eikna romance
Menu

Weather Girl by Rachel Lynn Solomon Review

Eikna Score: 7.9/10. Recommended.

Weather Girl is a warm, funny workplace rom-com about a Seattle TV meteorologist and a sports reporter who team up to reunite their divorced bosses and fall for each other instead. Its real strength is Ari's depression, written with honesty and hope; the romance itself moves a little faster than it should.

Read it if you want a soft, considerate hero, frank and tender sex, and mental health representation that is neither tragic nor tidy. Skip it if you want a light, fizzy comedy with no heavy material, or you need a slow, fully developed friendship before the romance.

Weather Girl by Rachel Lynn Solomon book cover

Weather Girl at a Glance

Weather Girl is Rachel Lynn Solomon's standalone contemporary romance, published by Berkley on January 11, 2022. It pairs meteorologist Ari Abrams, 27, with sports reporter Russell Barringer at a Seattle TV station, ends with a happily ever after, and runs 352 pages in paperback.

AuthorRachel Lynn Solomon
SeriesStandalone
SubgenreRomantic comedy (Seattle TV newsroom)
Main tropesWorkplace romance, matchmaking schemes, coworkers to lovers, sunshine heroine and gentle hero, single dad
Spice level3/5: Moderate, some open door
Content warningsDepression and therapy, suicidal thoughts referenced, parental abandonment, fatphobia, teen pregnancy in backstory (full list below)
POVFirst person, Ari
EndingHEA
Pages352 (paperback)
AudiobookNarrated by Sarah Mollo-Christensen, 10 hours 42 minutes
First publishedJanuary 11, 2022
PublisherBerkley

What Is Weather Girl About?

Weather Girl follows Ari Abrams, a 27 year old meteorologist at Seattle's KSEA 6, who wants nothing more than to learn from her famous boss, chief meteorologist Torrance Hale. Unfortunately Torrance is locked in a messy, very public feud with her ex-husband Seth, the station's news director, and the whole newsroom is suffering for it.

Ari teams up with sports reporter Russell Barringer, a single dad with a twelve year old daughter, to get the bosses back together: gifts, double dates, careful scheming. The plan starts to work just as Ari realizes she is falling for her co-conspirator, and that letting Russell close means letting him see the depression she usually hides.

What Makes This Workplace Matchmaking Romance Work

Weather Girl works because the matchmaking plot is a comic engine for a much more personal story. Ari and Russell scheme like a pair of sitcom sidekicks, and the newsroom scenes are genuinely funny. The book's chapter headings, written like weather reports, set the tone.

The real hook is Ari. She lives with depression, manages it with therapy and medication, and has spent her life performing sunniness. Melanie at Smexy Books gave the book an A plus and praised its realistic portrayal of depression, along with its frank treatment of medication, libido and sexual communication.

Russell is the other draw: plus-size, self-conscious about it, kind and steady. Readers who love workplace romance and gentle heroes will find this one of the more emotionally honest rom-coms of its year, and fans of sunny heroines will recognize Ari.

My Review

Weather Girl surprised me. I expected a bright, breezy newsroom comedy and got that, plus one of the most careful portraits of living with depression I have read in a rom-com. It is not a perfect romance. It is a very good book about a woman learning to let someone see her on a gray day.

Romance and Chemistry

Ari and Russell are lovely together: playful, considerate and very good at talking about hard things. Lisa Fernandes at All About Romance valued Russell's considerate behavior, and it is the heart of their chemistry. He notices; he asks; he waits.

The weakness is speed. Kirkus felt the journey from friends to crushes to lovers was rushed, noting that the years Ari and Russell spent as coworkers are mostly unexplored. I felt that too. The romance arrives quickly, and the book has to lean on the matchmaking plot to fill in the friendship we never saw.

The Characters

Ari is funny, nervous, ambitious and honest about her illness in a way that never reduces her to it. Michele at Harlequin Junkie praised the depression portrayal, and I agree it is the book's best work. Ari's fear of being too much for a partner, and her history with a former fiance she never fully let in, are written with real sting.

Russell is a gentle hero with his own history: he became a father as a teenager and is a devoted dad. Some readers found him a little too smooth; Marie Reads Books felt he was not distinctive enough. Both leads are Jewish, which the book weaves in naturally. The bosses' second-chance subplot, Torrance and Seth, is a fun counterweight and gets its own happy ending.

Writing and Pacing

Solomon writes quick, warm first-person prose with good jokes, and the newsroom feels lived in, even if Read Between the Spines questioned how plausible the workplace is.

The tone is the challenge. Melinda at AudioGals found Ari's inner struggle too heavy for the comedy she had expected, and readers who want pure fizz should know the book goes to darker places. I thought the balance mostly worked.

Weather Girl is a warm, sexy, honest workplace rom-com with a rushed romance and an exceptional heroine. Read it for Ari and for a hero who listens; skip it if you want comedy with no clouds.

