eikna romance
Menu

The True Love Experiment by Christina Lauren Review

Eikna Score: 7.3/10. Recommended.

The True Love Experiment gives Fizzy, the scene-stealing best friend from The Soulmate Equation, a romance as loud and generous as she is: a romance writer starring in a dating show while falling for the man producing it. It is funnier and steamier than its predecessor, but it runs long, and a late reveal about the past will split readers.

Read it if you loved Fizzy in The Soulmate Equation, or you want a behind-the-scenes reality TV rom com with a single dad hero and dual points of view. Skip it if past infidelity in a lead's history is a hard line for you, or you want a tight, short rom com.

The True Love Experiment by Christina Lauren book cover

The True Love Experiment at a Glance

The True Love Experiment is a contemporary romantic comedy by Christina Lauren, first published by Gallery Books on May 16, 2023, and a companion to The Soulmate Equation. Fizzy Chen and producer Connor Prince share the first person narration. It has moderate open-door heat and a happily ever after.

AuthorChristina Lauren (Christina Hobbs and Lauren Billings)
SeriesCompanion to The Soulmate Equation; reads as a standalone
SubgenreRomantic comedy, contemporary romance
Main tropesReality dating show, workplace romance, single dad, off-limits attraction, grand gesture
Spice level3/5: Moderate, some open door
Content warningsPast infidelity, divorce and co-parenting (full list below)
POVDual first person, Fizzy and Connor
EndingHEA
Pages416 (2023 hardcover); the 2024 Gallery paperback runs 496
AudiobookNarrated by Cindy Kay and Jonathan Cole, 10 hours 59 minutes (Simon & Schuster Audio)
First publishedMay 16, 2023
PublisherGallery Books, an imprint of Simon & Schuster

What Is The True Love Experiment About?

Felicity Chen, known to everyone as Fizzy, writes romance novels for a living and has started to wonder whether she believes in them. Her love life is a string of fun first dates and nothing more, and the words have dried up.

Connor Prince is a documentary filmmaker and divorced father who needs a hit to keep his job and stay close to his daughter. His boss wants a reality dating show. Connor wants a lead who is funny, honest and unafraid of the camera, and he finds one in Fizzy. She agrees to star in The True Love Experiment and meet a group of potential matches on air. The person she cannot stop looking at is the one behind the camera.

What Makes This Reality Dating Show Romance Work

The True Love Experiment works because it puts the romance where the cameras are not. Fizzy is surrounded by handsome men chosen to fall for her, and her real connection grows in production meetings, car rides and quiet moments off the clock with the producer who cannot be part of the story. That gives the book a clean, built-in obstacle.

Fizzy is also the hook. Readers met her as Jess's outrageous best friend, and this book lets her be the lead without sanding her down. Kirkus valued her agency and gave the book a starred review, and Publishers Weekly praised the way the authors play with romance tropes while still delivering them. A romance novelist running out of faith in romance is a good joke, and the book knows it.

Connor is a softer kind of hero: a devoted father, practical, a little rumpled and very kind. The dual narration lets him be more than a pretty obstacle, and Krista at Thoughts About Things valued that access to both viewpoints. If you like your rom com heroes warm rather than brooding, the pairing lands.

My Review

I liked The True Love Experiment more than The Soulmate Equation, which surprised me. It is less tidy and less clever about its premise, but it is funnier, it gives both leads a voice, and Fizzy is simply better company than almost anyone in the earlier book. The show gives the plot a calendar and the jokes a stage.

It is also long for a rom com, and it feels it. The middle stretch, where filming settles into routine, could lose fifty pages. And a late revelation about the past changed how some readers see one of the leads. That is the hinge for most opinions on this book.

Romance and Chemistry

Fizzy and Connor have chemistry from their first meeting, before any filming starts, and Krista at Thoughts About Things singled out that early spark. Their banter is quick and their attraction is adult, built on respect for each other's work. Dolly Sickles at All About Romance praised the character and dialogue work, and Phoebe Wright at Read & Wright enjoyed the affectionate genre humor.

The difficulty is the late disclosure. A piece of past infidelity comes out near the end, and the book asks the couple, and the reader, to work through it quickly. Krista at Thoughts About Things defended the growth the book shows afterward. The StoryGraph reviewer rkreads rejected the handling outright, and bookbruin questioned how fast the repair happens. I thought the book took it seriously but resolved it too neatly. Cristina at Girl in the Pages praised the grand gesture that follows, and it is a good one.

The Characters

Fizzy is the reason to read. She is warm, impulsive, unembarrassed about desire and fiercely loyal, and her Chinese American family, which Harlequin Junkie noted, gives her scenes outside the show. Andrea Lowry at Bookmarked by Andrea valued the family and friendship warmth, and Jess and River from The Soulmate Equation drop in without taking over.

Connor is likeable but less distinct. Brittany at Beauty and the Bean Boots found him less memorable and wanted deeper backstories for both leads, and I agree that his inner life is mostly his daughter and his job. The co-parenting thread, which bookbruin enjoyed, is the most grounded part of him, and his relationship with his ex-wife is handled with more grace than the genre usually allows.

Writing and Pacing

The writing is Christina Lauren at full volume: fast dialogue, running jokes, set pieces built around the show's challenges. Jen Ryland found the dating show energizing without crowding out the central couple, which is the balance the book needs. Phoebe Wright wanted more of the show itself, and I can see why. The contestants are a blur.

