. Recommended with reservations.
The Love Wager is a breezy, text-heavy rom-com about two people who agree to help each other find love and end up fake dating at a run of weddings. The banter is genuinely funny and the friendship stage is the best part, but the leads behave younger than their ages and a late act of meddling sits badly.
Read it if you love texting banter, wedding set pieces and friends who fall for each other, or you enjoyed Mr. Wrong Number and want Jack's story. Skip it if you want emotional depth and adult communication, or a hero who quietly interferes with the heroine's dating life will spoil the romance for you.
The Love Wager at a Glance
The Love Wager is Lynn Painter's second adult romance, published by Berkley in March 2023. It follows Hallie Piper and Jack Marshall, who meet again after a one-night stand, become dating allies and then fake dates for a string of weddings. It is told in alternating first person, has some open-door heat and ends happily.
| Author | Lynn Painter |
|---|---|
| Series | Mr. Wrong Number #2 (reads as a standalone) |
| Subgenre | Romantic comedy, contemporary romance |
| Main tropes | Fake dating, friends to lovers, dating app reunion, wedding dates, a bet |
| Spice level | 3/5: Moderate, some open door |
| Content warnings | Alcohol, jealousy, grief for an uncle, interference in a partner's dating life (full list below) |
| POV | Dual first person, Hallie and Jack |
| Ending | HEA |
| Pages | 320 (US paperback) |
| Audiobook | Narrated by Kristen DiMercurio and Zachary Webber, about 7 hours 1 minute |
| First published | March 14, 2023 |
| Publisher | Berkley (Penguin Random House) |
What Is The Love Wager About?
Hallie Piper sneaks out of a hotel room after a night she would rather forget and decides she is done with bad decisions. She wants to make deliberate choices, starting with a real relationship, so she joins a dating app. The first familiar face it serves her is Jack, the man whose room she snuck out of.
Jack is not looking for anything serious, but he is funny and easy to talk to, so they make a deal: they will help each other find someone. Soon they are texting daily, ranking each other's dates, and then posing as a couple at a series of weddings to keep the questions away. There is a bet on the side. Of course there is.
What Makes This Fake Dating Romance Work
The Love Wager works because its fake dating rests on a real friendship. Hallie and Jack spend a long stretch of the book as genuine pals who text all day, coach each other through bad dates and show up for each other, so when the wedding pretending starts there is something underneath it.
The second hook is the texting. Lynn Painter writes message exchanges better than almost anyone in the genre, and Andrea Reid at The Nerd Daily singled out the texting and the flow. Kirkus, reviewing the audiobook, praised the way the two narrators handle the message threads.
Then there are the weddings. Each one is a set piece with an open bar, a family audience and a chance for the act to slip. If you like fake dating romances that play the setup for laughs, this one does that well.
My Review
The Love Wager made me laugh out loud in its first third, and I kept reading on the strength of that. It is a quick, light book that knows its appeal: two people who are better at being friends than they want to admit, trading texts at all hours.
Romance and Chemistry
The chemistry is strongest when Hallie and Jack are just friends. Their conversations have rhythm, and the dating-ally setup gives them reasons to be honest about what they want from other people. B for Bookslut praised the chemistry, and Ana's Attic loved the becoming-friends arc. So did I.
Once the fake dating and the feelings arrive, the book leans on avoidance. Kayne Spooner at All About Romance enjoyed the dates and supporting cast but found that delayed communication slows the later story. Then there is the meddling: without spoiling it, a choice one lead makes about the other's dating prospects is the kind of thing that should cost more than it does. Brittany at Beauty and the Bean Boots objected strongly to that interference and the thin accountability for it, and I agree with her.
The Characters
Hallie is impulsive and warm, and her attempt to build a steadier life gives the book a spine. Jack is charming but less developed; Publishers Weekly praised the shared humor while finding Jack the thinner of the two, and his relationship anxiety after an uncle's death is mentioned more than it is explored.