How Spicy Is Weather Girl?

Weather Girl is a 3 out of 5 on our scale: Moderate, some open door. There are on-page sex scenes once Ari and Russell are together, and one in particular is detailed, tender and steamy. Melanie at Smexy Books called it one of the steamiest scenes she had read in a long time.

The intimacy is built on explicit communication and consent, including frank talk about how Ari's medication affects her libido, which StoryGraph readers praised as realistic.

Content warnings, drawn from the author's notes where available, reader reports and our own read:

Our content warnings guide explains how we compile these lists, and our heat levels guide explains the full spice scale.

Who Should Read Weather Girl?

Weather Girl suits readers who want a funny workplace rom-com with honest depression representation, a plus-size hero, Jewish leads and tender open-door scenes. It is less suited to readers who want a light, drama-free comedy or a slow-building friendship before the romance.

Best for:

Not for:

What Readers and Critics Are Saying

Weather Girl was well reviewed. Publishers Weekly gave it a starred review and called it wildly appealing, praising characters with real problems. Kirkus was more measured, finding the romance rushed and the connection slightly underdeveloped while predicting readers would be satisfied.

Where they agree. Ari and the depression portrayal. Smexy Books, Harlequin Junkie and All About Romance all praise the honesty about mental health and Russell's kindness.

Where they split. Pace, tone and the epilogue. Kirkus and some StoryGraph readers found the chemistry underdeveloped; AudioGals felt the heavy material crowded out the comedy; Marie Reads Books found Russell bland; and readers on r/RomanceBooks objected to the epilogue's public gesture. Cannonball Read wondered why Ari could open up to Russell when she never could with her former fiance.

The Eikna Evidence Scorecard

Weather Girl scores 7.9 out of 10 on the Eikna Evidence Scorecard, with its highest mark for emotional impact and lower marks for a romance that moves faster than its friendship.

DimensionScore (/5)Why
Romance (20%)3.5Sweet and sexy, but Kirkus found the move from coworkers to lovers rushed.
Characters (15%)4Ari and Russell are warm, Jewish, flawed and kind; Smexy Books loved the plus-size hero.
Writing and pacing (15%)4Funny newsroom scenes and chapter headings; Publishers Weekly called it wildly appealing in a starred review.
Emotional impact (15%)4.5Ari's depression is written with rare honesty, per Smexy Books and Harlequin Junkie.
Heat level (10%)4One scene Smexy Books called among the steamiest she had read in years, built on care and consent.
Ending satisfaction (15%)4An HEA for both couples, per AudioGals, though some readers disliked the public epilogue gesture.
Reread appeal (10%)3.5Comforting to revisit; the matchmaking plot is thinner the second time.

The Eikna Overall Ranking: Weather Girl is among Rachel Lynn Solomon's best adult romances and one of the more emotionally honest workplace rom-coms we have reviewed. Final Eikna Score 7.9/10.

Is Weather Girl a Standalone?

Yes. Weather Girl is a standalone romantic comedy with its own couple and a happily ever after. You do not need to read The Ex Talk or any other Rachel Lynn Solomon book first.

Best format: print or ebook for the weather-report chapter headings; the audiobook, narrated by Sarah Mollo-Christensen, runs 10 hours 42 minutes. Our HEA and HFN guide explains how we label endings.

If You Loved Weather Girl, Read These Next

If you loved Weather Girl, look for rom-coms with workplace schemes, kind heroes and honest emotional stakes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Weather Girl raises the same questions from most readers: how spicy it is, whether it connects to The Ex Talk and how it handles depression. Short answers below.

Is Weather Girl spicy?

Moderately. Weather Girl is a 3 out of 5 on our scale, with open-door scenes, one of them quite steamy.

Is Weather Girl connected to The Ex Talk?

No. Weather Girl is a standalone, and you do not need to read The Ex Talk first.

Does Weather Girl have a happy ending?

Yes. Ari and Russell get a happily ever after, and so do their bosses.

Does Weather Girl deal with depression?

Yes. Ari lives with depression and manages it with therapy and medication, and the book treats it honestly.

How old is Ari in Weather Girl?

Ari Abrams is 27. Russell is an adult single dad with a twelve year old daughter.

Is there a Weather Girl audiobook?

Yes. It is narrated by Sarah Mollo-Christensen and runs 10 hours 42 minutes.

The Bottom Line

Weather Girl earns a 7.9/10 and a Recommended badge. It is for readers who want a funny workplace rom-com with a kind, plus-size hero, tender open-door scenes and one of the most honest portrayals of depression in the genre, and who can forgive a romance that arrives a little fast. The reason to pick it up is Ari, a sunny heroine allowed to have cloudy days.

Buy on Amazon Buy at Bookshop.org Listen on Audible Listen on Libro.fm

Some links on this page are affiliate links: Eikna Romance may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Sources

How we review: every Eikna score is built from a seven-part evidence scorecard. Read our methodology.