Length is the real problem. The book is long for a rom com, and bookbruin questioned it too. Kaetrin Allen at All About Romance, reviewing the audiobook, wanted more aftermath for Connor's boss, whose behavior drives a lot of the plot and gets little consequence. The audiobook is a good way through the long middle: Kaetrin praised both narrators.

The True Love Experiment is a funny, warm and slightly overlong reality TV rom com that finally gives Fizzy the spotlight, with a late reveal that will make or break it for some readers. Read it if you want a big-hearted, moderately steamy romance and can accept a messy past.

How Spicy Is The True Love Experiment?

The True Love Experiment is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. Once Fizzy and Connor stop resisting, there are several open-door, consensual scenes, frank and fairly detailed. Kirkus described them as steamy, and Andrea Lowry at Bookmarked by Andrea confirmed open-door treatment, while Phoebe Wright gave a lower personal spice rating.

It is a little warmer than The Soulmate Equation but nowhere near the most explicit end of the genre. For more in this range, see our spicy romance list.

Content warnings, drawn from reader reviews and the Eikna team's reading:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and our romance heat levels guide explains the scale.

Who Should Read The True Love Experiment?

The True Love Experiment suits readers who want a lively, behind-the-scenes rom com with a confident heroine, a single dad hero and moderate heat. It is a weaker fit for readers who want a short book or who cannot accept infidelity in a lead's past.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

The True Love Experiment drew a starred review from Kirkus and a positive one from Publishers Weekly, plus a blurb from Jodi Picoult on the jacket. Reader coverage is large and mostly warm, with one sharp line of disagreement.

Where they agree. Fizzy and the dialogue. Kirkus valued her agency and the steamy scenes, Publishers Weekly praised the chemistry and genre play, Dolly Sickles at All About Romance favored the character work and said the book reads on its own, and Jen Ryland enjoyed how the show energizes the story. Cristina at Girl in the Pages reported a satisfying HEA and grand gesture.

Where they split. The late reveal and the length. rkreads on The StoryGraph rejected the handling of past cheating and the characterization, while Krista at Thoughts About Things defended the growth that follows. bookbruin enjoyed the banter but questioned the length and the speed of repair, and Brittany at Beauty and the Bean Boots wanted deeper backstories and a more distinct Connor.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

The True Love Experiment scores 7.3 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with top marks for romance and heat and its lowest for characters, writing and reread appeal, where a thin Connor and a long middle hold it back.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)4Early, adult chemistry praised by Thoughts About Things and Publishers Weekly.
Characters (15%)3.5Fizzy is a star; Beauty and the Bean Boots finds Connor less distinct.
Writing and pacing (15%)3.5Fast, funny dialogue per All About Romance; bookbruin finds it overlong.
Emotional impact (15%)3.5Kirkus promises big laughs and a few tears; the late reveal divides readers.
Heat level (10%)4Delivers the steamy open-door scenes Kirkus describes without overwhelming the comedy.
Ending satisfaction (15%)3.5A HEA with a strong grand gesture, per Girl in the Pages; the repair is quick.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5Fun to revisit for Fizzy, though the long middle tests a reread.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: The True Love Experiment edges out The Soulmate Equation as the stronger of Christina Lauren's two linked rom coms, and it earns a final Eikna Score of 7.3/10.

Is The True Love Experiment a Standalone?

Yes, with a connection. The True Love Experiment is a complete romance that All About Romance found easy to read on its own, but Fizzy is introduced in The Soulmate Equation, and Jess and River reappear here. Read them in this order if you want everything in sequence:

  1. The Soulmate Equation (2021): Jess and River
  2. The True Love Experiment (2023): Fizzy and Connor

Best format: the Simon & Schuster audiobook splits the narration between Cindy Kay and Jonathan Cole, and Kaetrin Allen at All About Romance praised both performances. Two voices suit a dual point of view book this talky. Our series order guide covers longer connected series.

If You Loved The True Love Experiment, Read These Next

If you loved The True Love Experiment, look for rom coms set behind the scenes of TV or publishing, and romances where the obstacle is a job.

Frequently Asked Questions

The True Love Experiment raises a predictable set of questions: is it spicy, do you need to read The Soulmate Equation first, is there cheating and who narrates it. Short answers below.

Is The True Love Experiment spicy?

Yes, moderately. The True Love Experiment is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with several open-door, consensual scenes that Kirkus called steamy.

Do I need to read The Soulmate Equation first?

No. The True Love Experiment works as a standalone, but reading The Soulmate Equation first gives you Fizzy's earlier scenes and a cameo from its couple.

Is there cheating in The True Love Experiment?

There is no cheating between Fizzy and Connor, but past infidelity is revealed late in the book, and readers are divided on how it is handled.

Does The True Love Experiment have a happy ending?

Yes. The True Love Experiment ends with a happily ever after and a grand gesture.

Whose point of view is The True Love Experiment told from?

The book alternates first person chapters between Fizzy and Connor.

Who narrates The True Love Experiment audiobook?

Cindy Kay and Jonathan Cole narrate the Simon & Schuster Audio edition, which runs about 11 hours.

The Bottom Line

The True Love Experiment earns a 7.3/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a funny, warm, moderately steamy rom com set behind the cameras of a dating show, and who can live with a long middle and a messy reveal. The one reason to pick it up is Fizzy, who finally gets the leading role she always played anyway.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.