Both leads sometimes act younger than they are. B for Bookslut found the jealousy childish and the development shallow, and the StoryGraph reader itschelseaw disliked the immaturity and the constant texting. The supporting cast, including friends and family at the weddings, is lively and helps cover the gaps.
Writing and Pacing
Painter's comic timing is the reason to read the book. Dialogue is quick, scenes are short and the pages turn. Donna at Reading in Pajamas enjoyed the banter and friendship while rolling her eyes at a few situations, which is a fair summary.
Andrea Reid at The Nerd Daily noted how wedding-heavy the plot is, and by the last wedding the structure feels repetitive. At 320 pages it moves fast. The audiobook, with Kristen DiMercurio and Zachary Webber alternating chapters, is a strong way to take it in; the text threads land better aloud than I expected.
The Love Wager is a funny, fast fake dating rom-com whose friendship stage is better than its romance stage. Read it for the texts and the weddings; skip it if immature communication and a meddling lead will sour the ending for you.
How Spicy Is The Love Wager?
The Love Wager is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. The book opens after a one-night stand, and once Hallie and Jack get together there are on-page sex scenes that readers describe as steamy without being the focus of the story.
Michele at Harlequin Junkie and Donna at Reading in Pajamas both noted the steamy scenes. Consent is clear on the page. The heavier notes are emotional: Jack's anxiety about relationships after his uncle's death, a jealous public scene and one lead's hidden interference in the other's dating life.
Content warnings, drawn from critics, reader reviews and our own read:
- Alcohol, including the night of the opening hookup
- Jealousy and a public confrontation
- Grief and anxiety after the death of an uncle
- Concealed interference in a partner's dating choices
- On-page sexual content
Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and our heat levels guide explains the full scale.
Who Should Read The Love Wager?
The Love Wager suits readers who want a light, funny rom-com with texting banter, wedding scenes and a friendship that turns romantic. It is less suited to readers who want mature conflict, a deeply drawn hero or a romance with no manipulative choices in it.
Best for:
- Fans of Mr. Wrong Number who want Jack's story
- Readers who love fake dating and wedding set pieces
- Anyone who enjoys rom-coms told partly through texts
- Audiobook listeners who like dual narrators
Not for:
- Readers who want emotional depth over banter
- Anyone bothered by jealous or meddling leads
- Readers tired of miscommunication plots
- Anyone looking for a closed-door read
What Readers and Critics Are Saying
The Love Wager drew mixed but mostly warm reception. Santa at The Romance Dish praised the banter and reported a happy ending, Michele at Harlequin Junkie enjoyed the friendship and cast, and Asha Reads liked the dual narration and confirmed the book reads on its own.
Where they agree. The humor and the friendship. Publishers Weekly praised the shared humor, Andrea Reid at The Nerd Daily praised the flow and texting, and Ana's Attic loved how the leads become friends first. Kirkus's audiobook review praised the alternating narrators. Where they split. Maturity and accountability. B for Bookslut found the development shallow and the jealousy childish. Brittany at Beauty and the Bean Boots objected to one lead's interference. Kayne Spooner at All About Romance found delayed communication slowed the back half, and Ana's Attic questioned the predictable structure.The Eikna Evidence Scorecard
The Love Wager scores 6.6 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with fair marks for the romance, writing and heat, and lower marks for depth and emotional impact.
| Dimension | Score (/5) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Romance (20%) | 3.5 | Strong friends-first chemistry, per B for Bookslut and Ana's Attic; later avoidance drags. |
| Characters (15%) | 3 | Hallie works; Jack is thinner, per Publishers Weekly. |
| Writing and pacing (15%) | 3.5 | Fast, funny dialogue and texts, per The Nerd Daily; the wedding structure repeats. |
| Emotional impact (15%) | 3 | Light and pleasant rather than moving. |
| Heat level (10%) | 3.5 | Steamy scenes that fit the tone, per Harlequin Junkie. |
| Ending satisfaction (15%) | 3.5 | A happy ending, per The Romance Dish; the meddling is under-addressed. |
| Reread appeal (10%) | 3 | Fun on audio, but the plot holds few surprises on a reread. |
The Eikna Overall Ranking: The Love Wager is a lighter, slighter follow-up to Mr. Wrong Number and a middle-of-the-pack fake dating rom-com, with a final Eikna Score of 6.6/10.
Mr. Wrong Number Reading Order
The Love Wager is book 2 of Lynn Painter's Mr. Wrong Number series, but it works as a standalone. Jack is the older brother of Olivia, the heroine of Mr. Wrong Number, and the first book's couple turns up in the background. Two short bonus epilogues for Olivia and Colin also exist and are optional.
- Book 1: Mr. Wrong Number (2022): Olivia Marshall and Colin Beck
- Book 2: The Love Wager (2023): Hallie Piper and Jack Marshall
Where to start: Mr. Wrong Number if you want the full family picture, otherwise The Love Wager stands up on its own. Best format: the audiobook, where two narrators handle the text threads. Our series order guide covers more connected romances.
If You Loved The Love Wager, Read These Next
If you loved The Love Wager, try these funny fake dating and wedding romances.
- Mr. Wrong Number by Lynn Painter: the first book, with Olivia and her brother's best friend trading texts.
- Happily Never After by Lynn Painter: Painter's next rom-com, built around a hired wedding objector.
- The Spanish Love Deception by Elena Armas: a fake date to a family wedding, with a much slower burn.
- The Unhoneymooners by Christina Lauren: two enemies take a wedding trip together and fake a marriage.
- The Wedding Date by Jasmine Guillory: a stranger in a stuck elevator becomes a fake wedding date.
Frequently Asked Questions
The Love Wager raises a few common questions about heat, reading order and the ending. Short answers below.
Is The Love Wager spicy?
Moderately. The Love Wager is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with a few open-door scenes once the leads get together.
Do I need to read Mr. Wrong Number before The Love Wager?
No. The Love Wager is book 2 in the Mr. Wrong Number series but works as a standalone; Jack is Olivia's older brother from book 1.
Does The Love Wager have a happy ending?
Yes. The Love Wager ends with a happily ever after for Hallie and Jack.
What is the wager in The Love Wager?
Hallie and Jack make a side bet while helping each other date, and it keeps the friendship and the fake dating tangled together.
Who narrates The Love Wager audiobook?
Kristen DiMercurio and Zachary Webber narrate the audiobook, which runs about 7 hours 1 minute.
The Bottom Line
The Love Wager earns a 6.6/10 and a Recommended with reservations badge. It is for readers who want a quick, funny rom-com built on texting, weddings and a friendship that turns into more, and who can forgive immature communication and one meddling choice. The reason to pick it up is the banter: Lynn Painter makes two people texting at midnight genuinely fun to read.
Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm
Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Sources
- The Love Wager, Penguin Random House (Berkley)
- The Love Wager, Lynn Painter official page
- Mr. Wrong Number series, Goodreads
- The Love Wager audiobook, Libro.fm (Kristen DiMercurio and Zachary Webber)
- The Love Wager, Publishers Weekly
- The Love Wager audiobook, Kirkus Reviews
- Review, All About Romance (Kayne Spooner)
- Review, The Nerd Daily (Andrea Reid)
- Review, Reading in Pajamas (Donna)
- Review, B for Bookslut
- Review, Harlequin Junkie (Michele)
- Review, Beauty and the Bean Boots (Brittany)
- Review, Ana's Attic
- Review, Asha Reads
- Review, The Romance Dish (Santa)
- Reader review, StoryGraph (itschelseaw)
Spice level is our own reading of reader reports; Lynn Painter does not publish a heat rating.
How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.